Avoiding, Treating & Curing Cancer With the Immune System | Dr. Alex Marson
3/9/2026148 mintranscribing
0:00We're living in this amazing moment of biology where we can put a gene that
0:00We're living in this amazing moment of biology where we can put a gene that
0:00We're living in this amazing moment of biology where we can put a gene that
0:00We're living in this amazing moment of biology where we can put a gene that
0:00We're living in this amazing moment of biology where we can put a gene that
0:00We're living in this amazing moment of biology where we can put a gene that
0:03encodes something on the surface of T -cells that will make them programmed to search
0:03encodes something on the surface of T -cells that will make them programmed to search
0:03encodes something on the surface of T -cells that will make them programmed to search
0:03encodes something on the surface of T -cells that will make them programmed to search
0:03encodes something on the surface of T -cells that will make them programmed to search
0:03encodes something on the surface of T -cells that will make them programmed to search
0:09and destroy for cancer cells.
0:09and destroy for cancer cells.
0:09and destroy for cancer cells.
0:09and destroy for cancer cells.
0:09and destroy for cancer cells.
0:09and destroy for cancer cells.
0:11Now, this is largely known as CAR T -cells, chimeric antigen receptor.
0:11Now, this is largely known as CAR T -cells, chimeric antigen receptor.
0:11Now, this is largely known as CAR T -cells, chimeric antigen receptor.
0:11Now, this is largely known as CAR T -cells, chimeric antigen receptor.
0:11Now, this is largely known as CAR T -cells, chimeric antigen receptor.
0:11Now, this is largely known as CAR T -cells, chimeric antigen receptor.
0:16This is a receptor that was designed in a lab, does not exist in nature.
0:16This is a receptor that was designed in a lab, does not exist in nature.
0:16This is a receptor that was designed in a lab, does not exist in nature.
0:16This is a receptor that was designed in a lab, does not exist in nature.
0:16This is a receptor that was designed in a lab, does not exist in nature.
0:16This is a receptor that was designed in a lab, does not exist in nature.
0:20When those T -cells get re -infused into a patient the way that you get
0:20When those T -cells get re -infused into a patient the way that you get
0:20When those T -cells get re -infused into a patient the way that you get
0:20When those T -cells get re -infused into a patient the way that you get
0:20When those T -cells get re -infused into a patient the way that you get
0:20When those T -cells get re -infused into a patient the way that you get
0:23like a blood transfusion, those CARs are directed to go against cancers.
0:23like a blood transfusion, those CARs are directed to go against cancers.
0:23like a blood transfusion, those CARs are directed to go against cancers.
0:23like a blood transfusion, those CARs are directed to go against cancers.
0:23like a blood transfusion, those CARs are directed to go against cancers.
0:23like a blood transfusion, those CARs are directed to go against cancers.
0:28Welcome to the Huberman Lab Podcast, where we discuss science and science -based tools for
0:28Welcome to the Huberman Lab Podcast, where we discuss science and science -based tools for
0:28Welcome to the Huberman Lab Podcast, where we discuss science and science -based tools for
0:28Welcome to the Huberman Lab Podcast, where we discuss science and science -based tools for
0:28Welcome to the Huberman Lab Podcast, where we discuss science and science -based tools for
0:28Welcome to the Huberman Lab Podcast, where we discuss science and science -based tools for
0:33everyday life. I'm Andrew Huberman, and I'm a professor of neurobiology and ophthalmology at Stanford
0:33everyday life. I'm Andrew Huberman, and I'm a professor of neurobiology and ophthalmology at Stanford
0:33everyday life. I'm Andrew Huberman, and I'm a professor of neurobiology and ophthalmology at Stanford
0:33everyday life. I'm Andrew Huberman, and I'm a professor of neurobiology and ophthalmology at Stanford
0:33everyday life. I'm Andrew Huberman, and I'm a professor of neurobiology and ophthalmology at Stanford
0:33everyday life. I'm Andrew Huberman, and I'm a professor of neurobiology and ophthalmology at Stanford
0:42School of Medicine. My guest today is Dr.
0:42School of Medicine. My guest today is Dr.
0:42School of Medicine. My guest today is Dr.
0:42School of Medicine. My guest today is Dr.
0:42School of Medicine. My guest today is Dr.
0:42School of Medicine. My guest today is Dr.
0:45Alex Marson. Dr. Alex Marson is a medical doctor and scientist at the University of
0:45Alex Marson. Dr. Alex Marson is a medical doctor and scientist at the University of
0:45Alex Marson. Dr. Alex Marson is a medical doctor and scientist at the University of
0:45Alex Marson. Dr. Alex Marson is a medical doctor and scientist at the University of
0:45Alex Marson. Dr. Alex Marson is a medical doctor and scientist at the University of
0:45Alex Marson. Dr. Alex Marson is a medical doctor and scientist at the University of
0:49California, San Francisco. He is developing new ways to reprogram the immune system to cure
0:49California, San Francisco. He is developing new ways to reprogram the immune system to cure
0:49California, San Francisco. He is developing new ways to reprogram the immune system to cure
0:49California, San Francisco. He is developing new ways to reprogram the immune system to cure
0:49California, San Francisco. He is developing new ways to reprogram the immune system to cure
0:49California, San Francisco. He is developing new ways to reprogram the immune system to cure
0:54cancers. Today, we discuss how your immune system works, how autoimmunity works, and how gene
0:54cancers. Today, we discuss how your immune system works, how autoimmunity works, and how gene
0:54cancers. Today, we discuss how your immune system works, how autoimmunity works, and how gene
0:54cancers. Today, we discuss how your immune system works, how autoimmunity works, and how gene
0:54cancers. Today, we discuss how your immune system works, how autoimmunity works, and how gene
0:54cancers. Today, we discuss how your immune system works, how autoimmunity works, and how gene
1:00editing and other new technologies can be successfully leveraged to defeat childhood and adult cancers.
1:00editing and other new technologies can be successfully leveraged to defeat childhood and adult cancers.
1:00editing and other new technologies can be successfully leveraged to defeat childhood and adult cancers.
1:00editing and other new technologies can be successfully leveraged to defeat childhood and adult cancers.
1:00editing and other new technologies can be successfully leveraged to defeat childhood and adult cancers.
1:00editing and other new technologies can be successfully leveraged to defeat childhood and adult cancers.
1:07Dr. Marson is truly one of a kind in his understanding of the clinical aspects
1:07Dr. Marson is truly one of a kind in his understanding of the clinical aspects
1:07Dr. Marson is truly one of a kind in his understanding of the clinical aspects
1:07Dr. Marson is truly one of a kind in his understanding of the clinical aspects
1:07Dr. Marson is truly one of a kind in his understanding of the clinical aspects
1:07Dr. Marson is truly one of a kind in his understanding of the clinical aspects
1:11of cancer treatment, the science of the immune system, and, as you'll soon hear, in
1:11of cancer treatment, the science of the immune system, and, as you'll soon hear, in
1:11of cancer treatment, the science of the immune system, and, as you'll soon hear, in
1:11of cancer treatment, the science of the immune system, and, as you'll soon hear, in
1:11of cancer treatment, the science of the immune system, and, as you'll soon hear, in
1:11of cancer treatment, the science of the immune system, and, as you'll soon hear, in
1:16explaining the things that genuinely increase your cancer risk, many of which are surprising, and
1:16explaining the things that genuinely increase your cancer risk, many of which are surprising, and
1:16explaining the things that genuinely increase your cancer risk, many of which are surprising, and
1:16explaining the things that genuinely increase your cancer risk, many of which are surprising, and
1:16explaining the things that genuinely increase your cancer risk, many of which are surprising, and
1:16explaining the things that genuinely increase your cancer risk, many of which are surprising, and
1:21the actionable steps that we can all take to reduce our probability of getting cancer.
1:21the actionable steps that we can all take to reduce our probability of getting cancer.
1:21the actionable steps that we can all take to reduce our probability of getting cancer.
1:21the actionable steps that we can all take to reduce our probability of getting cancer.
1:21the actionable steps that we can all take to reduce our probability of getting cancer.
1:21the actionable steps that we can all take to reduce our probability of getting cancer.
1:26In addition to the usual factors, smoking, UV light, and environmental toxins, such as pesticides,
1:26In addition to the usual factors, smoking, UV light, and environmental toxins, such as pesticides,
1:26In addition to the usual factors, smoking, UV light, and environmental toxins, such as pesticides,
1:26In addition to the usual factors, smoking, UV light, and environmental toxins, such as pesticides,
1:26In addition to the usual factors, smoking, UV light, and environmental toxins, such as pesticides,
1:26In addition to the usual factors, smoking, UV light, and environmental toxins, such as pesticides,
1:32we discuss the actual cancer risks that come from things like eating charred meats, airport
1:32we discuss the actual cancer risks that come from things like eating charred meats, airport
1:32we discuss the actual cancer risks that come from things like eating charred meats, airport
1:32we discuss the actual cancer risks that come from things like eating charred meats, airport
1:32we discuss the actual cancer risks that come from things like eating charred meats, airport
1:32we discuss the actual cancer risks that come from things like eating charred meats, airport
1:37scanners, and food additives, and how to gauge your individual level of risk.
1:37scanners, and food additives, and how to gauge your individual level of risk.
1:37scanners, and food additives, and how to gauge your individual level of risk.
1:37scanners, and food additives, and how to gauge your individual level of risk.
1:37scanners, and food additives, and how to gauge your individual level of risk.
1:37scanners, and food additives, and how to gauge your individual level of risk.
1:41We also explore gene editing for reversing diseases, which until recently was science fiction, but
1:41We also explore gene editing for reversing diseases, which until recently was science fiction, but
1:41We also explore gene editing for reversing diseases, which until recently was science fiction, but
1:41We also explore gene editing for reversing diseases, which until recently was science fiction, but
1:41We also explore gene editing for reversing diseases, which until recently was science fiction, but
1:41We also explore gene editing for reversing diseases, which until recently was science fiction, but
1:47now is a reality. By the end of today's episode, thanks to Dr.
1:47now is a reality. By the end of today's episode, thanks to Dr.
1:47now is a reality. By the end of today's episode, thanks to Dr.
1:47now is a reality. By the end of today's episode, thanks to Dr.
1:47now is a reality. By the end of today's episode, thanks to Dr.
1:47now is a reality. By the end of today's episode, thanks to Dr.
1:51Marson, you'll have the most up -to -date understanding of the state -of -the -art
1:51Marson, you'll have the most up -to -date understanding of the state -of -the -art
1:51Marson, you'll have the most up -to -date understanding of the state -of -the -art
1:51Marson, you'll have the most up -to -date understanding of the state -of -the -art
1:51Marson, you'll have the most up -to -date understanding of the state -of -the -art
1:51Marson, you'll have the most up -to -date understanding of the state -of -the -art
1:54science for cancer prevention and treatment, knowledge that is certain to impact you or a
1:54science for cancer prevention and treatment, knowledge that is certain to impact you or a
1:54science for cancer prevention and treatment, knowledge that is certain to impact you or a
1:54science for cancer prevention and treatment, knowledge that is certain to impact you or a
1:54science for cancer prevention and treatment, knowledge that is certain to impact you or a
1:54science for cancer prevention and treatment, knowledge that is certain to impact you or a
1:59close friend or family member in your lifetime.
1:59close friend or family member in your lifetime.
1:59close friend or family member in your lifetime.
1:59close friend or family member in your lifetime.
1:59close friend or family member in your lifetime.
1:59close friend or family member in your lifetime.
2:02Before we begin, I'd like to emphasize that this podcast is separate from my teaching
2:02Before we begin, I'd like to emphasize that this podcast is separate from my teaching
2:02Before we begin, I'd like to emphasize that this podcast is separate from my teaching
2:02Before we begin, I'd like to emphasize that this podcast is separate from my teaching
2:02Before we begin, I'd like to emphasize that this podcast is separate from my teaching
2:02Before we begin, I'd like to emphasize that this podcast is separate from my teaching
2:06and research roles at Stanford.
2:06and research roles at Stanford.
2:06and research roles at Stanford.
2:06and research roles at Stanford.
2:06and research roles at Stanford.
2:06and research roles at Stanford.
2:07It is, however, part of my desire and effort to bring zero -cost -to -consumer
2:07It is, however, part of my desire and effort to bring zero -cost -to -consumer
2:07It is, however, part of my desire and effort to bring zero -cost -to -consumer
2:07It is, however, part of my desire and effort to bring zero -cost -to -consumer
2:07It is, however, part of my desire and effort to bring zero -cost -to -consumer
2:07It is, however, part of my desire and effort to bring zero -cost -to -consumer
2:11information about science and science -related tools to the general public.
2:11information about science and science -related tools to the general public.
2:11information about science and science -related tools to the general public.
2:11information about science and science -related tools to the general public.
2:11information about science and science -related tools to the general public.
2:11information about science and science -related tools to the general public.
2:15In keeping with that theme, today's episode does include sponsors.
2:15In keeping with that theme, today's episode does include sponsors.
2:15In keeping with that theme, today's episode does include sponsors.
2:15In keeping with that theme, today's episode does include sponsors.
2:15In keeping with that theme, today's episode does include sponsors.
2:15In keeping with that theme, today's episode does include sponsors.
2:18And now for my discussion with Dr.
2:18And now for my discussion with Dr.
2:18And now for my discussion with Dr.
2:18And now for my discussion with Dr.
2:18And now for my discussion with Dr.
2:18And now for my discussion with Dr.
2:20Alex Marson. Dr. Alex Marson, welcome.
2:20Alex Marson. Dr. Alex Marson, welcome.
2:20Alex Marson. Dr. Alex Marson, welcome.
2:20Alex Marson. Dr. Alex Marson, welcome.
2:20Alex Marson. Dr. Alex Marson, welcome.
2:20Alex Marson. Dr. Alex Marson, welcome.
2:24Andrew. This is the first time that we're going to have a serious discussion about
2:24Andrew. This is the first time that we're going to have a serious discussion about
2:24Andrew. This is the first time that we're going to have a serious discussion about
2:24Andrew. This is the first time that we're going to have a serious discussion about
2:24Andrew. This is the first time that we're going to have a serious discussion about
2:24Andrew. This is the first time that we're going to have a serious discussion about
2:28the immune system, cancer, and gene editing technologies on this podcast.
2:28the immune system, cancer, and gene editing technologies on this podcast.
2:28the immune system, cancer, and gene editing technologies on this podcast.
2:28the immune system, cancer, and gene editing technologies on this podcast.
2:28the immune system, cancer, and gene editing technologies on this podcast.
2:28the immune system, cancer, and gene editing technologies on this podcast.
2:33So I'm delighted that you're here.
2:33So I'm delighted that you're here.
2:33So I'm delighted that you're here.
2:33So I'm delighted that you're here.
2:33So I'm delighted that you're here.
2:33So I'm delighted that you're here.
2:35It's also great to see you again.
2:35It's also great to see you again.
2:35It's also great to see you again.
2:35It's also great to see you again.
2:35It's also great to see you again.
2:35It's also great to see you again.
2:36Thank you for having me.
2:36Thank you for having me.
2:36Thank you for having me.
2:36Thank you for having me.
2:36Thank you for having me.
2:36Thank you for having me.
2:37Really, really good to see you.
2:37Really, really good to see you.
2:37Really, really good to see you.
2:37Really, really good to see you.
2:37Really, really good to see you.
2:37Really, really good to see you.
2:38It's been a while. Let's start off with the big picture.
2:38It's been a while. Let's start off with the big picture.
2:38It's been a while. Let's start off with the big picture.
2:38It's been a while. Let's start off with the big picture.
2:38It's been a while. Let's start off with the big picture.
2:38It's been a while. Let's start off with the big picture.
2:43How are we doing? How's biology looking?
2:43How are we doing? How's biology looking?
2:43How are we doing? How's biology looking?
2:43How are we doing? How's biology looking?
2:43How are we doing? How's biology looking?
2:43How are we doing? How's biology looking?
2:46How's medicine looking? Are we on the fast track to much better things?
2:46How's medicine looking? Are we on the fast track to much better things?
2:46How's medicine looking? Are we on the fast track to much better things?
2:46How's medicine looking? Are we on the fast track to much better things?
2:46How's medicine looking? Are we on the fast track to much better things?
2:46How's medicine looking? Are we on the fast track to much better things?
2:50Are we going to slog along for another 10 years before we have cures to
2:50Are we going to slog along for another 10 years before we have cures to
2:50Are we going to slog along for another 10 years before we have cures to
2:50Are we going to slog along for another 10 years before we have cures to
2:50Are we going to slog along for another 10 years before we have cures to
2:50Are we going to slog along for another 10 years before we have cures to
2:54the many concerns that people have about cancer, Alzheimer's, and the rest?
2:54the many concerns that people have about cancer, Alzheimer's, and the rest?
2:54the many concerns that people have about cancer, Alzheimer's, and the rest?
2:54the many concerns that people have about cancer, Alzheimer's, and the rest?
2:54the many concerns that people have about cancer, Alzheimer's, and the rest?
2:54the many concerns that people have about cancer, Alzheimer's, and the rest?
2:57Or are you encouraged by what's happening right now?
2:57Or are you encouraged by what's happening right now?
2:57Or are you encouraged by what's happening right now?
2:57Or are you encouraged by what's happening right now?
2:57Or are you encouraged by what's happening right now?
2:57Or are you encouraged by what's happening right now?
3:01I think maybe the general public doesn't quite know how excited biologists are about what's
3:01I think maybe the general public doesn't quite know how excited biologists are about what's
3:01I think maybe the general public doesn't quite know how excited biologists are about what's
3:01I think maybe the general public doesn't quite know how excited biologists are about what's
3:01I think maybe the general public doesn't quite know how excited biologists are about what's
3:01I think maybe the general public doesn't quite know how excited biologists are about what's
3:09possible. And maybe we've overpromised.
3:09possible. And maybe we've overpromised.
3:09possible. And maybe we've overpromised.
3:09possible. And maybe we've overpromised.
3:09possible. And maybe we've overpromised.
3:09possible. And maybe we've overpromised.
3:11Maybe in the past we've said we're on the brink of curing disease and people
3:11Maybe in the past we've said we're on the brink of curing disease and people
3:11Maybe in the past we've said we're on the brink of curing disease and people
3:11Maybe in the past we've said we're on the brink of curing disease and people
3:11Maybe in the past we've said we're on the brink of curing disease and people
3:11Maybe in the past we've said we're on the brink of curing disease and people
3:14haven't seen it. But something is materially different right now.
3:14haven't seen it. But something is materially different right now.
3:14haven't seen it. But something is materially different right now.
3:14haven't seen it. But something is materially different right now.
3:14haven't seen it. But something is materially different right now.
3:14haven't seen it. But something is materially different right now.
3:18And there is a convergence of so many different ways of understanding biology, but then
3:18And there is a convergence of so many different ways of understanding biology, but then
3:18And there is a convergence of so many different ways of understanding biology, but then
3:18And there is a convergence of so many different ways of understanding biology, but then
3:18And there is a convergence of so many different ways of understanding biology, but then
3:18And there is a convergence of so many different ways of understanding biology, but then
3:25not having that stop at understanding, but to actually intervene at the root causes of
3:25not having that stop at understanding, but to actually intervene at the root causes of
3:25not having that stop at understanding, but to actually intervene at the root causes of
3:25not having that stop at understanding, but to actually intervene at the root causes of
3:25not having that stop at understanding, but to actually intervene at the root causes of
3:25not having that stop at understanding, but to actually intervene at the root causes of
3:30disease. And over the course of this conversation, I imagine we're going to talk about
3:30disease. And over the course of this conversation, I imagine we're going to talk about
3:30disease. And over the course of this conversation, I imagine we're going to talk about
3:30disease. And over the course of this conversation, I imagine we're going to talk about
3:30disease. And over the course of this conversation, I imagine we're going to talk about
3:30disease. And over the course of this conversation, I imagine we're going to talk about
3:35DNA sequencing, understanding cells, but going all the way to rewriting specific DNA sequences inside
3:35DNA sequencing, understanding cells, but going all the way to rewriting specific DNA sequences inside
3:35DNA sequencing, understanding cells, but going all the way to rewriting specific DNA sequences inside
3:35DNA sequencing, understanding cells, but going all the way to rewriting specific DNA sequences inside
3:35DNA sequencing, understanding cells, but going all the way to rewriting specific DNA sequences inside
3:35DNA sequencing, understanding cells, but going all the way to rewriting specific DNA sequences inside
3:43of the cells of our immune system, doing this not one at a time, but
3:43of the cells of our immune system, doing this not one at a time, but
3:43of the cells of our immune system, doing this not one at a time, but
3:43of the cells of our immune system, doing this not one at a time, but
3:43of the cells of our immune system, doing this not one at a time, but
3:43of the cells of our immune system, doing this not one at a time, but
3:47testing every gene and understanding pieces of DNA throughout our entire genome to understand what
3:47testing every gene and understanding pieces of DNA throughout our entire genome to understand what
3:47testing every gene and understanding pieces of DNA throughout our entire genome to understand what
3:47testing every gene and understanding pieces of DNA throughout our entire genome to understand what
3:47testing every gene and understanding pieces of DNA throughout our entire genome to understand what
3:47testing every gene and understanding pieces of DNA throughout our entire genome to understand what
3:52controls our cells. And then being able to take that information and actually do something
3:52controls our cells. And then being able to take that information and actually do something
3:52controls our cells. And then being able to take that information and actually do something
3:52controls our cells. And then being able to take that information and actually do something
3:52controls our cells. And then being able to take that information and actually do something
3:52controls our cells. And then being able to take that information and actually do something
3:56about it to boost our immune system to go after cancer, to balance it for
3:56about it to boost our immune system to go after cancer, to balance it for
3:56about it to boost our immune system to go after cancer, to balance it for
3:56about it to boost our immune system to go after cancer, to balance it for
3:56about it to boost our immune system to go after cancer, to balance it for
3:56about it to boost our immune system to go after cancer, to balance it for
4:02inflammation and autoimmunity. And that doesn't just have to be sort of searching for a
4:02inflammation and autoimmunity. And that doesn't just have to be sort of searching for a
4:02inflammation and autoimmunity. And that doesn't just have to be sort of searching for a
4:02inflammation and autoimmunity. And that doesn't just have to be sort of searching for a
4:02inflammation and autoimmunity. And that doesn't just have to be sort of searching for a
4:02inflammation and autoimmunity. And that doesn't just have to be sort of searching for a
4:08pill. All of a sudden we can actually talk to our own cells and give
4:08pill. All of a sudden we can actually talk to our own cells and give
4:08pill. All of a sudden we can actually talk to our own cells and give
4:08pill. All of a sudden we can actually talk to our own cells and give
4:08pill. All of a sudden we can actually talk to our own cells and give
4:08pill. All of a sudden we can actually talk to our own cells and give
4:12them instructions in the language of DNA and the language of molecular biology.
4:12them instructions in the language of DNA and the language of molecular biology.
4:12them instructions in the language of DNA and the language of molecular biology.
4:12them instructions in the language of DNA and the language of molecular biology.
4:12them instructions in the language of DNA and the language of molecular biology.
4:12them instructions in the language of DNA and the language of molecular biology.
4:16And in some instances this is being done with CRISPR, but it's also being done
4:16And in some instances this is being done with CRISPR, but it's also being done
4:16And in some instances this is being done with CRISPR, but it's also being done
4:16And in some instances this is being done with CRISPR, but it's also being done
4:16And in some instances this is being done with CRISPR, but it's also being done
4:16And in some instances this is being done with CRISPR, but it's also being done
4:21with lipid nanoparticles and vaccines and we're still inventing new ways of giving these instructions.
4:21with lipid nanoparticles and vaccines and we're still inventing new ways of giving these instructions.
4:21with lipid nanoparticles and vaccines and we're still inventing new ways of giving these instructions.
4:21with lipid nanoparticles and vaccines and we're still inventing new ways of giving these instructions.
4:21with lipid nanoparticles and vaccines and we're still inventing new ways of giving these instructions.
4:21with lipid nanoparticles and vaccines and we're still inventing new ways of giving these instructions.
4:28But all of a sudden medicine is programming the behavior of cells in a way
4:28But all of a sudden medicine is programming the behavior of cells in a way
4:28But all of a sudden medicine is programming the behavior of cells in a way
4:28But all of a sudden medicine is programming the behavior of cells in a way
4:28But all of a sudden medicine is programming the behavior of cells in a way
4:28But all of a sudden medicine is programming the behavior of cells in a way
4:33that's much more directed than was ever conceivable before.
4:33that's much more directed than was ever conceivable before.
4:33that's much more directed than was ever conceivable before.
4:33that's much more directed than was ever conceivable before.
4:33that's much more directed than was ever conceivable before.
4:33that's much more directed than was ever conceivable before.
4:38Like there's really a step function in what's imaginable and achievable in medicine.
4:38Like there's really a step function in what's imaginable and achievable in medicine.
4:38Like there's really a step function in what's imaginable and achievable in medicine.
4:38Like there's really a step function in what's imaginable and achievable in medicine.
4:38Like there's really a step function in what's imaginable and achievable in medicine.
4:38Like there's really a step function in what's imaginable and achievable in medicine.
4:42Super exciting. Do you think that molecular biology and genetic engineering and or AI are
4:42Super exciting. Do you think that molecular biology and genetic engineering and or AI are
4:42Super exciting. Do you think that molecular biology and genetic engineering and or AI are
4:42Super exciting. Do you think that molecular biology and genetic engineering and or AI are
4:42Super exciting. Do you think that molecular biology and genetic engineering and or AI are
4:42Super exciting. Do you think that molecular biology and genetic engineering and or AI are
4:50the reasons that things are on this accelerated timeline?
4:50the reasons that things are on this accelerated timeline?
4:50the reasons that things are on this accelerated timeline?
4:50the reasons that things are on this accelerated timeline?
4:50the reasons that things are on this accelerated timeline?
4:50the reasons that things are on this accelerated timeline?
4:54Yes is the answer. All of those things.
4:54Yes is the answer. All of those things.
4:54Yes is the answer. All of those things.
4:54Yes is the answer. All of those things.
4:54Yes is the answer. All of those things.
4:54Yes is the answer. All of those things.
4:56I think we can do experiments at a different level of scale.
4:56I think we can do experiments at a different level of scale.
4:56I think we can do experiments at a different level of scale.
4:56I think we can do experiments at a different level of scale.
4:56I think we can do experiments at a different level of scale.
4:56I think we can do experiments at a different level of scale.
5:01We can generate data. And then we have the computational tools, including AI, but we
5:01We can generate data. And then we have the computational tools, including AI, but we
5:01We can generate data. And then we have the computational tools, including AI, but we
5:01We can generate data. And then we have the computational tools, including AI, but we
5:01We can generate data. And then we have the computational tools, including AI, but we
5:01We can generate data. And then we have the computational tools, including AI, but we
5:06have computational sophistication to actually extract insights from massive amounts of data.
5:06have computational sophistication to actually extract insights from massive amounts of data.
5:06have computational sophistication to actually extract insights from massive amounts of data.
5:06have computational sophistication to actually extract insights from massive amounts of data.
5:06have computational sophistication to actually extract insights from massive amounts of data.
5:06have computational sophistication to actually extract insights from massive amounts of data.
5:15And, you know, I think historically biology was, we were, it was an observational science,
5:15And, you know, I think historically biology was, we were, it was an observational science,
5:15And, you know, I think historically biology was, we were, it was an observational science,
5:15And, you know, I think historically biology was, we were, it was an observational science,
5:15And, you know, I think historically biology was, we were, it was an observational science,
5:15And, you know, I think historically biology was, we were, it was an observational science,
5:21especially if you wanted to study things in humans.
5:21especially if you wanted to study things in humans.
5:21especially if you wanted to study things in humans.
5:21especially if you wanted to study things in humans.
5:21especially if you wanted to study things in humans.
5:21especially if you wanted to study things in humans.
5:23There was... in a way to intervene.
5:23There was... in a way to intervene.
5:23There was... in a way to intervene.
5:23There was... in a way to intervene.
5:23There was... in a way to intervene.
5:23There was... in a way to intervene.
5:25Now all of a sudden we're taking human cells, we're taking them into the lab
5:25Now all of a sudden we're taking human cells, we're taking them into the lab
5:25Now all of a sudden we're taking human cells, we're taking them into the lab
5:25Now all of a sudden we're taking human cells, we're taking them into the lab
5:25Now all of a sudden we're taking human cells, we're taking them into the lab
5:25Now all of a sudden we're taking human cells, we're taking them into the lab
5:28and making genetic changes and reading out the consequences and directly being able to observe
5:28and making genetic changes and reading out the consequences and directly being able to observe
5:28and making genetic changes and reading out the consequences and directly being able to observe
5:28and making genetic changes and reading out the consequences and directly being able to observe
5:28and making genetic changes and reading out the consequences and directly being able to observe
5:28and making genetic changes and reading out the consequences and directly being able to observe
5:35the effect. And we have tools to do this with imaging, we have the tools
5:35the effect. And we have tools to do this with imaging, we have the tools
5:35the effect. And we have tools to do this with imaging, we have the tools
5:35the effect. And we have tools to do this with imaging, we have the tools
5:35the effect. And we have tools to do this with imaging, we have the tools
5:35the effect. And we have tools to do this with imaging, we have the tools
5:42to do this with DNA sequencing, and we can take this all the way into
5:42to do this with DNA sequencing, and we can take this all the way into
5:42to do this with DNA sequencing, and we can take this all the way into
5:42to do this with DNA sequencing, and we can take this all the way into
5:42to do this with DNA sequencing, and we can take this all the way into
5:42to do this with DNA sequencing, and we can take this all the way into
5:46clinical trials and see what are the consequences when we actually go after targeted DNA
5:46clinical trials and see what are the consequences when we actually go after targeted DNA
5:46clinical trials and see what are the consequences when we actually go after targeted DNA
5:46clinical trials and see what are the consequences when we actually go after targeted DNA
5:46clinical trials and see what are the consequences when we actually go after targeted DNA
5:46clinical trials and see what are the consequences when we actually go after targeted DNA
5:51sequences and make our cells better at treating disease.
5:51sequences and make our cells better at treating disease.
5:51sequences and make our cells better at treating disease.
5:51sequences and make our cells better at treating disease.
5:51sequences and make our cells better at treating disease.
5:51sequences and make our cells better at treating disease.
5:56Would you mind educating us about the immune system a bit, the adaptive and the
5:56Would you mind educating us about the immune system a bit, the adaptive and the
5:56Would you mind educating us about the immune system a bit, the adaptive and the
5:56Would you mind educating us about the immune system a bit, the adaptive and the
5:56Would you mind educating us about the immune system a bit, the adaptive and the
5:56Would you mind educating us about the immune system a bit, the adaptive and the
6:01innate immune system, some of the major cell types, because I think those are going
6:01innate immune system, some of the major cell types, because I think those are going
6:01innate immune system, some of the major cell types, because I think those are going
6:01innate immune system, some of the major cell types, because I think those are going
6:01innate immune system, some of the major cell types, because I think those are going
6:01innate immune system, some of the major cell types, because I think those are going
6:04to form the kind of building blocks of our discussions about cancer and other things
6:04to form the kind of building blocks of our discussions about cancer and other things
6:04to form the kind of building blocks of our discussions about cancer and other things
6:04to form the kind of building blocks of our discussions about cancer and other things
6:04to form the kind of building blocks of our discussions about cancer and other things
6:04to form the kind of building blocks of our discussions about cancer and other things
6:09today. Our immune system permeates almost every aspect of our health and disease.
6:09today. Our immune system permeates almost every aspect of our health and disease.
6:09today. Our immune system permeates almost every aspect of our health and disease.
6:09today. Our immune system permeates almost every aspect of our health and disease.
6:09today. Our immune system permeates almost every aspect of our health and disease.
6:09today. Our immune system permeates almost every aspect of our health and disease.
6:14It is a system really in the sense of it's involved in every part of
6:14It is a system really in the sense of it's involved in every part of
6:14It is a system really in the sense of it's involved in every part of
6:14It is a system really in the sense of it's involved in every part of
6:14It is a system really in the sense of it's involved in every part of
6:14It is a system really in the sense of it's involved in every part of
6:20our body that has evolved to protect us, largely to protect us against infections, viruses,
6:20our body that has evolved to protect us, largely to protect us against infections, viruses,
6:20our body that has evolved to protect us, largely to protect us against infections, viruses,
6:20our body that has evolved to protect us, largely to protect us against infections, viruses,
6:20our body that has evolved to protect us, largely to protect us against infections, viruses,
6:20our body that has evolved to protect us, largely to protect us against infections, viruses,
6:27bacteria, fungus, all sorts of foreign invasions.
6:27bacteria, fungus, all sorts of foreign invasions.
6:27bacteria, fungus, all sorts of foreign invasions.
6:27bacteria, fungus, all sorts of foreign invasions.
6:27bacteria, fungus, all sorts of foreign invasions.
6:27bacteria, fungus, all sorts of foreign invasions.
6:31And our immune system has developed a balance that when it's working properly doesn't recognize
6:31And our immune system has developed a balance that when it's working properly doesn't recognize
6:31And our immune system has developed a balance that when it's working properly doesn't recognize
6:31And our immune system has developed a balance that when it's working properly doesn't recognize
6:31And our immune system has developed a balance that when it's working properly doesn't recognize
6:31And our immune system has developed a balance that when it's working properly doesn't recognize
6:39the cells that are supposed to be in the body, but is finely tuned to
6:39the cells that are supposed to be in the body, but is finely tuned to
6:39the cells that are supposed to be in the body, but is finely tuned to
6:39the cells that are supposed to be in the body, but is finely tuned to
6:39the cells that are supposed to be in the body, but is finely tuned to
6:39the cells that are supposed to be in the body, but is finely tuned to
6:44recognize signs of things that shouldn't be in the body and to eliminate them.
6:44recognize signs of things that shouldn't be in the body and to eliminate them.
6:44recognize signs of things that shouldn't be in the body and to eliminate them.
6:44recognize signs of things that shouldn't be in the body and to eliminate them.
6:44recognize signs of things that shouldn't be in the body and to eliminate them.
6:44recognize signs of things that shouldn't be in the body and to eliminate them.
6:48I mean, at its core, that's the basic job of the immune system.
6:48I mean, at its core, that's the basic job of the immune system.
6:48I mean, at its core, that's the basic job of the immune system.
6:48I mean, at its core, that's the basic job of the immune system.
6:48I mean, at its core, that's the basic job of the immune system.
6:48I mean, at its core, that's the basic job of the immune system.
6:53To recognize us versus non -us.
6:53To recognize us versus non -us.
6:53To recognize us versus non -us.
6:53To recognize us versus non -us.
6:53To recognize us versus non -us.
6:53To recognize us versus non -us.
6:56Exactly. And you talked about the innate versus the adaptive immune system.
6:56Exactly. And you talked about the innate versus the adaptive immune system.
6:56Exactly. And you talked about the innate versus the adaptive immune system.
6:56Exactly. And you talked about the innate versus the adaptive immune system.
6:56Exactly. And you talked about the innate versus the adaptive immune system.
6:56Exactly. And you talked about the innate versus the adaptive immune system.
7:02Largely what we're talking about are white blood cells.
7:02Largely what we're talking about are white blood cells.
7:02Largely what we're talking about are white blood cells.
7:02Largely what we're talking about are white blood cells.
7:02Largely what we're talking about are white blood cells.
7:02Largely what we're talking about are white blood cells.
7:05We're talking about different types of white blood cells that are either inside of tissues
7:05We're talking about different types of white blood cells that are either inside of tissues
7:05We're talking about different types of white blood cells that are either inside of tissues
7:05We're talking about different types of white blood cells that are either inside of tissues
7:05We're talking about different types of white blood cells that are either inside of tissues
7:05We're talking about different types of white blood cells that are either inside of tissues
7:10or circulating in our bloodstream that go around and play coordinated and specialized roles in
7:10or circulating in our bloodstream that go around and play coordinated and specialized roles in
7:10or circulating in our bloodstream that go around and play coordinated and specialized roles in
7:10or circulating in our bloodstream that go around and play coordinated and specialized roles in
7:10or circulating in our bloodstream that go around and play coordinated and specialized roles in
7:10or circulating in our bloodstream that go around and play coordinated and specialized roles in
7:18sensing when something comes in that is not us, that's foreign, that shouldn't be there.
7:18sensing when something comes in that is not us, that's foreign, that shouldn't be there.
7:18sensing when something comes in that is not us, that's foreign, that shouldn't be there.
7:18sensing when something comes in that is not us, that's foreign, that shouldn't be there.
7:18sensing when something comes in that is not us, that's foreign, that shouldn't be there.
7:18sensing when something comes in that is not us, that's foreign, that shouldn't be there.
7:24The innate immune system is sort of thought of as the first alarm system, that
7:24The innate immune system is sort of thought of as the first alarm system, that
7:24The innate immune system is sort of thought of as the first alarm system, that
7:24The innate immune system is sort of thought of as the first alarm system, that
7:24The innate immune system is sort of thought of as the first alarm system, that
7:24The innate immune system is sort of thought of as the first alarm system, that
7:29something's wrong. And with the innate immune system, which consists of cells like dendritic cells,
7:29something's wrong. And with the innate immune system, which consists of cells like dendritic cells,
7:29something's wrong. And with the innate immune system, which consists of cells like dendritic cells,
7:29something's wrong. And with the innate immune system, which consists of cells like dendritic cells,
7:29something's wrong. And with the innate immune system, which consists of cells like dendritic cells,
7:29something's wrong. And with the innate immune system, which consists of cells like dendritic cells,
7:36macrophages, these are cells that are going around and they're looking for patterns of things
7:36macrophages, these are cells that are going around and they're looking for patterns of things
7:36macrophages, these are cells that are going around and they're looking for patterns of things
7:36macrophages, these are cells that are going around and they're looking for patterns of things
7:36macrophages, these are cells that are going around and they're looking for patterns of things
7:36macrophages, these are cells that are going around and they're looking for patterns of things
7:43that just generally aren't in human cells.
7:43that just generally aren't in human cells.
7:43that just generally aren't in human cells.
7:43that just generally aren't in human cells.
7:43that just generally aren't in human cells.
7:43that just generally aren't in human cells.
7:46Some signs of damage, some signs of things that shouldn't be there in a generic
7:46Some signs of damage, some signs of things that shouldn't be there in a generic
7:46Some signs of damage, some signs of things that shouldn't be there in a generic
7:46Some signs of damage, some signs of things that shouldn't be there in a generic
7:46Some signs of damage, some signs of things that shouldn't be there in a generic
7:46Some signs of damage, some signs of things that shouldn't be there in a generic
7:51way in a healthy human.
7:51way in a healthy human.
7:51way in a healthy human.
7:51way in a healthy human.
7:51way in a healthy human.
7:51way in a healthy human.
7:53When those first alarm systems get triggered, all of a sudden these innate immune systems
7:53When those first alarm systems get triggered, all of a sudden these innate immune systems
7:53When those first alarm systems get triggered, all of a sudden these innate immune systems
7:53When those first alarm systems get triggered, all of a sudden these innate immune systems
7:53When those first alarm systems get triggered, all of a sudden these innate immune systems
7:53When those first alarm systems get triggered, all of a sudden these innate immune systems
7:58start releasing things, they change their state, and they send off an alarm to other
7:58start releasing things, they change their state, and they send off an alarm to other
7:58start releasing things, they change their state, and they send off an alarm to other
7:58start releasing things, they change their state, and they send off an alarm to other
7:58start releasing things, they change their state, and they send off an alarm to other
7:58start releasing things, they change their state, and they send off an alarm to other
8:03cells in the immune system.
8:03cells in the immune system.
8:03cells in the immune system.
8:03cells in the immune system.
8:03cells in the immune system.
8:03cells in the immune system.
8:05And then they often recruit in the second arm of the immune system that you
8:05And then they often recruit in the second arm of the immune system that you
8:05And then they often recruit in the second arm of the immune system that you
8:05And then they often recruit in the second arm of the immune system that you
8:05And then they often recruit in the second arm of the immune system that you
8:05And then they often recruit in the second arm of the immune system that you
8:09mentioned, the adaptive immune system.
8:09mentioned, the adaptive immune system.
8:09mentioned, the adaptive immune system.
8:09mentioned, the adaptive immune system.
8:09mentioned, the adaptive immune system.
8:09mentioned, the adaptive immune system.
8:12We'll talk a lot about the adaptive immune system today.
8:12We'll talk a lot about the adaptive immune system today.
8:12We'll talk a lot about the adaptive immune system today.
8:12We'll talk a lot about the adaptive immune system today.
8:12We'll talk a lot about the adaptive immune system today.
8:12We'll talk a lot about the adaptive immune system today.
8:15And the major players in the adaptive immune system are a group of white blood
8:15And the major players in the adaptive immune system are a group of white blood
8:15And the major players in the adaptive immune system are a group of white blood
8:15And the major players in the adaptive immune system are a group of white blood
8:15And the major players in the adaptive immune system are a group of white blood
8:15And the major players in the adaptive immune system are a group of white blood
8:20cells that are collectively known as lymphocytes.
8:20cells that are collectively known as lymphocytes.
8:20cells that are collectively known as lymphocytes.
8:20cells that are collectively known as lymphocytes.
8:20cells that are collectively known as lymphocytes.
8:20cells that are collectively known as lymphocytes.
8:23But we'll talk about B cells and T cells in particular, which are major groups
8:23But we'll talk about B cells and T cells in particular, which are major groups
8:23But we'll talk about B cells and T cells in particular, which are major groups
8:23But we'll talk about B cells and T cells in particular, which are major groups
8:23But we'll talk about B cells and T cells in particular, which are major groups
8:23But we'll talk about B cells and T cells in particular, which are major groups
8:28of lymphocytes. We've been focused heavily on T cells.
8:28of lymphocytes. We've been focused heavily on T cells.
8:28of lymphocytes. We've been focused heavily on T cells.
8:28of lymphocytes. We've been focused heavily on T cells.
8:28of lymphocytes. We've been focused heavily on T cells.
8:28of lymphocytes. We've been focused heavily on T cells.
8:33T cells play a central role in coordinating the fine -tuning of the immune response.
8:33T cells play a central role in coordinating the fine -tuning of the immune response.
8:33T cells play a central role in coordinating the fine -tuning of the immune response.
8:33T cells play a central role in coordinating the fine -tuning of the immune response.
8:33T cells play a central role in coordinating the fine -tuning of the immune response.
8:33T cells play a central role in coordinating the fine -tuning of the immune response.
8:39One of the amazing things about the T cells is that each T cell naturally
8:39One of the amazing things about the T cells is that each T cell naturally
8:39One of the amazing things about the T cells is that each T cell naturally
8:39One of the amazing things about the T cells is that each T cell naturally
8:39One of the amazing things about the T cells is that each T cell naturally
8:39One of the amazing things about the T cells is that each T cell naturally
8:42in our body is one of the few places where each cell will actually have
8:42in our body is one of the few places where each cell will actually have
8:42in our body is one of the few places where each cell will actually have
8:42in our body is one of the few places where each cell will actually have
8:42in our body is one of the few places where each cell will actually have
8:42in our body is one of the few places where each cell will actually have
8:47a different piece of DNA that's not inherited in our germline sequence.
8:47a different piece of DNA that's not inherited in our germline sequence.
8:47a different piece of DNA that's not inherited in our germline sequence.
8:47a different piece of DNA that's not inherited in our germline sequence.
8:47a different piece of DNA that's not inherited in our germline sequence.
8:47a different piece of DNA that's not inherited in our germline sequence.
8:51Each T cell will make its own receptor that is generated largely at random to
8:51Each T cell will make its own receptor that is generated largely at random to
8:51Each T cell will make its own receptor that is generated largely at random to
8:51Each T cell will make its own receptor that is generated largely at random to
8:51Each T cell will make its own receptor that is generated largely at random to
8:51Each T cell will make its own receptor that is generated largely at random to
8:59go and sense something. And those sensors that get put on the surface of T
8:59go and sense something. And those sensors that get put on the surface of T
8:59go and sense something. And those sensors that get put on the surface of T
8:59go and sense something. And those sensors that get put on the surface of T
8:59go and sense something. And those sensors that get put on the surface of T
8:59go and sense something. And those sensors that get put on the surface of T
9:05cells are there to engage.
9:05cells are there to engage.
9:05cells are there to engage.
9:05cells are there to engage.
9:05cells are there to engage.
9:05cells are there to engage.
9:07And if they're engaged, it's a sign that something has been recognized as foreign.
9:07And if they're engaged, it's a sign that something has been recognized as foreign.
9:07And if they're engaged, it's a sign that something has been recognized as foreign.
9:07And if they're engaged, it's a sign that something has been recognized as foreign.
9:07And if they're engaged, it's a sign that something has been recognized as foreign.
9:07And if they're engaged, it's a sign that something has been recognized as foreign.
9:11And so we have this incredible diversity of different T cell receptors that have developed
9:11And so we have this incredible diversity of different T cell receptors that have developed
9:11And so we have this incredible diversity of different T cell receptors that have developed
9:11And so we have this incredible diversity of different T cell receptors that have developed
9:11And so we have this incredible diversity of different T cell receptors that have developed
9:11And so we have this incredible diversity of different T cell receptors that have developed
9:19on our T cells. Each one will have a different, unique receptor on its surface.
9:19on our T cells. Each one will have a different, unique receptor on its surface.
9:19on our T cells. Each one will have a different, unique receptor on its surface.
9:19on our T cells. Each one will have a different, unique receptor on its surface.
9:19on our T cells. Each one will have a different, unique receptor on its surface.
9:19on our T cells. Each one will have a different, unique receptor on its surface.
9:23Each cell will have a different receptor on its surface.
9:23Each cell will have a different receptor on its surface.
9:23Each cell will have a different receptor on its surface.
9:23Each cell will have a different receptor on its surface.
9:23Each cell will have a different receptor on its surface.
9:23Each cell will have a different receptor on its surface.
9:26And the way to think about these receptors is that they're sensors.
9:26And the way to think about these receptors is that they're sensors.
9:26And the way to think about these receptors is that they're sensors.
9:26And the way to think about these receptors is that they're sensors.
9:26And the way to think about these receptors is that they're sensors.
9:26And the way to think about these receptors is that they're sensors.
9:31When they're engaged, they send a signal to the T cell that, okay, we found
9:31When they're engaged, they send a signal to the T cell that, okay, we found
9:31When they're engaged, they send a signal to the T cell that, okay, we found
9:31When they're engaged, they send a signal to the T cell that, okay, we found
9:31When they're engaged, they send a signal to the T cell that, okay, we found
9:31When they're engaged, they send a signal to the T cell that, okay, we found
9:35something that you've been programmed to recognize.
9:35something that you've been programmed to recognize.
9:35something that you've been programmed to recognize.
9:35something that you've been programmed to recognize.
9:35something that you've been programmed to recognize.
9:35something that you've been programmed to recognize.
9:38And the program is recognized as far and if the immune system is working properly.
9:38And the program is recognized as far and if the immune system is working properly.
9:38And the program is recognized as far and if the immune system is working properly.
9:38And the program is recognized as far and if the immune system is working properly.
9:38And the program is recognized as far and if the immune system is working properly.
9:38And the program is recognized as far and if the immune system is working properly.
9:42And are the genes that these T cells make as these receptors, are those based
9:42And are the genes that these T cells make as these receptors, are those based
9:42And are the genes that these T cells make as these receptors, are those based
9:42And are the genes that these T cells make as these receptors, are those based
9:42And are the genes that these T cells make as these receptors, are those based
9:42And are the genes that these T cells make as these receptors, are those based
9:47on experience of the organism?
9:47on experience of the organism?
9:47on experience of the organism?
9:47on experience of the organism?
9:47on experience of the organism?
9:47on experience of the organism?
9:49Because you said that it doesn't come from the germline, but we should clarify that
9:49Because you said that it doesn't come from the germline, but we should clarify that
9:49Because you said that it doesn't come from the germline, but we should clarify that
9:49Because you said that it doesn't come from the germline, but we should clarify that
9:49Because you said that it doesn't come from the germline, but we should clarify that
9:49Because you said that it doesn't come from the germline, but we should clarify that
9:52the germline is not about infectious germs in this context.
9:52the germline is not about infectious germs in this context.
9:52the germline is not about infectious germs in this context.
9:52the germline is not about infectious germs in this context.
9:52the germline is not about infectious germs in this context.
9:52the germline is not about infectious germs in this context.
9:55The germline DNA is from the sperm and egg that were your parents.
9:55The germline DNA is from the sperm and egg that were your parents.
9:55The germline DNA is from the sperm and egg that were your parents.
9:55The germline DNA is from the sperm and egg that were your parents.
9:55The germline DNA is from the sperm and egg that were your parents.
9:55The germline DNA is from the sperm and egg that were your parents.
10:01It became you. There's recombination of those genes.
10:01It became you. There's recombination of those genes.
10:01It became you. There's recombination of those genes.
10:01It became you. There's recombination of those genes.
10:01It became you. There's recombination of those genes.
10:01It became you. There's recombination of those genes.
10:03And then there's you, all, each and all.
10:03And then there's you, all, each and all.
10:03And then there's you, all, each and all.
10:03And then there's you, all, each and all.
10:03And then there's you, all, each and all.
10:03And then there's you, all, each and all.
10:06And the T cells are making genes that neither your parents necessarily expressed nor that
10:06And the T cells are making genes that neither your parents necessarily expressed nor that
10:06And the T cells are making genes that neither your parents necessarily expressed nor that
10:06And the T cells are making genes that neither your parents necessarily expressed nor that
10:06And the T cells are making genes that neither your parents necessarily expressed nor that
10:06And the T cells are making genes that neither your parents necessarily expressed nor that
10:11you were expected to express except based on what?
10:11you were expected to express except based on what?
10:11you were expected to express except based on what?
10:11you were expected to express except based on what?
10:11you were expected to express except based on what?
10:11you were expected to express except based on what?
10:14Exposure to particular pathogens? Like why do they make certain receptors and not others?
10:14Exposure to particular pathogens? Like why do they make certain receptors and not others?
10:14Exposure to particular pathogens? Like why do they make certain receptors and not others?
10:14Exposure to particular pathogens? Like why do they make certain receptors and not others?
10:14Exposure to particular pathogens? Like why do they make certain receptors and not others?
10:14Exposure to particular pathogens? Like why do they make certain receptors and not others?
10:19Largely random. It's actually, there's the pieces of DNA at this part of the DNA
10:19Largely random. It's actually, there's the pieces of DNA at this part of the DNA
10:19Largely random. It's actually, there's the pieces of DNA at this part of the DNA
10:19Largely random. It's actually, there's the pieces of DNA at this part of the DNA
10:19Largely random. It's actually, there's the pieces of DNA at this part of the DNA
10:19Largely random. It's actually, there's the pieces of DNA at this part of the DNA
10:25actually recombine and get pasted together in unique ways.
10:25actually recombine and get pasted together in unique ways.
10:25actually recombine and get pasted together in unique ways.
10:25actually recombine and get pasted together in unique ways.
10:25actually recombine and get pasted together in unique ways.
10:25actually recombine and get pasted together in unique ways.
10:30So it's probabilistic. It's probabilistic.
10:30So it's probabilistic. It's probabilistic.
10:30So it's probabilistic. It's probabilistic.
10:30So it's probabilistic. It's probabilistic.
10:30So it's probabilistic. It's probabilistic.
10:30So it's probabilistic. It's probabilistic.
10:32And that's what allows us to have cells that lying there and waiting for things
10:32And that's what allows us to have cells that lying there and waiting for things
10:32And that's what allows us to have cells that lying there and waiting for things
10:32And that's what allows us to have cells that lying there and waiting for things
10:32And that's what allows us to have cells that lying there and waiting for things
10:32And that's what allows us to have cells that lying there and waiting for things
10:38that we've never encountered. If a bacteria might come into existence or a virus might
10:38that we've never encountered. If a bacteria might come into existence or a virus might
10:38that we've never encountered. If a bacteria might come into existence or a virus might
10:38that we've never encountered. If a bacteria might come into existence or a virus might
10:38that we've never encountered. If a bacteria might come into existence or a virus might
10:38that we've never encountered. If a bacteria might come into existence or a virus might
10:43come into existence that doesn't even exist now in nature, but we might have T
10:43come into existence that doesn't even exist now in nature, but we might have T
10:43come into existence that doesn't even exist now in nature, but we might have T
10:43come into existence that doesn't even exist now in nature, but we might have T
10:43come into existence that doesn't even exist now in nature, but we might have T
10:43come into existence that doesn't even exist now in nature, but we might have T
10:47cells lying there waiting that could be engaged by those.
10:47cells lying there waiting that could be engaged by those.
10:47cells lying there waiting that could be engaged by those.
10:47cells lying there waiting that could be engaged by those.
10:47cells lying there waiting that could be engaged by those.
10:47cells lying there waiting that could be engaged by those.
10:51And that's what we're trying to do to do to do to do to do
10:51And that's what we're trying to do to do to do to do to do
10:51And that's what we're trying to do to do to do to do to do
10:51And that's what we're trying to do to do to do to do to do
10:51And that's what we're trying to do to do to do to do to do
10:51And that's what we're trying to do to do to do to do to do
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51do to do to do to do to do to do to do to do
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51to do to do to do to do to do to do to do to
10:51do to do to do to do to do proteins on the surface that viruses
10:51do to do to do to do to do proteins on the surface that viruses
10:51do to do to do to do to do proteins on the surface that viruses
10:51do to do to do to do to do proteins on the surface that viruses
10:51do to do to do to do to do proteins on the surface that viruses
10:51do to do to do to do to do proteins on the surface that viruses
10:54would introduce. That's incredible. Would you mind mentioning the role of the thymus?
10:54would introduce. That's incredible. Would you mind mentioning the role of the thymus?
10:54would introduce. That's incredible. Would you mind mentioning the role of the thymus?
10:54would introduce. That's incredible. Would you mind mentioning the role of the thymus?
10:54would introduce. That's incredible. Would you mind mentioning the role of the thymus?
10:54would introduce. That's incredible. Would you mind mentioning the role of the thymus?
10:58These days I'm hearing more and more about we have a thymus and we lose
10:58These days I'm hearing more and more about we have a thymus and we lose
10:58These days I'm hearing more and more about we have a thymus and we lose
10:58These days I'm hearing more and more about we have a thymus and we lose
10:58These days I'm hearing more and more about we have a thymus and we lose
10:58These days I'm hearing more and more about we have a thymus and we lose
11:01a thymus. Would it be beneficial if we could keep our thymus around?
11:01a thymus. Would it be beneficial if we could keep our thymus around?
11:01a thymus. Would it be beneficial if we could keep our thymus around?
11:01a thymus. Would it be beneficial if we could keep our thymus around?
11:01a thymus. Would it be beneficial if we could keep our thymus around?
11:01a thymus. Would it be beneficial if we could keep our thymus around?
11:04So thymus is actually the reason the T cells are called T cells is the
11:04So thymus is actually the reason the T cells are called T cells is the
11:04So thymus is actually the reason the T cells are called T cells is the
11:04So thymus is actually the reason the T cells are called T cells is the
11:04So thymus is actually the reason the T cells are called T cells is the
11:04So thymus is actually the reason the T cells are called T cells is the
11:10T stands for thymus. And the thymus is an organ that it does sort of
11:10T stands for thymus. And the thymus is an organ that it does sort of
11:10T stands for thymus. And the thymus is an organ that it does sort of
11:10T stands for thymus. And the thymus is an organ that it does sort of
11:10T stands for thymus. And the thymus is an organ that it does sort of
11:10T stands for thymus. And the thymus is an organ that it does sort of
11:16shrink as we age. But at least in childhood, it sort of lies by your
11:16shrink as we age. But at least in childhood, it sort of lies by your
11:16shrink as we age. But at least in childhood, it sort of lies by your
11:16shrink as we age. But at least in childhood, it sort of lies by your
11:16shrink as we age. But at least in childhood, it sort of lies by your
11:16shrink as we age. But at least in childhood, it sort of lies by your
11:20heart. And it is the place where T cells go in a key place of
11:20heart. And it is the place where T cells go in a key place of
11:20heart. And it is the place where T cells go in a key place of
11:20heart. And it is the place where T cells go in a key place of
11:20heart. And it is the place where T cells go in a key place of
11:20heart. And it is the place where T cells go in a key place of
11:24their education. So they are making these sensors largely at random.
11:24their education. So they are making these sensors largely at random.
11:24their education. So they are making these sensors largely at random.
11:24their education. So they are making these sensors largely at random.
11:24their education. So they are making these sensors largely at random.
11:24their education. So they are making these sensors largely at random.
11:30And in the thymus they get called.
11:30And in the thymus they get called.
11:30And in the thymus they get called.
11:30And in the thymus they get called.
11:30And in the thymus they get called.
11:30And in the thymus they get called.
11:33They get selected. And the ones that by accident are generated that recognize something that
11:33They get selected. And the ones that by accident are generated that recognize something that
11:33They get selected. And the ones that by accident are generated that recognize something that
11:33They get selected. And the ones that by accident are generated that recognize something that
11:33They get selected. And the ones that by accident are generated that recognize something that
11:33They get selected. And the ones that by accident are generated that recognize something that
11:41is supposed to be in your body, if the T cell engages a natural target
11:41is supposed to be in your body, if the T cell engages a natural target
11:41is supposed to be in your body, if the T cell engages a natural target
11:41is supposed to be in your body, if the T cell engages a natural target
11:41is supposed to be in your body, if the T cell engages a natural target
11:41is supposed to be in your body, if the T cell engages a natural target
11:46in the thymus, those cells will die.
11:46in the thymus, those cells will die.
11:46in the thymus, those cells will die.
11:46in the thymus, those cells will die.
11:46in the thymus, those cells will die.
11:46in the thymus, those cells will die.
11:49And so what emerges from the thymus should be, and this is not a perfect
11:49And so what emerges from the thymus should be, and this is not a perfect
11:49And so what emerges from the thymus should be, and this is not a perfect
11:49And so what emerges from the thymus should be, and this is not a perfect
11:49And so what emerges from the thymus should be, and this is not a perfect
11:49And so what emerges from the thymus should be, and this is not a perfect
11:53process, but should be things that have emerged at random but then are selected to
11:53process, but should be things that have emerged at random but then are selected to
11:53process, but should be things that have emerged at random but then are selected to
11:53process, but should be things that have emerged at random but then are selected to
11:53process, but should be things that have emerged at random but then are selected to
11:53process, but should be things that have emerged at random but then are selected to
11:59remove things that recognize your own body targets.
11:59remove things that recognize your own body targets.
11:59remove things that recognize your own body targets.
11:59remove things that recognize your own body targets.
11:59remove things that recognize your own body targets.
11:59remove things that recognize your own body targets.
12:02There's sort of a negative selection of the stuff that's you so that your immune
12:02There's sort of a negative selection of the stuff that's you so that your immune
12:02There's sort of a negative selection of the stuff that's you so that your immune
12:02There's sort of a negative selection of the stuff that's you so that your immune
12:02There's sort of a negative selection of the stuff that's you so that your immune
12:02There's sort of a negative selection of the stuff that's you so that your immune
12:06system doesn't attack you and it knows you from non -you.
12:06system doesn't attack you and it knows you from non -you.
12:06system doesn't attack you and it knows you from non -you.
12:06system doesn't attack you and it knows you from non -you.
12:06system doesn't attack you and it knows you from non -you.
12:06system doesn't attack you and it knows you from non -you.
12:10Yeah, that's exactly right. There's actually both a positive selection and a negative selection.
12:10Yeah, that's exactly right. There's actually both a positive selection and a negative selection.
12:10Yeah, that's exactly right. There's actually both a positive selection and a negative selection.
12:10Yeah, that's exactly right. There's actually both a positive selection and a negative selection.
12:10Yeah, that's exactly right. There's actually both a positive selection and a negative selection.
12:10Yeah, that's exactly right. There's actually both a positive selection and a negative selection.
12:14That's exactly the right way to think.
12:14That's exactly the right way to think.
12:14That's exactly the right way to think.
12:14That's exactly the right way to think.
12:14That's exactly the right way to think.
12:14That's exactly the right way to think.
12:15The cells will only emerge from the thymus that if they have a receptor on
12:15The cells will only emerge from the thymus that if they have a receptor on
12:15The cells will only emerge from the thymus that if they have a receptor on
12:15The cells will only emerge from the thymus that if they have a receptor on
12:15The cells will only emerge from the thymus that if they have a receptor on
12:15The cells will only emerge from the thymus that if they have a receptor on
12:20their surface that's there, so that's one positive selection.
12:20their surface that's there, so that's one positive selection.
12:20their surface that's there, so that's one positive selection.
12:20their surface that's there, so that's one positive selection.
12:20their surface that's there, so that's one positive selection.
12:20their surface that's there, so that's one positive selection.
12:25But if it engages with a self -target in the thymus, it gets negatively selected.
12:25But if it engages with a self -target in the thymus, it gets negatively selected.
12:25But if it engages with a self -target in the thymus, it gets negatively selected.
12:25But if it engages with a self -target in the thymus, it gets negatively selected.
12:25But if it engages with a self -target in the thymus, it gets negatively selected.
12:25But if it engages with a self -target in the thymus, it gets negatively selected.
12:29So what comes out are T cells that are there with sensors in place to
12:29So what comes out are T cells that are there with sensors in place to
12:29So what comes out are T cells that are there with sensors in place to
12:29So what comes out are T cells that are there with sensors in place to
12:29So what comes out are T cells that are there with sensors in place to
12:29So what comes out are T cells that are there with sensors in place to
12:34recognize things that shouldn't be there.
12:34recognize things that shouldn't be there.
12:34recognize things that shouldn't be there.
12:34recognize things that shouldn't be there.
12:34recognize things that shouldn't be there.
12:34recognize things that shouldn't be there.
12:36Okay, so your thymus and your T cells get educated in childhood.
12:36Okay, so your thymus and your T cells get educated in childhood.
12:36Okay, so your thymus and your T cells get educated in childhood.
12:36Okay, so your thymus and your T cells get educated in childhood.
12:36Okay, so your thymus and your T cells get educated in childhood.
12:36Okay, so your thymus and your T cells get educated in childhood.
12:41Yeah. And that's what you're working with, except that the immune system can adapt and
12:41Yeah. And that's what you're working with, except that the immune system can adapt and
12:41Yeah. And that's what you're working with, except that the immune system can adapt and
12:41Yeah. And that's what you're working with, except that the immune system can adapt and
12:41Yeah. And that's what you're working with, except that the immune system can adapt and
12:41Yeah. And that's what you're working with, except that the immune system can adapt and
12:46make antibodies to things it doesn't recognize.
12:46make antibodies to things it doesn't recognize.
12:46make antibodies to things it doesn't recognize.
12:46make antibodies to things it doesn't recognize.
12:46make antibodies to things it doesn't recognize.
12:46make antibodies to things it doesn't recognize.
12:50The antibodies come from the other type of lymphocytes.
12:50The antibodies come from the other type of lymphocytes.
12:50The antibodies come from the other type of lymphocytes.
12:50The antibodies come from the other type of lymphocytes.
12:50The antibodies come from the other type of lymphocytes.
12:50The antibodies come from the other type of lymphocytes.
12:53So lymphocytes, so now we can talk about the B cells.
12:53So lymphocytes, so now we can talk about the B cells.
12:53So lymphocytes, so now we can talk about the B cells.
12:53So lymphocytes, so now we can talk about the B cells.
12:53So lymphocytes, so now we can talk about the B cells.
12:53So lymphocytes, so now we can talk about the B cells.
12:58B cells are this other type of lymphocyte that work in coordination with T cells
12:58B cells are this other type of lymphocyte that work in coordination with T cells
12:58B cells are this other type of lymphocyte that work in coordination with T cells
12:58B cells are this other type of lymphocyte that work in coordination with T cells
12:58B cells are this other type of lymphocyte that work in coordination with T cells
12:58B cells are this other type of lymphocyte that work in coordination with T cells
13:02and they're the antibody -producing cells.
13:02and they're the antibody -producing cells.
13:02and they're the antibody -producing cells.
13:02and they're the antibody -producing cells.
13:02and they're the antibody -producing cells.
13:02and they're the antibody -producing cells.
13:05So they actually have a similar process where they're generating different antibodies at random through
13:05So they actually have a similar process where they're generating different antibodies at random through
13:05So they actually have a similar process where they're generating different antibodies at random through
13:05So they actually have a similar process where they're generating different antibodies at random through
13:05So they actually have a similar process where they're generating different antibodies at random through
13:05So they actually have a similar process where they're generating different antibodies at random through
13:10a similar kind of recombination event.
13:10a similar kind of recombination event.
13:10a similar kind of recombination event.
13:10a similar kind of recombination event.
13:10a similar kind of recombination event.
13:10a similar kind of recombination event.
13:11They have their own form of selection that they go through and then those antibodies
13:11They have their own form of selection that they go through and then those antibodies
13:11They have their own form of selection that they go through and then those antibodies
13:11They have their own form of selection that they go through and then those antibodies
13:11They have their own form of selection that they go through and then those antibodies
13:11They have their own form of selection that they go through and then those antibodies
13:16can then be released into the bloodstream and are the basis for protection against infections
13:16can then be released into the bloodstream and are the basis for protection against infections
13:16can then be released into the bloodstream and are the basis for protection against infections
13:16can then be released into the bloodstream and are the basis for protection against infections
13:16can then be released into the bloodstream and are the basis for protection against infections
13:16can then be released into the bloodstream and are the basis for protection against infections
13:22after we get them. I'd like to take a quick break and acknowledge our sponsor,
13:22after we get them. I'd like to take a quick break and acknowledge our sponsor,
13:22after we get them. I'd like to take a quick break and acknowledge our sponsor,
13:22after we get them. I'd like to take a quick break and acknowledge our sponsor,
13:22after we get them. I'd like to take a quick break and acknowledge our sponsor,
13:22after we get them. I'd like to take a quick break and acknowledge our sponsor,
13:26BetterHelp. BetterHelp offers professional therapy with a licensed therapist carried out entirely online.
13:26BetterHelp. BetterHelp offers professional therapy with a licensed therapist carried out entirely online.
13:26BetterHelp. BetterHelp offers professional therapy with a licensed therapist carried out entirely online.
13:26BetterHelp. BetterHelp offers professional therapy with a licensed therapist carried out entirely online.
13:26BetterHelp. BetterHelp offers professional therapy with a licensed therapist carried out entirely online.
13:26BetterHelp. BetterHelp offers professional therapy with a licensed therapist carried out entirely online.
13:32Now, I've been doing therapy for a very long time and I can tell you
13:32Now, I've been doing therapy for a very long time and I can tell you
13:32Now, I've been doing therapy for a very long time and I can tell you
13:32Now, I've been doing therapy for a very long time and I can tell you
13:32Now, I've been doing therapy for a very long time and I can tell you
13:32Now, I've been doing therapy for a very long time and I can tell you
13:36that it's a lot like physical workouts.
13:36that it's a lot like physical workouts.
13:36that it's a lot like physical workouts.
13:36that it's a lot like physical workouts.
13:36that it's a lot like physical workouts.
13:36that it's a lot like physical workouts.
13:37There are days when I want to do it and there are days when I
13:37There are days when I want to do it and there are days when I
13:37There are days when I want to do it and there are days when I
13:37There are days when I want to do it and there are days when I
13:37There are days when I want to do it and there are days when I
13:37There are days when I want to do it and there are days when I
13:40don't want to do it.
13:40don't want to do it.
13:40don't want to do it.
13:40don't want to do it.
13:40don't want to do it.
13:40don't want to do it.
13:41But when I finish a therapy session, every single time I come away feeling better
13:41But when I finish a therapy session, every single time I come away feeling better
13:41But when I finish a therapy session, every single time I come away feeling better
13:41But when I finish a therapy session, every single time I come away feeling better
13:41But when I finish a therapy session, every single time I come away feeling better
13:41But when I finish a therapy session, every single time I come away feeling better
13:44and knowing that the time was well spent.
13:44and knowing that the time was well spent.
13:44and knowing that the time was well spent.
13:44and knowing that the time was well spent.
13:44and knowing that the time was well spent.
13:44and knowing that the time was well spent.
13:47And typically, when I finish a therapy session, I come away with a valuable insight
13:47And typically, when I finish a therapy session, I come away with a valuable insight
13:47And typically, when I finish a therapy session, I come away with a valuable insight
13:47And typically, when I finish a therapy session, I come away with a valuable insight
13:47And typically, when I finish a therapy session, I come away with a valuable insight
13:47And typically, when I finish a therapy session, I come away with a valuable insight
13:51or some new perspective on something that I've been working through, whether or not that's
13:51or some new perspective on something that I've been working through, whether or not that's
13:51or some new perspective on something that I've been working through, whether or not that's
13:51or some new perspective on something that I've been working through, whether or not that's
13:51or some new perspective on something that I've been working through, whether or not that's
13:51or some new perspective on something that I've been working through, whether or not that's
13:54with work, with relationships, my personal life, or simply my relationship with myself.
13:54with work, with relationships, my personal life, or simply my relationship with myself.
13:54with work, with relationships, my personal life, or simply my relationship with myself.
13:54with work, with relationships, my personal life, or simply my relationship with myself.
13:54with work, with relationships, my personal life, or simply my relationship with myself.
13:54with work, with relationships, my personal life, or simply my relationship with myself.
13:59There's just so much benefit that comes through effective therapy.
13:59There's just so much benefit that comes through effective therapy.
13:59There's just so much benefit that comes through effective therapy.
13:59There's just so much benefit that comes through effective therapy.
13:59There's just so much benefit that comes through effective therapy.
13:59There's just so much benefit that comes through effective therapy.
14:02And that's not just my personal experience.
14:02And that's not just my personal experience.
14:02And that's not just my personal experience.
14:02And that's not just my personal experience.
14:02And that's not just my personal experience.
14:02And that's not just my personal experience.
14:03There are loads and loads of clinical studies to support that.
14:03There are loads and loads of clinical studies to support that.
14:03There are loads and loads of clinical studies to support that.
14:03There are loads and loads of clinical studies to support that.
14:03There are loads and loads of clinical studies to support that.
14:03There are loads and loads of clinical studies to support that.
14:06With BetterHelp, they make it very easy to find an expert therapist who can help
14:06With BetterHelp, they make it very easy to find an expert therapist who can help
14:06With BetterHelp, they make it very easy to find an expert therapist who can help
14:06With BetterHelp, they make it very easy to find an expert therapist who can help
14:06With BetterHelp, they make it very easy to find an expert therapist who can help
14:06With BetterHelp, they make it very easy to find an expert therapist who can help
14:10provide the benefits that come through effective therapy.
14:10provide the benefits that come through effective therapy.
14:10provide the benefits that come through effective therapy.
14:10provide the benefits that come through effective therapy.
14:10provide the benefits that come through effective therapy.
14:10provide the benefits that come through effective therapy.
14:12They have a short questionnaire to help match you to the ideal therapist for you.
14:12They have a short questionnaire to help match you to the ideal therapist for you.
14:12They have a short questionnaire to help match you to the ideal therapist for you.
14:12They have a short questionnaire to help match you to the ideal therapist for you.
14:12They have a short questionnaire to help match you to the ideal therapist for you.
14:12They have a short questionnaire to help match you to the ideal therapist for you.
14:16And while BetterHelp has an industry -leading match rate, if you aren't happy with your
14:16And while BetterHelp has an industry -leading match rate, if you aren't happy with your
14:16And while BetterHelp has an industry -leading match rate, if you aren't happy with your
14:16And while BetterHelp has an industry -leading match rate, if you aren't happy with your
14:16And while BetterHelp has an industry -leading match rate, if you aren't happy with your
14:16And while BetterHelp has an industry -leading match rate, if you aren't happy with your
14:20match, you can switch to a different therapist anytime.
14:20match, you can switch to a different therapist anytime.
14:20match, you can switch to a different therapist anytime.
14:20match, you can switch to a different therapist anytime.
14:20match, you can switch to a different therapist anytime.
14:20match, you can switch to a different therapist anytime.
14:22Also, because BetterHelp is done entirely online, it's extremely time efficient.
14:22Also, because BetterHelp is done entirely online, it's extremely time efficient.
14:22Also, because BetterHelp is done entirely online, it's extremely time efficient.
14:22Also, because BetterHelp is done entirely online, it's extremely time efficient.
14:22Also, because BetterHelp is done entirely online, it's extremely time efficient.
14:22Also, because BetterHelp is done entirely online, it's extremely time efficient.
14:27You simply log on and have your session.
14:27You simply log on and have your session.
14:27You simply log on and have your session.
14:27You simply log on and have your session.
14:27You simply log on and have your session.
14:27You simply log on and have your session.
14:29If you would like to try BetterHelp, go to betterhelp .com slash Huberman to get
14:29If you would like to try BetterHelp, go to betterhelp .com slash Huberman to get
14:29If you would like to try BetterHelp, go to betterhelp .com slash Huberman to get
14:29If you would like to try BetterHelp, go to betterhelp .com slash Huberman to get
14:29If you would like to try BetterHelp, go to betterhelp .com slash Huberman to get
14:29If you would like to try BetterHelp, go to betterhelp .com slash Huberman to get
14:3410 % off your first month.
14:3410 % off your first month.
14:3410 % off your first month.
14:3410 % off your first month.
14:3410 % off your first month.
14:3410 % off your first month.
14:36Again, that's betterhelp .com slash Huberman.
14:36Again, that's betterhelp .com slash Huberman.
14:36Again, that's betterhelp .com slash Huberman.
14:36Again, that's betterhelp .com slash Huberman.
14:36Again, that's betterhelp .com slash Huberman.
14:36Again, that's betterhelp .com slash Huberman.
14:39Today's episode is also brought to us by Helix Sleep.
14:39Today's episode is also brought to us by Helix Sleep.
14:39Today's episode is also brought to us by Helix Sleep.
14:39Today's episode is also brought to us by Helix Sleep.
14:39Today's episode is also brought to us by Helix Sleep.
14:39Today's episode is also brought to us by Helix Sleep.
14:42Helix Sleep makes mattresses and pillows that are customized to your unique sleep needs.
14:42Helix Sleep makes mattresses and pillows that are customized to your unique sleep needs.
14:42Helix Sleep makes mattresses and pillows that are customized to your unique sleep needs.
14:42Helix Sleep makes mattresses and pillows that are customized to your unique sleep needs.
14:42Helix Sleep makes mattresses and pillows that are customized to your unique sleep needs.
14:42Helix Sleep makes mattresses and pillows that are customized to your unique sleep needs.
14:47Now, I've spoken many times before on this and on other podcasts about the fact
14:47Now, I've spoken many times before on this and on other podcasts about the fact
14:47Now, I've spoken many times before on this and on other podcasts about the fact
14:47Now, I've spoken many times before on this and on other podcasts about the fact
14:47Now, I've spoken many times before on this and on other podcasts about the fact
14:47Now, I've spoken many times before on this and on other podcasts about the fact
14:52that getting a great night's sleep is the foundation of mental health, physical health, and
14:52that getting a great night's sleep is the foundation of mental health, physical health, and
14:52that getting a great night's sleep is the foundation of mental health, physical health, and
14:52that getting a great night's sleep is the foundation of mental health, physical health, and
14:52that getting a great night's sleep is the foundation of mental health, physical health, and
14:52that getting a great night's sleep is the foundation of mental health, physical health, and
14:56performance. When we aren't getting great sleep on a consistent basis, everything suffers.
14:56performance. When we aren't getting great sleep on a consistent basis, everything suffers.
14:56performance. When we aren't getting great sleep on a consistent basis, everything suffers.
14:56performance. When we aren't getting great sleep on a consistent basis, everything suffers.
14:56performance. When we aren't getting great sleep on a consistent basis, everything suffers.
14:56performance. When we aren't getting great sleep on a consistent basis, everything suffers.
15:00And when we are sleeping well and enough, our mental health, physical health, and performance
15:00And when we are sleeping well and enough, our mental health, physical health, and performance
15:00And when we are sleeping well and enough, our mental health, physical health, and performance
15:00And when we are sleeping well and enough, our mental health, physical health, and performance
15:00And when we are sleeping well and enough, our mental health, physical health, and performance
15:00And when we are sleeping well and enough, our mental health, physical health, and performance
15:04in all endeavors improve markedly.
15:04in all endeavors improve markedly.
15:04in all endeavors improve markedly.
15:04in all endeavors improve markedly.
15:04in all endeavors improve markedly.
15:04in all endeavors improve markedly.
15:07Now, the mattress you sleep on makes a huge difference in the quality of sleep
15:07Now, the mattress you sleep on makes a huge difference in the quality of sleep
15:07Now, the mattress you sleep on makes a huge difference in the quality of sleep
15:07Now, the mattress you sleep on makes a huge difference in the quality of sleep
15:07Now, the mattress you sleep on makes a huge difference in the quality of sleep
15:07Now, the mattress you sleep on makes a huge difference in the quality of sleep
15:11that you get each night.
15:11that you get each night.
15:11that you get each night.
15:11that you get each night.
15:11that you get each night.
15:11that you get each night.
15:12How soft it is or how firm it is all play into your comfort and
15:12How soft it is or how firm it is all play into your comfort and
15:12How soft it is or how firm it is all play into your comfort and
15:12How soft it is or how firm it is all play into your comfort and
15:12How soft it is or how firm it is all play into your comfort and
15:12How soft it is or how firm it is all play into your comfort and
15:16need to be tailored to your unique sleep needs.
15:16need to be tailored to your unique sleep needs.
15:16need to be tailored to your unique sleep needs.
15:16need to be tailored to your unique sleep needs.
15:16need to be tailored to your unique sleep needs.
15:16need to be tailored to your unique sleep needs.
15:18If you go to the Helix website, you can take a brief two -minute quiz
15:18If you go to the Helix website, you can take a brief two -minute quiz
15:18If you go to the Helix website, you can take a brief two -minute quiz
15:18If you go to the Helix website, you can take a brief two -minute quiz
15:18If you go to the Helix website, you can take a brief two -minute quiz
15:18If you go to the Helix website, you can take a brief two -minute quiz
15:21and it will ask you questions such as, do you sleep on your back, your
15:21and it will ask you questions such as, do you sleep on your back, your
15:21and it will ask you questions such as, do you sleep on your back, your
15:21and it will ask you questions such as, do you sleep on your back, your
15:21and it will ask you questions such as, do you sleep on your back, your
15:21and it will ask you questions such as, do you sleep on your back, your
15:24side, or your stomach? Maybe you know, maybe you don't.
15:24side, or your stomach? Maybe you know, maybe you don't.
15:24side, or your stomach? Maybe you know, maybe you don't.
15:24side, or your stomach? Maybe you know, maybe you don't.
15:24side, or your stomach? Maybe you know, maybe you don't.
15:24side, or your stomach? Maybe you know, maybe you don't.
15:27Do you tend to run hot or cold during the night?
15:27Do you tend to run hot or cold during the night?
15:27Do you tend to run hot or cold during the night?
15:27Do you tend to run hot or cold during the night?
15:27Do you tend to run hot or cold during the night?
15:27Do you tend to run hot or cold during the night?
15:29Things of that sort. You answer those questions and Helix will match you to the
15:29Things of that sort. You answer those questions and Helix will match you to the
15:29Things of that sort. You answer those questions and Helix will match you to the
15:29Things of that sort. You answer those questions and Helix will match you to the
15:29Things of that sort. You answer those questions and Helix will match you to the
15:29Things of that sort. You answer those questions and Helix will match you to the
15:32ideal mattress for you. For me, that turned out to be the Dusk, D -U
15:32ideal mattress for you. For me, that turned out to be the Dusk, D -U
15:32ideal mattress for you. For me, that turned out to be the Dusk, D -U
15:32ideal mattress for you. For me, that turned out to be the Dusk, D -U
15:32ideal mattress for you. For me, that turned out to be the Dusk, D -U
15:32ideal mattress for you. For me, that turned out to be the Dusk, D -U
15:36-S -K mattress. I've been sleeping on a Dusk mattress for more than four years
15:36-S -K mattress. I've been sleeping on a Dusk mattress for more than four years
15:36-S -K mattress. I've been sleeping on a Dusk mattress for more than four years
15:36-S -K mattress. I've been sleeping on a Dusk mattress for more than four years
15:36-S -K mattress. I've been sleeping on a Dusk mattress for more than four years
15:36-S -K mattress. I've been sleeping on a Dusk mattress for more than four years
15:40now, and it's been far and away the best sleep that I've ever had.
15:40now, and it's been far and away the best sleep that I've ever had.
15:40now, and it's been far and away the best sleep that I've ever had.
15:40now, and it's been far and away the best sleep that I've ever had.
15:40now, and it's been far and away the best sleep that I've ever had.
15:40now, and it's been far and away the best sleep that I've ever had.
15:44If you'd like to try Helix, you can go to helixsleep .com slash Huberman, take
15:44If you'd like to try Helix, you can go to helixsleep .com slash Huberman, take
15:44If you'd like to try Helix, you can go to helixsleep .com slash Huberman, take
15:44If you'd like to try Helix, you can go to helixsleep .com slash Huberman, take
15:44If you'd like to try Helix, you can go to helixsleep .com slash Huberman, take
15:44If you'd like to try Helix, you can go to helixsleep .com slash Huberman, take
15:49that two -minute sleep quiz, and Helix will match you to a mattress that's customized
15:49that two -minute sleep quiz, and Helix will match you to a mattress that's customized
15:49that two -minute sleep quiz, and Helix will match you to a mattress that's customized
15:49that two -minute sleep quiz, and Helix will match you to a mattress that's customized
15:49that two -minute sleep quiz, and Helix will match you to a mattress that's customized
15:49that two -minute sleep quiz, and Helix will match you to a mattress that's customized
15:53for you. Right now, Helix is giving up to 27 % off their entire site.
15:53for you. Right now, Helix is giving up to 27 % off their entire site.
15:53for you. Right now, Helix is giving up to 27 % off their entire site.
15:53for you. Right now, Helix is giving up to 27 % off their entire site.
15:53for you. Right now, Helix is giving up to 27 % off their entire site.
15:53for you. Right now, Helix is giving up to 27 % off their entire site.
15:58Helix has also teamed up with TruMed, which allows you to use your HSA FSA
15:58Helix has also teamed up with TruMed, which allows you to use your HSA FSA
15:58Helix has also teamed up with TruMed, which allows you to use your HSA FSA
15:58Helix has also teamed up with TruMed, which allows you to use your HSA FSA
15:58Helix has also teamed up with TruMed, which allows you to use your HSA FSA
15:58Helix has also teamed up with TruMed, which allows you to use your HSA FSA
16:03dollars to shop Helix's award -winning mattresses.
16:03dollars to shop Helix's award -winning mattresses.
16:03dollars to shop Helix's award -winning mattresses.
16:03dollars to shop Helix's award -winning mattresses.
16:03dollars to shop Helix's award -winning mattresses.
16:03dollars to shop Helix's award -winning mattresses.
16:06Again, that's helixsleep .com slash Huberman to get up to 27 % off.
16:06Again, that's helixsleep .com slash Huberman to get up to 27 % off.
16:06Again, that's helixsleep .com slash Huberman to get up to 27 % off.
16:06Again, that's helixsleep .com slash Huberman to get up to 27 % off.
16:06Again, that's helixsleep .com slash Huberman to get up to 27 % off.
16:06Again, that's helixsleep .com slash Huberman to get up to 27 % off.
16:11What underlies the sort of efficiency and functioning of the immune system?
16:11What underlies the sort of efficiency and functioning of the immune system?
16:11What underlies the sort of efficiency and functioning of the immune system?
16:11What underlies the sort of efficiency and functioning of the immune system?
16:11What underlies the sort of efficiency and functioning of the immune system?
16:11What underlies the sort of efficiency and functioning of the immune system?
16:18I know I and many...
16:18I know I and many...
16:18I know I and many...
16:18I know I and many...
16:18I know I and many...
16:18I know I and many...
16:19People are thinking, okay, we hear like our immune system gets activated or our immune
16:19People are thinking, okay, we hear like our immune system gets activated or our immune
16:19People are thinking, okay, we hear like our immune system gets activated or our immune
16:19People are thinking, okay, we hear like our immune system gets activated or our immune
16:19People are thinking, okay, we hear like our immune system gets activated or our immune
16:19People are thinking, okay, we hear like our immune system gets activated or our immune
16:25system is impaired. The one thing that I'm certain supports the immune system is great
16:25system is impaired. The one thing that I'm certain supports the immune system is great
16:25system is impaired. The one thing that I'm certain supports the immune system is great
16:25system is impaired. The one thing that I'm certain supports the immune system is great
16:25system is impaired. The one thing that I'm certain supports the immune system is great
16:25system is impaired. The one thing that I'm certain supports the immune system is great
16:31sleep, right? We just know this.
16:31sleep, right? We just know this.
16:31sleep, right? We just know this.
16:31sleep, right? We just know this.
16:31sleep, right? We just know this.
16:31sleep, right? We just know this.
16:33If we don't sleep well or enough, we get sick.
16:33If we don't sleep well or enough, we get sick.
16:33If we don't sleep well or enough, we get sick.
16:33If we don't sleep well or enough, we get sick.
16:33If we don't sleep well or enough, we get sick.
16:33If we don't sleep well or enough, we get sick.
16:36Is that because there's a known impairment of the immune system?
16:36Is that because there's a known impairment of the immune system?
16:36Is that because there's a known impairment of the immune system?
16:36Is that because there's a known impairment of the immune system?
16:36Is that because there's a known impairment of the immune system?
16:36Is that because there's a known impairment of the immune system?
16:41I wonder about this too.
16:41I wonder about this too.
16:41I wonder about this too.
16:41I wonder about this too.
16:41I wonder about this too.
16:41I wonder about this too.
16:42I mean, I agree, anecdotally I've experienced that so many times of being run down
16:42I mean, I agree, anecdotally I've experienced that so many times of being run down
16:42I mean, I agree, anecdotally I've experienced that so many times of being run down
16:42I mean, I agree, anecdotally I've experienced that so many times of being run down
16:42I mean, I agree, anecdotally I've experienced that so many times of being run down
16:42I mean, I agree, anecdotally I've experienced that so many times of being run down
16:47and then experiencing that I'm susceptible to infection, but I don't actually know the basis
16:47and then experiencing that I'm susceptible to infection, but I don't actually know the basis
16:47and then experiencing that I'm susceptible to infection, but I don't actually know the basis
16:47and then experiencing that I'm susceptible to infection, but I don't actually know the basis
16:47and then experiencing that I'm susceptible to infection, but I don't actually know the basis
16:47and then experiencing that I'm susceptible to infection, but I don't actually know the basis
16:54of that. I mean, it's kind of amazing how much we don't know about these
16:54of that. I mean, it's kind of amazing how much we don't know about these
16:54of that. I mean, it's kind of amazing how much we don't know about these
16:54of that. I mean, it's kind of amazing how much we don't know about these
16:54of that. I mean, it's kind of amazing how much we don't know about these
16:54of that. I mean, it's kind of amazing how much we don't know about these
16:59determinants of immune health, largely because there are often variables that are left out of
16:59determinants of immune health, largely because there are often variables that are left out of
16:59determinants of immune health, largely because there are often variables that are left out of
16:59determinants of immune health, largely because there are often variables that are left out of
16:59determinants of immune health, largely because there are often variables that are left out of
16:59determinants of immune health, largely because there are often variables that are left out of
17:04the mouse studies that we're doing.
17:04the mouse studies that we're doing.
17:04the mouse studies that we're doing.
17:04the mouse studies that we're doing.
17:04the mouse studies that we're doing.
17:04the mouse studies that we're doing.
17:07We're studying largely steady state immune responses, in mice and I would say we haven't
17:07We're studying largely steady state immune responses, in mice and I would say we haven't
17:07We're studying largely steady state immune responses, in mice and I would say we haven't
17:07We're studying largely steady state immune responses, in mice and I would say we haven't
17:07We're studying largely steady state immune responses, in mice and I would say we haven't
17:07We're studying largely steady state immune responses, in mice and I would say we haven't
17:15done a full exploration yet of all the types of ways that general health impinges
17:15done a full exploration yet of all the types of ways that general health impinges
17:15done a full exploration yet of all the types of ways that general health impinges
17:15done a full exploration yet of all the types of ways that general health impinges
17:15done a full exploration yet of all the types of ways that general health impinges
17:15done a full exploration yet of all the types of ways that general health impinges
17:21on the immune system. I had someone in my lab, a post -doc named Sagar
17:21on the immune system. I had someone in my lab, a post -doc named Sagar
17:21on the immune system. I had someone in my lab, a post -doc named Sagar
17:21on the immune system. I had someone in my lab, a post -doc named Sagar
17:21on the immune system. I had someone in my lab, a post -doc named Sagar
17:21on the immune system. I had someone in my lab, a post -doc named Sagar
17:27Bupat, who came to my lab with an interest in metabolic health and wanted to
17:27Bupat, who came to my lab with an interest in metabolic health and wanted to
17:27Bupat, who came to my lab with an interest in metabolic health and wanted to
17:27Bupat, who came to my lab with an interest in metabolic health and wanted to
17:27Bupat, who came to my lab with an interest in metabolic health and wanted to
17:27Bupat, who came to my lab with an interest in metabolic health and wanted to
17:33study the effect of metabolic health on T cells.
17:33study the effect of metabolic health on T cells.
17:33study the effect of metabolic health on T cells.
17:33study the effect of metabolic health on T cells.
17:33study the effect of metabolic health on T cells.
17:33study the effect of metabolic health on T cells.
17:35And there's some sub -growing stuff on this, but it's another, like, what are the
17:35And there's some sub -growing stuff on this, but it's another, like, what are the
17:35And there's some sub -growing stuff on this, but it's another, like, what are the
17:35And there's some sub -growing stuff on this, but it's another, like, what are the
17:35And there's some sub -growing stuff on this, but it's another, like, what are the
17:35And there's some sub -growing stuff on this, but it's another, like, what are the
17:39determinants of it? And he did experiments in my lab where he exposed an allergen,
17:39determinants of it? And he did experiments in my lab where he exposed an allergen,
17:39determinants of it? And he did experiments in my lab where he exposed an allergen,
17:39determinants of it? And he did experiments in my lab where he exposed an allergen,
17:39determinants of it? And he did experiments in my lab where he exposed an allergen,
17:39determinants of it? And he did experiments in my lab where he exposed an allergen,
17:49something that irritated the skin and caused an allergic -type reaction in the skin of
17:49something that irritated the skin and caused an allergic -type reaction in the skin of
17:49something that irritated the skin and caused an allergic -type reaction in the skin of
17:49something that irritated the skin and caused an allergic -type reaction in the skin of
17:49something that irritated the skin and caused an allergic -type reaction in the skin of
17:49something that irritated the skin and caused an allergic -type reaction in the skin of
17:54mice. He did it in mice that were eating a normal mouse diet versus a
17:54mice. He did it in mice that were eating a normal mouse diet versus a
17:54mice. He did it in mice that were eating a normal mouse diet versus a
17:54mice. He did it in mice that were eating a normal mouse diet versus a
17:54mice. He did it in mice that were eating a normal mouse diet versus a
17:54mice. He did it in mice that were eating a normal mouse diet versus a
17:59high -fat diet that caused obesity.
17:59high -fat diet that caused obesity.
17:59high -fat diet that caused obesity.
17:59high -fat diet that caused obesity.
17:59high -fat diet that caused obesity.
17:59high -fat diet that caused obesity.
18:02And what we saw was that it was actually not just a quantitative difference in
18:02And what we saw was that it was actually not just a quantitative difference in
18:02And what we saw was that it was actually not just a quantitative difference in
18:02And what we saw was that it was actually not just a quantitative difference in
18:02And what we saw was that it was actually not just a quantitative difference in
18:02And what we saw was that it was actually not just a quantitative difference in
18:08the immune system, but actually a qualitative difference.
18:08the immune system, but actually a qualitative difference.
18:08the immune system, but actually a qualitative difference.
18:08the immune system, but actually a qualitative difference.
18:08the immune system, but actually a qualitative difference.
18:08the immune system, but actually a qualitative difference.
18:10The actual type of inflammation, the cell responses were different in the mice eating a
18:10The actual type of inflammation, the cell responses were different in the mice eating a
18:10The actual type of inflammation, the cell responses were different in the mice eating a
18:10The actual type of inflammation, the cell responses were different in the mice eating a
18:10The actual type of inflammation, the cell responses were different in the mice eating a
18:10The actual type of inflammation, the cell responses were different in the mice eating a
18:16high -fat diet. And I think we haven't done enough studies like that where we
18:16high -fat diet. And I think we haven't done enough studies like that where we
18:16high -fat diet. And I think we haven't done enough studies like that where we
18:16high -fat diet. And I think we haven't done enough studies like that where we
18:16high -fat diet. And I think we haven't done enough studies like that where we
18:16high -fat diet. And I think we haven't done enough studies like that where we
18:19actually start playing with the variables of life and test them in a mechanistic way
18:19actually start playing with the variables of life and test them in a mechanistic way
18:19actually start playing with the variables of life and test them in a mechanistic way
18:19actually start playing with the variables of life and test them in a mechanistic way
18:19actually start playing with the variables of life and test them in a mechanistic way
18:19actually start playing with the variables of life and test them in a mechanistic way
18:25to isolate individual variants. What was interesting there was that the allergic reaction actually looked
18:25to isolate individual variants. What was interesting there was that the allergic reaction actually looked
18:25to isolate individual variants. What was interesting there was that the allergic reaction actually looked
18:25to isolate individual variants. What was interesting there was that the allergic reaction actually looked
18:25to isolate individual variants. What was interesting there was that the allergic reaction actually looked
18:25to isolate individual variants. What was interesting there was that the allergic reaction actually looked
18:33totally different in the obese mice.
18:33totally different in the obese mice.
18:33totally different in the obese mice.
18:33totally different in the obese mice.
18:33totally different in the obese mice.
18:33totally different in the obese mice.
18:34And if we used surrogates that are for the types of drugs that are being
18:34And if we used surrogates that are for the types of drugs that are being
18:34And if we used surrogates that are for the types of drugs that are being
18:34And if we used surrogates that are for the types of drugs that are being
18:34And if we used surrogates that are for the types of drugs that are being
18:34And if we used surrogates that are for the types of drugs that are being
18:38used now to treat severe allergy, so we gave antibodies that block allergic responses, the
18:38used now to treat severe allergy, so we gave antibodies that block allergic responses, the
18:38used now to treat severe allergy, so we gave antibodies that block allergic responses, the
18:38used now to treat severe allergy, so we gave antibodies that block allergic responses, the
18:38used now to treat severe allergy, so we gave antibodies that block allergic responses, the
18:38used now to treat severe allergy, so we gave antibodies that block allergic responses, the
18:45normal diet mice would respond favorably to these.
18:45normal diet mice would respond favorably to these.
18:45normal diet mice would respond favorably to these.
18:45normal diet mice would respond favorably to these.
18:45normal diet mice would respond favorably to these.
18:45normal diet mice would respond favorably to these.
18:49They didn't help the mice that had the obese high -fat diet response to inflammation.
18:49They didn't help the mice that had the obese high -fat diet response to inflammation.
18:49They didn't help the mice that had the obese high -fat diet response to inflammation.
18:49They didn't help the mice that had the obese high -fat diet response to inflammation.
18:49They didn't help the mice that had the obese high -fat diet response to inflammation.
18:49They didn't help the mice that had the obese high -fat diet response to inflammation.
18:55And in some cases, it actually maybe made it worse.
18:55And in some cases, it actually maybe made it worse.
18:55And in some cases, it actually maybe made it worse.
18:55And in some cases, it actually maybe made it worse.
18:55And in some cases, it actually maybe made it worse.
18:55And in some cases, it actually maybe made it worse.
18:58So I think that there are these systemic ways.
18:58So I think that there are these systemic ways.
18:58So I think that there are these systemic ways.
18:58So I think that there are these systemic ways.
18:58So I think that there are these systemic ways.
18:58So I think that there are these systemic ways.
19:01I mean, clearly, our intuition tells us this strongly, that systemic health can feed into
19:01I mean, clearly, our intuition tells us this strongly, that systemic health can feed into
19:01I mean, clearly, our intuition tells us this strongly, that systemic health can feed into
19:01I mean, clearly, our intuition tells us this strongly, that systemic health can feed into
19:01I mean, clearly, our intuition tells us this strongly, that systemic health can feed into
19:01I mean, clearly, our intuition tells us this strongly, that systemic health can feed into
19:07our immune responses. But I think it's still been underexplored in rigorous ways.
19:07our immune responses. But I think it's still been underexplored in rigorous ways.
19:07our immune responses. But I think it's still been underexplored in rigorous ways.
19:07our immune responses. But I think it's still been underexplored in rigorous ways.
19:07our immune responses. But I think it's still been underexplored in rigorous ways.
19:07our immune responses. But I think it's still been underexplored in rigorous ways.
19:13I realize I'm asking very top -contour -type questions, for which there probably aren't specific
19:13I realize I'm asking very top -contour -type questions, for which there probably aren't specific
19:13I realize I'm asking very top -contour -type questions, for which there probably aren't specific
19:13I realize I'm asking very top -contour -type questions, for which there probably aren't specific
19:13I realize I'm asking very top -contour -type questions, for which there probably aren't specific
19:13I realize I'm asking very top -contour -type questions, for which there probably aren't specific
19:19answers. But we all know people that get sick all the time.
19:19answers. But we all know people that get sick all the time.
19:19answers. But we all know people that get sick all the time.
19:19answers. But we all know people that get sick all the time.
19:19answers. But we all know people that get sick all the time.
19:19answers. But we all know people that get sick all the time.
19:25And we know people who never seem to catch the bugs that everyone else seems
19:25And we know people who never seem to catch the bugs that everyone else seems
19:25And we know people who never seem to catch the bugs that everyone else seems
19:25And we know people who never seem to catch the bugs that everyone else seems
19:25And we know people who never seem to catch the bugs that everyone else seems
19:25And we know people who never seem to catch the bugs that everyone else seems
19:29to catch. Is there any understanding of what a more robust immune system is at
19:29to catch. Is there any understanding of what a more robust immune system is at
19:29to catch. Is there any understanding of what a more robust immune system is at
19:29to catch. Is there any understanding of what a more robust immune system is at
19:29to catch. Is there any understanding of what a more robust immune system is at
19:29to catch. Is there any understanding of what a more robust immune system is at
19:34the level? Is it more T cells?
19:34the level? Is it more T cells?
19:34the level? Is it more T cells?
19:34the level? Is it more T cells?
19:34the level? Is it more T cells?
19:34the level? Is it more T cells?
19:36Is it, you know, are the B cells engaged more quickly so they can generate
19:36Is it, you know, are the B cells engaged more quickly so they can generate
19:36Is it, you know, are the B cells engaged more quickly so they can generate
19:36Is it, you know, are the B cells engaged more quickly so they can generate
19:36Is it, you know, are the B cells engaged more quickly so they can generate
19:36Is it, you know, are the B cells engaged more quickly so they can generate
19:40antibodies more quickly? What is it?
19:40antibodies more quickly? What is it?
19:40antibodies more quickly? What is it?
19:40antibodies more quickly? What is it?
19:40antibodies more quickly? What is it?
19:40antibodies more quickly? What is it?
19:43These are great questions that I don't think have full answers.
19:43These are great questions that I don't think have full answers.
19:43These are great questions that I don't think have full answers.
19:43These are great questions that I don't think have full answers.
19:43These are great questions that I don't think have full answers.
19:43These are great questions that I don't think have full answers.
19:49There's been a lot of work on genetic determinants.
19:49There's been a lot of work on genetic determinants.
19:49There's been a lot of work on genetic determinants.
19:49There's been a lot of work on genetic determinants.
19:49There's been a lot of work on genetic determinants.
19:49There's been a lot of work on genetic determinants.
19:52And there's extreme cases where people have a genetic gap in their immune system where
19:52And there's extreme cases where people have a genetic gap in their immune system where
19:52And there's extreme cases where people have a genetic gap in their immune system where
19:52And there's extreme cases where people have a genetic gap in their immune system where
19:52And there's extreme cases where people have a genetic gap in their immune system where
19:52And there's extreme cases where people have a genetic gap in their immune system where
19:56they're really susceptible to something that healthy people should not be susceptible to.
19:56they're really susceptible to something that healthy people should not be susceptible to.
19:56they're really susceptible to something that healthy people should not be susceptible to.
19:56they're really susceptible to something that healthy people should not be susceptible to.
19:56they're really susceptible to something that healthy people should not be susceptible to.
19:56they're really susceptible to something that healthy people should not be susceptible to.
20:01And you see that there are certain types of infections that either happen or happen
20:01And you see that there are certain types of infections that either happen or happen
20:01And you see that there are certain types of infections that either happen or happen
20:01And you see that there are certain types of infections that either happen or happen
20:01And you see that there are certain types of infections that either happen or happen
20:01And you see that there are certain types of infections that either happen or happen
20:05with a different type of severity in people with genetic deficits in certain branches of
20:05with a different type of severity in people with genetic deficits in certain branches of
20:05with a different type of severity in people with genetic deficits in certain branches of
20:05with a different type of severity in people with genetic deficits in certain branches of
20:05with a different type of severity in people with genetic deficits in certain branches of
20:05with a different type of severity in people with genetic deficits in certain branches of
20:12their immune system. And in some cases you can pinpoint that we just talked about
20:12their immune system. And in some cases you can pinpoint that we just talked about
20:12their immune system. And in some cases you can pinpoint that we just talked about
20:12their immune system. And in some cases you can pinpoint that we just talked about
20:12their immune system. And in some cases you can pinpoint that we just talked about
20:12their immune system. And in some cases you can pinpoint that we just talked about
20:15the innate immune response, the adaptive immune response.
20:15the innate immune response, the adaptive immune response.
20:15the innate immune response, the adaptive immune response.
20:15the innate immune response, the adaptive immune response.
20:15the innate immune response, the adaptive immune response.
20:15the innate immune response, the adaptive immune response.
20:18You can see that certain genetic mutations that people inherit could influence one or multiple
20:18You can see that certain genetic mutations that people inherit could influence one or multiple
20:18You can see that certain genetic mutations that people inherit could influence one or multiple
20:18You can see that certain genetic mutations that people inherit could influence one or multiple
20:18You can see that certain genetic mutations that people inherit could influence one or multiple
20:18You can see that certain genetic mutations that people inherit could influence one or multiple
20:23branches of that immune response and the consequences that manifests itself with different types of
20:23branches of that immune response and the consequences that manifests itself with different types of
20:23branches of that immune response and the consequences that manifests itself with different types of
20:23branches of that immune response and the consequences that manifests itself with different types of
20:23branches of that immune response and the consequences that manifests itself with different types of
20:23branches of that immune response and the consequences that manifests itself with different types of
20:28infection. And I suspect that there's some spectrum of that.
20:28infection. And I suspect that there's some spectrum of that.
20:28infection. And I suspect that there's some spectrum of that.
20:28infection. And I suspect that there's some spectrum of that.
20:28infection. And I suspect that there's some spectrum of that.
20:28infection. And I suspect that there's some spectrum of that.
20:31We see that you can diagnose the really strong genetic consequences and then there might
20:31We see that you can diagnose the really strong genetic consequences and then there might
20:31We see that you can diagnose the really strong genetic consequences and then there might
20:31We see that you can diagnose the really strong genetic consequences and then there might
20:31We see that you can diagnose the really strong genetic consequences and then there might
20:31We see that you can diagnose the really strong genetic consequences and then there might
20:36be a long tail of more subtle genetic that might be multigenic that we don't
20:36be a long tail of more subtle genetic that might be multigenic that we don't
20:36be a long tail of more subtle genetic that might be multigenic that we don't
20:36be a long tail of more subtle genetic that might be multigenic that we don't
20:36be a long tail of more subtle genetic that might be multigenic that we don't
20:36be a long tail of more subtle genetic that might be multigenic that we don't
20:41fully understand. And then I'm sure that there's other determinants of health that are just
20:41fully understand. And then I'm sure that there's other determinants of health that are just
20:41fully understand. And then I'm sure that there's other determinants of health that are just
20:41fully understand. And then I'm sure that there's other determinants of health that are just
20:41fully understand. And then I'm sure that there's other determinants of health that are just
20:41fully understand. And then I'm sure that there's other determinants of health that are just
20:45multifactorial. And it also becomes this interplay between the health and then what you get
20:45multifactorial. And it also becomes this interplay between the health and then what you get
20:45multifactorial. And it also becomes this interplay between the health and then what you get
20:45multifactorial. And it also becomes this interplay between the health and then what you get
20:45multifactorial. And it also becomes this interplay between the health and then what you get
20:45multifactorial. And it also becomes this interplay between the health and then what you get
20:54exposed to by your environment.
20:54exposed to by your environment.
20:54exposed to by your environment.
20:54exposed to by your environment.
20:54exposed to by your environment.
20:54exposed to by your environment.
20:56Yeah, speaking of which, I'm familiar with some studies from Stanford, I believe, where kids
20:56Yeah, speaking of which, I'm familiar with some studies from Stanford, I believe, where kids
20:56Yeah, speaking of which, I'm familiar with some studies from Stanford, I believe, where kids
20:56Yeah, speaking of which, I'm familiar with some studies from Stanford, I believe, where kids
20:56Yeah, speaking of which, I'm familiar with some studies from Stanford, I believe, where kids
20:56Yeah, speaking of which, I'm familiar with some studies from Stanford, I believe, where kids
21:03that have no exposure to peanuts get peanut allergies.
21:03that have no exposure to peanuts get peanut allergies.
21:03that have no exposure to peanuts get peanut allergies.
21:03that have no exposure to peanuts get peanut allergies.
21:03that have no exposure to peanuts get peanut allergies.
21:03that have no exposure to peanuts get peanut allergies.
21:07And careful, subtle, increasing exposure to peanuts essentially protects them against peanut allergies.
21:07And careful, subtle, increasing exposure to peanuts essentially protects them against peanut allergies.
21:07And careful, subtle, increasing exposure to peanuts essentially protects them against peanut allergies.
21:07And careful, subtle, increasing exposure to peanuts essentially protects them against peanut allergies.
21:07And careful, subtle, increasing exposure to peanuts essentially protects them against peanut allergies.
21:07And careful, subtle, increasing exposure to peanuts essentially protects them against peanut allergies.
21:17So is it true that when we're young that exposure to pathogens and different foods
21:17So is it true that when we're young that exposure to pathogens and different foods
21:17So is it true that when we're young that exposure to pathogens and different foods
21:17So is it true that when we're young that exposure to pathogens and different foods
21:17So is it true that when we're young that exposure to pathogens and different foods
21:17So is it true that when we're young that exposure to pathogens and different foods
21:25gives us a more robust immune system?
21:25gives us a more robust immune system?
21:25gives us a more robust immune system?
21:25gives us a more robust immune system?
21:25gives us a more robust immune system?
21:25gives us a more robust immune system?
21:28I think that what we're exposed to and what we develop tolerance for is critically
21:28I think that what we're exposed to and what we develop tolerance for is critically
21:28I think that what we're exposed to and what we develop tolerance for is critically
21:28I think that what we're exposed to and what we develop tolerance for is critically
21:28I think that what we're exposed to and what we develop tolerance for is critically
21:28I think that what we're exposed to and what we develop tolerance for is critically
21:36important during some windows of early life that I think we're particularly susceptible to becoming
21:36important during some windows of early life that I think we're particularly susceptible to becoming
21:36important during some windows of early life that I think we're particularly susceptible to becoming
21:36important during some windows of early life that I think we're particularly susceptible to becoming
21:36important during some windows of early life that I think we're particularly susceptible to becoming
21:36important during some windows of early life that I think we're particularly susceptible to becoming
21:42tolerant. And I think if we don't get the proper exposure to certain things, it's
21:42tolerant. And I think if we don't get the proper exposure to certain things, it's
21:42tolerant. And I think if we don't get the proper exposure to certain things, it's
21:42tolerant. And I think if we don't get the proper exposure to certain things, it's
21:42tolerant. And I think if we don't get the proper exposure to certain things, it's
21:42tolerant. And I think if we don't get the proper exposure to certain things, it's
21:46all of a sudden... our body can start to be hypersensitive to them, which manifests
21:46all of a sudden... our body can start to be hypersensitive to them, which manifests
21:46all of a sudden... our body can start to be hypersensitive to them, which manifests
21:46all of a sudden... our body can start to be hypersensitive to them, which manifests
21:46all of a sudden... our body can start to be hypersensitive to them, which manifests
21:46all of a sudden... our body can start to be hypersensitive to them, which manifests
21:51as allergies. Now there's this balancing act, I think the fear of allergies makes people
21:51as allergies. Now there's this balancing act, I think the fear of allergies makes people
21:51as allergies. Now there's this balancing act, I think the fear of allergies makes people
21:51as allergies. Now there's this balancing act, I think the fear of allergies makes people
21:51as allergies. Now there's this balancing act, I think the fear of allergies makes people
21:51as allergies. Now there's this balancing act, I think the fear of allergies makes people
21:55more hesitant to expose kids and I think it can get into these dangerous zones
21:55more hesitant to expose kids and I think it can get into these dangerous zones
21:55more hesitant to expose kids and I think it can get into these dangerous zones
21:55more hesitant to expose kids and I think it can get into these dangerous zones
21:55more hesitant to expose kids and I think it can get into these dangerous zones
21:55more hesitant to expose kids and I think it can get into these dangerous zones
22:00of you don't want to expose kids who are going to have a dangerous allergic
22:00of you don't want to expose kids who are going to have a dangerous allergic
22:00of you don't want to expose kids who are going to have a dangerous allergic
22:00of you don't want to expose kids who are going to have a dangerous allergic
22:00of you don't want to expose kids who are going to have a dangerous allergic
22:00of you don't want to expose kids who are going to have a dangerous allergic
22:05response. But on the other hand, critical early exposure is part of how tolerance is
22:05response. But on the other hand, critical early exposure is part of how tolerance is
22:05response. But on the other hand, critical early exposure is part of how tolerance is
22:05response. But on the other hand, critical early exposure is part of how tolerance is
22:05response. But on the other hand, critical early exposure is part of how tolerance is
22:05response. But on the other hand, critical early exposure is part of how tolerance is
22:10maintained and I think peanut allergies, there is strong evidence that exposure to peanuts can
22:10maintained and I think peanut allergies, there is strong evidence that exposure to peanuts can
22:10maintained and I think peanut allergies, there is strong evidence that exposure to peanuts can
22:10maintained and I think peanut allergies, there is strong evidence that exposure to peanuts can
22:10maintained and I think peanut allergies, there is strong evidence that exposure to peanuts can
22:10maintained and I think peanut allergies, there is strong evidence that exposure to peanuts can
22:16be beneficial. In people who are not yet allergic.
22:16be beneficial. In people who are not yet allergic.
22:16be beneficial. In people who are not yet allergic.
22:16be beneficial. In people who are not yet allergic.
22:16be beneficial. In people who are not yet allergic.
22:16be beneficial. In people who are not yet allergic.
22:19What's going on with autoimmune conditions?
22:19What's going on with autoimmune conditions?
22:19What's going on with autoimmune conditions?
22:19What's going on with autoimmune conditions?
22:19What's going on with autoimmune conditions?
22:19What's going on with autoimmune conditions?
22:23Yeah. Is this that the B cells and T cells are at a probabilistic level,
22:23Yeah. Is this that the B cells and T cells are at a probabilistic level,
22:23Yeah. Is this that the B cells and T cells are at a probabilistic level,
22:23Yeah. Is this that the B cells and T cells are at a probabilistic level,
22:23Yeah. Is this that the B cells and T cells are at a probabilistic level,
22:23Yeah. Is this that the B cells and T cells are at a probabilistic level,
22:28the T cells developed some reaction, so to speak, a binding to cells that we
22:28the T cells developed some reaction, so to speak, a binding to cells that we
22:28the T cells developed some reaction, so to speak, a binding to cells that we
22:28the T cells developed some reaction, so to speak, a binding to cells that we
22:28the T cells developed some reaction, so to speak, a binding to cells that we
22:28the T cells developed some reaction, so to speak, a binding to cells that we
22:35naturally make that they shouldn't have, it's just like it happens.
22:35naturally make that they shouldn't have, it's just like it happens.
22:35naturally make that they shouldn't have, it's just like it happens.
22:35naturally make that they shouldn't have, it's just like it happens.
22:35naturally make that they shouldn't have, it's just like it happens.
22:35naturally make that they shouldn't have, it's just like it happens.
22:38I've always been intrigued by the idea that when the immune system is really ramped
22:38I've always been intrigued by the idea that when the immune system is really ramped
22:38I've always been intrigued by the idea that when the immune system is really ramped
22:38I've always been intrigued by the idea that when the immune system is really ramped
22:38I've always been intrigued by the idea that when the immune system is really ramped
22:38I've always been intrigued by the idea that when the immune system is really ramped
22:42up, people will experience autoimmune -like symptoms.
22:42up, people will experience autoimmune -like symptoms.
22:42up, people will experience autoimmune -like symptoms.
22:42up, people will experience autoimmune -like symptoms.
22:42up, people will experience autoimmune -like symptoms.
22:42up, people will experience autoimmune -like symptoms.
22:45I experienced that as a master's student.
22:45I experienced that as a master's student.
22:45I experienced that as a master's student.
22:45I experienced that as a master's student.
22:45I experienced that as a master's student.
22:45I experienced that as a master's student.
22:48I was working so much and probably not eating enough and drinking so much caffeine
22:48I was working so much and probably not eating enough and drinking so much caffeine
22:48I was working so much and probably not eating enough and drinking so much caffeine
22:48I was working so much and probably not eating enough and drinking so much caffeine
22:48I was working so much and probably not eating enough and drinking so much caffeine
22:48I was working so much and probably not eating enough and drinking so much caffeine
22:54back then that I got some kind of funky skin lesion things.
22:54back then that I got some kind of funky skin lesion things.
22:54back then that I got some kind of funky skin lesion things.
22:54back then that I got some kind of funky skin lesion things.
22:54back then that I got some kind of funky skin lesion things.
22:54back then that I got some kind of funky skin lesion things.
22:58I went to the doctor and I'm like, oh, you're starting to get some attack
22:58I went to the doctor and I'm like, oh, you're starting to get some attack
22:58I went to the doctor and I'm like, oh, you're starting to get some attack
22:58I went to the doctor and I'm like, oh, you're starting to get some attack
22:58I went to the doctor and I'm like, oh, you're starting to get some attack
22:58I went to the doctor and I'm like, oh, you're starting to get some attack
23:01of the deeper layers of your skin.
23:01of the deeper layers of your skin.
23:01of the deeper layers of your skin.
23:01of the deeper layers of your skin.
23:01of the deeper layers of your skin.
23:01of the deeper layers of your skin.
23:04You just need to work a little less.
23:04You just need to work a little less.
23:04You just need to work a little less.
23:04You just need to work a little less.
23:04You just need to work a little less.
23:04You just need to work a little less.
23:06And sure enough, did that.
23:06And sure enough, did that.
23:06And sure enough, did that.
23:06And sure enough, did that.
23:06And sure enough, did that.
23:06And sure enough, did that.
23:07That did the trick? It did the trick.
23:07That did the trick? It did the trick.
23:07That did the trick? It did the trick.
23:07That did the trick? It did the trick.
23:07That did the trick? It did the trick.
23:07That did the trick? It did the trick.
23:09You know, but I was just, it made me so keenly aware of how the
23:09You know, but I was just, it made me so keenly aware of how the
23:09You know, but I was just, it made me so keenly aware of how the
23:09You know, but I was just, it made me so keenly aware of how the
23:09You know, but I was just, it made me so keenly aware of how the
23:09You know, but I was just, it made me so keenly aware of how the
23:14immune system will, for lack of a better word, adapt to conditions.
23:14immune system will, for lack of a better word, adapt to conditions.
23:14immune system will, for lack of a better word, adapt to conditions.
23:14immune system will, for lack of a better word, adapt to conditions.
23:14immune system will, for lack of a better word, adapt to conditions.
23:14immune system will, for lack of a better word, adapt to conditions.
23:18And it was trying to keep me healthy and it overshot the mark, basically.
23:18And it was trying to keep me healthy and it overshot the mark, basically.
23:18And it was trying to keep me healthy and it overshot the mark, basically.
23:18And it was trying to keep me healthy and it overshot the mark, basically.
23:18And it was trying to keep me healthy and it overshot the mark, basically.
23:18And it was trying to keep me healthy and it overshot the mark, basically.
23:22I sort of walked you through at a first principle, like how things are supposed
23:22I sort of walked you through at a first principle, like how things are supposed
23:22I sort of walked you through at a first principle, like how things are supposed
23:22I sort of walked you through at a first principle, like how things are supposed
23:22I sort of walked you through at a first principle, like how things are supposed
23:22I sort of walked you through at a first principle, like how things are supposed
23:27to work. I told you, okay, there's this process of generating receptors on the surface
23:27to work. I told you, okay, there's this process of generating receptors on the surface
23:27to work. I told you, okay, there's this process of generating receptors on the surface
23:27to work. I told you, okay, there's this process of generating receptors on the surface
23:27to work. I told you, okay, there's this process of generating receptors on the surface
23:27to work. I told you, okay, there's this process of generating receptors on the surface
23:32of T cells. Antibodies get generated on B cells.
23:32of T cells. Antibodies get generated on B cells.
23:32of T cells. Antibodies get generated on B cells.
23:32of T cells. Antibodies get generated on B cells.
23:32of T cells. Antibodies get generated on B cells.
23:32of T cells. Antibodies get generated on B cells.
23:35They go through this positive selection and negative selection.
23:35They go through this positive selection and negative selection.
23:35They go through this positive selection and negative selection.
23:35They go through this positive selection and negative selection.
23:35They go through this positive selection and negative selection.
23:35They go through this positive selection and negative selection.
23:38That's a delicate balancing act and it doesn't actually work that way in practice.
23:38That's a delicate balancing act and it doesn't actually work that way in practice.
23:38That's a delicate balancing act and it doesn't actually work that way in practice.
23:38That's a delicate balancing act and it doesn't actually work that way in practice.
23:38That's a delicate balancing act and it doesn't actually work that way in practice.
23:38That's a delicate balancing act and it doesn't actually work that way in practice.
23:41In practice, T cells escape from the thymus that do recognize our own self -antigens.
23:41In practice, T cells escape from the thymus that do recognize our own self -antigens.
23:41In practice, T cells escape from the thymus that do recognize our own self -antigens.
23:41In practice, T cells escape from the thymus that do recognize our own self -antigens.
23:41In practice, T cells escape from the thymus that do recognize our own self -antigens.
23:41In practice, T cells escape from the thymus that do recognize our own self -antigens.
23:49And there's actually secondary mechanisms to block that.
23:49And there's actually secondary mechanisms to block that.
23:49And there's actually secondary mechanisms to block that.
23:49And there's actually secondary mechanisms to block that.
23:49And there's actually secondary mechanisms to block that.
23:49And there's actually secondary mechanisms to block that.
23:52But autoimmune diseases emerge when those normal checks fail.
23:52But autoimmune diseases emerge when those normal checks fail.
23:52But autoimmune diseases emerge when those normal checks fail.
23:52But autoimmune diseases emerge when those normal checks fail.
23:52But autoimmune diseases emerge when those normal checks fail.
23:52But autoimmune diseases emerge when those normal checks fail.
23:58And I think it's a consequence that the immune system has two major responsibilities.
23:58And I think it's a consequence that the immune system has two major responsibilities.
23:58And I think it's a consequence that the immune system has two major responsibilities.
23:58And I think it's a consequence that the immune system has two major responsibilities.
23:58And I think it's a consequence that the immune system has two major responsibilities.
23:58And I think it's a consequence that the immune system has two major responsibilities.
24:03It has to be primed to protect us from infections, which would be fatal, and
24:03It has to be primed to protect us from infections, which would be fatal, and
24:03It has to be primed to protect us from infections, which would be fatal, and
24:03It has to be primed to protect us from infections, which would be fatal, and
24:03It has to be primed to protect us from infections, which would be fatal, and
24:03It has to be primed to protect us from infections, which would be fatal, and
24:08be strong and recognize this incredible diversity of potential foreign dangerous things that we might
24:08be strong and recognize this incredible diversity of potential foreign dangerous things that we might
24:08be strong and recognize this incredible diversity of potential foreign dangerous things that we might
24:08be strong and recognize this incredible diversity of potential foreign dangerous things that we might
24:08be strong and recognize this incredible diversity of potential foreign dangerous things that we might
24:08be strong and recognize this incredible diversity of potential foreign dangerous things that we might
24:13experience. But it also has to not recognize our own cells.
24:13experience. But it also has to not recognize our own cells.
24:13experience. But it also has to not recognize our own cells.
24:13experience. But it also has to not recognize our own cells.
24:13experience. But it also has to not recognize our own cells.
24:13experience. But it also has to not recognize our own cells.
24:16And it can miss the mark in both ways.
24:16And it can miss the mark in both ways.
24:16And it can miss the mark in both ways.
24:16And it can miss the mark in both ways.
24:16And it can miss the mark in both ways.
24:16And it can miss the mark in both ways.
24:20And so autoimmune disease manifests in different tissues.
24:20And so autoimmune disease manifests in different tissues.
24:20And so autoimmune disease manifests in different tissues.
24:20And so autoimmune disease manifests in different tissues.
24:20And so autoimmune disease manifests in different tissues.
24:20And so autoimmune disease manifests in different tissues.
24:23If your immune system starts recognizing targets in your joints, it can cause rheumatoid arthritis.
24:23If your immune system starts recognizing targets in your joints, it can cause rheumatoid arthritis.
24:23If your immune system starts recognizing targets in your joints, it can cause rheumatoid arthritis.
24:23If your immune system starts recognizing targets in your joints, it can cause rheumatoid arthritis.
24:23If your immune system starts recognizing targets in your joints, it can cause rheumatoid arthritis.
24:23If your immune system starts recognizing targets in your joints, it can cause rheumatoid arthritis.
24:31If it's in the cells that produce insulin in the pancreas, it causes type 1
24:31If it's in the cells that produce insulin in the pancreas, it causes type 1
24:31If it's in the cells that produce insulin in the pancreas, it causes type 1
24:31If it's in the cells that produce insulin in the pancreas, it causes type 1
24:31If it's in the cells that produce insulin in the pancreas, it causes type 1
24:31If it's in the cells that produce insulin in the pancreas, it causes type 1
24:35or childhood diabetes. If it's the myelinated cells in the brain, it's multiple sclerosis.
24:35or childhood diabetes. If it's the myelinated cells in the brain, it's multiple sclerosis.
24:35or childhood diabetes. If it's the myelinated cells in the brain, it's multiple sclerosis.
24:35or childhood diabetes. If it's the myelinated cells in the brain, it's multiple sclerosis.
24:35or childhood diabetes. If it's the myelinated cells in the brain, it's multiple sclerosis.
24:35or childhood diabetes. If it's the myelinated cells in the brain, it's multiple sclerosis.
24:42So this is autoimmunity and inflammation of different kinds cause their own pathology.
24:42So this is autoimmunity and inflammation of different kinds cause their own pathology.
24:42So this is autoimmunity and inflammation of different kinds cause their own pathology.
24:42So this is autoimmunity and inflammation of different kinds cause their own pathology.
24:42So this is autoimmunity and inflammation of different kinds cause their own pathology.
24:42So this is autoimmunity and inflammation of different kinds cause their own pathology.
24:48So we want to... The immune system is always these sort of two sides of
24:48So we want to... The immune system is always these sort of two sides of
24:48So we want to... The immune system is always these sort of two sides of
24:48So we want to... The immune system is always these sort of two sides of
24:48So we want to... The immune system is always these sort of two sides of
24:48So we want to... The immune system is always these sort of two sides of
24:52the coin, making sure that we're having strong responses to infection.
24:52the coin, making sure that we're having strong responses to infection.
24:52the coin, making sure that we're having strong responses to infection.
24:52the coin, making sure that we're having strong responses to infection.
24:52the coin, making sure that we're having strong responses to infection.
24:52the coin, making sure that we're having strong responses to infection.
24:57We'll talk about cancer where we want to also strengthen our responses.
24:57We'll talk about cancer where we want to also strengthen our responses.
24:57We'll talk about cancer where we want to also strengthen our responses.
24:57We'll talk about cancer where we want to also strengthen our responses.
24:57We'll talk about cancer where we want to also strengthen our responses.
24:57We'll talk about cancer where we want to also strengthen our responses.
25:01But for autoimmunity, inflammation, allergies, we want to make sure that...
25:01But for autoimmunity, inflammation, allergies, we want to make sure that...
25:01But for autoimmunity, inflammation, allergies, we want to make sure that...
25:01But for autoimmunity, inflammation, allergies, we want to make sure that...
25:01But for autoimmunity, inflammation, allergies, we want to make sure that...
25:01But for autoimmunity, inflammation, allergies, we want to make sure that...
25:06Like our goal therapeutically with drugs is to make sure that we make the immune
25:06Like our goal therapeutically with drugs is to make sure that we make the immune
25:06Like our goal therapeutically with drugs is to make sure that we make the immune
25:06Like our goal therapeutically with drugs is to make sure that we make the immune
25:06Like our goal therapeutically with drugs is to make sure that we make the immune
25:06Like our goal therapeutically with drugs is to make sure that we make the immune
25:11system under control and ideally do it in a targeted way so that you don't
25:11system under control and ideally do it in a targeted way so that you don't
25:11system under control and ideally do it in a targeted way so that you don't
25:11system under control and ideally do it in a targeted way so that you don't
25:11system under control and ideally do it in a targeted way so that you don't
25:11system under control and ideally do it in a targeted way so that you don't
25:16have to turn off the whole immune system with blanket immunosuppression, but to do it
25:16have to turn off the whole immune system with blanket immunosuppression, but to do it
25:16have to turn off the whole immune system with blanket immunosuppression, but to do it
25:16have to turn off the whole immune system with blanket immunosuppression, but to do it
25:16have to turn off the whole immune system with blanket immunosuppression, but to do it
25:16have to turn off the whole immune system with blanket immunosuppression, but to do it
25:21in a way that just makes you tolerant or not reactive against the things that
25:21in a way that just makes you tolerant or not reactive against the things that
25:21in a way that just makes you tolerant or not reactive against the things that
25:21in a way that just makes you tolerant or not reactive against the things that
25:21in a way that just makes you tolerant or not reactive against the things that
25:21in a way that just makes you tolerant or not reactive against the things that
25:24are being inappropriately targeted by the immune system.
25:24are being inappropriately targeted by the immune system.
25:24are being inappropriately targeted by the immune system.
25:24are being inappropriately targeted by the immune system.
25:24are being inappropriately targeted by the immune system.
25:24are being inappropriately targeted by the immune system.
25:28Two things that I'd love to understand about the immune system is how is it
25:28Two things that I'd love to understand about the immune system is how is it
25:28Two things that I'd love to understand about the immune system is how is it
25:28Two things that I'd love to understand about the immune system is how is it
25:28Two things that I'd love to understand about the immune system is how is it
25:28Two things that I'd love to understand about the immune system is how is it
25:33that an immune response, let's say to a cold virus, is systemic?
25:33that an immune response, let's say to a cold virus, is systemic?
25:33that an immune response, let's say to a cold virus, is systemic?
25:33that an immune response, let's say to a cold virus, is systemic?
25:33that an immune response, let's say to a cold virus, is systemic?
25:33that an immune response, let's say to a cold virus, is systemic?
25:38Like where is the sort of master controller?
25:38Like where is the sort of master controller?
25:38Like where is the sort of master controller?
25:38Like where is the sort of master controller?
25:38Like where is the sort of master controller?
25:38Like where is the sort of master controller?
25:44Is it... Or maybe it's a distributed system that says like, okay, we need to
25:44Is it... Or maybe it's a distributed system that says like, okay, we need to
25:44Is it... Or maybe it's a distributed system that says like, okay, we need to
25:44Is it... Or maybe it's a distributed system that says like, okay, we need to
25:44Is it... Or maybe it's a distributed system that says like, okay, we need to
25:44Is it... Or maybe it's a distributed system that says like, okay, we need to
25:47launch a body -wide response as opposed to a localized response.
25:47launch a body -wide response as opposed to a localized response.
25:47launch a body -wide response as opposed to a localized response.
25:47launch a body -wide response as opposed to a localized response.
25:47launch a body -wide response as opposed to a localized response.
25:47launch a body -wide response as opposed to a localized response.
25:52I can imagine like with a splinter, of course, you're going to get a localized
25:52I can imagine like with a splinter, of course, you're going to get a localized
25:52I can imagine like with a splinter, of course, you're going to get a localized
25:52I can imagine like with a splinter, of course, you're going to get a localized
25:52I can imagine like with a splinter, of course, you're going to get a localized
25:52I can imagine like with a splinter, of course, you're going to get a localized
25:55response. It's a little piece of wood or metal.
25:55response. It's a little piece of wood or metal.
25:55response. It's a little piece of wood or metal.
25:55response. It's a little piece of wood or metal.
25:55response. It's a little piece of wood or metal.
25:55response. It's a little piece of wood or metal.
25:58And so you're going to get the innate response and you're going to get some
25:58And so you're going to get the innate response and you're going to get some
25:58And so you're going to get the innate response and you're going to get some
25:58And so you're going to get the innate response and you're going to get some
25:58And so you're going to get the innate response and you're going to get some
25:58And so you're going to get the innate response and you're going to get some
26:00pus around it and it will kind of localize the wound.
26:00pus around it and it will kind of localize the wound.
26:00pus around it and it will kind of localize the wound.
26:00pus around it and it will kind of localize the wound.
26:00pus around it and it will kind of localize the wound.
26:00pus around it and it will kind of localize the wound.
26:02But when it comes to an invasive virus like the cold virus, it overtakes us,
26:02But when it comes to an invasive virus like the cold virus, it overtakes us,
26:02But when it comes to an invasive virus like the cold virus, it overtakes us,
26:02But when it comes to an invasive virus like the cold virus, it overtakes us,
26:02But when it comes to an invasive virus like the cold virus, it overtakes us,
26:02But when it comes to an invasive virus like the cold virus, it overtakes us,
26:08right? The production of mucus, the headache, like the...
26:08right? The production of mucus, the headache, like the...
26:08right? The production of mucus, the headache, like the...
26:08right? The production of mucus, the headache, like the...
26:08right? The production of mucus, the headache, like the...
26:08right? The production of mucus, the headache, like the...
26:10And I think it's the systemic effect that intrigues me so much.
26:10And I think it's the systemic effect that intrigues me so much.
26:10And I think it's the systemic effect that intrigues me so much.
26:10And I think it's the systemic effect that intrigues me so much.
26:10And I think it's the systemic effect that intrigues me so much.
26:10And I think it's the systemic effect that intrigues me so much.
26:15Like where is the signal to launch a systemic versus a localized response in the
26:15Like where is the signal to launch a systemic versus a localized response in the
26:15Like where is the signal to launch a systemic versus a localized response in the
26:15Like where is the signal to launch a systemic versus a localized response in the
26:15Like where is the signal to launch a systemic versus a localized response in the
26:15Like where is the signal to launch a systemic versus a localized response in the
26:21immune system? How does it determine that?
26:21immune system? How does it determine that?
26:21immune system? How does it determine that?
26:21immune system? How does it determine that?
26:21immune system? How does it determine that?
26:21immune system? How does it determine that?
26:23You know, I think some of it depends on what virus we're talking about, how
26:23You know, I think some of it depends on what virus we're talking about, how
26:23You know, I think some of it depends on what virus we're talking about, how
26:23You know, I think some of it depends on what virus we're talking about, how
26:23You know, I think some of it depends on what virus we're talking about, how
26:23You know, I think some of it depends on what virus we're talking about, how
26:27systemically invasive the different viruses can be.
26:27systemically invasive the different viruses can be.
26:27systemically invasive the different viruses can be.
26:27systemically invasive the different viruses can be.
26:27systemically invasive the different viruses can be.
26:27systemically invasive the different viruses can be.
26:31And some of it can be that the immune system has different levels of, you
26:31And some of it can be that the immune system has different levels of, you
26:31And some of it can be that the immune system has different levels of, you
26:31And some of it can be that the immune system has different levels of, you
26:31And some of it can be that the immune system has different levels of, you
26:31And some of it can be that the immune system has different levels of, you
26:35know, it can have a local response.
26:35know, it can have a local response.
26:35know, it can have a local response.
26:35know, it can have a local response.
26:35know, it can have a local response.
26:35know, it can have a local response.
26:36But the cells that we talked about in the immune system, one of their jobs
26:36But the cells that we talked about in the immune system, one of their jobs
26:36But the cells that we talked about in the immune system, one of their jobs
26:36But the cells that we talked about in the immune system, one of their jobs
26:36But the cells that we talked about in the immune system, one of their jobs
26:36But the cells that we talked about in the immune system, one of their jobs
26:41can actually be to secrete things into the bloodstream, things that are essentially chemical signals
26:41can actually be to secrete things into the bloodstream, things that are essentially chemical signals
26:41can actually be to secrete things into the bloodstream, things that are essentially chemical signals
26:41can actually be to secrete things into the bloodstream, things that are essentially chemical signals
26:41can actually be to secrete things into the bloodstream, things that are essentially chemical signals
26:41can actually be to secrete things into the bloodstream, things that are essentially chemical signals
26:48that something is wrong. Major ones, they're called cytokines and they can act locally but
26:48that something is wrong. Major ones, they're called cytokines and they can act locally but
26:48that something is wrong. Major ones, they're called cytokines and they can act locally but
26:48that something is wrong. Major ones, they're called cytokines and they can act locally but
26:48that something is wrong. Major ones, they're called cytokines and they can act locally but
26:48that something is wrong. Major ones, they're called cytokines and they can act locally but
26:53they can also have more distributed effects.
26:53they can also have more distributed effects.
26:53they can also have more distributed effects.
26:53they can also have more distributed effects.
26:53they can also have more distributed effects.
26:53they can also have more distributed effects.
26:55And some of the things that the cytokines can do can influence, can cause the
26:55And some of the things that the cytokines can do can influence, can cause the
26:55And some of the things that the cytokines can do can influence, can cause the
26:55And some of the things that the cytokines can do can influence, can cause the
26:55And some of the things that the cytokines can do can influence, can cause the
26:55And some of the things that the cytokines can do can influence, can cause the
27:01development of fever, right? So you can have these sort of cascading effects of something
27:01development of fever, right? So you can have these sort of cascading effects of something
27:01development of fever, right? So you can have these sort of cascading effects of something
27:01development of fever, right? So you can have these sort of cascading effects of something
27:01development of fever, right? So you can have these sort of cascading effects of something
27:01development of fever, right? So you can have these sort of cascading effects of something
27:05being recognized at a particular side of the body than sending distributed signals to the
27:05being recognized at a particular side of the body than sending distributed signals to the
27:05being recognized at a particular side of the body than sending distributed signals to the
27:05being recognized at a particular side of the body than sending distributed signals to the
27:05being recognized at a particular side of the body than sending distributed signals to the
27:05being recognized at a particular side of the body than sending distributed signals to the
27:10blood that will make us feel sick.
27:10blood that will make us feel sick.
27:10blood that will make us feel sick.
27:10blood that will make us feel sick.
27:10blood that will make us feel sick.
27:10blood that will make us feel sick.
27:12And, you know, in some cases there's again this bad...
27:12And, you know, in some cases there's again this bad...
27:12And, you know, in some cases there's again this bad...
27:12And, you know, in some cases there's again this bad...
27:12And, you know, in some cases there's again this bad...
27:12And, you know, in some cases there's again this bad...
27:15balancing act of maybe the fever gives us some edge in fighting some types of
27:15balancing act of maybe the fever gives us some edge in fighting some types of
27:15balancing act of maybe the fever gives us some edge in fighting some types of
27:15balancing act of maybe the fever gives us some edge in fighting some types of
27:15balancing act of maybe the fever gives us some edge in fighting some types of
27:15balancing act of maybe the fever gives us some edge in fighting some types of
27:19infection, but it also makes us feel lousy.
27:19infection, but it also makes us feel lousy.
27:19infection, but it also makes us feel lousy.
27:19infection, but it also makes us feel lousy.
27:19infection, but it also makes us feel lousy.
27:19infection, but it also makes us feel lousy.
27:21And so the immune system is always walking.
27:21And so the immune system is always walking.
27:21And so the immune system is always walking.
27:21And so the immune system is always walking.
27:21And so the immune system is always walking.
27:21And so the immune system is always walking.
27:25I think sometimes the immune system response to infections is too strong.
27:25I think sometimes the immune system response to infections is too strong.
27:25I think sometimes the immune system response to infections is too strong.
27:25I think sometimes the immune system response to infections is too strong.
27:25I think sometimes the immune system response to infections is too strong.
27:25I think sometimes the immune system response to infections is too strong.
27:30And a lot of the negative consequences of what we experience is the immune system
27:30And a lot of the negative consequences of what we experience is the immune system
27:30And a lot of the negative consequences of what we experience is the immune system
27:30And a lot of the negative consequences of what we experience is the immune system
27:30And a lot of the negative consequences of what we experience is the immune system
27:30And a lot of the negative consequences of what we experience is the immune system
27:34going too far and having to come back as an infection gets under control.
27:34going too far and having to come back as an infection gets under control.
27:34going too far and having to come back as an infection gets under control.
27:34going too far and having to come back as an infection gets under control.
27:34going too far and having to come back as an infection gets under control.
27:34going too far and having to come back as an infection gets under control.
27:39Thank you. One of the reasons I ask that is, well, I hate being sick.
27:39Thank you. One of the reasons I ask that is, well, I hate being sick.
27:39Thank you. One of the reasons I ask that is, well, I hate being sick.
27:39Thank you. One of the reasons I ask that is, well, I hate being sick.
27:39Thank you. One of the reasons I ask that is, well, I hate being sick.
27:39Thank you. One of the reasons I ask that is, well, I hate being sick.
27:43Fortunately, I don't get sick too often.
27:43Fortunately, I don't get sick too often.
27:43Fortunately, I don't get sick too often.
27:43Fortunately, I don't get sick too often.
27:43Fortunately, I don't get sick too often.
27:43Fortunately, I don't get sick too often.
27:45If I take good care, which I think is like most people, I think about
27:45If I take good care, which I think is like most people, I think about
27:45If I take good care, which I think is like most people, I think about
27:45If I take good care, which I think is like most people, I think about
27:45If I take good care, which I think is like most people, I think about
27:45If I take good care, which I think is like most people, I think about
27:48antibiotics, for instance. Antibiotics are amazing.
27:48antibiotics, for instance. Antibiotics are amazing.
27:48antibiotics, for instance. Antibiotics are amazing.
27:48antibiotics, for instance. Antibiotics are amazing.
27:48antibiotics, for instance. Antibiotics are amazing.
27:48antibiotics, for instance. Antibiotics are amazing.
27:51I've had a few things where I was like, oh, this thing's bothering me.
27:51I've had a few things where I was like, oh, this thing's bothering me.
27:51I've had a few things where I was like, oh, this thing's bothering me.
27:51I've had a few things where I was like, oh, this thing's bothering me.
27:51I've had a few things where I was like, oh, this thing's bothering me.
27:51I've had a few things where I was like, oh, this thing's bothering me.
27:55And like I had this sinus infection a few years back.
27:55And like I had this sinus infection a few years back.
27:55And like I had this sinus infection a few years back.
27:55And like I had this sinus infection a few years back.
27:55And like I had this sinus infection a few years back.
27:55And like I had this sinus infection a few years back.
27:58And I was like, oh, this is definitely not a cold.
27:58And I was like, oh, this is definitely not a cold.
27:58And I was like, oh, this is definitely not a cold.
27:58And I was like, oh, this is definitely not a cold.
27:58And I was like, oh, this is definitely not a cold.
27:58And I was like, oh, this is definitely not a cold.
28:00And then they tell you it's not a sinus infection unless I was like, I
28:00And then they tell you it's not a sinus infection unless I was like, I
28:00And then they tell you it's not a sinus infection unless I was like, I
28:00And then they tell you it's not a sinus infection unless I was like, I
28:00And then they tell you it's not a sinus infection unless I was like, I
28:00And then they tell you it's not a sinus infection unless I was like, I
28:03have a feeling. Now, I'm not a physician, of course, but it got really bad.
28:03have a feeling. Now, I'm not a physician, of course, but it got really bad.
28:03have a feeling. Now, I'm not a physician, of course, but it got really bad.
28:03have a feeling. Now, I'm not a physician, of course, but it got really bad.
28:03have a feeling. Now, I'm not a physician, of course, but it got really bad.
28:03have a feeling. Now, I'm not a physician, of course, but it got really bad.
28:08And I took antibiotics. And within a day, I was feeling substantially better.
28:08And I took antibiotics. And within a day, I was feeling substantially better.
28:08And I took antibiotics. And within a day, I was feeling substantially better.
28:08And I took antibiotics. And within a day, I was feeling substantially better.
28:08And I took antibiotics. And within a day, I was feeling substantially better.
28:08And I took antibiotics. And within a day, I was feeling substantially better.
28:15That's great. Many people have such experiences with antibiotics.
28:15That's great. Many people have such experiences with antibiotics.
28:15That's great. Many people have such experiences with antibiotics.
28:15That's great. Many people have such experiences with antibiotics.
28:15That's great. Many people have such experiences with antibiotics.
28:15That's great. Many people have such experiences with antibiotics.
28:18I realize they can be overprescribed and you can end up with antibiotic -resistant infections.
28:18I realize they can be overprescribed and you can end up with antibiotic -resistant infections.
28:18I realize they can be overprescribed and you can end up with antibiotic -resistant infections.
28:18I realize they can be overprescribed and you can end up with antibiotic -resistant infections.
28:18I realize they can be overprescribed and you can end up with antibiotic -resistant infections.
28:18I realize they can be overprescribed and you can end up with antibiotic -resistant infections.
28:23That's a concern for sure.
28:23That's a concern for sure.
28:23That's a concern for sure.
28:23That's a concern for sure.
28:23That's a concern for sure.
28:23That's a concern for sure.
28:24But what is the sort of inherent danger of using things like antibiotics the way
28:24But what is the sort of inherent danger of using things like antibiotics the way
28:24But what is the sort of inherent danger of using things like antibiotics the way
28:24But what is the sort of inherent danger of using things like antibiotics the way
28:24But what is the sort of inherent danger of using things like antibiotics the way
28:24But what is the sort of inherent danger of using things like antibiotics the way
28:31I described, like not in a life or death situation, to mitigate the duration or
28:31I described, like not in a life or death situation, to mitigate the duration or
28:31I described, like not in a life or death situation, to mitigate the duration or
28:31I described, like not in a life or death situation, to mitigate the duration or
28:31I described, like not in a life or death situation, to mitigate the duration or
28:31I described, like not in a life or death situation, to mitigate the duration or
28:38the intensity of some sort of infection?
28:38the intensity of some sort of infection?
28:38the intensity of some sort of infection?
28:38the intensity of some sort of infection?
28:38the intensity of some sort of infection?
28:38the intensity of some sort of infection?
28:40Because surely you're short -circuiting your immune system's ability to eventually just fight that thing
28:40Because surely you're short -circuiting your immune system's ability to eventually just fight that thing
28:40Because surely you're short -circuiting your immune system's ability to eventually just fight that thing
28:40Because surely you're short -circuiting your immune system's ability to eventually just fight that thing
28:40Because surely you're short -circuiting your immune system's ability to eventually just fight that thing
28:40Because surely you're short -circuiting your immune system's ability to eventually just fight that thing
28:47off. Like is part of building a robust immune system across your lifespan, allowing your
28:47off. Like is part of building a robust immune system across your lifespan, allowing your
28:47off. Like is part of building a robust immune system across your lifespan, allowing your
28:47off. Like is part of building a robust immune system across your lifespan, allowing your
28:47off. Like is part of building a robust immune system across your lifespan, allowing your
28:47off. Like is part of building a robust immune system across your lifespan, allowing your
28:52immune system to do the work and going through the misery of being really sick
28:52immune system to do the work and going through the misery of being really sick
28:52immune system to do the work and going through the misery of being really sick
28:52immune system to do the work and going through the misery of being really sick
28:52immune system to do the work and going through the misery of being really sick
28:52immune system to do the work and going through the misery of being really sick
28:56and infected? I don't think so.
28:56and infected? I don't think so.
28:56and infected? I don't think so.
28:56and infected? I don't think so.
28:56and infected? I don't think so.
28:56and infected? I don't think so.
28:57Great. Okay. Fantastic. Love that answer.
28:57Great. Okay. Fantastic. Love that answer.
28:57Great. Okay. Fantastic. Love that answer.
28:57Great. Okay. Fantastic. Love that answer.
28:57Great. Okay. Fantastic. Love that answer.
28:57Great. Okay. Fantastic. Love that answer.
28:59Love that answer. I think you probably were exposed and had an immune response.
28:59Love that answer. I think you probably were exposed and had an immune response.
28:59Love that answer. I think you probably were exposed and had an immune response.
28:59Love that answer. I think you probably were exposed and had an immune response.
28:59Love that answer. I think you probably were exposed and had an immune response.
28:59Love that answer. I think you probably were exposed and had an immune response.
29:04The antibiotics, when they're used for bacterial infections that are susceptible to them, are a
29:04The antibiotics, when they're used for bacterial infections that are susceptible to them, are a
29:04The antibiotics, when they're used for bacterial infections that are susceptible to them, are a
29:04The antibiotics, when they're used for bacterial infections that are susceptible to them, are a
29:04The antibiotics, when they're used for bacterial infections that are susceptible to them, are a
29:04The antibiotics, when they're used for bacterial infections that are susceptible to them, are a
29:10miracle. And, you know, we live in this amazing sliver of human history where we
29:10miracle. And, you know, we live in this amazing sliver of human history where we
29:10miracle. And, you know, we live in this amazing sliver of human history where we
29:10miracle. And, you know, we live in this amazing sliver of human history where we
29:10miracle. And, you know, we live in this amazing sliver of human history where we
29:10miracle. And, you know, we live in this amazing sliver of human history where we
29:15have antibiotics that can cure disease.
29:15have antibiotics that can cure disease.
29:15have antibiotics that can cure disease.
29:15have antibiotics that can cure disease.
29:15have antibiotics that can cure disease.
29:15have antibiotics that can cure disease.
29:17I mean, I think many of us have had bacterial infections of different kinds, cuts
29:17I mean, I think many of us have had bacterial infections of different kinds, cuts
29:17I mean, I think many of us have had bacterial infections of different kinds, cuts
29:17I mean, I think many of us have had bacterial infections of different kinds, cuts
29:17I mean, I think many of us have had bacterial infections of different kinds, cuts
29:17I mean, I think many of us have had bacterial infections of different kinds, cuts
29:23and wounds that would have been deadly in other generations and we're the beneficiaries of
29:23and wounds that would have been deadly in other generations and we're the beneficiaries of
29:23and wounds that would have been deadly in other generations and we're the beneficiaries of
29:23and wounds that would have been deadly in other generations and we're the beneficiaries of
29:23and wounds that would have been deadly in other generations and we're the beneficiaries of
29:23and wounds that would have been deadly in other generations and we're the beneficiaries of
29:28having antibiotics that work. We are at some risk that if we overuse them, that
29:28having antibiotics that work. We are at some risk that if we overuse them, that
29:28having antibiotics that work. We are at some risk that if we overuse them, that
29:28having antibiotics that work. We are at some risk that if we overuse them, that
29:28having antibiotics that work. We are at some risk that if we overuse them, that
29:28having antibiotics that work. We are at some risk that if we overuse them, that
29:35window of human history might come to an end if we don't continue to replenish
29:35window of human history might come to an end if we don't continue to replenish
29:35window of human history might come to an end if we don't continue to replenish
29:35window of human history might come to an end if we don't continue to replenish
29:35window of human history might come to an end if we don't continue to replenish
29:35window of human history might come to an end if we don't continue to replenish
29:38new antibiotics, but we gain more and more bacteria that are resistant to antibiotics.
29:38new antibiotics, but we gain more and more bacteria that are resistant to antibiotics.
29:38new antibiotics, but we gain more and more bacteria that are resistant to antibiotics.
29:38new antibiotics, but we gain more and more bacteria that are resistant to antibiotics.
29:38new antibiotics, but we gain more and more bacteria that are resistant to antibiotics.
29:38new antibiotics, but we gain more and more bacteria that are resistant to antibiotics.
29:43Are people developing new antibiotics?
29:43Are people developing new antibiotics?
29:43Are people developing new antibiotics?
29:43Are people developing new antibiotics?
29:43Are people developing new antibiotics?
29:43Are people developing new antibiotics?
29:45It's an underfunded area of medicine.
29:45It's an underfunded area of medicine.
29:45It's an underfunded area of medicine.
29:45It's an underfunded area of medicine.
29:45It's an underfunded area of medicine.
29:45It's an underfunded area of medicine.
29:47Because I just hear amoxicillin, penicillin.
29:47Because I just hear amoxicillin, penicillin.
29:47Because I just hear amoxicillin, penicillin.
29:47Because I just hear amoxicillin, penicillin.
29:47Because I just hear amoxicillin, penicillin.
29:47Because I just hear amoxicillin, penicillin.
29:48I have a friend over in the UK who's been having some eye symptoms that,
29:48I have a friend over in the UK who's been having some eye symptoms that,
29:48I have a friend over in the UK who's been having some eye symptoms that,
29:48I have a friend over in the UK who's been having some eye symptoms that,
29:48I have a friend over in the UK who's been having some eye symptoms that,
29:48I have a friend over in the UK who's been having some eye symptoms that,
29:53from what I'm learning, we're still learning, is likely an infection near the posterior chamber,
29:53from what I'm learning, we're still learning, is likely an infection near the posterior chamber,
29:53from what I'm learning, we're still learning, is likely an infection near the posterior chamber,
29:53from what I'm learning, we're still learning, is likely an infection near the posterior chamber,
29:53from what I'm learning, we're still learning, is likely an infection near the posterior chamber,
29:53from what I'm learning, we're still learning, is likely an infection near the posterior chamber,
29:59which just simply means his vision is potentially at risk.
29:59which just simply means his vision is potentially at risk.
29:59which just simply means his vision is potentially at risk.
29:59which just simply means his vision is potentially at risk.
29:59which just simply means his vision is potentially at risk.
29:59which just simply means his vision is potentially at risk.
30:02Systemic antibiotics are very likely going to save his vision.
30:02Systemic antibiotics are very likely going to save his vision.
30:02Systemic antibiotics are very likely going to save his vision.
30:02Systemic antibiotics are very likely going to save his vision.
30:02Systemic antibiotics are very likely going to save his vision.
30:02Systemic antibiotics are very likely going to save his vision.
30:05And so people say, well, antibiotics are better, like 100 years ago, they would have
30:05And so people say, well, antibiotics are better, like 100 years ago, they would have
30:05And so people say, well, antibiotics are better, like 100 years ago, they would have
30:05And so people say, well, antibiotics are better, like 100 years ago, they would have
30:05And so people say, well, antibiotics are better, like 100 years ago, they would have
30:05And so people say, well, antibiotics are better, like 100 years ago, they would have
30:10just enucleated the eye, which is to be blind, right?
30:10just enucleated the eye, which is to be blind, right?
30:10just enucleated the eye, which is to be blind, right?
30:10just enucleated the eye, which is to be blind, right?
30:10just enucleated the eye, which is to be blind, right?
30:10just enucleated the eye, which is to be blind, right?
30:14So I think they're a spectacularly good tool, but it seems like there's just a
30:14So I think they're a spectacularly good tool, but it seems like there's just a
30:14So I think they're a spectacularly good tool, but it seems like there's just a
30:14So I think they're a spectacularly good tool, but it seems like there's just a
30:14So I think they're a spectacularly good tool, but it seems like there's just a
30:14So I think they're a spectacularly good tool, but it seems like there's just a
30:17kit of maybe, what, five to a dozen very commonly prescribed ones.
30:17kit of maybe, what, five to a dozen very commonly prescribed ones.
30:17kit of maybe, what, five to a dozen very commonly prescribed ones.
30:17kit of maybe, what, five to a dozen very commonly prescribed ones.
30:17kit of maybe, what, five to a dozen very commonly prescribed ones.
30:17kit of maybe, what, five to a dozen very commonly prescribed ones.
30:23Why aren't people developing better, newer, new generation antibiotics?
30:23Why aren't people developing better, newer, new generation antibiotics?
30:23Why aren't people developing better, newer, new generation antibiotics?
30:23Why aren't people developing better, newer, new generation antibiotics?
30:23Why aren't people developing better, newer, new generation antibiotics?
30:23Why aren't people developing better, newer, new generation antibiotics?
30:27It seems like it would be, if for no other reason, a trillion dollar industry,
30:27It seems like it would be, if for no other reason, a trillion dollar industry,
30:27It seems like it would be, if for no other reason, a trillion dollar industry,
30:27It seems like it would be, if for no other reason, a trillion dollar industry,
30:27It seems like it would be, if for no other reason, a trillion dollar industry,
30:27It seems like it would be, if for no other reason, a trillion dollar industry,
30:31but also save a lot of lives.
30:31but also save a lot of lives.
30:31but also save a lot of lives.
30:31but also save a lot of lives.
30:31but also save a lot of lives.
30:31but also save a lot of lives.
30:33I don't know whether there's a business reason for that, but it is an underfunded
30:33I don't know whether there's a business reason for that, but it is an underfunded
30:33I don't know whether there's a business reason for that, but it is an underfunded
30:33I don't know whether there's a business reason for that, but it is an underfunded
30:33I don't know whether there's a business reason for that, but it is an underfunded
30:33I don't know whether there's a business reason for that, but it is an underfunded
30:39area. It's not where medicine has turned enough attention, and I do think it's a
30:39area. It's not where medicine has turned enough attention, and I do think it's a
30:39area. It's not where medicine has turned enough attention, and I do think it's a
30:39area. It's not where medicine has turned enough attention, and I do think it's a
30:39area. It's not where medicine has turned enough attention, and I do think it's a
30:39area. It's not where medicine has turned enough attention, and I do think it's a
30:43genuine risk. All right. Well, some entrepreneurial young guy or gal or both will launch
30:43genuine risk. All right. Well, some entrepreneurial young guy or gal or both will launch
30:43genuine risk. All right. Well, some entrepreneurial young guy or gal or both will launch
30:43genuine risk. All right. Well, some entrepreneurial young guy or gal or both will launch
30:43genuine risk. All right. Well, some entrepreneurial young guy or gal or both will launch
30:43genuine risk. All right. Well, some entrepreneurial young guy or gal or both will launch
30:50into it. I want to understand the relationship between the immune system and cancer.
30:50into it. I want to understand the relationship between the immune system and cancer.
30:50into it. I want to understand the relationship between the immune system and cancer.
30:50into it. I want to understand the relationship between the immune system and cancer.
30:50into it. I want to understand the relationship between the immune system and cancer.
30:50into it. I want to understand the relationship between the immune system and cancer.
30:56But perhaps first we should talk about cancer, what it is and what it isn't.
30:56But perhaps first we should talk about cancer, what it is and what it isn't.
30:56But perhaps first we should talk about cancer, what it is and what it isn't.
30:56But perhaps first we should talk about cancer, what it is and what it isn't.
30:56But perhaps first we should talk about cancer, what it is and what it isn't.
30:56But perhaps first we should talk about cancer, what it is and what it isn't.
31:00I think there's a lot of misunderstanding out there that cancer did not exist in
31:00I think there's a lot of misunderstanding out there that cancer did not exist in
31:00I think there's a lot of misunderstanding out there that cancer did not exist in
31:00I think there's a lot of misunderstanding out there that cancer did not exist in
31:00I think there's a lot of misunderstanding out there that cancer did not exist in
31:00I think there's a lot of misunderstanding out there that cancer did not exist in
31:06our not -so -distant past.
31:06our not -so -distant past.
31:06our not -so -distant past.
31:06our not -so -distant past.
31:06our not -so -distant past.
31:06our not -so -distant past.
31:09I mean, you hear this, like people say, oh, you know, cancer is a new
31:09I mean, you hear this, like people say, oh, you know, cancer is a new
31:09I mean, you hear this, like people say, oh, you know, cancer is a new
31:09I mean, you hear this, like people say, oh, you know, cancer is a new
31:09I mean, you hear this, like people say, oh, you know, cancer is a new
31:09I mean, you hear this, like people say, oh, you know, cancer is a new
31:11thing because of the advent of, you know, all these devices with EMFs and radiation.
31:11thing because of the advent of, you know, all these devices with EMFs and radiation.
31:11thing because of the advent of, you know, all these devices with EMFs and radiation.
31:11thing because of the advent of, you know, all these devices with EMFs and radiation.
31:11thing because of the advent of, you know, all these devices with EMFs and radiation.
31:11thing because of the advent of, you know, all these devices with EMFs and radiation.
31:16That's certainly not what I believe.
31:16That's certainly not what I believe.
31:16That's certainly not what I believe.
31:16That's certainly not what I believe.
31:16That's certainly not what I believe.
31:16That's certainly not what I believe.
31:18Has cancer been around a very, very long time?
31:18Has cancer been around a very, very long time?
31:18Has cancer been around a very, very long time?
31:18Has cancer been around a very, very long time?
31:18Has cancer been around a very, very long time?
31:18Has cancer been around a very, very long time?
31:20Do we have evidence for that?
31:20Do we have evidence for that?
31:20Do we have evidence for that?
31:20Do we have evidence for that?
31:20Do we have evidence for that?
31:20Do we have evidence for that?
31:21Yeah, I mean, if anyone's really interested, I would highly recommend this book, The Emperor
31:21Yeah, I mean, if anyone's really interested, I would highly recommend this book, The Emperor
31:21Yeah, I mean, if anyone's really interested, I would highly recommend this book, The Emperor
31:21Yeah, I mean, if anyone's really interested, I would highly recommend this book, The Emperor
31:21Yeah, I mean, if anyone's really interested, I would highly recommend this book, The Emperor
31:21Yeah, I mean, if anyone's really interested, I would highly recommend this book, The Emperor
31:27of All Maladies, which is really a biography of cancer as a disease and talk
31:27of All Maladies, which is really a biography of cancer as a disease and talk
31:27of All Maladies, which is really a biography of cancer as a disease and talk
31:27of All Maladies, which is really a biography of cancer as a disease and talk
31:27of All Maladies, which is really a biography of cancer as a disease and talk
31:27of All Maladies, which is really a biography of cancer as a disease and talk
31:33about, I mean, the long history of going back as far as there's records of
31:33about, I mean, the long history of going back as far as there's records of
31:33about, I mean, the long history of going back as far as there's records of
31:33about, I mean, the long history of going back as far as there's records of
31:33about, I mean, the long history of going back as far as there's records of
31:33about, I mean, the long history of going back as far as there's records of
31:38tumors of various kinds and the misery associated with that.
31:38tumors of various kinds and the misery associated with that.
31:38tumors of various kinds and the misery associated with that.
31:38tumors of various kinds and the misery associated with that.
31:38tumors of various kinds and the misery associated with that.
31:38tumors of various kinds and the misery associated with that.
31:42But we have a very different understanding of cancer right now, right?
31:42But we have a very different understanding of cancer right now, right?
31:42But we have a very different understanding of cancer right now, right?
31:42But we have a very different understanding of cancer right now, right?
31:42But we have a very different understanding of cancer right now, right?
31:42But we have a very different understanding of cancer right now, right?
31:47And I think cancer is one of the most sophisticated, where we have one of
31:47And I think cancer is one of the most sophisticated, where we have one of
31:47And I think cancer is one of the most sophisticated, where we have one of
31:47And I think cancer is one of the most sophisticated, where we have one of
31:47And I think cancer is one of the most sophisticated, where we have one of
31:47And I think cancer is one of the most sophisticated, where we have one of
31:50the most sophisticated genetic understandings of disease.
31:50the most sophisticated genetic understandings of disease.
31:50the most sophisticated genetic understandings of disease.
31:50the most sophisticated genetic understandings of disease.
31:50the most sophisticated genetic understandings of disease.
31:50the most sophisticated genetic understandings of disease.
31:54It doesn't mean we can always do things about it, but now we can understand
31:54It doesn't mean we can always do things about it, but now we can understand
31:54It doesn't mean we can always do things about it, but now we can understand
31:54It doesn't mean we can always do things about it, but now we can understand
31:54It doesn't mean we can always do things about it, but now we can understand
31:54It doesn't mean we can always do things about it, but now we can understand
31:57mutations that accumulate in cells.
31:57mutations that accumulate in cells.
31:57mutations that accumulate in cells.
31:57mutations that accumulate in cells.
31:57mutations that accumulate in cells.
31:57mutations that accumulate in cells.
32:00And all of a sudden, so the DNA inside of a healthy cell is there
32:00And all of a sudden, so the DNA inside of a healthy cell is there
32:00And all of a sudden, so the DNA inside of a healthy cell is there
32:00And all of a sudden, so the DNA inside of a healthy cell is there
32:00And all of a sudden, so the DNA inside of a healthy cell is there
32:00And all of a sudden, so the DNA inside of a healthy cell is there
32:06programming. So if you have a skin cell, your DNA is programming your skin cell
32:06programming. So if you have a skin cell, your DNA is programming your skin cell
32:06programming. So if you have a skin cell, your DNA is programming your skin cell
32:06programming. So if you have a skin cell, your DNA is programming your skin cell
32:06programming. So if you have a skin cell, your DNA is programming your skin cell
32:06programming. So if you have a skin cell, your DNA is programming your skin cell
32:10to be a skin cell.
32:10to be a skin cell.
32:10to be a skin cell.
32:10to be a skin cell.
32:10to be a skin cell.
32:10to be a skin cell.
32:12In cancer, all of a sudden, some combination of mutations emerge in that cell that
32:12In cancer, all of a sudden, some combination of mutations emerge in that cell that
32:12In cancer, all of a sudden, some combination of mutations emerge in that cell that
32:12In cancer, all of a sudden, some combination of mutations emerge in that cell that
32:12In cancer, all of a sudden, some combination of mutations emerge in that cell that
32:12In cancer, all of a sudden, some combination of mutations emerge in that cell that
32:18lose its normal regulation. The skin cell is no longer getting the proper signals from
32:18lose its normal regulation. The skin cell is no longer getting the proper signals from
32:18lose its normal regulation. The skin cell is no longer getting the proper signals from
32:18lose its normal regulation. The skin cell is no longer getting the proper signals from
32:18lose its normal regulation. The skin cell is no longer getting the proper signals from
32:18lose its normal regulation. The skin cell is no longer getting the proper signals from
32:25its DNA to stay in the right place, and it goes and switches into a
32:25its DNA to stay in the right place, and it goes and switches into a
32:25its DNA to stay in the right place, and it goes and switches into a
32:25its DNA to stay in the right place, and it goes and switches into a
32:25its DNA to stay in the right place, and it goes and switches into a
32:25its DNA to stay in the right place, and it goes and switches into a
32:28mode where it's dividing out of control.
32:28mode where it's dividing out of control.
32:28mode where it's dividing out of control.
32:28mode where it's dividing out of control.
32:28mode where it's dividing out of control.
32:28mode where it's dividing out of control.
32:30And the result is that those cells will then transform into cancer cells.
32:30And the result is that those cells will then transform into cancer cells.
32:30And the result is that those cells will then transform into cancer cells.
32:30And the result is that those cells will then transform into cancer cells.
32:30And the result is that those cells will then transform into cancer cells.
32:30And the result is that those cells will then transform into cancer cells.
32:34They'll start dividing, they'll lose the normal architecture.
32:34They'll start dividing, they'll lose the normal architecture.
32:34They'll start dividing, they'll lose the normal architecture.
32:34They'll start dividing, they'll lose the normal architecture.
32:34They'll start dividing, they'll lose the normal architecture.
32:34They'll start dividing, they'll lose the normal architecture.
32:38The risk is that they can disrupt things in the tissue where they are, or...
32:38The risk is that they can disrupt things in the tissue where they are, or...
32:38The risk is that they can disrupt things in the tissue where they are, or...
32:38The risk is that they can disrupt things in the tissue where they are, or...
32:38The risk is that they can disrupt things in the tissue where they are, or...
32:38The risk is that they can disrupt things in the tissue where they are, or...
32:42that further mutations can accumulate and they can actually start spreading into distant sites in
32:42that further mutations can accumulate and they can actually start spreading into distant sites in
32:42that further mutations can accumulate and they can actually start spreading into distant sites in
32:42that further mutations can accumulate and they can actually start spreading into distant sites in
32:42that further mutations can accumulate and they can actually start spreading into distant sites in
32:42that further mutations can accumulate and they can actually start spreading into distant sites in
32:47the body and that's metastasis when a cancer goes from one local site to another
32:47the body and that's metastasis when a cancer goes from one local site to another
32:47the body and that's metastasis when a cancer goes from one local site to another
32:47the body and that's metastasis when a cancer goes from one local site to another
32:47the body and that's metastasis when a cancer goes from one local site to another
32:47the body and that's metastasis when a cancer goes from one local site to another
32:53part of the body. And as that happens, those cancerous cells, it's really an evolutionary
32:53part of the body. And as that happens, those cancerous cells, it's really an evolutionary
32:53part of the body. And as that happens, those cancerous cells, it's really an evolutionary
32:53part of the body. And as that happens, those cancerous cells, it's really an evolutionary
32:53part of the body. And as that happens, those cancerous cells, it's really an evolutionary
32:53part of the body. And as that happens, those cancerous cells, it's really an evolutionary
33:01process where those cancerous cells have acquired new genetics that are focused on their well
33:01process where those cancerous cells have acquired new genetics that are focused on their well
33:01process where those cancerous cells have acquired new genetics that are focused on their well
33:01process where those cancerous cells have acquired new genetics that are focused on their well
33:01process where those cancerous cells have acquired new genetics that are focused on their well
33:01process where those cancerous cells have acquired new genetics that are focused on their well
33:07-being. Those cells are dividing, they're growing out of control and they're taking the resources,
33:07-being. Those cells are dividing, they're growing out of control and they're taking the resources,
33:07-being. Those cells are dividing, they're growing out of control and they're taking the resources,
33:07-being. Those cells are dividing, they're growing out of control and they're taking the resources,
33:07-being. Those cells are dividing, they're growing out of control and they're taking the resources,
33:07-being. Those cells are dividing, they're growing out of control and they're taking the resources,
33:12they're growing at the expense of the normal coordination of the human body.
33:12they're growing at the expense of the normal coordination of the human body.
33:12they're growing at the expense of the normal coordination of the human body.
33:12they're growing at the expense of the normal coordination of the human body.
33:12they're growing at the expense of the normal coordination of the human body.
33:12they're growing at the expense of the normal coordination of the human body.
33:16And that's really at its core what cancer is.
33:16And that's really at its core what cancer is.
33:16And that's really at its core what cancer is.
33:16And that's really at its core what cancer is.
33:16And that's really at its core what cancer is.
33:16And that's really at its core what cancer is.
33:21It's a genetic disease where cells lose the normal regulation and are dividing out of
33:21It's a genetic disease where cells lose the normal regulation and are dividing out of
33:21It's a genetic disease where cells lose the normal regulation and are dividing out of
33:21It's a genetic disease where cells lose the normal regulation and are dividing out of
33:21It's a genetic disease where cells lose the normal regulation and are dividing out of
33:21It's a genetic disease where cells lose the normal regulation and are dividing out of
33:28control in various tissues. I can see the picture in my mind where an otherwise
33:28control in various tissues. I can see the picture in my mind where an otherwise
33:28control in various tissues. I can see the picture in my mind where an otherwise
33:28control in various tissues. I can see the picture in my mind where an otherwise
33:28control in various tissues. I can see the picture in my mind where an otherwise
33:28control in various tissues. I can see the picture in my mind where an otherwise
33:34healthy cell gets a mutation, we can talk about how mutations arise, and then starts
33:34healthy cell gets a mutation, we can talk about how mutations arise, and then starts
33:34healthy cell gets a mutation, we can talk about how mutations arise, and then starts
33:34healthy cell gets a mutation, we can talk about how mutations arise, and then starts
33:34healthy cell gets a mutation, we can talk about how mutations arise, and then starts
33:34healthy cell gets a mutation, we can talk about how mutations arise, and then starts
33:39spitting off daughter cells, as it's referred to.
33:39spitting off daughter cells, as it's referred to.
33:39spitting off daughter cells, as it's referred to.
33:39spitting off daughter cells, as it's referred to.
33:39spitting off daughter cells, as it's referred to.
33:39spitting off daughter cells, as it's referred to.
33:42Why would the daughter cells inherit the mutation necessarily to then create more cells?
33:42Why would the daughter cells inherit the mutation necessarily to then create more cells?
33:42Why would the daughter cells inherit the mutation necessarily to then create more cells?
33:42Why would the daughter cells inherit the mutation necessarily to then create more cells?
33:42Why would the daughter cells inherit the mutation necessarily to then create more cells?
33:42Why would the daughter cells inherit the mutation necessarily to then create more cells?
33:48Because that's the proliferation of the tumor.
33:48Because that's the proliferation of the tumor.
33:48Because that's the proliferation of the tumor.
33:48Because that's the proliferation of the tumor.
33:48Because that's the proliferation of the tumor.
33:48Because that's the proliferation of the tumor.
33:51Certainly cells propagate their DNA into their daughter cells, but I could imagine a situation
33:51Certainly cells propagate their DNA into their daughter cells, but I could imagine a situation
33:51Certainly cells propagate their DNA into their daughter cells, but I could imagine a situation
33:51Certainly cells propagate their DNA into their daughter cells, but I could imagine a situation
33:51Certainly cells propagate their DNA into their daughter cells, but I could imagine a situation
33:51Certainly cells propagate their DNA into their daughter cells, but I could imagine a situation
34:00where every day some of our cells get a mutation, spit off a couple daughter
34:00where every day some of our cells get a mutation, spit off a couple daughter
34:00where every day some of our cells get a mutation, spit off a couple daughter
34:00where every day some of our cells get a mutation, spit off a couple daughter
34:00where every day some of our cells get a mutation, spit off a couple daughter
34:00where every day some of our cells get a mutation, spit off a couple daughter
34:04cells, and then those daughter cells are terminal, as we say, right?
34:04cells, and then those daughter cells are terminal, as we say, right?
34:04cells, and then those daughter cells are terminal, as we say, right?
34:04cells, and then those daughter cells are terminal, as we say, right?
34:04cells, and then those daughter cells are terminal, as we say, right?
34:04cells, and then those daughter cells are terminal, as we say, right?
34:08And they don't create more cells.
34:08And they don't create more cells.
34:08And they don't create more cells.
34:08And they don't create more cells.
34:08And they don't create more cells.
34:08And they don't create more cells.
34:10Is that happening all over the body every day?
34:10Is that happening all over the body every day?
34:10Is that happening all over the body every day?
34:10Is that happening all over the body every day?
34:10Is that happening all over the body every day?
34:10Is that happening all over the body every day?
34:12So how is it that the DNA that creates the further propagation gets passed from
34:12So how is it that the DNA that creates the further propagation gets passed from
34:12So how is it that the DNA that creates the further propagation gets passed from
34:12So how is it that the DNA that creates the further propagation gets passed from
34:12So how is it that the DNA that creates the further propagation gets passed from
34:12So how is it that the DNA that creates the further propagation gets passed from
34:20one cell to the next?
34:20one cell to the next?
34:20one cell to the next?
34:20one cell to the next?
34:20one cell to the next?
34:20one cell to the next?
34:21I do think this is happening constantly.
34:21I do think this is happening constantly.
34:21I do think this is happening constantly.
34:21I do think this is happening constantly.
34:21I do think this is happening constantly.
34:21I do think this is happening constantly.
34:23It's a process that every time a cell is around, especially as it's dividing, there
34:23It's a process that every time a cell is around, especially as it's dividing, there
34:23It's a process that every time a cell is around, especially as it's dividing, there
34:23It's a process that every time a cell is around, especially as it's dividing, there
34:23It's a process that every time a cell is around, especially as it's dividing, there
34:23It's a process that every time a cell is around, especially as it's dividing, there
34:29is some imperfection in how the DNA has inside each of our cells, if that
34:29is some imperfection in how the DNA has inside each of our cells, if that
34:29is some imperfection in how the DNA has inside each of our cells, if that
34:29is some imperfection in how the DNA has inside each of our cells, if that
34:29is some imperfection in how the DNA has inside each of our cells, if that
34:29is some imperfection in how the DNA has inside each of our cells, if that
34:35cell is going to replicate, the DNA has to replicate itself.
34:35cell is going to replicate, the DNA has to replicate itself.
34:35cell is going to replicate, the DNA has to replicate itself.
34:35cell is going to replicate, the DNA has to replicate itself.
34:35cell is going to replicate, the DNA has to replicate itself.
34:35cell is going to replicate, the DNA has to replicate itself.
34:38So you end up with two copies of DNA that should be the same, each
34:38So you end up with two copies of DNA that should be the same, each
34:38So you end up with two copies of DNA that should be the same, each
34:38So you end up with two copies of DNA that should be the same, each
34:38So you end up with two copies of DNA that should be the same, each
34:38So you end up with two copies of DNA that should be the same, each
34:42one being passed on to the two daughter cells of that dividing cell.
34:42one being passed on to the two daughter cells of that dividing cell.
34:42one being passed on to the two daughter cells of that dividing cell.
34:42one being passed on to the two daughter cells of that dividing cell.
34:42one being passed on to the two daughter cells of that dividing cell.
34:42one being passed on to the two daughter cells of that dividing cell.
34:46That process of DNA replication is imperfect, and if there's any kind of damage during
34:46That process of DNA replication is imperfect, and if there's any kind of damage during
34:46That process of DNA replication is imperfect, and if there's any kind of damage during
34:46That process of DNA replication is imperfect, and if there's any kind of damage during
34:46That process of DNA replication is imperfect, and if there's any kind of damage during
34:46That process of DNA replication is imperfect, and if there's any kind of damage during
34:51that process, one of those two copies might end up different than the other one,
34:51that process, one of those two copies might end up different than the other one,
34:51that process, one of those two copies might end up different than the other one,
34:51that process, one of those two copies might end up different than the other one,
34:51that process, one of those two copies might end up different than the other one,
34:51that process, one of those two copies might end up different than the other one,
34:55in which case you end up with a mutation now in one daughter cell and
34:55in which case you end up with a mutation now in one daughter cell and
34:55in which case you end up with a mutation now in one daughter cell and
34:55in which case you end up with a mutation now in one daughter cell and
34:55in which case you end up with a mutation now in one daughter cell and
34:55in which case you end up with a mutation now in one daughter cell and
34:59not the other. If that is deleterious or if it's damaging, which probably most mutations
34:59not the other. If that is deleterious or if it's damaging, which probably most mutations
34:59not the other. If that is deleterious or if it's damaging, which probably most mutations
34:59not the other. If that is deleterious or if it's damaging, which probably most mutations
34:59not the other. If that is deleterious or if it's damaging, which probably most mutations
34:59not the other. If that is deleterious or if it's damaging, which probably most mutations
35:06are, those cells might start to die off.
35:06are, those cells might start to die off.
35:06are, those cells might start to die off.
35:06are, those cells might start to die off.
35:06are, those cells might start to die off.
35:06are, those cells might start to die off.
35:08Okay, the DNA got messed up.
35:08Okay, the DNA got messed up.
35:08Okay, the DNA got messed up.
35:08Okay, the DNA got messed up.
35:08Okay, the DNA got messed up.
35:08Okay, the DNA got messed up.
35:11Those cells that are carrying that DNA die.
35:11Those cells that are carrying that DNA die.
35:11Those cells that are carrying that DNA die.
35:11Those cells that are carrying that DNA die.
35:11Those cells that are carrying that DNA die.
35:11Those cells that are carrying that DNA die.
35:13Yeah, they can't take up glucose.
35:13Yeah, they can't take up glucose.
35:13Yeah, they can't take up glucose.
35:13Yeah, they can't take up glucose.
35:13Yeah, they can't take up glucose.
35:13Yeah, they can't take up glucose.
35:14They just can't do cell stuff.
35:14They just can't do cell stuff.
35:14They just can't do cell stuff.
35:14They just can't do cell stuff.
35:14They just can't do cell stuff.
35:14They just can't do cell stuff.
35:17And there's a lot of control mechanisms in the cell that say, if something's wrong,
35:17And there's a lot of control mechanisms in the cell that say, if something's wrong,
35:17And there's a lot of control mechanisms in the cell that say, if something's wrong,
35:17And there's a lot of control mechanisms in the cell that say, if something's wrong,
35:17And there's a lot of control mechanisms in the cell that say, if something's wrong,
35:17And there's a lot of control mechanisms in the cell that say, if something's wrong,
35:21let's send a programmed cell death signal to that cell and cells will kind of
35:21let's send a programmed cell death signal to that cell and cells will kind of
35:21let's send a programmed cell death signal to that cell and cells will kind of
35:21let's send a programmed cell death signal to that cell and cells will kind of
35:21let's send a programmed cell death signal to that cell and cells will kind of
35:21let's send a programmed cell death signal to that cell and cells will kind of
35:26implode with various processes when something's wrong.
35:26implode with various processes when something's wrong.
35:26implode with various processes when something's wrong.
35:26implode with various processes when something's wrong.
35:26implode with various processes when something's wrong.
35:26implode with various processes when something's wrong.
35:29And that happens most of the time.
35:29And that happens most of the time.
35:29And that happens most of the time.
35:29And that happens most of the time.
35:29And that happens most of the time.
35:29And that happens most of the time.
35:31The problem is if that change all of a sudden starts to not be damaging,
35:31The problem is if that change all of a sudden starts to not be damaging,
35:31The problem is if that change all of a sudden starts to not be damaging,
35:31The problem is if that change all of a sudden starts to not be damaging,
35:31The problem is if that change all of a sudden starts to not be damaging,
35:31The problem is if that change all of a sudden starts to not be damaging,
35:38but to actually be a signal, okay, now the cell is growing more, it has
35:38but to actually be a signal, okay, now the cell is growing more, it has
35:38but to actually be a signal, okay, now the cell is growing more, it has
35:38but to actually be a signal, okay, now the cell is growing more, it has
35:38but to actually be a signal, okay, now the cell is growing more, it has
35:38but to actually be a signal, okay, now the cell is growing more, it has
35:43some benefit that it's accumulated as a result of that mutation.
35:43some benefit that it's accumulated as a result of that mutation.
35:43some benefit that it's accumulated as a result of that mutation.
35:43some benefit that it's accumulated as a result of that mutation.
35:43some benefit that it's accumulated as a result of that mutation.
35:43some benefit that it's accumulated as a result of that mutation.
35:46Now that cell will start to divide more and that cell that's carrying that first
35:46Now that cell will start to divide more and that cell that's carrying that first
35:46Now that cell will start to divide more and that cell that's carrying that first
35:46Now that cell will start to divide more and that cell that's carrying that first
35:46Now that cell will start to divide more and that cell that's carrying that first
35:46Now that cell will start to divide more and that cell that's carrying that first
35:51mutation might start dividing more.
35:51mutation might start dividing more.
35:51mutation might start dividing more.
35:51mutation might start dividing more.
35:51mutation might start dividing more.
35:51mutation might start dividing more.
35:54Both of its daughters now will pass on this mutation that's made it divide more.
35:54Both of its daughters now will pass on this mutation that's made it divide more.
35:54Both of its daughters now will pass on this mutation that's made it divide more.
35:54Both of its daughters now will pass on this mutation that's made it divide more.
35:54Both of its daughters now will pass on this mutation that's made it divide more.
35:54Both of its daughters now will pass on this mutation that's made it divide more.
35:58And if in subsequent rounds it gets a second hit, the combination may go from
35:58And if in subsequent rounds it gets a second hit, the combination may go from
35:58And if in subsequent rounds it gets a second hit, the combination may go from
35:58And if in subsequent rounds it gets a second hit, the combination may go from
35:58And if in subsequent rounds it gets a second hit, the combination may go from
35:58And if in subsequent rounds it gets a second hit, the combination may go from
36:05just cells that are dividing a little bit more to cells that take off and
36:05just cells that are dividing a little bit more to cells that take off and
36:05just cells that are dividing a little bit more to cells that take off and
36:05just cells that are dividing a little bit more to cells that take off and
36:05just cells that are dividing a little bit more to cells that take off and
36:05just cells that are dividing a little bit more to cells that take off and
36:09become full -blown cancer. Now there's certain processes that will accelerate that.
36:09become full -blown cancer. Now there's certain processes that will accelerate that.
36:09become full -blown cancer. Now there's certain processes that will accelerate that.
36:09become full -blown cancer. Now there's certain processes that will accelerate that.
36:09become full -blown cancer. Now there's certain processes that will accelerate that.
36:09become full -blown cancer. Now there's certain processes that will accelerate that.
36:13One was exposure to things that cause DNA damage, right?
36:13One was exposure to things that cause DNA damage, right?
36:13One was exposure to things that cause DNA damage, right?
36:13One was exposure to things that cause DNA damage, right?
36:13One was exposure to things that cause DNA damage, right?
36:13One was exposure to things that cause DNA damage, right?
36:18The major one is smoking.
36:18The major one is smoking.
36:18The major one is smoking.
36:18The major one is smoking.
36:18The major one is smoking.
36:18The major one is smoking.
36:21When smoking causes chemicals to go into your lungs, the lung cells get exposed to
36:21When smoking causes chemicals to go into your lungs, the lung cells get exposed to
36:21When smoking causes chemicals to go into your lungs, the lung cells get exposed to
36:21When smoking causes chemicals to go into your lungs, the lung cells get exposed to
36:21When smoking causes chemicals to go into your lungs, the lung cells get exposed to
36:21When smoking causes chemicals to go into your lungs, the lung cells get exposed to
36:28these chemicals that then cause higher amounts of DNA damage, more mutations.
36:28these chemicals that then cause higher amounts of DNA damage, more mutations.
36:28these chemicals that then cause higher amounts of DNA damage, more mutations.
36:28these chemicals that then cause higher amounts of DNA damage, more mutations.
36:28these chemicals that then cause higher amounts of DNA damage, more mutations.
36:28these chemicals that then cause higher amounts of DNA damage, more mutations.
36:33And just as you have more mutations at a higher frequency, you're more likely to
36:33And just as you have more mutations at a higher frequency, you're more likely to
36:33And just as you have more mutations at a higher frequency, you're more likely to
36:33And just as you have more mutations at a higher frequency, you're more likely to
36:33And just as you have more mutations at a higher frequency, you're more likely to
36:33And just as you have more mutations at a higher frequency, you're more likely to
36:37accumulate a set of mutations that will gradually go on to cause the generation of
36:37accumulate a set of mutations that will gradually go on to cause the generation of
36:37accumulate a set of mutations that will gradually go on to cause the generation of
36:37accumulate a set of mutations that will gradually go on to cause the generation of
36:37accumulate a set of mutations that will gradually go on to cause the generation of
36:37accumulate a set of mutations that will gradually go on to cause the generation of
36:42cancer. Another way that this process can be accelerated is that some people carry an
36:42cancer. Another way that this process can be accelerated is that some people carry an
36:42cancer. Another way that this process can be accelerated is that some people carry an
36:42cancer. Another way that this process can be accelerated is that some people carry an
36:42cancer. Another way that this process can be accelerated is that some people carry an
36:42cancer. Another way that this process can be accelerated is that some people carry an
36:48underlying genetic predisposition to cancer.
36:48underlying genetic predisposition to cancer.
36:48underlying genetic predisposition to cancer.
36:48underlying genetic predisposition to cancer.
36:48underlying genetic predisposition to cancer.
36:48underlying genetic predisposition to cancer.
36:50So people will likely have heard of the BRCA or the BRCA genes which predispose
36:50So people will likely have heard of the BRCA or the BRCA genes which predispose
36:50So people will likely have heard of the BRCA or the BRCA genes which predispose
36:50So people will likely have heard of the BRCA or the BRCA genes which predispose
36:50So people will likely have heard of the BRCA or the BRCA genes which predispose
36:50So people will likely have heard of the BRCA or the BRCA genes which predispose
36:56to breast cancer and other types of cancer.
36:56to breast cancer and other types of cancer.
36:56to breast cancer and other types of cancer.
36:56to breast cancer and other types of cancer.
36:56to breast cancer and other types of cancer.
36:56to breast cancer and other types of cancer.
36:59There people start with one copy that's already setting them on a road to higher
36:59There people start with one copy that's already setting them on a road to higher
36:59There people start with one copy that's already setting them on a road to higher
36:59There people start with one copy that's already setting them on a road to higher
36:59There people start with one copy that's already setting them on a road to higher
36:59There people start with one copy that's already setting them on a road to higher
37:05risk of mutations accumulating and the whole process happens with a higher frequency.
37:05risk of mutations accumulating and the whole process happens with a higher frequency.
37:05risk of mutations accumulating and the whole process happens with a higher frequency.
37:05risk of mutations accumulating and the whole process happens with a higher frequency.
37:05risk of mutations accumulating and the whole process happens with a higher frequency.
37:05risk of mutations accumulating and the whole process happens with a higher frequency.
37:12And so this march towards cancer cells is more likely to occur in people with
37:12And so this march towards cancer cells is more likely to occur in people with
37:12And so this march towards cancer cells is more likely to occur in people with
37:12And so this march towards cancer cells is more likely to occur in people with
37:12And so this march towards cancer cells is more likely to occur in people with
37:12And so this march towards cancer cells is more likely to occur in people with
37:18that type of predisposition. How common is the BRCA mutation?
37:18that type of predisposition. How common is the BRCA mutation?
37:18that type of predisposition. How common is the BRCA mutation?
37:18that type of predisposition. How common is the BRCA mutation?
37:18that type of predisposition. How common is the BRCA mutation?
37:18that type of predisposition. How common is the BRCA mutation?
37:22Is it equally distributed in men and women?
37:22Is it equally distributed in men and women?
37:22Is it equally distributed in men and women?
37:22Is it equally distributed in men and women?
37:22Is it equally distributed in men and women?
37:22Is it equally distributed in men and women?
37:26Yeah, what can you tell us?
37:26Yeah, what can you tell us?
37:26Yeah, what can you tell us?
37:26Yeah, what can you tell us?
37:26Yeah, what can you tell us?
37:26Yeah, what can you tell us?
37:28And should everyone get tested for BRCA?
37:28And should everyone get tested for BRCA?
37:28And should everyone get tested for BRCA?
37:28And should everyone get tested for BRCA?
37:28And should everyone get tested for BRCA?
37:28And should everyone get tested for BRCA?
37:29And there's a lot of questions here.
37:29And there's a lot of questions here.
37:29And there's a lot of questions here.
37:29And there's a lot of questions here.
37:29And there's a lot of questions here.
37:29And there's a lot of questions here.
37:31I'll ask them again one by one.
37:31I'll ask them again one by one.
37:31I'll ask them again one by one.
37:31I'll ask them again one by one.
37:31I'll ask them again one by one.
37:31I'll ask them again one by one.
37:33And then, of course, we'll talk about things that can be protective, not just, but
37:33And then, of course, we'll talk about things that can be protective, not just, but
37:33And then, of course, we'll talk about things that can be protective, not just, but
37:33And then, of course, we'll talk about things that can be protective, not just, but
37:33And then, of course, we'll talk about things that can be protective, not just, but
37:33And then, of course, we'll talk about things that can be protective, not just, but
37:37certainly avoiding smoking would be paramount.
37:37certainly avoiding smoking would be paramount.
37:37certainly avoiding smoking would be paramount.
37:37certainly avoiding smoking would be paramount.
37:37certainly avoiding smoking would be paramount.
37:37certainly avoiding smoking would be paramount.
37:40So how common is BRCA?
37:40So how common is BRCA?
37:40So how common is BRCA?
37:40So how common is BRCA?
37:40So how common is BRCA?
37:40So how common is BRCA?
37:41So in terms of mutagens, like the big ones are smoking, sun exposure for melanoma.
37:41So in terms of mutagens, like the big ones are smoking, sun exposure for melanoma.
37:41So in terms of mutagens, like the big ones are smoking, sun exposure for melanoma.
37:41So in terms of mutagens, like the big ones are smoking, sun exposure for melanoma.
37:41So in terms of mutagens, like the big ones are smoking, sun exposure for melanoma.
37:41So in terms of mutagens, like the big ones are smoking, sun exposure for melanoma.
37:48They're another balancing features of sun exposure.
37:48They're another balancing features of sun exposure.
37:48They're another balancing features of sun exposure.
37:48They're another balancing features of sun exposure.
37:48They're another balancing features of sun exposure.
37:48They're another balancing features of sun exposure.
37:50Yeah, we can talk about that.
37:50Yeah, we can talk about that.
37:50Yeah, we can talk about that.
37:50Yeah, we can talk about that.
37:50Yeah, we can talk about that.
37:50Yeah, we can talk about that.
37:52But clearly UV is a risk factor for DNA damage in the skin.
37:52But clearly UV is a risk factor for DNA damage in the skin.
37:52But clearly UV is a risk factor for DNA damage in the skin.
37:52But clearly UV is a risk factor for DNA damage in the skin.
37:52But clearly UV is a risk factor for DNA damage in the skin.
37:52But clearly UV is a risk factor for DNA damage in the skin.
37:58I mean, I'm perfectly happy going on record.
37:58I mean, I'm perfectly happy going on record.
37:58I mean, I'm perfectly happy going on record.
37:58I mean, I'm perfectly happy going on record.
37:58I mean, I'm perfectly happy going on record.
37:58I mean, I'm perfectly happy going on record.
38:00The things I've said around sunlight have been contorted so many different ways.
38:00The things I've said around sunlight have been contorted so many different ways.
38:00The things I've said around sunlight have been contorted so many different ways.
38:00The things I've said around sunlight have been contorted so many different ways.
38:00The things I've said around sunlight have been contorted so many different ways.
38:00The things I've said around sunlight have been contorted so many different ways.
38:03It's like a pretzel twist now.
38:03It's like a pretzel twist now.
38:03It's like a pretzel twist now.
38:03It's like a pretzel twist now.
38:03It's like a pretzel twist now.
38:03It's like a pretzel twist now.
38:04No, it's more like one of those balloon animals at a party, but it's not,
38:04No, it's more like one of those balloon animals at a party, but it's not,
38:04No, it's more like one of those balloon animals at a party, but it's not,
38:04No, it's more like one of those balloon animals at a party, but it's not,
38:04No, it's more like one of those balloon animals at a party, but it's not,
38:04No, it's more like one of those balloon animals at a party, but it's not,
38:07it's a mess. The too much...
38:07it's a mess. The too much...
38:07it's a mess. The too much...
38:07it's a mess. The too much...
38:07it's a mess. The too much...
38:07it's a mess. The too much...
38:10UV is bad for skin cells.
38:10UV is bad for skin cells.
38:10UV is bad for skin cells.
38:10UV is bad for skin cells.
38:10UV is bad for skin cells.
38:10UV is bad for skin cells.
38:13It's just bad. You need some, but too much is bad.
38:13It's just bad. You need some, but too much is bad.
38:13It's just bad. You need some, but too much is bad.
38:13It's just bad. You need some, but too much is bad.
38:13It's just bad. You need some, but too much is bad.
38:13It's just bad. You need some, but too much is bad.
38:15Long wavelength light is great, and therein lies the challenge.
38:15Long wavelength light is great, and therein lies the challenge.
38:15Long wavelength light is great, and therein lies the challenge.
38:15Long wavelength light is great, and therein lies the challenge.
38:15Long wavelength light is great, and therein lies the challenge.
38:15Long wavelength light is great, and therein lies the challenge.
38:19But yeah, love sunlight, but you don't want excessive UV.
38:19But yeah, love sunlight, but you don't want excessive UV.
38:19But yeah, love sunlight, but you don't want excessive UV.
38:19But yeah, love sunlight, but you don't want excessive UV.
38:19But yeah, love sunlight, but you don't want excessive UV.
38:19But yeah, love sunlight, but you don't want excessive UV.
38:23Avoid getting sunburned, folks. Yeah, thank you.
38:23Avoid getting sunburned, folks. Yeah, thank you.
38:23Avoid getting sunburned, folks. Yeah, thank you.
38:23Avoid getting sunburned, folks. Yeah, thank you.
38:23Avoid getting sunburned, folks. Yeah, thank you.
38:23Avoid getting sunburned, folks. Yeah, thank you.
38:26So yeah, the BRCA mutation, I have a personal relationship to this because I lost
38:26So yeah, the BRCA mutation, I have a personal relationship to this because I lost
38:26So yeah, the BRCA mutation, I have a personal relationship to this because I lost
38:26So yeah, the BRCA mutation, I have a personal relationship to this because I lost
38:26So yeah, the BRCA mutation, I have a personal relationship to this because I lost
38:26So yeah, the BRCA mutation, I have a personal relationship to this because I lost
38:31both my graduate advisor and my postdoctoral advisor to BRCA mutation -related cancers, 50 and
38:31both my graduate advisor and my postdoctoral advisor to BRCA mutation -related cancers, 50 and
38:31both my graduate advisor and my postdoctoral advisor to BRCA mutation -related cancers, 50 and
38:31both my graduate advisor and my postdoctoral advisor to BRCA mutation -related cancers, 50 and
38:31both my graduate advisor and my postdoctoral advisor to BRCA mutation -related cancers, 50 and
38:31both my graduate advisor and my postdoctoral advisor to BRCA mutation -related cancers, 50 and
38:37just a little bit older than 60 and the other.
38:37just a little bit older than 60 and the other.
38:37just a little bit older than 60 and the other.
38:37just a little bit older than 60 and the other.
38:37just a little bit older than 60 and the other.
38:37just a little bit older than 60 and the other.
38:39And, you know, brutal, especially when you, you know, one of them, I know, they're
38:39And, you know, brutal, especially when you, you know, one of them, I know, they're
38:39And, you know, brutal, especially when you, you know, one of them, I know, they're
38:39And, you know, brutal, especially when you, you know, one of them, I know, they're
38:39And, you know, brutal, especially when you, you know, one of them, I know, they're
38:39And, you know, brutal, especially when you, you know, one of them, I know, they're
38:45kids. And, you know, it's just for young people getting cancer, and I know they're
38:45kids. And, you know, it's just for young people getting cancer, and I know they're
38:45kids. And, you know, it's just for young people getting cancer, and I know they're
38:45kids. And, you know, it's just for young people getting cancer, and I know they're
38:45kids. And, you know, it's just for young people getting cancer, and I know they're
38:45kids. And, you know, it's just for young people getting cancer, and I know they're
38:49childhood cancers, but BRCA seems pretty common.
38:49childhood cancers, but BRCA seems pretty common.
38:49childhood cancers, but BRCA seems pretty common.
38:49childhood cancers, but BRCA seems pretty common.
38:49childhood cancers, but BRCA seems pretty common.
38:49childhood cancers, but BRCA seems pretty common.
38:53I don't know the numbers off the top of my head.
38:53I don't know the numbers off the top of my head.
38:53I don't know the numbers off the top of my head.
38:53I don't know the numbers off the top of my head.
38:53I don't know the numbers off the top of my head.
38:53I don't know the numbers off the top of my head.
38:55I mean, they're not the major, like, numerical causes of cancer.
38:55I mean, they're not the major, like, numerical causes of cancer.
38:55I mean, they're not the major, like, numerical causes of cancer.
38:55I mean, they're not the major, like, numerical causes of cancer.
38:55I mean, they're not the major, like, numerical causes of cancer.
38:55I mean, they're not the major, like, numerical causes of cancer.
39:01In the scheme of cancers that developed, it's a minority.
39:01In the scheme of cancers that developed, it's a minority.
39:01In the scheme of cancers that developed, it's a minority.
39:01In the scheme of cancers that developed, it's a minority.
39:01In the scheme of cancers that developed, it's a minority.
39:01In the scheme of cancers that developed, it's a minority.
39:06It's a relatively small set number of the full set of cancers.
39:06It's a relatively small set number of the full set of cancers.
39:06It's a relatively small set number of the full set of cancers.
39:06It's a relatively small set number of the full set of cancers.
39:06It's a relatively small set number of the full set of cancers.
39:06It's a relatively small set number of the full set of cancers.
39:08The problem is if you inherit a BRCA mutation, as an individual, you have a
39:08The problem is if you inherit a BRCA mutation, as an individual, you have a
39:08The problem is if you inherit a BRCA mutation, as an individual, you have a
39:08The problem is if you inherit a BRCA mutation, as an individual, you have a
39:08The problem is if you inherit a BRCA mutation, as an individual, you have a
39:08The problem is if you inherit a BRCA mutation, as an individual, you have a
39:14very high risk of developing cancer.
39:14very high risk of developing cancer.
39:14very high risk of developing cancer.
39:14very high risk of developing cancer.
39:14very high risk of developing cancer.
39:14very high risk of developing cancer.
39:16So as an individual, your risk goes way, way up, and of certain types of
39:16So as an individual, your risk goes way, way up, and of certain types of
39:16So as an individual, your risk goes way, way up, and of certain types of
39:16So as an individual, your risk goes way, way up, and of certain types of
39:16So as an individual, your risk goes way, way up, and of certain types of
39:16So as an individual, your risk goes way, way up, and of certain types of
39:21cancer in particular. And we can all get tested for it now pretty cheaply, right?
39:21cancer in particular. And we can all get tested for it now pretty cheaply, right?
39:21cancer in particular. And we can all get tested for it now pretty cheaply, right?
39:21cancer in particular. And we can all get tested for it now pretty cheaply, right?
39:21cancer in particular. And we can all get tested for it now pretty cheaply, right?
39:21cancer in particular. And we can all get tested for it now pretty cheaply, right?
39:25Yes. Yeah. Yeah. That's certainly recommended if there's a family history of cancer for BRCA
39:25Yes. Yeah. Yeah. That's certainly recommended if there's a family history of cancer for BRCA
39:25Yes. Yeah. Yeah. That's certainly recommended if there's a family history of cancer for BRCA
39:25Yes. Yeah. Yeah. That's certainly recommended if there's a family history of cancer for BRCA
39:25Yes. Yeah. Yeah. That's certainly recommended if there's a family history of cancer for BRCA
39:25Yes. Yeah. Yeah. That's certainly recommended if there's a family history of cancer for BRCA
39:31mutations and a couple of other ones.
39:31mutations and a couple of other ones.
39:31mutations and a couple of other ones.
39:31mutations and a couple of other ones.
39:31mutations and a couple of other ones.
39:31mutations and a couple of other ones.
39:33But you're right. It's the tests are available.
39:33But you're right. It's the tests are available.
39:33But you're right. It's the tests are available.
39:33But you're right. It's the tests are available.
39:33But you're right. It's the tests are available.
39:33But you're right. It's the tests are available.
39:36And you asked about men and women.
39:36And you asked about men and women.
39:36And you asked about men and women.
39:36And you asked about men and women.
39:36And you asked about men and women.
39:36And you asked about men and women.
39:38It actually was men were some of the ways that those BRCA genes were identified.
39:38It actually was men were some of the ways that those BRCA genes were identified.
39:38It actually was men were some of the ways that those BRCA genes were identified.
39:38It actually was men were some of the ways that those BRCA genes were identified.
39:38It actually was men were some of the ways that those BRCA genes were identified.
39:38It actually was men were some of the ways that those BRCA genes were identified.
39:45Because it's so rare for men to develop breast cancer, the ones who did develop
39:45Because it's so rare for men to develop breast cancer, the ones who did develop
39:45Because it's so rare for men to develop breast cancer, the ones who did develop
39:45Because it's so rare for men to develop breast cancer, the ones who did develop
39:45Because it's so rare for men to develop breast cancer, the ones who did develop
39:45Because it's so rare for men to develop breast cancer, the ones who did develop
39:50it, there was a thought, well, maybe there's an underlying genetic predisposition.
39:50it, there was a thought, well, maybe there's an underlying genetic predisposition.
39:50it, there was a thought, well, maybe there's an underlying genetic predisposition.
39:50it, there was a thought, well, maybe there's an underlying genetic predisposition.
39:50it, there was a thought, well, maybe there's an underlying genetic predisposition.
39:50it, there was a thought, well, maybe there's an underlying genetic predisposition.
39:53And that helped identify those genes.
39:53And that helped identify those genes.
39:53And that helped identify those genes.
39:53And that helped identify those genes.
39:53And that helped identify those genes.
39:53And that helped identify those genes.
39:56Interesting. Everyone, get tested for BRCA, you know, because there are lifestyle factors that can
39:56Interesting. Everyone, get tested for BRCA, you know, because there are lifestyle factors that can
39:56Interesting. Everyone, get tested for BRCA, you know, because there are lifestyle factors that can
39:56Interesting. Everyone, get tested for BRCA, you know, because there are lifestyle factors that can
39:56Interesting. Everyone, get tested for BRCA, you know, because there are lifestyle factors that can
39:56Interesting. Everyone, get tested for BRCA, you know, because there are lifestyle factors that can
40:03reduce your cancer risk. I'd like to talk about mutagens.
40:03reduce your cancer risk. I'd like to talk about mutagens.
40:03reduce your cancer risk. I'd like to talk about mutagens.
40:03reduce your cancer risk. I'd like to talk about mutagens.
40:03reduce your cancer risk. I'd like to talk about mutagens.
40:03reduce your cancer risk. I'd like to talk about mutagens.
40:06Yeah. Smoking, bad. I'll go on record saying vaping, bad.
40:06Yeah. Smoking, bad. I'll go on record saying vaping, bad.
40:06Yeah. Smoking, bad. I'll go on record saying vaping, bad.
40:06Yeah. Smoking, bad. I'll go on record saying vaping, bad.
40:06Yeah. Smoking, bad. I'll go on record saying vaping, bad.
40:06Yeah. Smoking, bad. I'll go on record saying vaping, bad.
40:11Perhaps not as bad as smoking, but still way, way worse than not vaping.
40:11Perhaps not as bad as smoking, but still way, way worse than not vaping.
40:11Perhaps not as bad as smoking, but still way, way worse than not vaping.
40:11Perhaps not as bad as smoking, but still way, way worse than not vaping.
40:11Perhaps not as bad as smoking, but still way, way worse than not vaping.
40:11Perhaps not as bad as smoking, but still way, way worse than not vaping.
40:15But the battle to sort of protect vaping is like beyond me, but okay, to
40:15But the battle to sort of protect vaping is like beyond me, but okay, to
40:15But the battle to sort of protect vaping is like beyond me, but okay, to
40:15But the battle to sort of protect vaping is like beyond me, but okay, to
40:15But the battle to sort of protect vaping is like beyond me, but okay, to
40:15But the battle to sort of protect vaping is like beyond me, but okay, to
40:23each their own. Environmental sort of and workplace hazards, you know, like known mutagens.
40:23each their own. Environmental sort of and workplace hazards, you know, like known mutagens.
40:23each their own. Environmental sort of and workplace hazards, you know, like known mutagens.
40:23each their own. Environmental sort of and workplace hazards, you know, like known mutagens.
40:23each their own. Environmental sort of and workplace hazards, you know, like known mutagens.
40:23each their own. Environmental sort of and workplace hazards, you know, like known mutagens.
40:30You work in a laboratory, you're working with mutagens, right?
40:30You work in a laboratory, you're working with mutagens, right?
40:30You work in a laboratory, you're working with mutagens, right?
40:30You work in a laboratory, you're working with mutagens, right?
40:30You work in a laboratory, you're working with mutagens, right?
40:30You work in a laboratory, you're working with mutagens, right?
40:34Yeah. You're working with things that literally pull DNA apart.
40:34Yeah. You're working with things that literally pull DNA apart.
40:34Yeah. You're working with things that literally pull DNA apart.
40:34Yeah. You're working with things that literally pull DNA apart.
40:34Yeah. You're working with things that literally pull DNA apart.
40:34Yeah. You're working with things that literally pull DNA apart.
40:37Yes. This always worried me working in a laboratory.
40:37Yes. This always worried me working in a laboratory.
40:37Yes. This always worried me working in a laboratory.
40:37Yes. This always worried me working in a laboratory.
40:37Yes. This always worried me working in a laboratory.
40:37Yes. This always worried me working in a laboratory.
40:39There are a lot of carcinogenic chemicals in a laboratory.
40:39There are a lot of carcinogenic chemicals in a laboratory.
40:39There are a lot of carcinogenic chemicals in a laboratory.
40:39There are a lot of carcinogenic chemicals in a laboratory.
40:39There are a lot of carcinogenic chemicals in a laboratory.
40:39There are a lot of carcinogenic chemicals in a laboratory.
40:42For good reason. Right. This is the, you know, we're trying to study cancer, but
40:42For good reason. Right. This is the, you know, we're trying to study cancer, but
40:42For good reason. Right. This is the, you know, we're trying to study cancer, but
40:42For good reason. Right. This is the, you know, we're trying to study cancer, but
40:42For good reason. Right. This is the, you know, we're trying to study cancer, but
40:42For good reason. Right. This is the, you know, we're trying to study cancer, but
40:46we're certainly working around a lot of things that could cause cancer.
40:46we're certainly working around a lot of things that could cause cancer.
40:46we're certainly working around a lot of things that could cause cancer.
40:46we're certainly working around a lot of things that could cause cancer.
40:46we're certainly working around a lot of things that could cause cancer.
40:46we're certainly working around a lot of things that could cause cancer.
40:49Yeah. Chemicals, radiation. Yeah. I don't know if you, but you know, I did a
40:49Yeah. Chemicals, radiation. Yeah. I don't know if you, but you know, I did a
40:49Yeah. Chemicals, radiation. Yeah. I don't know if you, but you know, I did a
40:49Yeah. Chemicals, radiation. Yeah. I don't know if you, but you know, I did a
40:49Yeah. Chemicals, radiation. Yeah. I don't know if you, but you know, I did a
40:49Yeah. Chemicals, radiation. Yeah. I don't know if you, but you know, I did a
40:54lot of, a lot of experiments, radio labeling cells.
40:54lot of, a lot of experiments, radio labeling cells.
40:54lot of, a lot of experiments, radio labeling cells.
40:54lot of, a lot of experiments, radio labeling cells.
40:54lot of, a lot of experiments, radio labeling cells.
40:54lot of, a lot of experiments, radio labeling cells.
40:57Yeah. I mean, we, well, fortunately we worked with, you know, radio tagged amino acids
40:57Yeah. I mean, we, well, fortunately we worked with, you know, radio tagged amino acids
40:57Yeah. I mean, we, well, fortunately we worked with, you know, radio tagged amino acids
40:57Yeah. I mean, we, well, fortunately we worked with, you know, radio tagged amino acids
40:57Yeah. I mean, we, well, fortunately we worked with, you know, radio tagged amino acids
40:57Yeah. I mean, we, well, fortunately we worked with, you know, radio tagged amino acids
41:03with radiation that was, we were told, and I do believe was not, not as,
41:03with radiation that was, we were told, and I do believe was not, not as,
41:03with radiation that was, we were told, and I do believe was not, not as,
41:03with radiation that was, we were told, and I do believe was not, not as,
41:03with radiation that was, we were told, and I do believe was not, not as,
41:03with radiation that was, we were told, and I do believe was not, not as,
41:08as dangerous as some of the others, but yeah, I mean, so chemical exposures are
41:08as dangerous as some of the others, but yeah, I mean, so chemical exposures are
41:08as dangerous as some of the others, but yeah, I mean, so chemical exposures are
41:08as dangerous as some of the others, but yeah, I mean, so chemical exposures are
41:08as dangerous as some of the others, but yeah, I mean, so chemical exposures are
41:08as dangerous as some of the others, but yeah, I mean, so chemical exposures are
41:12a big one. Yep. And so those, those labels on paints and thinners and stuff
41:12a big one. Yep. And so those, those labels on paints and thinners and stuff
41:12a big one. Yep. And so those, those labels on paints and thinners and stuff
41:12a big one. Yep. And so those, those labels on paints and thinners and stuff
41:12a big one. Yep. And so those, those labels on paints and thinners and stuff
41:12a big one. Yep. And so those, those labels on paints and thinners and stuff
41:17in the garage, that's real.
41:17in the garage, that's real.
41:17in the garage, that's real.
41:17in the garage, that's real.
41:17in the garage, that's real.
41:17in the garage, that's real.
41:18Yeah. That's a, that's a real thing.
41:18Yeah. That's a, that's a real thing.
41:18Yeah. That's a, that's a real thing.
41:18Yeah. That's a, that's a real thing.
41:18Yeah. That's a, that's a real thing.
41:18Yeah. That's a, that's a real thing.
41:20They mutate cells. And there's a, you know, there's some spectrum of stronger and less
41:20They mutate cells. And there's a, you know, there's some spectrum of stronger and less
41:20They mutate cells. And there's a, you know, there's some spectrum of stronger and less
41:20They mutate cells. And there's a, you know, there's some spectrum of stronger and less
41:20They mutate cells. And there's a, you know, there's some spectrum of stronger and less
41:20They mutate cells. And there's a, you know, there's some spectrum of stronger and less
41:25strong ones. And I think oftentimes we're operating in an absence of great data, but
41:25strong ones. And I think oftentimes we're operating in an absence of great data, but
41:25strong ones. And I think oftentimes we're operating in an absence of great data, but
41:25strong ones. And I think oftentimes we're operating in an absence of great data, but
41:25strong ones. And I think oftentimes we're operating in an absence of great data, but
41:25strong ones. And I think oftentimes we're operating in an absence of great data, but
41:30I, you know, I think there's a lot of things are implicated as potential mutagens.
41:30I, you know, I think there's a lot of things are implicated as potential mutagens.
41:30I, you know, I think there's a lot of things are implicated as potential mutagens.
41:30I, you know, I think there's a lot of things are implicated as potential mutagens.
41:30I, you know, I think there's a lot of things are implicated as potential mutagens.
41:30I, you know, I think there's a lot of things are implicated as potential mutagens.
41:33Pesticides. Yeah. I mean, look at cancer rates in, in rural areas near where, you
41:33Pesticides. Yeah. I mean, look at cancer rates in, in rural areas near where, you
41:33Pesticides. Yeah. I mean, look at cancer rates in, in rural areas near where, you
41:33Pesticides. Yeah. I mean, look at cancer rates in, in rural areas near where, you
41:33Pesticides. Yeah. I mean, look at cancer rates in, in rural areas near where, you
41:33Pesticides. Yeah. I mean, look at cancer rates in, in rural areas near where, you
41:39know, crops are dusted with pesticides.
41:39know, crops are dusted with pesticides.
41:39know, crops are dusted with pesticides.
41:39know, crops are dusted with pesticides.
41:39know, crops are dusted with pesticides.
41:39know, crops are dusted with pesticides.
41:42And we've had, Shawna Swan came on here and she's like, listen, you know, the,
41:42And we've had, Shawna Swan came on here and she's like, listen, you know, the,
41:42And we've had, Shawna Swan came on here and she's like, listen, you know, the,
41:42And we've had, Shawna Swan came on here and she's like, listen, you know, the,
41:42And we've had, Shawna Swan came on here and she's like, listen, you know, the,
41:42And we've had, Shawna Swan came on here and she's like, listen, you know, the,
41:45the cancer risks, the, you know, endocrine disruptor risks, we think of as like big
41:45the cancer risks, the, you know, endocrine disruptor risks, we think of as like big
41:45the cancer risks, the, you know, endocrine disruptor risks, we think of as like big
41:45the cancer risks, the, you know, endocrine disruptor risks, we think of as like big
41:45the cancer risks, the, you know, endocrine disruptor risks, we think of as like big
41:45the cancer risks, the, you know, endocrine disruptor risks, we think of as like big
41:49cities as, as dirty and dangerous.
41:49cities as, as dirty and dangerous.
41:49cities as, as dirty and dangerous.
41:49cities as, as dirty and dangerous.
41:49cities as, as dirty and dangerous.
41:49cities as, as dirty and dangerous.
41:51And they are for certain reasons.
41:51And they are for certain reasons.
41:51And they are for certain reasons.
41:51And they are for certain reasons.
41:51And they are for certain reasons.
41:51And they are for certain reasons.
41:53But she said, if you really see the spikes in, in these cancers related to
41:53But she said, if you really see the spikes in, in these cancers related to
41:53But she said, if you really see the spikes in, in these cancers related to
41:53But she said, if you really see the spikes in, in these cancers related to
41:53But she said, if you really see the spikes in, in these cancers related to
41:53But she said, if you really see the spikes in, in these cancers related to
41:59environmental factors, it's less so bus exhaust than it is pesticides.
41:59environmental factors, it's less so bus exhaust than it is pesticides.
41:59environmental factors, it's less so bus exhaust than it is pesticides.
41:59environmental factors, it's less so bus exhaust than it is pesticides.
41:59environmental factors, it's less so bus exhaust than it is pesticides.
41:59environmental factors, it's less so bus exhaust than it is pesticides.
42:04I mean, it is not evenly or fairly distributed.
42:04I mean, it is not evenly or fairly distributed.
42:04I mean, it is not evenly or fairly distributed.
42:04I mean, it is not evenly or fairly distributed.
42:04I mean, it is not evenly or fairly distributed.
42:04I mean, it is not evenly or fairly distributed.
42:07Some people get exposed way more to these things and we haven't studied them enough.
42:07Some people get exposed way more to these things and we haven't studied them enough.
42:07Some people get exposed way more to these things and we haven't studied them enough.
42:07Some people get exposed way more to these things and we haven't studied them enough.
42:07Some people get exposed way more to these things and we haven't studied them enough.
42:07Some people get exposed way more to these things and we haven't studied them enough.
42:11We need, we need way more study to really be able to answer.
42:11We need, we need way more study to really be able to answer.
42:11We need, we need way more study to really be able to answer.
42:11We need, we need way more study to really be able to answer.
42:11We need, we need way more study to really be able to answer.
42:11We need, we need way more study to really be able to answer.
42:15Okay. And, and, and people shouldn't be left.
42:15Okay. And, and, and people shouldn't be left.
42:15Okay. And, and, and people shouldn't be left.
42:15Okay. And, and, and people shouldn't be left.
42:15Okay. And, and, and people shouldn't be left.
42:15Okay. And, and, and people shouldn't be left.
42:17I mean, this is my, this is me just speaking as in, it's kind of
42:17I mean, this is my, this is me just speaking as in, it's kind of
42:17I mean, this is my, this is me just speaking as in, it's kind of
42:17I mean, this is my, this is me just speaking as in, it's kind of
42:17I mean, this is my, this is me just speaking as in, it's kind of
42:17I mean, this is my, this is me just speaking as in, it's kind of
42:20amazing to me how much we're left on our own to be figuring out what
42:20amazing to me how much we're left on our own to be figuring out what
42:20amazing to me how much we're left on our own to be figuring out what
42:20amazing to me how much we're left on our own to be figuring out what
42:20amazing to me how much we're left on our own to be figuring out what
42:20amazing to me how much we're left on our own to be figuring out what
42:24the risk of individual products is.
42:24the risk of individual products is.
42:24the risk of individual products is.
42:24the risk of individual products is.
42:24the risk of individual products is.
42:24the risk of individual products is.
42:26And I, I think it's a place where we should be investing a lot more
42:26And I, I think it's a place where we should be investing a lot more
42:26And I, I think it's a place where we should be investing a lot more
42:26And I, I think it's a place where we should be investing a lot more
42:26And I, I think it's a place where we should be investing a lot more
42:26And I, I think it's a place where we should be investing a lot more
42:30to get clarity on where the real risks are.
42:30to get clarity on where the real risks are.
42:30to get clarity on where the real risks are.
42:30to get clarity on where the real risks are.
42:30to get clarity on where the real risks are.
42:30to get clarity on where the real risks are.
42:34As many of you know, I've been taking AG1 for nearly 15 years now.
42:34As many of you know, I've been taking AG1 for nearly 15 years now.
42:34As many of you know, I've been taking AG1 for nearly 15 years now.
42:34As many of you know, I've been taking AG1 for nearly 15 years now.
42:34As many of you know, I've been taking AG1 for nearly 15 years now.
42:34As many of you know, I've been taking AG1 for nearly 15 years now.
42:38I discovered it way back in 2012, long before I ever had a podcast.
42:38I discovered it way back in 2012, long before I ever had a podcast.
42:38I discovered it way back in 2012, long before I ever had a podcast.
42:38I discovered it way back in 2012, long before I ever had a podcast.
42:38I discovered it way back in 2012, long before I ever had a podcast.
42:38I discovered it way back in 2012, long before I ever had a podcast.
42:43And I've been taking it every day since the reason I started taking it.
42:43And I've been taking it every day since the reason I started taking it.
42:43And I've been taking it every day since the reason I started taking it.
42:43And I've been taking it every day since the reason I started taking it.
42:43And I've been taking it every day since the reason I started taking it.
42:43And I've been taking it every day since the reason I started taking it.
42:46And the reason I still take it is because AG1 is to my knowledge, the
42:46And the reason I still take it is because AG1 is to my knowledge, the
42:46And the reason I still take it is because AG1 is to my knowledge, the
42:46And the reason I still take it is because AG1 is to my knowledge, the
42:46And the reason I still take it is because AG1 is to my knowledge, the
42:46And the reason I still take it is because AG1 is to my knowledge, the
42:50highest quality and most comprehensive of the foundational nutritional supplements on the market.
42:50highest quality and most comprehensive of the foundational nutritional supplements on the market.
42:50highest quality and most comprehensive of the foundational nutritional supplements on the market.
42:50highest quality and most comprehensive of the foundational nutritional supplements on the market.
42:50highest quality and most comprehensive of the foundational nutritional supplements on the market.
42:50highest quality and most comprehensive of the foundational nutritional supplements on the market.
42:54It combines vitamins, minerals, prebiotics, probiotics, and adaptogens into a single scoop that's easy to
42:54It combines vitamins, minerals, prebiotics, probiotics, and adaptogens into a single scoop that's easy to
42:54It combines vitamins, minerals, prebiotics, probiotics, and adaptogens into a single scoop that's easy to
42:54It combines vitamins, minerals, prebiotics, probiotics, and adaptogens into a single scoop that's easy to
42:54It combines vitamins, minerals, prebiotics, probiotics, and adaptogens into a single scoop that's easy to
42:54It combines vitamins, minerals, prebiotics, probiotics, and adaptogens into a single scoop that's easy to
43:01drink. And it tastes great.
43:01drink. And it tastes great.
43:01drink. And it tastes great.
43:01drink. And it tastes great.
43:01drink. And it tastes great.
43:01drink. And it tastes great.
43:03It's designed to support things like gut health, immune health, and overall energy.
43:03It's designed to support things like gut health, immune health, and overall energy.
43:03It's designed to support things like gut health, immune health, and overall energy.
43:03It's designed to support things like gut health, immune health, and overall energy.
43:03It's designed to support things like gut health, immune health, and overall energy.
43:03It's designed to support things like gut health, immune health, and overall energy.
43:07And it does so by helping to fill any gaps you might have in your
43:07And it does so by helping to fill any gaps you might have in your
43:07And it does so by helping to fill any gaps you might have in your
43:07And it does so by helping to fill any gaps you might have in your
43:07And it does so by helping to fill any gaps you might have in your
43:10daily nutrition. Now, of course, everyone should strive to eat nutritious whole foods.
43:10daily nutrition. Now, of course, everyone should strive to eat nutritious whole foods.
43:10daily nutrition. Now, of course, everyone should strive to eat nutritious whole foods.
43:10daily nutrition. Now, of course, everyone should strive to eat nutritious whole foods.
43:10daily nutrition. Now, of course, everyone should strive to eat nutritious whole foods.
43:14I certainly do that every day, but I'm often asked if you could take just
43:14I certainly do that every day, but I'm often asked if you could take just
43:14I certainly do that every day, but I'm often asked if you could take just
43:14I certainly do that every day, but I'm often asked if you could take just
43:14I certainly do that every day, but I'm often asked if you could take just
43:18one supplement, what would that supplement be?
43:18one supplement, what would that supplement be?
43:18one supplement, what would that supplement be?
43:18one supplement, what would that supplement be?
43:18one supplement, what would that supplement be?
43:20And my answer is always AG1, because it has just been oh so critical to
43:20And my answer is always AG1, because it has just been oh so critical to
43:20And my answer is always AG1, because it has just been oh so critical to
43:20And my answer is always AG1, because it has just been oh so critical to
43:20And my answer is always AG1, because it has just been oh so critical to
43:25supporting all aspects of my physical health, mental health, and performance.
43:25supporting all aspects of my physical health, mental health, and performance.
43:25supporting all aspects of my physical health, mental health, and performance.
43:25supporting all aspects of my physical health, mental health, and performance.
43:25supporting all aspects of my physical health, mental health, and performance.
43:28I know this from my own experience with AG1, and I continually hear this from
43:28I know this from my own experience with AG1, and I continually hear this from
43:28I know this from my own experience with AG1, and I continually hear this from
43:28I know this from my own experience with AG1, and I continually hear this from
43:28I know this from my own experience with AG1, and I continually hear this from
43:32other people who use AG1 daily.
43:32other people who use AG1 daily.
43:32other people who use AG1 daily.
43:32other people who use AG1 daily.
43:32other people who use AG1 daily.
43:35If you would like to try AG1, you can go to drink AG1.
43:35If you would like to try AG1, you can go to drink AG1.
43:35If you would like to try AG1, you can go to drink AG1.
43:35If you would like to try AG1, you can go to drink AG1.
43:35If you would like to try AG1, you can go to drink AG1.
43:38AG1 .com slash Huberman to get a special offer.
43:38AG1 .com slash Huberman to get a special offer.
43:38AG1 .com slash Huberman to get a special offer.
43:38AG1 .com slash Huberman to get a special offer.
43:38AG1 .com slash Huberman to get a special offer.
43:41For a limited time, AG1 is giving away six free travel packs of AG1 and
43:41For a limited time, AG1 is giving away six free travel packs of AG1 and
43:41For a limited time, AG1 is giving away six free travel packs of AG1 and
43:41For a limited time, AG1 is giving away six free travel packs of AG1 and
43:41For a limited time, AG1 is giving away six free travel packs of AG1 and
43:46a bottle of vitamin D3K2 with your subscription.
43:46a bottle of vitamin D3K2 with your subscription.
43:46a bottle of vitamin D3K2 with your subscription.
43:46a bottle of vitamin D3K2 with your subscription.
43:46a bottle of vitamin D3K2 with your subscription.
43:48Again, that's drink AG1 with the numeral one dot com slash Huberman to get six
43:48Again, that's drink AG1 with the numeral one dot com slash Huberman to get six
43:48Again, that's drink AG1 with the numeral one dot com slash Huberman to get six
43:48Again, that's drink AG1 with the numeral one dot com slash Huberman to get six
43:48Again, that's drink AG1 with the numeral one dot com slash Huberman to get six
43:53free travel packs and a bottle of vitamin D3K2 with your subscription.
43:53free travel packs and a bottle of vitamin D3K2 with your subscription.
43:53free travel packs and a bottle of vitamin D3K2 with your subscription.
43:53free travel packs and a bottle of vitamin D3K2 with your subscription.
43:53free travel packs and a bottle of vitamin D3K2 with your subscription.
43:58I get x -rays at the dentist now and again, but I prefer not to
43:58I get x -rays at the dentist now and again, but I prefer not to
43:58I get x -rays at the dentist now and again, but I prefer not to
43:58I get x -rays at the dentist now and again, but I prefer not to
43:58I get x -rays at the dentist now and again, but I prefer not to
44:02get them. X -rays cause mutations.
44:02get them. X -rays cause mutations.
44:02get them. X -rays cause mutations.
44:02get them. X -rays cause mutations.
44:02get them. X -rays cause mutations.
44:04Yeah. Again, there's a trade off in the dose.
44:04Yeah. Again, there's a trade off in the dose.
44:04Yeah. Again, there's a trade off in the dose.
44:04Yeah. Again, there's a trade off in the dose.
44:04Yeah. Again, there's a trade off in the dose.
44:07You know, when you need an x -ray, you need an x -ray, but I
44:07You know, when you need an x -ray, you need an x -ray, but I
44:07You know, when you need an x -ray, you need an x -ray, but I
44:07You know, when you need an x -ray, you need an x -ray, but I
44:07You know, when you need an x -ray, you need an x -ray, but I
44:11wouldn't do them for fun.
44:11wouldn't do them for fun.
44:11wouldn't do them for fun.
44:11wouldn't do them for fun.
44:11wouldn't do them for fun.
44:12Right. I mean, I have colleagues who prefer to do the slower manual pat down
44:12Right. I mean, I have colleagues who prefer to do the slower manual pat down
44:12Right. I mean, I have colleagues who prefer to do the slower manual pat down
44:12Right. I mean, I have colleagues who prefer to do the slower manual pat down
44:12Right. I mean, I have colleagues who prefer to do the slower manual pat down
44:20at the airport to going through the scanner.
44:20at the airport to going through the scanner.
44:20at the airport to going through the scanner.
44:20at the airport to going through the scanner.
44:20at the airport to going through the scanner.
44:24It's a low level of radiation is what they tell me.
44:24It's a low level of radiation is what they tell me.
44:24It's a low level of radiation is what they tell me.
44:24It's a low level of radiation is what they tell me.
44:24It's a low level of radiation is what they tell me.
44:27But if you're traveling a lot, you're getting multiple low level exposures.
44:27But if you're traveling a lot, you're getting multiple low level exposures.
44:27But if you're traveling a lot, you're getting multiple low level exposures.
44:27But if you're traveling a lot, you're getting multiple low level exposures.
44:27But if you're traveling a lot, you're getting multiple low level exposures.
44:32And we know pilots, and this is for other reasons because they're, you know, you
44:32And we know pilots, and this is for other reasons because they're, you know, you
44:32And we know pilots, and this is for other reasons because they're, you know, you
44:32And we know pilots, and this is for other reasons because they're, you know, you
44:32And we know pilots, and this is for other reasons because they're, you know, you
44:36can tell us, but atmospherically they're exposed to more radiation.
44:36can tell us, but atmospherically they're exposed to more radiation.
44:36can tell us, but atmospherically they're exposed to more radiation.
44:36can tell us, but atmospherically they're exposed to more radiation.
44:36can tell us, but atmospherically they're exposed to more radiation.
44:39Cancer rates are higher in pilots.
44:39Cancer rates are higher in pilots.
44:39Cancer rates are higher in pilots.
44:39Cancer rates are higher in pilots.
44:39Cancer rates are higher in pilots.
44:41Now, they're sitting a lot too, prostate cancer.
44:41Now, they're sitting a lot too, prostate cancer.
44:41Now, they're sitting a lot too, prostate cancer.
44:41Now, they're sitting a lot too, prostate cancer.
44:41Now, they're sitting a lot too, prostate cancer.
44:43Okay, there's a bunch of things there.
44:43Okay, there's a bunch of things there.
44:43Okay, there's a bunch of things there.
44:43Okay, there's a bunch of things there.
44:43Okay, there's a bunch of things there.
44:44But do you yourself avoid the scanner at the airport?
44:44But do you yourself avoid the scanner at the airport?
44:44But do you yourself avoid the scanner at the airport?
44:44But do you yourself avoid the scanner at the airport?
44:44But do you yourself avoid the scanner at the airport?
44:50Honestly, I do, but I can't say that there's data for that.
44:50Honestly, I do, but I can't say that there's data for that.
44:50Honestly, I do, but I can't say that there's data for that.
44:50Honestly, I do, but I can't say that there's data for that.
44:50Honestly, I do, but I can't say that there's data for that.
44:54I feel the same way as you.
44:54I feel the same way as you.
44:54I feel the same way as you.
44:54I feel the same way as you.
44:54I feel the same way as you.
44:55Like, if I could avoid it, I'd try to minimize.
44:55Like, if I could avoid it, I'd try to minimize.
44:55Like, if I could avoid it, I'd try to minimize.
44:55Like, if I could avoid it, I'd try to minimize.
44:55Like, if I could avoid it, I'd try to minimize.
44:58But that's not based on some inside knowledge I have, but I have the same
44:58But that's not based on some inside knowledge I have, but I have the same
44:58But that's not based on some inside knowledge I have, but I have the same
44:58But that's not based on some inside knowledge I have, but I have the same
44:58But that's not based on some inside knowledge I have, but I have the same
45:02bias. Sure. Yeah. Less seems better.
45:02bias. Sure. Yeah. Less seems better.
45:02bias. Sure. Yeah. Less seems better.
45:02bias. Sure. Yeah. Less seems better.
45:02bias. Sure. Yeah. Less seems better.
45:05Yeah. I mean, I'm not out to get the scanner industry.
45:05Yeah. I mean, I'm not out to get the scanner industry.
45:05Yeah. I mean, I'm not out to get the scanner industry.
45:05Yeah. I mean, I'm not out to get the scanner industry.
45:05Yeah. I mean, I'm not out to get the scanner industry.
45:08I think it's useful for people to hear that, that one can have no formal
45:08I think it's useful for people to hear that, that one can have no formal
45:08I think it's useful for people to hear that, that one can have no formal
45:08I think it's useful for people to hear that, that one can have no formal
45:08I think it's useful for people to hear that, that one can have no formal
45:13data, but an understanding of mechanism that leads them to hedge.
45:13data, but an understanding of mechanism that leads them to hedge.
45:13data, but an understanding of mechanism that leads them to hedge.
45:13data, but an understanding of mechanism that leads them to hedge.
45:13data, but an understanding of mechanism that leads them to hedge.
45:17Yeah. It's good to know.
45:17Yeah. It's good to know.
45:17Yeah. It's good to know.
45:17Yeah. It's good to know.
45:17Yeah. It's good to know.
45:19Are there any mutagens and, well, is a carcinogen and a mutagen the same thing?
45:19Are there any mutagens and, well, is a carcinogen and a mutagen the same thing?
45:19Are there any mutagens and, well, is a carcinogen and a mutagen the same thing?
45:19Are there any mutagens and, well, is a carcinogen and a mutagen the same thing?
45:19Are there any mutagens and, well, is a carcinogen and a mutagen the same thing?
45:26So they're closely related. Mutagen, I think, means that you're mutating, that you're changing the
45:26So they're closely related. Mutagen, I think, means that you're mutating, that you're changing the
45:26So they're closely related. Mutagen, I think, means that you're mutating, that you're changing the
45:26So they're closely related. Mutagen, I think, means that you're mutating, that you're changing the
45:26So they're closely related. Mutagen, I think, means that you're mutating, that you're changing the
45:32DNA in the cell. So that's the idea that those mutations may or may not
45:32DNA in the cell. So that's the idea that those mutations may or may not
45:32DNA in the cell. So that's the idea that those mutations may or may not
45:32DNA in the cell. So that's the idea that those mutations may or may not
45:32DNA in the cell. So that's the idea that those mutations may or may not
45:37be linked to cancer. But by virtue of the fact that you're causing more mutations,
45:37be linked to cancer. But by virtue of the fact that you're causing more mutations,
45:37be linked to cancer. But by virtue of the fact that you're causing more mutations,
45:37be linked to cancer. But by virtue of the fact that you're causing more mutations,
45:37be linked to cancer. But by virtue of the fact that you're causing more mutations,
45:41almost inevitably, you're also increasing the risk of cancer.
45:41almost inevitably, you're also increasing the risk of cancer.
45:41almost inevitably, you're also increasing the risk of cancer.
45:41almost inevitably, you're also increasing the risk of cancer.
45:41almost inevitably, you're also increasing the risk of cancer.
45:44And carcinogens are things that increase the rate of cancer.
45:44And carcinogens are things that increase the rate of cancer.
45:44And carcinogens are things that increase the rate of cancer.
45:44And carcinogens are things that increase the rate of cancer.
45:44And carcinogens are things that increase the rate of cancer.
45:47I love barbecued meat. I don't like barbecue sauce because it's sweet, but I like
45:47I love barbecued meat. I don't like barbecue sauce because it's sweet, but I like
45:47I love barbecued meat. I don't like barbecue sauce because it's sweet, but I like
45:47I love barbecued meat. I don't like barbecue sauce because it's sweet, but I like
45:47I love barbecued meat. I don't like barbecue sauce because it's sweet, but I like
45:52meat with a char. Yeah.
45:52meat with a char. Yeah.
45:52meat with a char. Yeah.
45:52meat with a char. Yeah.
45:52meat with a char. Yeah.
45:54Yeah. Is the char bad?
45:54Yeah. Is the char bad?
45:54Yeah. Is the char bad?
45:54Yeah. Is the char bad?
45:54Yeah. Is the char bad?
45:55I think so. I mean, I like it too, but yeah.
45:55I think so. I mean, I like it too, but yeah.
45:55I think so. I mean, I like it too, but yeah.
45:55I think so. I mean, I like it too, but yeah.
45:55I think so. I mean, I like it too, but yeah.
45:58Again, these are balancing decisions in life.
45:58Again, these are balancing decisions in life.
45:58Again, these are balancing decisions in life.
45:58Again, these are balancing decisions in life.
45:58Again, these are balancing decisions in life.
46:02Sure. But yes, there's some, there's, I mean, meat in general has been implicated as
46:02Sure. But yes, there's some, there's, I mean, meat in general has been implicated as
46:02Sure. But yes, there's some, there's, I mean, meat in general has been implicated as
46:02Sure. But yes, there's some, there's, I mean, meat in general has been implicated as
46:02Sure. But yes, there's some, there's, I mean, meat in general has been implicated as
46:07a potential carcinogen, especially even colorectal cancer.
46:07a potential carcinogen, especially even colorectal cancer.
46:07a potential carcinogen, especially even colorectal cancer.
46:07a potential carcinogen, especially even colorectal cancer.
46:07a potential carcinogen, especially even colorectal cancer.
46:10There's some data around that.
46:10There's some data around that.
46:10There's some data around that.
46:10There's some data around that.
46:10There's some data around that.
46:12Yeah. My read of those data, not the char data, but the meat data is,
46:12Yeah. My read of those data, not the char data, but the meat data is,
46:12Yeah. My read of those data, not the char data, but the meat data is,
46:12Yeah. My read of those data, not the char data, but the meat data is,
46:12Yeah. My read of those data, not the char data, but the meat data is,
46:16it's tricky. From my, this is just my standpoint.
46:16it's tricky. From my, this is just my standpoint.
46:16it's tricky. From my, this is just my standpoint.
46:16it's tricky. From my, this is just my standpoint.
46:16it's tricky. From my, this is just my standpoint.
46:20I want to make sure I put brackets around this, that this is my read
46:20I want to make sure I put brackets around this, that this is my read
46:20I want to make sure I put brackets around this, that this is my read
46:20I want to make sure I put brackets around this, that this is my read
46:20I want to make sure I put brackets around this, that this is my read
46:24of the literature, is that many of the studies that looked at meat rich, red
46:24of the literature, is that many of the studies that looked at meat rich, red
46:24of the literature, is that many of the studies that looked at meat rich, red
46:24of the literature, is that many of the studies that looked at meat rich, red
46:24of the literature, is that many of the studies that looked at meat rich, red
46:29meat rich diets versus plant -based diets.
46:29meat rich diets versus plant -based diets.
46:29meat rich diets versus plant -based diets.
46:29meat rich diets versus plant -based diets.
46:29meat rich diets versus plant -based diets.
46:32The problem is a lot of times the red meat enriched diets had a bunch
46:32The problem is a lot of times the red meat enriched diets had a bunch
46:32The problem is a lot of times the red meat enriched diets had a bunch
46:32The problem is a lot of times the red meat enriched diets had a bunch
46:32The problem is a lot of times the red meat enriched diets had a bunch
46:37of other things in them.
46:37of other things in them.
46:37of other things in them.
46:37of other things in them.
46:37of other things in them.
46:38Like sourcing wasn't considered. There was also a lot of starches.
46:38Like sourcing wasn't considered. There was also a lot of starches.
46:38Like sourcing wasn't considered. There was also a lot of starches.
46:38Like sourcing wasn't considered. There was also a lot of starches.
46:38Like sourcing wasn't considered. There was also a lot of starches.
46:43Like, because nowadays you find people who seem to at least feel better, who knows
46:43Like, because nowadays you find people who seem to at least feel better, who knows
46:43Like, because nowadays you find people who seem to at least feel better, who knows
46:43Like, because nowadays you find people who seem to at least feel better, who knows
46:43Like, because nowadays you find people who seem to at least feel better, who knows
46:48about the longevity aspect, but feel better eating red meat, fruits and vegetables, limited amounts
46:48about the longevity aspect, but feel better eating red meat, fruits and vegetables, limited amounts
46:48about the longevity aspect, but feel better eating red meat, fruits and vegetables, limited amounts
46:48about the longevity aspect, but feel better eating red meat, fruits and vegetables, limited amounts
46:48about the longevity aspect, but feel better eating red meat, fruits and vegetables, limited amounts
46:53of starches. So I feel like the nutrition studies are a mess.
46:53of starches. So I feel like the nutrition studies are a mess.
46:53of starches. So I feel like the nutrition studies are a mess.
46:53of starches. So I feel like the nutrition studies are a mess.
46:53of starches. So I feel like the nutrition studies are a mess.
46:57They're kind of a disaster.
46:57They're kind of a disaster.
46:57They're kind of a disaster.
46:57They're kind of a disaster.
46:57They're kind of a disaster.
46:58I certainly don't have clarity on this.
46:58I certainly don't have clarity on this.
46:58I certainly don't have clarity on this.
46:58I certainly don't have clarity on this.
46:58I certainly don't have clarity on this.
47:01Yeah. Yeah. And then it seems like it changes the direction.
47:01Yeah. Yeah. And then it seems like it changes the direction.
47:01Yeah. Yeah. And then it seems like it changes the direction.
47:01Yeah. Yeah. And then it seems like it changes the direction.
47:01Yeah. Yeah. And then it seems like it changes the direction.
47:05I think some things we have pretty good common sense intuition about.
47:05I think some things we have pretty good common sense intuition about.
47:05I think some things we have pretty good common sense intuition about.
47:05I think some things we have pretty good common sense intuition about.
47:05I think some things we have pretty good common sense intuition about.
47:10Fiber. Yeah. Ultra processed foods are probably bad.
47:10Fiber. Yeah. Ultra processed foods are probably bad.
47:10Fiber. Yeah. Ultra processed foods are probably bad.
47:10Fiber. Yeah. Ultra processed foods are probably bad.
47:10Fiber. Yeah. Ultra processed foods are probably bad.
47:13Like, you know, but I think the balance of exactly what whole foods we're eating
47:13Like, you know, but I think the balance of exactly what whole foods we're eating
47:13Like, you know, but I think the balance of exactly what whole foods we're eating
47:13Like, you know, but I think the balance of exactly what whole foods we're eating
47:13Like, you know, but I think the balance of exactly what whole foods we're eating
47:18probably still needs to be worked out.
47:18probably still needs to be worked out.
47:18probably still needs to be worked out.
47:18probably still needs to be worked out.
47:18probably still needs to be worked out.
47:20How do you think about the data on like, for instance, food dyes, this is
47:20How do you think about the data on like, for instance, food dyes, this is
47:20How do you think about the data on like, for instance, food dyes, this is
47:20How do you think about the data on like, for instance, food dyes, this is
47:20How do you think about the data on like, for instance, food dyes, this is
47:26very timely, where a certain food dye at a very, very, very high concentration in
47:26very timely, where a certain food dye at a very, very, very high concentration in
47:26very timely, where a certain food dye at a very, very, very high concentration in
47:26very timely, where a certain food dye at a very, very, very high concentration in
47:26very timely, where a certain food dye at a very, very, very high concentration in
47:32laboratory animals creates a significantly higher incidence of tumors and cancers in those animals.
47:32laboratory animals creates a significantly higher incidence of tumors and cancers in those animals.
47:32laboratory animals creates a significantly higher incidence of tumors and cancers in those animals.
47:32laboratory animals creates a significantly higher incidence of tumors and cancers in those animals.
47:32laboratory animals creates a significantly higher incidence of tumors and cancers in those animals.
47:39But then the amount of food dye that's in the human food is a tiny
47:39But then the amount of food dye that's in the human food is a tiny
47:39But then the amount of food dye that's in the human food is a tiny
47:39But then the amount of food dye that's in the human food is a tiny
47:39But then the amount of food dye that's in the human food is a tiny
47:44fraction of that. I'm not trying to get political here.
47:44fraction of that. I'm not trying to get political here.
47:44fraction of that. I'm not trying to get political here.
47:44fraction of that. I'm not trying to get political here.
47:44fraction of that. I'm not trying to get political here.
47:47I just think as a framework for people to think about, there are many carcinogens,
47:47I just think as a framework for people to think about, there are many carcinogens,
47:47I just think as a framework for people to think about, there are many carcinogens,
47:47I just think as a framework for people to think about, there are many carcinogens,
47:47I just think as a framework for people to think about, there are many carcinogens,
47:50I'm sure, right in this environment.
47:50I'm sure, right in this environment.
47:50I'm sure, right in this environment.
47:50I'm sure, right in this environment.
47:50I'm sure, right in this environment.
47:51I don't doubt that the lacquer on this table, in fact, if that's even what
47:51I don't doubt that the lacquer on this table, in fact, if that's even what
47:51I don't doubt that the lacquer on this table, in fact, if that's even what
47:51I don't doubt that the lacquer on this table, in fact, if that's even what
47:51I don't doubt that the lacquer on this table, in fact, if that's even what
47:55they used, if ingested could cause cancer.
47:55they used, if ingested could cause cancer.
47:55they used, if ingested could cause cancer.
47:55they used, if ingested could cause cancer.
47:55they used, if ingested could cause cancer.
48:00I don't doubt that, right?
48:00I don't doubt that, right?
48:00I don't doubt that, right?
48:00I don't doubt that, right?
48:00I don't doubt that, right?
48:02But I don't know that in its form here, being near it for many hours
48:02But I don't know that in its form here, being near it for many hours
48:02But I don't know that in its form here, being near it for many hours
48:02But I don't know that in its form here, being near it for many hours
48:02But I don't know that in its form here, being near it for many hours
48:06a day does that. I doubt it.
48:06a day does that. I doubt it.
48:06a day does that. I doubt it.
48:06a day does that. I doubt it.
48:06a day does that. I doubt it.
48:08We're not inhaling the table.
48:08We're not inhaling the table.
48:08We're not inhaling the table.
48:08We're not inhaling the table.
48:08We're not inhaling the table.
48:09This is what I mean by this level of confusion.
48:09This is what I mean by this level of confusion.
48:09This is what I mean by this level of confusion.
48:09This is what I mean by this level of confusion.
48:09This is what I mean by this level of confusion.
48:12I think we all live with this background confusion of things.
48:12I think we all live with this background confusion of things.
48:12I think we all live with this background confusion of things.
48:12I think we all live with this background confusion of things.
48:12I think we all live with this background confusion of things.
48:15Some study has been published in mice at high concentrations exposure.
48:15Some study has been published in mice at high concentrations exposure.
48:15Some study has been published in mice at high concentrations exposure.
48:15Some study has been published in mice at high concentrations exposure.
48:15Some study has been published in mice at high concentrations exposure.
48:20It doesn't mean anything in our lives.
48:20It doesn't mean anything in our lives.
48:20It doesn't mean anything in our lives.
48:20It doesn't mean anything in our lives.
48:20It doesn't mean anything in our lives.
48:22What's the relative risk? So that's why I start with smoking, sunlight, and then say
48:22What's the relative risk? So that's why I start with smoking, sunlight, and then say
48:22What's the relative risk? So that's why I start with smoking, sunlight, and then say
48:22What's the relative risk? So that's why I start with smoking, sunlight, and then say
48:22What's the relative risk? So that's why I start with smoking, sunlight, and then say
48:27there's a tail. And I don't think we know fully what that distribution is yet.
48:27there's a tail. And I don't think we know fully what that distribution is yet.
48:27there's a tail. And I don't think we know fully what that distribution is yet.
48:27there's a tail. And I don't think we know fully what that distribution is yet.
48:27there's a tail. And I don't think we know fully what that distribution is yet.
48:32I'm sure there are some combination of things that are increasing our risk of cancer.
48:32I'm sure there are some combination of things that are increasing our risk of cancer.
48:32I'm sure there are some combination of things that are increasing our risk of cancer.
48:32I'm sure there are some combination of things that are increasing our risk of cancer.
48:32I'm sure there are some combination of things that are increasing our risk of cancer.
48:36We don't really know how to weigh duration and amount of exposure.
48:36We don't really know how to weigh duration and amount of exposure.
48:36We don't really know how to weigh duration and amount of exposure.
48:36We don't really know how to weigh duration and amount of exposure.
48:36We don't really know how to weigh duration and amount of exposure.
48:41And this is why I think it's really scary to people.
48:41And this is why I think it's really scary to people.
48:41And this is why I think it's really scary to people.
48:41And this is why I think it's really scary to people.
48:41And this is why I think it's really scary to people.
48:43People don't know, you know, they know smokers who don't get lung cancer.
48:43People don't know, you know, they know smokers who don't get lung cancer.
48:43People don't know, you know, they know smokers who don't get lung cancer.
48:43People don't know, you know, they know smokers who don't get lung cancer.
48:43People don't know, you know, they know smokers who don't get lung cancer.
48:47And non -smokers who do.
48:47And non -smokers who do.
48:47And non -smokers who do.
48:47And non -smokers who do.
48:47And non -smokers who do.
48:48And non -smokers who do.
48:48And non -smokers who do.
48:48And non -smokers who do.
48:48And non -smokers who do.
48:48And non -smokers who do.
48:50And so I think people go, well, like what they actually has caused, I believe,
48:50And so I think people go, well, like what they actually has caused, I believe,
48:50And so I think people go, well, like what they actually has caused, I believe,
48:50And so I think people go, well, like what they actually has caused, I believe,
48:50And so I think people go, well, like what they actually has caused, I believe,
48:54a lot of damage in the faith in medicine, unfortunately, because the messaging is all
48:54a lot of damage in the faith in medicine, unfortunately, because the messaging is all
48:54a lot of damage in the faith in medicine, unfortunately, because the messaging is all
48:54a lot of damage in the faith in medicine, unfortunately, because the messaging is all
48:54a lot of damage in the faith in medicine, unfortunately, because the messaging is all
48:59is mixed up. Yeah, I think that nowadays people are trying to do what they
48:59is mixed up. Yeah, I think that nowadays people are trying to do what they
48:59is mixed up. Yeah, I think that nowadays people are trying to do what they
48:59is mixed up. Yeah, I think that nowadays people are trying to do what they
48:59is mixed up. Yeah, I think that nowadays people are trying to do what they
49:03can to protect themselves. Yeah.
49:03can to protect themselves. Yeah.
49:03can to protect themselves. Yeah.
49:03can to protect themselves. Yeah.
49:03can to protect themselves. Yeah.
49:05But - But - People still get cancer.
49:05But - But - People still get cancer.
49:05But - But - People still get cancer.
49:05But - But - People still get cancer.
49:05But - But - People still get cancer.
49:06You can do everything right and still get cancer, even if you don't have a
49:06You can do everything right and still get cancer, even if you don't have a
49:06You can do everything right and still get cancer, even if you don't have a
49:06You can do everything right and still get cancer, even if you don't have a
49:06You can do everything right and still get cancer, even if you don't have a
49:10BRCA mutation. Absolutely. I mean, absolutely.
49:10BRCA mutation. Absolutely. I mean, absolutely.
49:10BRCA mutation. Absolutely. I mean, absolutely.
49:10BRCA mutation. Absolutely. I mean, absolutely.
49:10BRCA mutation. Absolutely. I mean, absolutely.
49:13You know, I think the last thing you ever want to do is like attribute
49:13You know, I think the last thing you ever want to do is like attribute
49:13You know, I think the last thing you ever want to do is like attribute
49:13You know, I think the last thing you ever want to do is like attribute
49:13You know, I think the last thing you ever want to do is like attribute
49:18someone's actions to cancer. I mean, it is a probabilistic disease where some set of
49:18someone's actions to cancer. I mean, it is a probabilistic disease where some set of
49:18someone's actions to cancer. I mean, it is a probabilistic disease where some set of
49:18someone's actions to cancer. I mean, it is a probabilistic disease where some set of
49:18someone's actions to cancer. I mean, it is a probabilistic disease where some set of
49:24mutations occur that cause a really devastating disease.
49:24mutations occur that cause a really devastating disease.
49:24mutations occur that cause a really devastating disease.
49:24mutations occur that cause a really devastating disease.
49:24mutations occur that cause a really devastating disease.
49:28And so, yeah, I mean, we don't know the answers, and I think we have
49:28And so, yeah, I mean, we don't know the answers, and I think we have
49:28And so, yeah, I mean, we don't know the answers, and I think we have
49:28And so, yeah, I mean, we don't know the answers, and I think we have
49:28And so, yeah, I mean, we don't know the answers, and I think we have
49:32to be humble about that.
49:32to be humble about that.
49:32to be humble about that.
49:32to be humble about that.
49:32to be humble about that.
49:34Now, what I think we can also talk about is, well, how do we handle,
49:34Now, what I think we can also talk about is, well, how do we handle,
49:34Now, what I think we can also talk about is, well, how do we handle,
49:34Now, what I think we can also talk about is, well, how do we handle,
49:34Now, what I think we can also talk about is, well, how do we handle,
49:38how do we treat cancer when it comes up?
49:38how do we treat cancer when it comes up?
49:38how do we treat cancer when it comes up?
49:38how do we treat cancer when it comes up?
49:38how do we treat cancer when it comes up?
49:40And this is where these two conversations that we've been having really come together of
49:40And this is where these two conversations that we've been having really come together of
49:40And this is where these two conversations that we've been having really come together of
49:40And this is where these two conversations that we've been having really come together of
49:40And this is where these two conversations that we've been having really come together of
49:44talking about the immune system.
49:44talking about the immune system.
49:44talking about the immune system.
49:44talking about the immune system.
49:44talking about the immune system.
49:45We went through a lot of, I think, I mean, actually, we went through a
49:45We went through a lot of, I think, I mean, actually, we went through a
49:45We went through a lot of, I think, I mean, actually, we went through a
49:45We went through a lot of, I think, I mean, actually, we went through a
49:45We went through a lot of, I think, I mean, actually, we went through a
49:48lot of sort of detailed mechanism thinking about the different cell constituents of our immune
49:48lot of sort of detailed mechanism thinking about the different cell constituents of our immune
49:48lot of sort of detailed mechanism thinking about the different cell constituents of our immune
49:48lot of sort of detailed mechanism thinking about the different cell constituents of our immune
49:48lot of sort of detailed mechanism thinking about the different cell constituents of our immune
49:52system. I will tell you that when I went to medical school, which wasn't that
49:52system. I will tell you that when I went to medical school, which wasn't that
49:52system. I will tell you that when I went to medical school, which wasn't that
49:52system. I will tell you that when I went to medical school, which wasn't that
49:52system. I will tell you that when I went to medical school, which wasn't that
49:58long ago, I graduated in 2010, and the dogma was don't waste time thinking about
49:58long ago, I graduated in 2010, and the dogma was don't waste time thinking about
49:58long ago, I graduated in 2010, and the dogma was don't waste time thinking about
49:58long ago, I graduated in 2010, and the dogma was don't waste time thinking about
49:58long ago, I graduated in 2010, and the dogma was don't waste time thinking about
50:05cancer immunology. Cancer immunology is a field that's going nowhere.
50:05cancer immunology. Cancer immunology is a field that's going nowhere.
50:05cancer immunology. Cancer immunology is a field that's going nowhere.
50:05cancer immunology. Cancer immunology is a field that's going nowhere.
50:05cancer immunology. Cancer immunology is a field that's going nowhere.
50:10I mean, I think I was in Boston, I think maybe there was some local
50:10I mean, I think I was in Boston, I think maybe there was some local
50:10I mean, I think I was in Boston, I think maybe there was some local
50:10I mean, I think I was in Boston, I think maybe there was some local
50:10I mean, I think I was in Boston, I think maybe there was some local
50:14bias in that direction, but this was not the mainstream of thinking about how we
50:14bias in that direction, but this was not the mainstream of thinking about how we
50:14bias in that direction, but this was not the mainstream of thinking about how we
50:14bias in that direction, but this was not the mainstream of thinking about how we
50:14bias in that direction, but this was not the mainstream of thinking about how we
50:18would treat cancer. At that point, the way that cancer was being treated was chemotherapy,
50:18would treat cancer. At that point, the way that cancer was being treated was chemotherapy,
50:18would treat cancer. At that point, the way that cancer was being treated was chemotherapy,
50:18would treat cancer. At that point, the way that cancer was being treated was chemotherapy,
50:18would treat cancer. At that point, the way that cancer was being treated was chemotherapy,
50:24which, you know, is something that's been around for decades, and it's basically to give
50:24which, you know, is something that's been around for decades, and it's basically to give
50:24which, you know, is something that's been around for decades, and it's basically to give
50:24which, you know, is something that's been around for decades, and it's basically to give
50:24which, you know, is something that's been around for decades, and it's basically to give
50:27toxins to the body that will be more toxic to the cancer cells than to
50:27toxins to the body that will be more toxic to the cancer cells than to
50:27toxins to the body that will be more toxic to the cancer cells than to
50:27toxins to the body that will be more toxic to the cancer cells than to
50:27toxins to the body that will be more toxic to the cancer cells than to
50:32the healthy cells, and ask people to endure all the side effects because they have
50:32the healthy cells, and ask people to endure all the side effects because they have
50:32the healthy cells, and ask people to endure all the side effects because they have
50:32the healthy cells, and ask people to endure all the side effects because they have
50:32the healthy cells, and ask people to endure all the side effects because they have
50:38to to get rid of the cancer cells, and that's still the mainstay of cancer
50:38to to get rid of the cancer cells, and that's still the mainstay of cancer
50:38to to get rid of the cancer cells, and that's still the mainstay of cancer
50:38to to get rid of the cancer cells, and that's still the mainstay of cancer
50:38to to get rid of the cancer cells, and that's still the mainstay of cancer
50:42treatment. We all want to do better than that.
50:42treatment. We all want to do better than that.
50:42treatment. We all want to do better than that.
50:42treatment. We all want to do better than that.
50:42treatment. We all want to do better than that.
50:45It's very unpleasant, very, very unpleasant.
50:45It's very unpleasant, very, very unpleasant.
50:45It's very unpleasant, very, very unpleasant.
50:45It's very unpleasant, very, very unpleasant.
50:45It's very unpleasant, very, very unpleasant.
50:48Unpleasant and worse. I mean, people endure, you know, we put people through horrific things
50:48Unpleasant and worse. I mean, people endure, you know, we put people through horrific things
50:48Unpleasant and worse. I mean, people endure, you know, we put people through horrific things
50:48Unpleasant and worse. I mean, people endure, you know, we put people through horrific things
50:48Unpleasant and worse. I mean, people endure, you know, we put people through horrific things
50:55because it's the best we can do.
50:55because it's the best we can do.
50:55because it's the best we can do.
50:55because it's the best we can do.
50:55because it's the best we can do.
50:58And then there was a wave of thinking, okay, well, let's try to make drugs
50:58And then there was a wave of thinking, okay, well, let's try to make drugs
50:58And then there was a wave of thinking, okay, well, let's try to make drugs
50:58And then there was a wave of thinking, okay, well, let's try to make drugs
50:58And then there was a wave of thinking, okay, well, let's try to make drugs
51:02that are targeted to the mutations that we talked about.
51:02that are targeted to the mutations that we talked about.
51:02that are targeted to the mutations that we talked about.
51:02that are targeted to the mutations that we talked about.
51:02that are targeted to the mutations that we talked about.
51:05And that was the hot thing, that was the promising avenue when I was in
51:05And that was the hot thing, that was the promising avenue when I was in
51:05And that was the hot thing, that was the promising avenue when I was in
51:05And that was the hot thing, that was the promising avenue when I was in
51:05And that was the hot thing, that was the promising avenue when I was in
51:09medical school of like, okay, now we've really measured, these are mutations that accumulate inside
51:09medical school of like, okay, now we've really measured, these are mutations that accumulate inside
51:09medical school of like, okay, now we've really measured, these are mutations that accumulate inside
51:09medical school of like, okay, now we've really measured, these are mutations that accumulate inside
51:09medical school of like, okay, now we've really measured, these are mutations that accumulate inside
51:14of cancer cells, this is what's causing cancer, let's make drugs that go after those
51:14of cancer cells, this is what's causing cancer, let's make drugs that go after those
51:14of cancer cells, this is what's causing cancer, let's make drugs that go after those
51:14of cancer cells, this is what's causing cancer, let's make drugs that go after those
51:14of cancer cells, this is what's causing cancer, let's make drugs that go after those
51:18things. And it turned out that that was, although a lot of good has come
51:18things. And it turned out that that was, although a lot of good has come
51:18things. And it turned out that that was, although a lot of good has come
51:18things. And it turned out that that was, although a lot of good has come
51:18things. And it turned out that that was, although a lot of good has come
51:23from that, people have extended lives, cancer has a way of working around that.
51:23from that, people have extended lives, cancer has a way of working around that.
51:23from that, people have extended lives, cancer has a way of working around that.
51:23from that, people have extended lives, cancer has a way of working around that.
51:23from that, people have extended lives, cancer has a way of working around that.
51:29So these are cell cycle inhibitors?
51:29So these are cell cycle inhibitors?
51:29So these are cell cycle inhibitors?
51:29So these are cell cycle inhibitors?
51:29So these are cell cycle inhibitors?
51:32Signaling, various mutations affect these growth properties of cells, and there's targeted drugs that have
51:32Signaling, various mutations affect these growth properties of cells, and there's targeted drugs that have
51:32Signaling, various mutations affect these growth properties of cells, and there's targeted drugs that have
51:32Signaling, various mutations affect these growth properties of cells, and there's targeted drugs that have
51:32Signaling, various mutations affect these growth properties of cells, and there's targeted drugs that have
51:39been designed to go after some of those pathways that are making the cells divide
51:39been designed to go after some of those pathways that are making the cells divide
51:39been designed to go after some of those pathways that are making the cells divide
51:39been designed to go after some of those pathways that are making the cells divide
51:39been designed to go after some of those pathways that are making the cells divide
51:43out of control. Yeah. I think that benefit has come, but cancer has ways of
51:43out of control. Yeah. I think that benefit has come, but cancer has ways of
51:43out of control. Yeah. I think that benefit has come, but cancer has ways of
51:43out of control. Yeah. I think that benefit has come, but cancer has ways of
51:43out of control. Yeah. I think that benefit has come, but cancer has ways of
51:48mutating around that and can be developing resistance.
51:48mutating around that and can be developing resistance.
51:48mutating around that and can be developing resistance.
51:48mutating around that and can be developing resistance.
51:48mutating around that and can be developing resistance.
51:51The same way we talked about resistance in bacteria to antibiotics, if they're exposed, cancer
51:51The same way we talked about resistance in bacteria to antibiotics, if they're exposed, cancer
51:51The same way we talked about resistance in bacteria to antibiotics, if they're exposed, cancer
51:51The same way we talked about resistance in bacteria to antibiotics, if they're exposed, cancer
51:51The same way we talked about resistance in bacteria to antibiotics, if they're exposed, cancer
51:56cells can evolve quickly and can become resistant to these targeted modifications.
51:56cells can evolve quickly and can become resistant to these targeted modifications.
51:56cells can evolve quickly and can become resistant to these targeted modifications.
51:56cells can evolve quickly and can become resistant to these targeted modifications.
51:56cells can evolve quickly and can become resistant to these targeted modifications.
52:02What has emerged as a whole new way of thinking about going after cancer is
52:02What has emerged as a whole new way of thinking about going after cancer is
52:02What has emerged as a whole new way of thinking about going after cancer is
52:02What has emerged as a whole new way of thinking about going after cancer is
52:02What has emerged as a whole new way of thinking about going after cancer is
52:07using the power of the immune system that we talked about at the beginning and
52:07using the power of the immune system that we talked about at the beginning and
52:07using the power of the immune system that we talked about at the beginning and
52:07using the power of the immune system that we talked about at the beginning and
52:07using the power of the immune system that we talked about at the beginning and
52:11redirecting that against cancer targets?
52:11redirecting that against cancer targets?
52:11redirecting that against cancer targets?
52:11redirecting that against cancer targets?
52:11redirecting that against cancer targets?
52:15This has changed how we think about cancer treatment.
52:15This has changed how we think about cancer treatment.
52:15This has changed how we think about cancer treatment.
52:15This has changed how we think about cancer treatment.
52:15This has changed how we think about cancer treatment.
52:18The hope is that all of us have this immune system that goes through every
52:18The hope is that all of us have this immune system that goes through every
52:18The hope is that all of us have this immune system that goes through every
52:18The hope is that all of us have this immune system that goes through every
52:18The hope is that all of us have this immune system that goes through every
52:23organ in our body, it circulates, we have white blood cells that are constantly going
52:23organ in our body, it circulates, we have white blood cells that are constantly going
52:23organ in our body, it circulates, we have white blood cells that are constantly going
52:23organ in our body, it circulates, we have white blood cells that are constantly going
52:23organ in our body, it circulates, we have white blood cells that are constantly going
52:27around and looking for things that shouldn't be there.
52:27around and looking for things that shouldn't be there.
52:27around and looking for things that shouldn't be there.
52:27around and looking for things that shouldn't be there.
52:27around and looking for things that shouldn't be there.
52:29can we unleash that immune system against cancer?
52:29can we unleash that immune system against cancer?
52:29can we unleash that immune system against cancer?
52:29can we unleash that immune system against cancer?
52:29can we unleash that immune system against cancer?
52:35And the hope would be that the cells of our immune system, we talked about
52:35And the hope would be that the cells of our immune system, we talked about
52:35And the hope would be that the cells of our immune system, we talked about
52:35And the hope would be that the cells of our immune system, we talked about
52:35And the hope would be that the cells of our immune system, we talked about
52:38how they're really exquisitely evolved to make a determination of this is a healthy cell,
52:38how they're really exquisitely evolved to make a determination of this is a healthy cell,
52:38how they're really exquisitely evolved to make a determination of this is a healthy cell,
52:38how they're really exquisitely evolved to make a determination of this is a healthy cell,
52:38how they're really exquisitely evolved to make a determination of this is a healthy cell,
52:43this is not a healthy cell, this cell should be here, this should not.
52:43this is not a healthy cell, this cell should be here, this should not.
52:43this is not a healthy cell, this cell should be here, this should not.
52:43this is not a healthy cell, this cell should be here, this should not.
52:43this is not a healthy cell, this cell should be here, this should not.
52:46If we could get that level of precision where we could have a durable immune
52:46If we could get that level of precision where we could have a durable immune
52:46If we could get that level of precision where we could have a durable immune
52:46If we could get that level of precision where we could have a durable immune
52:46If we could get that level of precision where we could have a durable immune
52:50response that gets rid of the cancer cells but leaves the healthy cells intact, that
52:50response that gets rid of the cancer cells but leaves the healthy cells intact, that
52:50response that gets rid of the cancer cells but leaves the healthy cells intact, that
52:50response that gets rid of the cancer cells but leaves the healthy cells intact, that
52:50response that gets rid of the cancer cells but leaves the healthy cells intact, that
52:54is what we want. Now, that is not science fiction and is now approved and
52:54is what we want. Now, that is not science fiction and is now approved and
52:54is what we want. Now, that is not science fiction and is now approved and
52:54is what we want. Now, that is not science fiction and is now approved and
52:54is what we want. Now, that is not science fiction and is now approved and
53:02used to treat a number of different cancers.
53:02used to treat a number of different cancers.
53:02used to treat a number of different cancers.
53:02used to treat a number of different cancers.
53:02used to treat a number of different cancers.
53:04The first place where this happened was in a class of medicines called checkpoint inhibitors
53:04The first place where this happened was in a class of medicines called checkpoint inhibitors
53:04The first place where this happened was in a class of medicines called checkpoint inhibitors
53:04The first place where this happened was in a class of medicines called checkpoint inhibitors
53:04The first place where this happened was in a class of medicines called checkpoint inhibitors
53:11or immunotherapy drugs. A lot of people will have heard of these things.
53:11or immunotherapy drugs. A lot of people will have heard of these things.
53:11or immunotherapy drugs. A lot of people will have heard of these things.
53:11or immunotherapy drugs. A lot of people will have heard of these things.
53:11or immunotherapy drugs. A lot of people will have heard of these things.
53:17PD -1, CTLA -4 are some targets where there are drugs that get infused that
53:17PD -1, CTLA -4 are some targets where there are drugs that get infused that
53:17PD -1, CTLA -4 are some targets where there are drugs that get infused that
53:17PD -1, CTLA -4 are some targets where there are drugs that get infused that
53:17PD -1, CTLA -4 are some targets where there are drugs that get infused that
53:23hit these things that are on the surface of T cells and they actually are
53:23hit these things that are on the surface of T cells and they actually are
53:23hit these things that are on the surface of T cells and they actually are
53:23hit these things that are on the surface of T cells and they actually are
53:23hit these things that are on the surface of T cells and they actually are
53:28natural breaks to the T cells.
53:28natural breaks to the T cells.
53:28natural breaks to the T cells.
53:28natural breaks to the T cells.
53:28natural breaks to the T cells.
53:31T cells might be in our body there but turned off or not turned on
53:31T cells might be in our body there but turned off or not turned on
53:31T cells might be in our body there but turned off or not turned on
53:31T cells might be in our body there but turned off or not turned on
53:31T cells might be in our body there but turned off or not turned on
53:36enough to be strong enough against cancer.
53:36enough to be strong enough against cancer.
53:36enough to be strong enough against cancer.
53:36enough to be strong enough against cancer.
53:36enough to be strong enough against cancer.
53:39And for certain types of cancer, it's been absolutely miraculous that if you make a
53:39And for certain types of cancer, it's been absolutely miraculous that if you make a
53:39And for certain types of cancer, it's been absolutely miraculous that if you make a
53:39And for certain types of cancer, it's been absolutely miraculous that if you make a
53:39And for certain types of cancer, it's been absolutely miraculous that if you make a
53:44drug that hits the break on the T cells, the T cells go stronger and
53:44drug that hits the break on the T cells, the T cells go stronger and
53:44drug that hits the break on the T cells, the T cells go stronger and
53:44drug that hits the break on the T cells, the T cells go stronger and
53:44drug that hits the break on the T cells, the T cells go stronger and
53:49they can be unleashed against cancer just by taking the breaks off of them.
53:49they can be unleashed against cancer just by taking the breaks off of them.
53:49they can be unleashed against cancer just by taking the breaks off of them.
53:49they can be unleashed against cancer just by taking the breaks off of them.
53:49they can be unleashed against cancer just by taking the breaks off of them.
53:52What sorts of cancers has it been successful for?
53:52What sorts of cancers has it been successful for?
53:52What sorts of cancers has it been successful for?
53:52What sorts of cancers has it been successful for?
53:52What sorts of cancers has it been successful for?
53:55The poster child for this has been melanoma.
53:55The poster child for this has been melanoma.
53:55The poster child for this has been melanoma.
53:55The poster child for this has been melanoma.
53:55The poster child for this has been melanoma.
53:58One of the big success cases was Jimmy Carter who had a melanoma which is
53:58One of the big success cases was Jimmy Carter who had a melanoma which is
53:58One of the big success cases was Jimmy Carter who had a melanoma which is
53:58One of the big success cases was Jimmy Carter who had a melanoma which is
53:58One of the big success cases was Jimmy Carter who had a melanoma which is
54:03a skin cell, aggressive skin cancer that had already gone to his brain which was
54:03a skin cell, aggressive skin cancer that had already gone to his brain which was
54:03a skin cell, aggressive skin cancer that had already gone to his brain which was
54:03a skin cell, aggressive skin cancer that had already gone to his brain which was
54:03a skin cell, aggressive skin cancer that had already gone to his brain which was
54:08thought of as a death sentence and he got treated with checkpoint inhibitors and basically
54:08thought of as a death sentence and he got treated with checkpoint inhibitors and basically
54:08thought of as a death sentence and he got treated with checkpoint inhibitors and basically
54:08thought of as a death sentence and he got treated with checkpoint inhibitors and basically
54:08thought of as a death sentence and he got treated with checkpoint inhibitors and basically
54:13was cured. Amazing. And so you saw these tumors just shrink away and not just
54:13was cured. Amazing. And so you saw these tumors just shrink away and not just
54:13was cured. Amazing. And so you saw these tumors just shrink away and not just
54:13was cured. Amazing. And so you saw these tumors just shrink away and not just
54:13was cured. Amazing. And so you saw these tumors just shrink away and not just
54:20him but in a large fraction of melanoma patients now respond to these.
54:20him but in a large fraction of melanoma patients now respond to these.
54:20him but in a large fraction of melanoma patients now respond to these.
54:20him but in a large fraction of melanoma patients now respond to these.
54:20him but in a large fraction of melanoma patients now respond to these.
54:24And so that has changed how melanoma is treated and other cancers to varying degrees
54:24And so that has changed how melanoma is treated and other cancers to varying degrees
54:24And so that has changed how melanoma is treated and other cancers to varying degrees
54:24And so that has changed how melanoma is treated and other cancers to varying degrees
54:24And so that has changed how melanoma is treated and other cancers to varying degrees
54:31because some types of cancers can respond.
54:31because some types of cancers can respond.
54:31because some types of cancers can respond.
54:31because some types of cancers can respond.
54:31because some types of cancers can respond.
54:33to this. That's taking a drug that unleashes the T -cells that are already in
54:33to this. That's taking a drug that unleashes the T -cells that are already in
54:33to this. That's taking a drug that unleashes the T -cells that are already in
54:33to this. That's taking a drug that unleashes the T -cells that are already in
54:33to this. That's taking a drug that unleashes the T -cells that are already in
54:38our body. The focus of my research in it is, well, the first thing I
54:38our body. The focus of my research in it is, well, the first thing I
54:38our body. The focus of my research in it is, well, the first thing I
54:38our body. The focus of my research in it is, well, the first thing I
54:38our body. The focus of my research in it is, well, the first thing I
54:43said was we're living in this amazing moment of biology where we can do things
54:43said was we're living in this amazing moment of biology where we can do things
54:43said was we're living in this amazing moment of biology where we can do things
54:43said was we're living in this amazing moment of biology where we can do things
54:43said was we're living in this amazing moment of biology where we can do things
54:47to cells in our body with incredible precision and we're often just limited by our
54:47to cells in our body with incredible precision and we're often just limited by our
54:47to cells in our body with incredible precision and we're often just limited by our
54:47to cells in our body with incredible precision and we're often just limited by our
54:47to cells in our body with incredible precision and we're often just limited by our
54:53imagination. And what we can see now is that we don't actually have to just
54:53imagination. And what we can see now is that we don't actually have to just
54:53imagination. And what we can see now is that we don't actually have to just
54:53imagination. And what we can see now is that we don't actually have to just
54:53imagination. And what we can see now is that we don't actually have to just
54:57be limited to the cells, the T -cells that are naturally in our body that
54:57be limited to the cells, the T -cells that are naturally in our body that
54:57be limited to the cells, the T -cells that are naturally in our body that
54:57be limited to the cells, the T -cells that are naturally in our body that
54:57be limited to the cells, the T -cells that are naturally in our body that
55:00already have this random distribution of sensors.
55:00already have this random distribution of sensors.
55:00already have this random distribution of sensors.
55:00already have this random distribution of sensors.
55:00already have this random distribution of sensors.
55:03We can actually genetically make one of these sensors for T -cells and put it
55:03We can actually genetically make one of these sensors for T -cells and put it
55:03We can actually genetically make one of these sensors for T -cells and put it
55:03We can actually genetically make one of these sensors for T -cells and put it
55:03We can actually genetically make one of these sensors for T -cells and put it
55:11into T -cells. We can put a gene that encodes something on the surface of
55:11into T -cells. We can put a gene that encodes something on the surface of
55:11into T -cells. We can put a gene that encodes something on the surface of
55:11into T -cells. We can put a gene that encodes something on the surface of
55:11into T -cells. We can put a gene that encodes something on the surface of
55:16T -cells that will make them programmed to search and destroy for cancer cells.
55:16T -cells that will make them programmed to search and destroy for cancer cells.
55:16T -cells that will make them programmed to search and destroy for cancer cells.
55:16T -cells that will make them programmed to search and destroy for cancer cells.
55:16T -cells that will make them programmed to search and destroy for cancer cells.
55:23Now, this is largely known as chimeric antigen receptor T -cells.
55:23Now, this is largely known as chimeric antigen receptor T -cells.
55:23Now, this is largely known as chimeric antigen receptor T -cells.
55:23Now, this is largely known as chimeric antigen receptor T -cells.
55:23Now, this is largely known as chimeric antigen receptor T -cells.
55:30That's a long term. They're known for short as CAR T -cells, chimeric antigen receptor.
55:30That's a long term. They're known for short as CAR T -cells, chimeric antigen receptor.
55:30That's a long term. They're known for short as CAR T -cells, chimeric antigen receptor.
55:30That's a long term. They're known for short as CAR T -cells, chimeric antigen receptor.
55:30That's a long term. They're known for short as CAR T -cells, chimeric antigen receptor.
55:36And what that means, chimeric, is that these are stitched together.
55:36And what that means, chimeric, is that these are stitched together.
55:36And what that means, chimeric, is that these are stitched together.
55:36And what that means, chimeric, is that these are stitched together.
55:36And what that means, chimeric, is that these are stitched together.
55:39This is a receptor that was designed in a lab, does not exist in nature,
55:39This is a receptor that was designed in a lab, does not exist in nature,
55:39This is a receptor that was designed in a lab, does not exist in nature,
55:39This is a receptor that was designed in a lab, does not exist in nature,
55:39This is a receptor that was designed in a lab, does not exist in nature,
55:43but can be put into a piece of DNA, delivered into a T -cell.
55:43but can be put into a piece of DNA, delivered into a T -cell.
55:43but can be put into a piece of DNA, delivered into a T -cell.
55:43but can be put into a piece of DNA, delivered into a T -cell.
55:43but can be put into a piece of DNA, delivered into a T -cell.
55:49And when that DNA goes into the genetic code of the T -cell, all of
55:49And when that DNA goes into the genetic code of the T -cell, all of
55:49And when that DNA goes into the genetic code of the T -cell, all of
55:49And when that DNA goes into the genetic code of the T -cell, all of
55:49And when that DNA goes into the genetic code of the T -cell, all of
55:52a sudden the T -cell will start making proteins that go on its surface and
55:52a sudden the T -cell will start making proteins that go on its surface and
55:52a sudden the T -cell will start making proteins that go on its surface and
55:52a sudden the T -cell will start making proteins that go on its surface and
55:52a sudden the T -cell will start making proteins that go on its surface and
55:56act as these artificial sensors.
55:56act as these artificial sensors.
55:56act as these artificial sensors.
55:56act as these artificial sensors.
55:56act as these artificial sensors.
55:58And those CARs, then when those T -cells get re -infused into a patient the
55:58And those CARs, then when those T -cells get re -infused into a patient the
55:58And those CARs, then when those T -cells get re -infused into a patient the
55:58And those CARs, then when those T -cells get re -infused into a patient the
55:58And those CARs, then when those T -cells get re -infused into a patient the
56:04way that you get like a blood transfusion, those CARs are directed to go against
56:04way that you get like a blood transfusion, those CARs are directed to go against
56:04way that you get like a blood transfusion, those CARs are directed to go against
56:04way that you get like a blood transfusion, those CARs are directed to go against
56:04way that you get like a blood transfusion, those CARs are directed to go against
56:08cancers. This has been done for certain types of leukemia and lymphoma, and there's been
56:08cancers. This has been done for certain types of leukemia and lymphoma, and there's been
56:08cancers. This has been done for certain types of leukemia and lymphoma, and there's been
56:08cancers. This has been done for certain types of leukemia and lymphoma, and there's been
56:08cancers. This has been done for certain types of leukemia and lymphoma, and there's been
56:14these amazing success stories. The thing that woke up me and the world was in
56:14these amazing success stories. The thing that woke up me and the world was in
56:14these amazing success stories. The thing that woke up me and the world was in
56:14these amazing success stories. The thing that woke up me and the world was in
56:14these amazing success stories. The thing that woke up me and the world was in
56:202012 there was a young girl who was the first pediatric patient to be treated
56:202012 there was a young girl who was the first pediatric patient to be treated
56:202012 there was a young girl who was the first pediatric patient to be treated
56:202012 there was a young girl who was the first pediatric patient to be treated
56:202012 there was a young girl who was the first pediatric patient to be treated
56:26with a CAR T -cell for cancer.
56:26with a CAR T -cell for cancer.
56:26with a CAR T -cell for cancer.
56:26with a CAR T -cell for cancer.
56:26with a CAR T -cell for cancer.
56:28So she's become a heroic figure, Emily Whitehead.
56:28So she's become a heroic figure, Emily Whitehead.
56:28So she's become a heroic figure, Emily Whitehead.
56:28So she's become a heroic figure, Emily Whitehead.
56:28So she's become a heroic figure, Emily Whitehead.
56:33She was, I think, eight at the time.
56:33She was, I think, eight at the time.
56:33She was, I think, eight at the time.
56:33She was, I think, eight at the time.
56:33She was, I think, eight at the time.
56:35And she had a form of leukemia that hadn't...
56:35And she had a form of leukemia that hadn't...
56:35And she had a form of leukemia that hadn't...
56:35And she had a form of leukemia that hadn't...
56:35And she had a form of leukemia that hadn't...
56:39It just was, for some reason, whatever reason, it failed all the treatments and it
56:39It just was, for some reason, whatever reason, it failed all the treatments and it
56:39It just was, for some reason, whatever reason, it failed all the treatments and it
56:39It just was, for some reason, whatever reason, it failed all the treatments and it
56:39It just was, for some reason, whatever reason, it failed all the treatments and it
56:44just, nothing worked. She was going to be sent home on hospice.
56:44just, nothing worked. She was going to be sent home on hospice.
56:44just, nothing worked. She was going to be sent home on hospice.
56:44just, nothing worked. She was going to be sent home on hospice.
56:44just, nothing worked. She was going to be sent home on hospice.
56:48She had exhausted all the possibilities at the age of eight.
56:48She had exhausted all the possibilities at the age of eight.
56:48She had exhausted all the possibilities at the age of eight.
56:48She had exhausted all the possibilities at the age of eight.
56:48She had exhausted all the possibilities at the age of eight.
56:52And she got enrolled in, at that time, highly experimental treatment to get these CAR
56:52And she got enrolled in, at that time, highly experimental treatment to get these CAR
56:52And she got enrolled in, at that time, highly experimental treatment to get these CAR
56:52And she got enrolled in, at that time, highly experimental treatment to get these CAR
56:52And she got enrolled in, at that time, highly experimental treatment to get these CAR
56:57T -cells. So her blood cells were taken out in a big blood donation.
56:57T -cells. So her blood cells were taken out in a big blood donation.
56:57T -cells. So her blood cells were taken out in a big blood donation.
56:57T -cells. So her blood cells were taken out in a big blood donation.
56:57T -cells. So her blood cells were taken out in a big blood donation.
57:01Her own T -cells were genetically modified.
57:01Her own T -cells were genetically modified.
57:01Her own T -cells were genetically modified.
57:01Her own T -cells were genetically modified.
57:01Her own T -cells were genetically modified.
57:04We can talk about how that was done.
57:04We can talk about how that was done.
57:04We can talk about how that was done.
57:04We can talk about how that was done.
57:04We can talk about how that was done.
57:05It was actually done with a pretty crude technique that's been around.
57:05It was actually done with a pretty crude technique that's been around.
57:05It was actually done with a pretty crude technique that's been around.
57:05It was actually done with a pretty crude technique that's been around.
57:05It was actually done with a pretty crude technique that's been around.
57:09It actually used viruses, lentiviruses.
57:09It actually used viruses, lentiviruses.
57:09It actually used viruses, lentiviruses.
57:09It actually used viruses, lentiviruses.
57:09It actually used viruses, lentiviruses.
57:12These are sort of modified HIV viruses to deliver this extra piece of DNA that
57:12These are sort of modified HIV viruses to deliver this extra piece of DNA that
57:12These are sort of modified HIV viruses to deliver this extra piece of DNA that
57:12These are sort of modified HIV viruses to deliver this extra piece of DNA that
57:12These are sort of modified HIV viruses to deliver this extra piece of DNA that
57:17encoded the CAR. And this was done on her cells.
57:17encoded the CAR. And this was done on her cells.
57:17encoded the CAR. And this was done on her cells.
57:17encoded the CAR. And this was done on her cells.
57:17encoded the CAR. And this was done on her cells.
57:21And then after that extra gene was put into the T -cells, the T -cells
57:21And then after that extra gene was put into the T -cells, the T -cells
57:21And then after that extra gene was put into the T -cells, the T -cells
57:21And then after that extra gene was put into the T -cells, the T -cells
57:21And then after that extra gene was put into the T -cells, the T -cells
57:26were re -infused into her body.
57:26were re -infused into her body.
57:26were re -infused into her body.
57:26were re -infused into her body.
57:26were re -infused into her body.
57:29And it was not a straightforward course.
57:29And it was not a straightforward course.
57:29And it was not a straightforward course.
57:29And it was not a straightforward course.
57:29And it was not a straightforward course.
57:32She ended up in the ICU.
57:32She ended up in the ICU.
57:32She ended up in the ICU.
57:32She ended up in the ICU.
57:32She ended up in the ICU.
57:33The immune system had to...
57:33The immune system had to...
57:33The immune system had to...
57:33The immune system had to...
57:33The immune system had to...
57:35In real time, people had to figure out how to control the immune systems and
57:35In real time, people had to figure out how to control the immune systems and
57:35In real time, people had to figure out how to control the immune systems and
57:35In real time, people had to figure out how to control the immune systems and
57:35In real time, people had to figure out how to control the immune systems and
57:38the side effects. But as that was controlled, all of a sudden, her cancer cells
57:38the side effects. But as that was controlled, all of a sudden, her cancer cells
57:38the side effects. But as that was controlled, all of a sudden, her cancer cells
57:38the side effects. But as that was controlled, all of a sudden, her cancer cells
57:38the side effects. But as that was controlled, all of a sudden, her cancer cells
57:43disappeared. Amazing. And the lentivirus itself didn't spark an immune reaction that outweighed the benefits
57:43disappeared. Amazing. And the lentivirus itself didn't spark an immune reaction that outweighed the benefits
57:43disappeared. Amazing. And the lentivirus itself didn't spark an immune reaction that outweighed the benefits
57:43disappeared. Amazing. And the lentivirus itself didn't spark an immune reaction that outweighed the benefits
57:43disappeared. Amazing. And the lentivirus itself didn't spark an immune reaction that outweighed the benefits
57:51of the cargo. No. Amazingly, it really hasn't.
57:51of the cargo. No. Amazingly, it really hasn't.
57:51of the cargo. No. Amazingly, it really hasn't.
57:51of the cargo. No. Amazingly, it really hasn't.
57:51of the cargo. No. Amazingly, it really hasn't.
57:55I mean, there's been some discussion about the risks of using these lentiviruses.
57:55I mean, there's been some discussion about the risks of using these lentiviruses.
57:55I mean, there's been some discussion about the risks of using these lentiviruses.
57:55I mean, there's been some discussion about the risks of using these lentiviruses.
57:55I mean, there's been some discussion about the risks of using these lentiviruses.
57:58And we'll talk in a second about how we could do better now.
57:58And we'll talk in a second about how we could do better now.
57:58And we'll talk in a second about how we could do better now.
57:58And we'll talk in a second about how we could do better now.
57:58And we'll talk in a second about how we could do better now.
58:02Yeah, people are going to hear putting viruses into cells and putting them into humans,
58:02Yeah, people are going to hear putting viruses into cells and putting them into humans,
58:02Yeah, people are going to hear putting viruses into cells and putting them into humans,
58:02Yeah, people are going to hear putting viruses into cells and putting them into humans,
58:02Yeah, people are going to hear putting viruses into cells and putting them into humans,
58:06and a bunch of people will freak out.
58:06and a bunch of people will freak out.
58:06and a bunch of people will freak out.
58:06and a bunch of people will freak out.
58:06and a bunch of people will freak out.
58:07But I promise you that things like adeno, which is like a cold virus, or
58:07But I promise you that things like adeno, which is like a cold virus, or
58:07But I promise you that things like adeno, which is like a cold virus, or
58:07But I promise you that things like adeno, which is like a cold virus, or
58:07But I promise you that things like adeno, which is like a cold virus, or
58:11lenti, which is similar to HIV, and of course, they didn't give her HIV.
58:11lenti, which is similar to HIV, and of course, they didn't give her HIV.
58:11lenti, which is similar to HIV, and of course, they didn't give her HIV.
58:11lenti, which is similar to HIV, and of course, they didn't give her HIV.
58:11lenti, which is similar to HIV, and of course, they didn't give her HIV.
58:15They changed the virus, so they're not delivering HIV.
58:15They changed the virus, so they're not delivering HIV.
58:15They changed the virus, so they're not delivering HIV.
58:15They changed the virus, so they're not delivering HIV.
58:15They changed the virus, so they're not delivering HIV.
58:17These viruses are incredible because they can create long -lasting expression of genes that you
58:17These viruses are incredible because they can create long -lasting expression of genes that you
58:17These viruses are incredible because they can create long -lasting expression of genes that you
58:17These viruses are incredible because they can create long -lasting expression of genes that you
58:17These viruses are incredible because they can create long -lasting expression of genes that you
58:24deliberately put into them. They're a shuttle.
58:24deliberately put into them. They're a shuttle.
58:24deliberately put into them. They're a shuttle.
58:24deliberately put into them. They're a shuttle.
58:24deliberately put into them. They're a shuttle.
58:27It's an amazing application of biological understanding, right?
58:27It's an amazing application of biological understanding, right?
58:27It's an amazing application of biological understanding, right?
58:27It's an amazing application of biological understanding, right?
58:27It's an amazing application of biological understanding, right?
58:30That all of a sudden, we've been studying viruses because of the risk that they
58:30That all of a sudden, we've been studying viruses because of the risk that they
58:30That all of a sudden, we've been studying viruses because of the risk that they
58:30That all of a sudden, we've been studying viruses because of the risk that they
58:30That all of a sudden, we've been studying viruses because of the risk that they
58:33have, but we've learned that they can deliver...
58:33have, but we've learned that they can deliver...
58:33have, but we've learned that they can deliver...
58:33have, but we've learned that they can deliver...
58:33have, but we've learned that they can deliver...
58:35That viruses have evolved to be very good shuttles and to deliver their genetic material
58:35That viruses have evolved to be very good shuttles and to deliver their genetic material
58:35That viruses have evolved to be very good shuttles and to deliver their genetic material
58:35That viruses have evolved to be very good shuttles and to deliver their genetic material
58:35That viruses have evolved to be very good shuttles and to deliver their genetic material
58:41into cells. The way I think of it is the viruses have evolved to take
58:41into cells. The way I think of it is the viruses have evolved to take
58:41into cells. The way I think of it is the viruses have evolved to take
58:41into cells. The way I think of it is the viruses have evolved to take
58:41into cells. The way I think of it is the viruses have evolved to take
58:47advantage of our biology and our genes, and so we did the ultimate touche in
58:47advantage of our biology and our genes, and so we did the ultimate touche in
58:47advantage of our biology and our genes, and so we did the ultimate touche in
58:47advantage of our biology and our genes, and so we did the ultimate touche in
58:47advantage of our biology and our genes, and so we did the ultimate touche in
58:53these instances. Like, you're so good at hijacking our cells' DNA and proliferating, all right,
58:53these instances. Like, you're so good at hijacking our cells' DNA and proliferating, all right,
58:53these instances. Like, you're so good at hijacking our cells' DNA and proliferating, all right,
58:53these instances. Like, you're so good at hijacking our cells' DNA and proliferating, all right,
58:53these instances. Like, you're so good at hijacking our cells' DNA and proliferating, all right,
58:58we'll leverage you to help us as opposed to hurt us, right?
58:58we'll leverage you to help us as opposed to hurt us, right?
58:58we'll leverage you to help us as opposed to hurt us, right?
58:58we'll leverage you to help us as opposed to hurt us, right?
58:58we'll leverage you to help us as opposed to hurt us, right?
59:02That's exactly right. And so that was done in 2012.
59:02That's exactly right. And so that was done in 2012.
59:02That's exactly right. And so that was done in 2012.
59:02That's exactly right. And so that was done in 2012.
59:02That's exactly right. And so that was done in 2012.
59:06Emily Whitehead was eight. It was done as an experimental treatment at the University of
59:06Emily Whitehead was eight. It was done as an experimental treatment at the University of
59:06Emily Whitehead was eight. It was done as an experimental treatment at the University of
59:06Emily Whitehead was eight. It was done as an experimental treatment at the University of
59:06Emily Whitehead was eight. It was done as an experimental treatment at the University of
59:12Pennsylvania, and the story now is that now, all these years later, Emily Whitehead has
59:12Pennsylvania, and the story now is that now, all these years later, Emily Whitehead has
59:12Pennsylvania, and the story now is that now, all these years later, Emily Whitehead has
59:12Pennsylvania, and the story now is that now, all these years later, Emily Whitehead has
59:12Pennsylvania, and the story now is that now, all these years later, Emily Whitehead has
59:18not only cured of her leukemia, she's pre -med at the University of Pennsylvania.
59:18not only cured of her leukemia, she's pre -med at the University of Pennsylvania.
59:18not only cured of her leukemia, she's pre -med at the University of Pennsylvania.
59:18not only cured of her leukemia, she's pre -med at the University of Pennsylvania.
59:18not only cured of her leukemia, she's pre -med at the University of Pennsylvania.
59:22So awesome. So awesome. No one could ignore that.
59:22So awesome. So awesome. No one could ignore that.
59:22So awesome. So awesome. No one could ignore that.
59:22So awesome. So awesome. No one could ignore that.
59:22So awesome. So awesome. No one could ignore that.
59:26You know, this was just all of a sudden this dogma that I had just
59:26You know, this was just all of a sudden this dogma that I had just
59:26You know, this was just all of a sudden this dogma that I had just
59:26You know, this was just all of a sudden this dogma that I had just
59:26You know, this was just all of a sudden this dogma that I had just
59:30been taught a couple of years early in medical school that we should ignore cancer
59:30been taught a couple of years early in medical school that we should ignore cancer
59:30been taught a couple of years early in medical school that we should ignore cancer
59:30been taught a couple of years early in medical school that we should ignore cancer
59:30been taught a couple of years early in medical school that we should ignore cancer
59:33immunotherapy. We were just wrong.
59:33immunotherapy. We were just wrong.
59:33immunotherapy. We were just wrong.
59:33immunotherapy. We were just wrong.
59:33immunotherapy. We were just wrong.
59:36And all of a sudden the field woke up and said, okay, the immune system
59:36And all of a sudden the field woke up and said, okay, the immune system
59:36And all of a sudden the field woke up and said, okay, the immune system
59:36And all of a sudden the field woke up and said, okay, the immune system
59:36And all of a sudden the field woke up and said, okay, the immune system
59:39is not just limited to treating viruses and bacteria, protecting us from viruses and bacteria.
59:39is not just limited to treating viruses and bacteria, protecting us from viruses and bacteria.
59:39is not just limited to treating viruses and bacteria, protecting us from viruses and bacteria.
59:39is not just limited to treating viruses and bacteria, protecting us from viruses and bacteria.
59:39is not just limited to treating viruses and bacteria, protecting us from viruses and bacteria.
59:45The immune system can be exploited and potentially re -engineered to protect us from cancer
59:45The immune system can be exploited and potentially re -engineered to protect us from cancer
59:45The immune system can be exploited and potentially re -engineered to protect us from cancer
59:45The immune system can be exploited and potentially re -engineered to protect us from cancer
59:45The immune system can be exploited and potentially re -engineered to protect us from cancer
59:50and maybe other diseases. So that was 2012.
59:50and maybe other diseases. So that was 2012.
59:50and maybe other diseases. So that was 2012.
59:50and maybe other diseases. So that was 2012.
59:50and maybe other diseases. So that was 2012.
59:552012 also was the year that a paper got published in Science by Emmanuel Sharpa.
59:552012 also was the year that a paper got published in Science by Emmanuel Sharpa.
59:552012 also was the year that a paper got published in Science by Emmanuel Sharpa.
59:552012 also was the year that a paper got published in Science by Emmanuel Sharpa.
59:552012 also was the year that a paper got published in Science by Emmanuel Sharpa.
1:00:01DA and Jennifer Doudna that introduced this new technology called CRISPR.
1:00:01DA and Jennifer Doudna that introduced this new technology called CRISPR.
1:00:01DA and Jennifer Doudna that introduced this new technology called CRISPR.
1:00:01DA and Jennifer Doudna that introduced this new technology called CRISPR.
1:00:01DA and Jennifer Doudna that introduced this new technology called CRISPR.
1:00:06And we'll talk about this, but CRISPR fundamentally is a tool to rewrite DNA sequences.
1:00:06And we'll talk about this, but CRISPR fundamentally is a tool to rewrite DNA sequences.
1:00:06And we'll talk about this, but CRISPR fundamentally is a tool to rewrite DNA sequences.
1:00:06And we'll talk about this, but CRISPR fundamentally is a tool to rewrite DNA sequences.
1:00:06And we'll talk about this, but CRISPR fundamentally is a tool to rewrite DNA sequences.
1:00:14That came out in 2012.
1:00:14That came out in 2012.
1:00:14That came out in 2012.
1:00:14That came out in 2012.
1:00:14That came out in 2012.
1:00:17And on a personal level, 2012 was also the year that I moved to San
1:00:17And on a personal level, 2012 was also the year that I moved to San
1:00:17And on a personal level, 2012 was also the year that I moved to San
1:00:17And on a personal level, 2012 was also the year that I moved to San
1:00:17And on a personal level, 2012 was also the year that I moved to San
1:00:21Francisco to start a lab studying T -cells and how genetics influences T -cells.
1:00:21Francisco to start a lab studying T -cells and how genetics influences T -cells.
1:00:21Francisco to start a lab studying T -cells and how genetics influences T -cells.
1:00:21Francisco to start a lab studying T -cells and how genetics influences T -cells.
1:00:21Francisco to start a lab studying T -cells and how genetics influences T -cells.
1:00:27I was looking around and trying to figure out what my lab would do.
1:00:27I was looking around and trying to figure out what my lab would do.
1:00:27I was looking around and trying to figure out what my lab would do.
1:00:27I was looking around and trying to figure out what my lab would do.
1:00:27I was looking around and trying to figure out what my lab would do.
1:00:30And all of a sudden, I was arriving with an empty lab space at exactly
1:00:30And all of a sudden, I was arriving with an empty lab space at exactly
1:00:30And all of a sudden, I was arriving with an empty lab space at exactly
1:00:30And all of a sudden, I was arriving with an empty lab space at exactly
1:00:30And all of a sudden, I was arriving with an empty lab space at exactly
1:00:34the same moment that the world was shown that T -cells could cure cancer and
1:00:34the same moment that the world was shown that T -cells could cure cancer and
1:00:34the same moment that the world was shown that T -cells could cure cancer and
1:00:34the same moment that the world was shown that T -cells could cure cancer and
1:00:34the same moment that the world was shown that T -cells could cure cancer and
1:00:40that we had a tool that could potentially rewrite DNA sequences and that we wouldn't
1:00:40that we had a tool that could potentially rewrite DNA sequences and that we wouldn't
1:00:40that we had a tool that could potentially rewrite DNA sequences and that we wouldn't
1:00:40that we had a tool that could potentially rewrite DNA sequences and that we wouldn't
1:00:40that we had a tool that could potentially rewrite DNA sequences and that we wouldn't
1:00:44be limited to these lentiviruses, which are kind of clunky, the best tools we had
1:00:44be limited to these lentiviruses, which are kind of clunky, the best tools we had
1:00:44be limited to these lentiviruses, which are kind of clunky, the best tools we had
1:00:44be limited to these lentiviruses, which are kind of clunky, the best tools we had
1:00:44be limited to these lentiviruses, which are kind of clunky, the best tools we had
1:00:48at the time, but pretty clunky and non -precise in how they insert genetic material.
1:00:48at the time, but pretty clunky and non -precise in how they insert genetic material.
1:00:48at the time, but pretty clunky and non -precise in how they insert genetic material.
1:00:48at the time, but pretty clunky and non -precise in how they insert genetic material.
1:00:48at the time, but pretty clunky and non -precise in how they insert genetic material.
1:00:52All of a sudden, we could imagine that we could take T -cells and use
1:00:52All of a sudden, we could imagine that we could take T -cells and use
1:00:52All of a sudden, we could imagine that we could take T -cells and use
1:00:52All of a sudden, we could imagine that we could take T -cells and use
1:00:52All of a sudden, we could imagine that we could take T -cells and use
1:00:55CRISPR to actually pick individual places in the genome and make targeted changes to program
1:00:55CRISPR to actually pick individual places in the genome and make targeted changes to program
1:00:55CRISPR to actually pick individual places in the genome and make targeted changes to program
1:00:55CRISPR to actually pick individual places in the genome and make targeted changes to program
1:00:55CRISPR to actually pick individual places in the genome and make targeted changes to program
1:01:02exactly how cells behave. And that is the basis for my ongoing work.
1:01:02exactly how cells behave. And that is the basis for my ongoing work.
1:01:02exactly how cells behave. And that is the basis for my ongoing work.
1:01:02exactly how cells behave. And that is the basis for my ongoing work.
1:01:02exactly how cells behave. And that is the basis for my ongoing work.
1:01:07We've put a lot of work over the years into being able to now take
1:01:07We've put a lot of work over the years into being able to now take
1:01:07We've put a lot of work over the years into being able to now take
1:01:07We've put a lot of work over the years into being able to now take
1:01:07We've put a lot of work over the years into being able to now take
1:01:11CRISPR technology, get it to work in T -cells, to learn the rules about what
1:01:11CRISPR technology, get it to work in T -cells, to learn the rules about what
1:01:11CRISPR technology, get it to work in T -cells, to learn the rules about what
1:01:11CRISPR technology, get it to work in T -cells, to learn the rules about what
1:01:11CRISPR technology, get it to work in T -cells, to learn the rules about what
1:01:16are the genetic changes that will be most effective at making T -cells into immunotherapies
1:01:16are the genetic changes that will be most effective at making T -cells into immunotherapies
1:01:16are the genetic changes that will be most effective at making T -cells into immunotherapies
1:01:16are the genetic changes that will be most effective at making T -cells into immunotherapies
1:01:16are the genetic changes that will be most effective at making T -cells into immunotherapies
1:01:24that cure patients with different diseases.
1:01:24that cure patients with different diseases.
1:01:24that cure patients with different diseases.
1:01:24that cure patients with different diseases.
1:01:24that cure patients with different diseases.
1:01:26And then to go all the way and then actually use CRISPR to make T
1:01:26And then to go all the way and then actually use CRISPR to make T
1:01:26And then to go all the way and then actually use CRISPR to make T
1:01:26And then to go all the way and then actually use CRISPR to make T
1:01:26And then to go all the way and then actually use CRISPR to make T
1:01:31-cells that can be put into patients with new levels of precision and power.
1:01:31-cells that can be put into patients with new levels of precision and power.
1:01:31-cells that can be put into patients with new levels of precision and power.
1:01:31-cells that can be put into patients with new levels of precision and power.
1:01:31-cells that can be put into patients with new levels of precision and power.
1:01:37And that's in clinical trials now.
1:01:37And that's in clinical trials now.
1:01:37And that's in clinical trials now.
1:01:37And that's in clinical trials now.
1:01:37And that's in clinical trials now.
1:01:39We're now in clinical trials with these CRISPR -engineered CAR T -cells.
1:01:39We're now in clinical trials with these CRISPR -engineered CAR T -cells.
1:01:39We're now in clinical trials with these CRISPR -engineered CAR T -cells.
1:01:39We're now in clinical trials with these CRISPR -engineered CAR T -cells.
1:01:39We're now in clinical trials with these CRISPR -engineered CAR T -cells.
1:01:43And we're not just going after leukemias, where these CAR T -cells have historically worked,
1:01:43And we're not just going after leukemias, where these CAR T -cells have historically worked,
1:01:43And we're not just going after leukemias, where these CAR T -cells have historically worked,
1:01:43And we're not just going after leukemias, where these CAR T -cells have historically worked,
1:01:43And we're not just going after leukemias, where these CAR T -cells have historically worked,
1:01:49but we're also thinking about can we make these work for the really common causes
1:01:49but we're also thinking about can we make these work for the really common causes
1:01:49but we're also thinking about can we make these work for the really common causes
1:01:49but we're also thinking about can we make these work for the really common causes
1:01:49but we're also thinking about can we make these work for the really common causes
1:01:55of cancer deaths, solid tumors.
1:01:55of cancer deaths, solid tumors.
1:01:55of cancer deaths, solid tumors.
1:01:55of cancer deaths, solid tumors.
1:01:55of cancer deaths, solid tumors.
1:01:58And that's been a challenge, and we can talk about that.
1:01:58And that's been a challenge, and we can talk about that.
1:01:58And that's been a challenge, and we can talk about that.
1:01:58And that's been a challenge, and we can talk about that.
1:01:58And that's been a challenge, and we can talk about that.
1:02:01But getting T -cells to find the right targets in tumors and then work inside
1:02:01But getting T -cells to find the right targets in tumors and then work inside
1:02:01But getting T -cells to find the right targets in tumors and then work inside
1:02:01But getting T -cells to find the right targets in tumors and then work inside
1:02:01But getting T -cells to find the right targets in tumors and then work inside
1:02:05of tumor environments, which are inherently immunosuppressive, requires figuring out additional gene edits that are
1:02:05of tumor environments, which are inherently immunosuppressive, requires figuring out additional gene edits that are
1:02:05of tumor environments, which are inherently immunosuppressive, requires figuring out additional gene edits that are
1:02:05of tumor environments, which are inherently immunosuppressive, requires figuring out additional gene edits that are
1:02:05of tumor environments, which are inherently immunosuppressive, requires figuring out additional gene edits that are
1:02:12now possible with CRISPR to try to beat the cancer at its own game.
1:02:12now possible with CRISPR to try to beat the cancer at its own game.
1:02:12now possible with CRISPR to try to beat the cancer at its own game.
1:02:12now possible with CRISPR to try to beat the cancer at its own game.
1:02:12now possible with CRISPR to try to beat the cancer at its own game.
1:02:16If cancer is evolving to make itself cloaked from the immune system, now with CRISPR
1:02:16If cancer is evolving to make itself cloaked from the immune system, now with CRISPR
1:02:16If cancer is evolving to make itself cloaked from the immune system, now with CRISPR
1:02:16If cancer is evolving to make itself cloaked from the immune system, now with CRISPR
1:02:16If cancer is evolving to make itself cloaked from the immune system, now with CRISPR
1:02:21we can think about getting one step ahead and making T -cells that are able
1:02:21we can think about getting one step ahead and making T -cells that are able
1:02:21we can think about getting one step ahead and making T -cells that are able
1:02:21we can think about getting one step ahead and making T -cells that are able
1:02:21we can think about getting one step ahead and making T -cells that are able
1:02:24to resist all the tricks that cancers throw at it to be more, and I
1:02:24to resist all the tricks that cancers throw at it to be more, and I
1:02:24to resist all the tricks that cancers throw at it to be more, and I
1:02:24to resist all the tricks that cancers throw at it to be more, and I
1:02:24to resist all the tricks that cancers throw at it to be more, and I
1:02:29think we're on the brink of having precise CRISPR -engineered cells that will, I hope,
1:02:29think we're on the brink of having precise CRISPR -engineered cells that will, I hope,
1:02:29think we're on the brink of having precise CRISPR -engineered cells that will, I hope,
1:02:29think we're on the brink of having precise CRISPR -engineered cells that will, I hope,
1:02:29think we're on the brink of having precise CRISPR -engineered cells that will, I hope,
1:02:36start to melt away cancers without the side effects of chemotherapy.
1:02:36start to melt away cancers without the side effects of chemotherapy.
1:02:36start to melt away cancers without the side effects of chemotherapy.
1:02:36start to melt away cancers without the side effects of chemotherapy.
1:02:36start to melt away cancers without the side effects of chemotherapy.
1:02:40Amazing. Just amazing. And the story of this young woman is spectacular.
1:02:40Amazing. Just amazing. And the story of this young woman is spectacular.
1:02:40Amazing. Just amazing. And the story of this young woman is spectacular.
1:02:40Amazing. Just amazing. And the story of this young woman is spectacular.
1:02:40Amazing. Just amazing. And the story of this young woman is spectacular.
1:02:48I have two questions before we talk about CRISPR technology.
1:02:48I have two questions before we talk about CRISPR technology.
1:02:48I have two questions before we talk about CRISPR technology.
1:02:48I have two questions before we talk about CRISPR technology.
1:02:48I have two questions before we talk about CRISPR technology.
1:02:51The first one is, is it true, I believe it is, but is it true
1:02:51The first one is, is it true, I believe it is, but is it true
1:02:51The first one is, is it true, I believe it is, but is it true
1:02:51The first one is, is it true, I believe it is, but is it true
1:02:51The first one is, is it true, I believe it is, but is it true
1:02:55that cancer risk goes up as we get older?
1:02:55that cancer risk goes up as we get older?
1:02:55that cancer risk goes up as we get older?
1:02:55that cancer risk goes up as we get older?
1:02:55that cancer risk goes up as we get older?
1:02:59And if so, why? So that's the first question.
1:02:59And if so, why? So that's the first question.
1:02:59And if so, why? So that's the first question.
1:02:59And if so, why? So that's the first question.
1:02:59And if so, why? So that's the first question.
1:03:04And then the other question has to do with how the immunotherapy that you described
1:03:04And then the other question has to do with how the immunotherapy that you described
1:03:04And then the other question has to do with how the immunotherapy that you described
1:03:04And then the other question has to do with how the immunotherapy that you described
1:03:04And then the other question has to do with how the immunotherapy that you described
1:03:12was able to target the cancer and not cause problems elsewhere, which is kind of
1:03:12was able to target the cancer and not cause problems elsewhere, which is kind of
1:03:12was able to target the cancer and not cause problems elsewhere, which is kind of
1:03:12was able to target the cancer and not cause problems elsewhere, which is kind of
1:03:12was able to target the cancer and not cause problems elsewhere, which is kind of
1:03:16the major issue of chemo and radiation therapy.
1:03:16the major issue of chemo and radiation therapy.
1:03:16the major issue of chemo and radiation therapy.
1:03:16the major issue of chemo and radiation therapy.
1:03:16the major issue of chemo and radiation therapy.
1:03:19But the first question, again, was, you know, why more mutations as we get older?
1:03:19But the first question, again, was, you know, why more mutations as we get older?
1:03:19But the first question, again, was, you know, why more mutations as we get older?
1:03:19But the first question, again, was, you know, why more mutations as we get older?
1:03:19But the first question, again, was, you know, why more mutations as we get older?
1:03:24So I think there's a few cancers that peak in childhood and there's risk as
1:03:24So I think there's a few cancers that peak in childhood and there's risk as
1:03:24So I think there's a few cancers that peak in childhood and there's risk as
1:03:24So I think there's a few cancers that peak in childhood and there's risk as
1:03:24So I think there's a few cancers that peak in childhood and there's risk as
1:03:29the body's developing of certain cancer, childhood cancers, and there's childhood leukemias, for example, and
1:03:29the body's developing of certain cancer, childhood cancers, and there's childhood leukemias, for example, and
1:03:29the body's developing of certain cancer, childhood cancers, and there's childhood leukemias, for example, and
1:03:29the body's developing of certain cancer, childhood cancers, and there's childhood leukemias, for example, and
1:03:29the body's developing of certain cancer, childhood cancers, and there's childhood leukemias, for example, and
1:03:35that's like when we talk about Emily Whitehead.
1:03:35that's like when we talk about Emily Whitehead.
1:03:35that's like when we talk about Emily Whitehead.
1:03:35that's like when we talk about Emily Whitehead.
1:03:35that's like when we talk about Emily Whitehead.
1:03:37But most cancers, as you said, exactly as you said, that there's this sort of
1:03:37But most cancers, as you said, exactly as you said, that there's this sort of
1:03:37But most cancers, as you said, exactly as you said, that there's this sort of
1:03:37But most cancers, as you said, exactly as you said, that there's this sort of
1:03:37But most cancers, as you said, exactly as you said, that there's this sort of
1:03:41increase and they're largely disease of later stages of life.
1:03:41increase and they're largely disease of later stages of life.
1:03:41increase and they're largely disease of later stages of life.
1:03:41increase and they're largely disease of later stages of life.
1:03:41increase and they're largely disease of later stages of life.
1:03:45I think that the reason for that is, remember when we talked about what causes
1:03:45I think that the reason for that is, remember when we talked about what causes
1:03:45I think that the reason for that is, remember when we talked about what causes
1:03:45I think that the reason for that is, remember when we talked about what causes
1:03:45I think that the reason for that is, remember when we talked about what causes
1:03:49cancer, it's this evolution where certain cells start to accumulate mutations.
1:03:49cancer, it's this evolution where certain cells start to accumulate mutations.
1:03:49cancer, it's this evolution where certain cells start to accumulate mutations.
1:03:49cancer, it's this evolution where certain cells start to accumulate mutations.
1:03:49cancer, it's this evolution where certain cells start to accumulate mutations.
1:03:55Numerically, a lot of the cells that have the mutations will die off and it's
1:03:55Numerically, a lot of the cells that have the mutations will die off and it's
1:03:55Numerically, a lot of the cells that have the mutations will die off and it's
1:03:55Numerically, a lot of the cells that have the mutations will die off and it's
1:03:55Numerically, a lot of the cells that have the mutations will die off and it's
1:03:58just a game that unfolds over time.
1:03:58just a game that unfolds over time.
1:03:58just a game that unfolds over time.
1:03:58just a game that unfolds over time.
1:03:58just a game that unfolds over time.
1:04:00And the more time you have cells dividing and sticking around in the body, they're
1:04:00And the more time you have cells dividing and sticking around in the body, they're
1:04:00And the more time you have cells dividing and sticking around in the body, they're
1:04:00And the more time you have cells dividing and sticking around in the body, they're
1:04:00And the more time you have cells dividing and sticking around in the body, they're
1:04:04accumulating more damage and eventually you're more likely that that damage would actually transform the
1:04:04accumulating more damage and eventually you're more likely that that damage would actually transform the
1:04:04accumulating more damage and eventually you're more likely that that damage would actually transform the
1:04:04accumulating more damage and eventually you're more likely that that damage would actually transform the
1:04:04accumulating more damage and eventually you're more likely that that damage would actually transform the
1:04:09cells into a cancer cell.
1:04:09cells into a cancer cell.
1:04:09cells into a cancer cell.
1:04:09cells into a cancer cell.
1:04:09cells into a cancer cell.
1:04:10So time is a big factor here, time and just accumulated damage.
1:04:10So time is a big factor here, time and just accumulated damage.
1:04:10So time is a big factor here, time and just accumulated damage.
1:04:10So time is a big factor here, time and just accumulated damage.
1:04:10So time is a big factor here, time and just accumulated damage.
1:04:16And the other question was, you know, how is it that the lentiviral cargo -carrying
1:04:16And the other question was, you know, how is it that the lentiviral cargo -carrying
1:04:16And the other question was, you know, how is it that the lentiviral cargo -carrying
1:04:16And the other question was, you know, how is it that the lentiviral cargo -carrying
1:04:16And the other question was, you know, how is it that the lentiviral cargo -carrying
1:04:25T cells know to attack the cancer and not something else?
1:04:25T cells know to attack the cancer and not something else?
1:04:25T cells know to attack the cancer and not something else?
1:04:25T cells know to attack the cancer and not something else?
1:04:25T cells know to attack the cancer and not something else?
1:04:31So this is a key question for the field, right?
1:04:31So this is a key question for the field, right?
1:04:31So this is a key question for the field, right?
1:04:31So this is a key question for the field, right?
1:04:31So this is a key question for the field, right?
1:04:34And I think one of the things that worked incredibly well was a brilliant choice
1:04:34And I think one of the things that worked incredibly well was a brilliant choice
1:04:34And I think one of the things that worked incredibly well was a brilliant choice
1:04:34And I think one of the things that worked incredibly well was a brilliant choice
1:04:34And I think one of the things that worked incredibly well was a brilliant choice
1:04:39by a group of scientists in a few different places that converged on the target
1:04:39by a group of scientists in a few different places that converged on the target
1:04:39by a group of scientists in a few different places that converged on the target
1:04:39by a group of scientists in a few different places that converged on the target
1:04:39by a group of scientists in a few different places that converged on the target
1:04:43that was used in the first CAR T cell.
1:04:43that was used in the first CAR T cell.
1:04:43that was used in the first CAR T cell.
1:04:43that was used in the first CAR T cell.
1:04:43that was used in the first CAR T cell.
1:04:45And what the target is known as is a protein called CD19.
1:04:45And what the target is known as is a protein called CD19.
1:04:45And what the target is known as is a protein called CD19.
1:04:45And what the target is known as is a protein called CD19.
1:04:45And what the target is known as is a protein called CD19.
1:04:51That's just the name of this thing that's found on a lot of different types
1:04:51That's just the name of this thing that's found on a lot of different types
1:04:51That's just the name of this thing that's found on a lot of different types
1:04:51That's just the name of this thing that's found on a lot of different types
1:04:51That's just the name of this thing that's found on a lot of different types
1:04:56of B cells. So this brings us back to this discussion.
1:04:56of B cells. So this brings us back to this discussion.
1:04:56of B cells. So this brings us back to this discussion.
1:04:56of B cells. So this brings us back to this discussion.
1:04:56of B cells. So this brings us back to this discussion.
1:04:59The leukemias themselves are a cancer of the immune cells, so they're a cancer of
1:04:59The leukemias themselves are a cancer of the immune cells, so they're a cancer of
1:04:59The leukemias themselves are a cancer of the immune cells, so they're a cancer of
1:04:59The leukemias themselves are a cancer of the immune cells, so they're a cancer of
1:04:59The leukemias themselves are a cancer of the immune cells, so they're a cancer of
1:05:05B cells. And CD19 is found on the surface of many, a large number of
1:05:05B cells. And CD19 is found on the surface of many, a large number of
1:05:05B cells. And CD19 is found on the surface of many, a large number of
1:05:05B cells. And CD19 is found on the surface of many, a large number of
1:05:05B cells. And CD19 is found on the surface of many, a large number of
1:05:12different types of B cell leukemias and lymphomas.
1:05:12different types of B cell leukemias and lymphomas.
1:05:12different types of B cell leukemias and lymphomas.
1:05:12different types of B cell leukemias and lymphomas.
1:05:12different types of B cell leukemias and lymphomas.
1:05:15I see. I think one of the things that turns out to be serendipitous here
1:05:15I see. I think one of the things that turns out to be serendipitous here
1:05:15I see. I think one of the things that turns out to be serendipitous here
1:05:15I see. I think one of the things that turns out to be serendipitous here
1:05:15I see. I think one of the things that turns out to be serendipitous here
1:05:19is that B cells themselves, natural, healthy B cells, actually also have CD19 on their
1:05:19is that B cells themselves, natural, healthy B cells, actually also have CD19 on their
1:05:19is that B cells themselves, natural, healthy B cells, actually also have CD19 on their
1:05:19is that B cells themselves, natural, healthy B cells, actually also have CD19 on their
1:05:19is that B cells themselves, natural, healthy B cells, actually also have CD19 on their
1:05:25surface. What just turns out to be serendipitous is...
1:05:25surface. What just turns out to be serendipitous is...
1:05:25surface. What just turns out to be serendipitous is...
1:05:25surface. What just turns out to be serendipitous is...
1:05:25surface. What just turns out to be serendipitous is...
1:05:28that the body can tolerate those cells going away.
1:05:28that the body can tolerate those cells going away.
1:05:28that the body can tolerate those cells going away.
1:05:28that the body can tolerate those cells going away.
1:05:28that the body can tolerate those cells going away.
1:05:31And so what has made this a particularly effective and safe and relatively well -tolerated
1:05:31And so what has made this a particularly effective and safe and relatively well -tolerated
1:05:31And so what has made this a particularly effective and safe and relatively well -tolerated
1:05:31And so what has made this a particularly effective and safe and relatively well -tolerated
1:05:31And so what has made this a particularly effective and safe and relatively well -tolerated
1:05:38treatment for cancer is that the collateral damage is actually not that damaging.
1:05:38treatment for cancer is that the collateral damage is actually not that damaging.
1:05:38treatment for cancer is that the collateral damage is actually not that damaging.
1:05:38treatment for cancer is that the collateral damage is actually not that damaging.
1:05:38treatment for cancer is that the collateral damage is actually not that damaging.
1:05:43That T cells in this case are not strictly distinguishing between cancer and health.
1:05:43That T cells in this case are not strictly distinguishing between cancer and health.
1:05:43That T cells in this case are not strictly distinguishing between cancer and health.
1:05:43That T cells in this case are not strictly distinguishing between cancer and health.
1:05:43That T cells in this case are not strictly distinguishing between cancer and health.
1:05:48They're not just getting the leukemia cells, they are getting collateral B cells.
1:05:48They're not just getting the leukemia cells, they are getting collateral B cells.
1:05:48They're not just getting the leukemia cells, they are getting collateral B cells.
1:05:48They're not just getting the leukemia cells, they are getting collateral B cells.
1:05:48They're not just getting the leukemia cells, they are getting collateral B cells.
1:05:52But by and large, to a first approximation, people can live without those cells.
1:05:52But by and large, to a first approximation, people can live without those cells.
1:05:52But by and large, to a first approximation, people can live without those cells.
1:05:52But by and large, to a first approximation, people can live without those cells.
1:05:52But by and large, to a first approximation, people can live without those cells.
1:05:56And so that side effect has just been tolerable.
1:05:56And so that side effect has just been tolerable.
1:05:56And so that side effect has just been tolerable.
1:05:56And so that side effect has just been tolerable.
1:05:56And so that side effect has just been tolerable.
1:06:01Finding that balance gets harder and harder for more cancers.
1:06:01Finding that balance gets harder and harder for more cancers.
1:06:01Finding that balance gets harder and harder for more cancers.
1:06:01Finding that balance gets harder and harder for more cancers.
1:06:01Finding that balance gets harder and harder for more cancers.
1:06:05If you start to think about pancreatic cancer or brain cancer, finding targets that if
1:06:05If you start to think about pancreatic cancer or brain cancer, finding targets that if
1:06:05If you start to think about pancreatic cancer or brain cancer, finding targets that if
1:06:05If you start to think about pancreatic cancer or brain cancer, finding targets that if
1:06:05If you start to think about pancreatic cancer or brain cancer, finding targets that if
1:06:12you hit the healthy pancreas or the healthy brain are not toxic, it's harder and
1:06:12you hit the healthy pancreas or the healthy brain are not toxic, it's harder and
1:06:12you hit the healthy pancreas or the healthy brain are not toxic, it's harder and
1:06:12you hit the healthy pancreas or the healthy brain are not toxic, it's harder and
1:06:12you hit the healthy pancreas or the healthy brain are not toxic, it's harder and
1:06:18harder. So people are thinking about more and more sophisticated ways to look for these
1:06:18harder. So people are thinking about more and more sophisticated ways to look for these
1:06:18harder. So people are thinking about more and more sophisticated ways to look for these
1:06:18harder. So people are thinking about more and more sophisticated ways to look for these
1:06:18harder. So people are thinking about more and more sophisticated ways to look for these
1:06:23targets that are selectively found on the cancer cell and not on the healthy cell,
1:06:23targets that are selectively found on the cancer cell and not on the healthy cell,
1:06:23targets that are selectively found on the cancer cell and not on the healthy cell,
1:06:23targets that are selectively found on the cancer cell and not on the healthy cell,
1:06:23targets that are selectively found on the cancer cell and not on the healthy cell,
1:06:27or to think about ways that you might actually make the cell depend on recognizing
1:06:27or to think about ways that you might actually make the cell depend on recognizing
1:06:27or to think about ways that you might actually make the cell depend on recognizing
1:06:27or to think about ways that you might actually make the cell depend on recognizing
1:06:27or to think about ways that you might actually make the cell depend on recognizing
1:06:32multiple features so that you can have what's sometimes talked about as like a two
1:06:32multiple features so that you can have what's sometimes talked about as like a two
1:06:32multiple features so that you can have what's sometimes talked about as like a two
1:06:32multiple features so that you can have what's sometimes talked about as like a two
1:06:32multiple features so that you can have what's sometimes talked about as like a two
1:06:36-factor authentication. Like the T cell will only kill cancer if it finds this and
1:06:36-factor authentication. Like the T cell will only kill cancer if it finds this and
1:06:36-factor authentication. Like the T cell will only kill cancer if it finds this and
1:06:36-factor authentication. Like the T cell will only kill cancer if it finds this and
1:06:36-factor authentication. Like the T cell will only kill cancer if it finds this and
1:06:41this, and that combination of things are not found on healthy cells, even if one
1:06:41this, and that combination of things are not found on healthy cells, even if one
1:06:41this, and that combination of things are not found on healthy cells, even if one
1:06:41this, and that combination of things are not found on healthy cells, even if one
1:06:41this, and that combination of things are not found on healthy cells, even if one
1:06:46or the other might be.
1:06:46or the other might be.
1:06:46or the other might be.
1:06:46or the other might be.
1:06:46or the other might be.
1:06:47So people are thinking about how do we get more sophisticated about building these discrimination
1:06:47So people are thinking about how do we get more sophisticated about building these discrimination
1:06:47So people are thinking about how do we get more sophisticated about building these discrimination
1:06:47So people are thinking about how do we get more sophisticated about building these discrimination
1:06:47So people are thinking about how do we get more sophisticated about building these discrimination
1:06:53systems into T cells. The building blocks are there, but the specifics for each cancer
1:06:53systems into T cells. The building blocks are there, but the specifics for each cancer
1:06:53systems into T cells. The building blocks are there, but the specifics for each cancer
1:06:53systems into T cells. The building blocks are there, but the specifics for each cancer
1:06:53systems into T cells. The building blocks are there, but the specifics for each cancer
1:06:58have to be invented. But we have the tools to do that.
1:06:58have to be invented. But we have the tools to do that.
1:06:58have to be invented. But we have the tools to do that.
1:06:58have to be invented. But we have the tools to do that.
1:06:58have to be invented. But we have the tools to do that.
1:07:02Awesome. Before we talk about CRISPR, there was one other question that I know many
1:07:02Awesome. Before we talk about CRISPR, there was one other question that I know many
1:07:02Awesome. Before we talk about CRISPR, there was one other question that I know many
1:07:02Awesome. Before we talk about CRISPR, there was one other question that I know many
1:07:02Awesome. Before we talk about CRISPR, there was one other question that I know many
1:07:06people will be thinking about.
1:07:06people will be thinking about.
1:07:06people will be thinking about.
1:07:06people will be thinking about.
1:07:06people will be thinking about.
1:07:07A few years back, maybe five, ten years back, there was a lot of discussion,
1:07:07A few years back, maybe five, ten years back, there was a lot of discussion,
1:07:07A few years back, maybe five, ten years back, there was a lot of discussion,
1:07:07A few years back, maybe five, ten years back, there was a lot of discussion,
1:07:07A few years back, maybe five, ten years back, there was a lot of discussion,
1:07:12maybe even some enthusiasm, about ketogenic diets to treat or prevent cancer.
1:07:12maybe even some enthusiasm, about ketogenic diets to treat or prevent cancer.
1:07:12maybe even some enthusiasm, about ketogenic diets to treat or prevent cancer.
1:07:12maybe even some enthusiasm, about ketogenic diets to treat or prevent cancer.
1:07:12maybe even some enthusiasm, about ketogenic diets to treat or prevent cancer.
1:07:18And my understanding from looking at that literature was that for some cancers, it perhaps,
1:07:18And my understanding from looking at that literature was that for some cancers, it perhaps,
1:07:18And my understanding from looking at that literature was that for some cancers, it perhaps,
1:07:18And my understanding from looking at that literature was that for some cancers, it perhaps,
1:07:18And my understanding from looking at that literature was that for some cancers, it perhaps,
1:07:25I want to bold underline and capitalize perhaps, might help.
1:07:25I want to bold underline and capitalize perhaps, might help.
1:07:25I want to bold underline and capitalize perhaps, might help.
1:07:25I want to bold underline and capitalize perhaps, might help.
1:07:25I want to bold underline and capitalize perhaps, might help.
1:07:31But for other cancers, it could make things worse.
1:07:31But for other cancers, it could make things worse.
1:07:31But for other cancers, it could make things worse.
1:07:31But for other cancers, it could make things worse.
1:07:31But for other cancers, it could make things worse.
1:07:34And then I also more recently started hearing about low glutamine diets.
1:07:34And then I also more recently started hearing about low glutamine diets.
1:07:34And then I also more recently started hearing about low glutamine diets.
1:07:34And then I also more recently started hearing about low glutamine diets.
1:07:34And then I also more recently started hearing about low glutamine diets.
1:07:40And, of course, this is the way the internet works.
1:07:40And, of course, this is the way the internet works.
1:07:40And, of course, this is the way the internet works.
1:07:40And, of course, this is the way the internet works.
1:07:40And, of course, this is the way the internet works.
1:07:42But I did see some papers in some decent journals that at least were exploring
1:07:42But I did see some papers in some decent journals that at least were exploring
1:07:42But I did see some papers in some decent journals that at least were exploring
1:07:42But I did see some papers in some decent journals that at least were exploring
1:07:42But I did see some papers in some decent journals that at least were exploring
1:07:49this. So are low, they're just low, let's call it what they are, ketogenic diets,
1:07:49this. So are low, they're just low, let's call it what they are, ketogenic diets,
1:07:49this. So are low, they're just low, let's call it what they are, ketogenic diets,
1:07:49this. So are low, they're just low, let's call it what they are, ketogenic diets,
1:07:49this. So are low, they're just low, let's call it what they are, ketogenic diets,
1:07:56have they been shown to be useful for treatment or avoidance of cancer?
1:07:56have they been shown to be useful for treatment or avoidance of cancer?
1:07:56have they been shown to be useful for treatment or avoidance of cancer?
1:07:56have they been shown to be useful for treatment or avoidance of cancer?
1:07:56have they been shown to be useful for treatment or avoidance of cancer?
1:08:00I have to defer to you.
1:08:00I have to defer to you.
1:08:00I have to defer to you.
1:08:00I have to defer to you.
1:08:00I have to defer to you.
1:08:01Actually, I don't know the answer to that.
1:08:01Actually, I don't know the answer to that.
1:08:01Actually, I don't know the answer to that.
1:08:01Actually, I don't know the answer to that.
1:08:01Actually, I don't know the answer to that.
1:08:02Yeah. Okay. My guess is that people are still looking at this.
1:08:02Yeah. Okay. My guess is that people are still looking at this.
1:08:02Yeah. Okay. My guess is that people are still looking at this.
1:08:02Yeah. Okay. My guess is that people are still looking at this.
1:08:02Yeah. Okay. My guess is that people are still looking at this.
1:08:05But, you know, there was also the idea that they could be useful for certain
1:08:05But, you know, there was also the idea that they could be useful for certain
1:08:05But, you know, there was also the idea that they could be useful for certain
1:08:05But, you know, there was also the idea that they could be useful for certain
1:08:05But, you know, there was also the idea that they could be useful for certain
1:08:09forms of dementia. There was an effort to call dementia, you know, type 3 diabetes.
1:08:09forms of dementia. There was an effort to call dementia, you know, type 3 diabetes.
1:08:09forms of dementia. There was an effort to call dementia, you know, type 3 diabetes.
1:08:09forms of dementia. There was an effort to call dementia, you know, type 3 diabetes.
1:08:09forms of dementia. There was an effort to call dementia, you know, type 3 diabetes.
1:08:13But my understanding from talking to the experts in this is that it might help
1:08:13But my understanding from talking to the experts in this is that it might help
1:08:13But my understanding from talking to the experts in this is that it might help
1:08:13But my understanding from talking to the experts in this is that it might help
1:08:13But my understanding from talking to the experts in this is that it might help
1:08:17through indirect mechanisms, but that it's not going to solve the problem.
1:08:17through indirect mechanisms, but that it's not going to solve the problem.
1:08:17through indirect mechanisms, but that it's not going to solve the problem.
1:08:17through indirect mechanisms, but that it's not going to solve the problem.
1:08:17through indirect mechanisms, but that it's not going to solve the problem.
1:08:21Okay. Well, thanks for entertaining that little cul -de -sac that I created.
1:08:21Okay. Well, thanks for entertaining that little cul -de -sac that I created.
1:08:21Okay. Well, thanks for entertaining that little cul -de -sac that I created.
1:08:21Okay. Well, thanks for entertaining that little cul -de -sac that I created.
1:08:21Okay. Well, thanks for entertaining that little cul -de -sac that I created.
1:08:27CRISPR. Tell us the story of CRISPR.
1:08:27CRISPR. Tell us the story of CRISPR.
1:08:27CRISPR. Tell us the story of CRISPR.
1:08:27CRISPR. Tell us the story of CRISPR.
1:08:27CRISPR. Tell us the story of CRISPR.
1:08:30Because I think CRISPR is one of those funny things in biology and medicine that
1:08:30Because I think CRISPR is one of those funny things in biology and medicine that
1:08:30Because I think CRISPR is one of those funny things in biology and medicine that
1:08:30Because I think CRISPR is one of those funny things in biology and medicine that
1:08:30Because I think CRISPR is one of those funny things in biology and medicine that
1:08:35almost everybody has heard about in the general population.
1:08:35almost everybody has heard about in the general population.
1:08:35almost everybody has heard about in the general population.
1:08:35almost everybody has heard about in the general population.
1:08:35almost everybody has heard about in the general population.
1:08:39Most people know it has something to do with changing genes, but it's sort of
1:08:39Most people know it has something to do with changing genes, but it's sort of
1:08:39Most people know it has something to do with changing genes, but it's sort of
1:08:39Most people know it has something to do with changing genes, but it's sort of
1:08:39Most people know it has something to do with changing genes, but it's sort of
1:08:43like AI. Yeah. It's here.
1:08:43like AI. Yeah. It's here.
1:08:43like AI. Yeah. It's here.
1:08:43like AI. Yeah. It's here.
1:08:43like AI. Yeah. It's here.
1:08:46It's powerful. It scares certain people.
1:08:46It's powerful. It scares certain people.
1:08:46It's powerful. It scares certain people.
1:08:46It's powerful. It scares certain people.
1:08:46It's powerful. It scares certain people.
1:08:49It excites other people. But most people don't know how it works because there's really
1:08:49It excites other people. But most people don't know how it works because there's really
1:08:49It excites other people. But most people don't know how it works because there's really
1:08:49It excites other people. But most people don't know how it works because there's really
1:08:49It excites other people. But most people don't know how it works because there's really
1:08:55no incentive to. But I think the story of CRISPR is actually also a story
1:08:55no incentive to. But I think the story of CRISPR is actually also a story
1:08:55no incentive to. But I think the story of CRISPR is actually also a story
1:08:55no incentive to. But I think the story of CRISPR is actually also a story
1:08:55no incentive to. But I think the story of CRISPR is actually also a story
1:09:00about how science works. Yeah.
1:09:00about how science works. Yeah.
1:09:00about how science works. Yeah.
1:09:00about how science works. Yeah.
1:09:00about how science works. Yeah.
1:09:03And that's important too. I think it's exactly true.
1:09:03And that's important too. I think it's exactly true.
1:09:03And that's important too. I think it's exactly true.
1:09:03And that's important too. I think it's exactly true.
1:09:03And that's important too. I think it's exactly true.
1:09:07I think it is a perfect illustration of something where a discovery happened that no
1:09:07I think it is a perfect illustration of something where a discovery happened that no
1:09:07I think it is a perfect illustration of something where a discovery happened that no
1:09:07I think it is a perfect illustration of something where a discovery happened that no
1:09:07I think it is a perfect illustration of something where a discovery happened that no
1:09:14one was planning but changed biology.
1:09:14one was planning but changed biology.
1:09:14one was planning but changed biology.
1:09:14one was planning but changed biology.
1:09:14one was planning but changed biology.
1:09:19Let me tell you this story in two separate arcs.
1:09:19Let me tell you this story in two separate arcs.
1:09:19Let me tell you this story in two separate arcs.
1:09:19Let me tell you this story in two separate arcs.
1:09:19Let me tell you this story in two separate arcs.
1:09:21One arc is the arc of understanding DNA.
1:09:21One arc is the arc of understanding DNA.
1:09:21One arc is the arc of understanding DNA.
1:09:21One arc is the arc of understanding DNA.
1:09:21One arc is the arc of understanding DNA.
1:09:24You know, if you go back to Watson and Crick, it's understanding the double helix
1:09:24You know, if you go back to Watson and Crick, it's understanding the double helix
1:09:24You know, if you go back to Watson and Crick, it's understanding the double helix
1:09:24You know, if you go back to Watson and Crick, it's understanding the double helix
1:09:24You know, if you go back to Watson and Crick, it's understanding the double helix
1:09:28to understand the structure of what a DNA sequence is.
1:09:28to understand the structure of what a DNA sequence is.
1:09:28to understand the structure of what a DNA sequence is.
1:09:28to understand the structure of what a DNA sequence is.
1:09:28to understand the structure of what a DNA sequence is.
1:09:32That matures. We've learned how to sequence, to understand, to be able to measure a
1:09:32That matures. We've learned how to sequence, to understand, to be able to measure a
1:09:32That matures. We've learned how to sequence, to understand, to be able to measure a
1:09:32That matures. We've learned how to sequence, to understand, to be able to measure a
1:09:32That matures. We've learned how to sequence, to understand, to be able to measure a
1:09:38row of ATs and Cs and Gs that in whatever combination they are will start
1:09:38row of ATs and Cs and Gs that in whatever combination they are will start
1:09:38row of ATs and Cs and Gs that in whatever combination they are will start
1:09:38row of ATs and Cs and Gs that in whatever combination they are will start
1:09:38row of ATs and Cs and Gs that in whatever combination they are will start
1:09:42to be the building blocks for programming, which proteins get made inside a cell.
1:09:42to be the building blocks for programming, which proteins get made inside a cell.
1:09:42to be the building blocks for programming, which proteins get made inside a cell.
1:09:42to be the building blocks for programming, which proteins get made inside a cell.
1:09:42to be the building blocks for programming, which proteins get made inside a cell.
1:09:47And then around 2000 we get to the first draft of the human genome, which
1:09:47And then around 2000 we get to the first draft of the human genome, which
1:09:47And then around 2000 we get to the first draft of the human genome, which
1:09:47And then around 2000 we get to the first draft of the human genome, which
1:09:47And then around 2000 we get to the first draft of the human genome, which
1:09:52is this multi -billion dollar project across the world to come up with a draft
1:09:52is this multi -billion dollar project across the world to come up with a draft
1:09:52is this multi -billion dollar project across the world to come up with a draft
1:09:52is this multi -billion dollar project across the world to come up with a draft
1:09:52is this multi -billion dollar project across the world to come up with a draft
1:09:57of one human genome sequence, a milestone for biology and medicine.
1:09:57of one human genome sequence, a milestone for biology and medicine.
1:09:57of one human genome sequence, a milestone for biology and medicine.
1:09:57of one human genome sequence, a milestone for biology and medicine.
1:09:57of one human genome sequence, a milestone for biology and medicine.
1:10:03And then DNA sequencing technologies continue to improve and cost comes down.
1:10:03And then DNA sequencing technologies continue to improve and cost comes down.
1:10:03And then DNA sequencing technologies continue to improve and cost comes down.
1:10:03And then DNA sequencing technologies continue to improve and cost comes down.
1:10:03And then DNA sequencing technologies continue to improve and cost comes down.
1:10:08And we're getting to the point where we can start to measure big chunks of
1:10:08And we're getting to the point where we can start to measure big chunks of
1:10:08And we're getting to the point where we can start to measure big chunks of
1:10:08And we're getting to the point where we can start to measure big chunks of
1:10:08And we're getting to the point where we can start to measure big chunks of
1:10:12our DNA at increasingly affordable costs.
1:10:12our DNA at increasingly affordable costs.
1:10:12our DNA at increasingly affordable costs.
1:10:12our DNA at increasingly affordable costs.
1:10:12our DNA at increasingly affordable costs.
1:10:16And people, we're starting to understand the differences between people with DNA at the level
1:10:16And people, we're starting to understand the differences between people with DNA at the level
1:10:16And people, we're starting to understand the differences between people with DNA at the level
1:10:16And people, we're starting to understand the differences between people with DNA at the level
1:10:16And people, we're starting to understand the differences between people with DNA at the level
1:10:21of at least statistics. Okay, people with this disease are more likely to have this
1:10:21of at least statistics. Okay, people with this disease are more likely to have this
1:10:21of at least statistics. Okay, people with this disease are more likely to have this
1:10:21of at least statistics. Okay, people with this disease are more likely to have this
1:10:21of at least statistics. Okay, people with this disease are more likely to have this
1:10:26gene than that. But we're getting to some limit of what we can do just
1:10:26gene than that. But we're getting to some limit of what we can do just
1:10:26gene than that. But we're getting to some limit of what we can do just
1:10:26gene than that. But we're getting to some limit of what we can do just
1:10:26gene than that. But we're getting to some limit of what we can do just
1:10:31by sequencing DNA. All of a sudden you're observing the DNA sequence that's in someone's
1:10:31by sequencing DNA. All of a sudden you're observing the DNA sequence that's in someone's
1:10:31by sequencing DNA. All of a sudden you're observing the DNA sequence that's in someone's
1:10:31by sequencing DNA. All of a sudden you're observing the DNA sequence that's in someone's
1:10:31by sequencing DNA. All of a sudden you're observing the DNA sequence that's in someone's
1:10:36cells but you don't really know what those effects are.
1:10:36cells but you don't really know what those effects are.
1:10:36cells but you don't really know what those effects are.
1:10:36cells but you don't really know what those effects are.
1:10:36cells but you don't really know what those effects are.
1:10:40Just as the sequencing world is maturing, we're desperately looking for a tool to say,
1:10:40Just as the sequencing world is maturing, we're desperately looking for a tool to say,
1:10:40Just as the sequencing world is maturing, we're desperately looking for a tool to say,
1:10:40Just as the sequencing world is maturing, we're desperately looking for a tool to say,
1:10:40Just as the sequencing world is maturing, we're desperately looking for a tool to say,
1:10:46well, now we want to, as we have all the sequences, we want to be
1:10:46well, now we want to, as we have all the sequences, we want to be
1:10:46well, now we want to, as we have all the sequences, we want to be
1:10:46well, now we want to, as we have all the sequences, we want to be
1:10:46well, now we want to, as we have all the sequences, we want to be
1:10:49able to see what happens if you change a sequence.
1:10:49able to see what happens if you change a sequence.
1:10:49able to see what happens if you change a sequence.
1:10:49able to see what happens if you change a sequence.
1:10:49able to see what happens if you change a sequence.
1:10:52And people were stumbling around looking for different...
1:10:52And people were stumbling around looking for different...
1:10:52And people were stumbling around looking for different...
1:10:52And people were stumbling around looking for different...
1:10:52And people were stumbling around looking for different...
1:10:56tools, there was a range of these things.
1:10:56tools, there was a range of these things.
1:10:56tools, there was a range of these things.
1:10:56tools, there was a range of these things.
1:10:56tools, there was a range of these things.
1:10:59There were zinc fingers, lentivirus was another one that we just talked about with different
1:10:59There were zinc fingers, lentivirus was another one that we just talked about with different
1:10:59There were zinc fingers, lentivirus was another one that we just talked about with different
1:10:59There were zinc fingers, lentivirus was another one that we just talked about with different
1:10:59There were zinc fingers, lentivirus was another one that we just talked about with different
1:11:05degrees of efficiency and people were trying to be able to change DNA sequences in
1:11:05degrees of efficiency and people were trying to be able to change DNA sequences in
1:11:05degrees of efficiency and people were trying to be able to change DNA sequences in
1:11:05degrees of efficiency and people were trying to be able to change DNA sequences in
1:11:05degrees of efficiency and people were trying to be able to change DNA sequences in
1:11:11cells and it had been a long -standing effort.
1:11:11cells and it had been a long -standing effort.
1:11:11cells and it had been a long -standing effort.
1:11:11cells and it had been a long -standing effort.
1:11:11cells and it had been a long -standing effort.
1:11:15Out of nowhere emerges CRISPR as the answer to this problem.
1:11:15Out of nowhere emerges CRISPR as the answer to this problem.
1:11:15Out of nowhere emerges CRISPR as the answer to this problem.
1:11:15Out of nowhere emerges CRISPR as the answer to this problem.
1:11:15Out of nowhere emerges CRISPR as the answer to this problem.
1:11:20CRISPR was being studied as an interesting and unusual set of DNA sequences that were
1:11:20CRISPR was being studied as an interesting and unusual set of DNA sequences that were
1:11:20CRISPR was being studied as an interesting and unusual set of DNA sequences that were
1:11:20CRISPR was being studied as an interesting and unusual set of DNA sequences that were
1:11:20CRISPR was being studied as an interesting and unusual set of DNA sequences that were
1:11:29found in certain types of bacteria.
1:11:29found in certain types of bacteria.
1:11:29found in certain types of bacteria.
1:11:29found in certain types of bacteria.
1:11:29found in certain types of bacteria.
1:11:31There were these repeated sequences and no one knew what they were.
1:11:31There were these repeated sequences and no one knew what they were.
1:11:31There were these repeated sequences and no one knew what they were.
1:11:31There were these repeated sequences and no one knew what they were.
1:11:31There were these repeated sequences and no one knew what they were.
1:11:35And people out of real basic curiosity about what was happening in bacteria started studying
1:11:35And people out of real basic curiosity about what was happening in bacteria started studying
1:11:35And people out of real basic curiosity about what was happening in bacteria started studying
1:11:35And people out of real basic curiosity about what was happening in bacteria started studying
1:11:35And people out of real basic curiosity about what was happening in bacteria started studying
1:11:40these repeat sequences and what they were doing.
1:11:40these repeat sequences and what they were doing.
1:11:40these repeat sequences and what they were doing.
1:11:40these repeat sequences and what they were doing.
1:11:40these repeat sequences and what they were doing.
1:11:43And little by little by little it was worked out that these repeat sequences actually
1:11:43And little by little by little it was worked out that these repeat sequences actually
1:11:43And little by little by little it was worked out that these repeat sequences actually
1:11:43And little by little by little it was worked out that these repeat sequences actually
1:11:43And little by little by little it was worked out that these repeat sequences actually
1:11:49formed the basis of a kind of immune system for bacteria.
1:11:49formed the basis of a kind of immune system for bacteria.
1:11:49formed the basis of a kind of immune system for bacteria.
1:11:49formed the basis of a kind of immune system for bacteria.
1:11:49formed the basis of a kind of immune system for bacteria.
1:11:53Now we talked about the human immune system.
1:11:53Now we talked about the human immune system.
1:11:53Now we talked about the human immune system.
1:11:53Now we talked about the human immune system.
1:11:53Now we talked about the human immune system.
1:11:56Bacteria are just an individual cell but they're also susceptible to infections which is sort
1:11:56Bacteria are just an individual cell but they're also susceptible to infections which is sort
1:11:56Bacteria are just an individual cell but they're also susceptible to infections which is sort
1:11:56Bacteria are just an individual cell but they're also susceptible to infections which is sort
1:11:56Bacteria are just an individual cell but they're also susceptible to infections which is sort
1:12:01of a strange idea. Bacteria cause infections in us but there's this arms race between
1:12:01of a strange idea. Bacteria cause infections in us but there's this arms race between
1:12:01of a strange idea. Bacteria cause infections in us but there's this arms race between
1:12:01of a strange idea. Bacteria cause infections in us but there's this arms race between
1:12:01of a strange idea. Bacteria cause infections in us but there's this arms race between
1:12:05organisms. Everyone's trying to kill everyone else.
1:12:05organisms. Everyone's trying to kill everyone else.
1:12:05organisms. Everyone's trying to kill everyone else.
1:12:05organisms. Everyone's trying to kill everyone else.
1:12:05organisms. Everyone's trying to kill everyone else.
1:12:07And so bacteria are constantly being bombarded by certain types of viruses.
1:12:07And so bacteria are constantly being bombarded by certain types of viruses.
1:12:07And so bacteria are constantly being bombarded by certain types of viruses.
1:12:07And so bacteria are constantly being bombarded by certain types of viruses.
1:12:07And so bacteria are constantly being bombarded by certain types of viruses.
1:12:12They're called bacteriophage viruses. And they've evolved a series of, bacteria have evolved a series
1:12:12They're called bacteriophage viruses. And they've evolved a series of, bacteria have evolved a series
1:12:12They're called bacteriophage viruses. And they've evolved a series of, bacteria have evolved a series
1:12:12They're called bacteriophage viruses. And they've evolved a series of, bacteria have evolved a series
1:12:12They're called bacteriophage viruses. And they've evolved a series of, bacteria have evolved a series
1:12:20of defense mechanisms to protect themselves from these viruses.
1:12:20of defense mechanisms to protect themselves from these viruses.
1:12:20of defense mechanisms to protect themselves from these viruses.
1:12:20of defense mechanisms to protect themselves from these viruses.
1:12:20of defense mechanisms to protect themselves from these viruses.
1:12:24CRISPR turns out to be a bacterial defense mechanism against viruses.
1:12:24CRISPR turns out to be a bacterial defense mechanism against viruses.
1:12:24CRISPR turns out to be a bacterial defense mechanism against viruses.
1:12:24CRISPR turns out to be a bacterial defense mechanism against viruses.
1:12:24CRISPR turns out to be a bacterial defense mechanism against viruses.
1:12:29It's kind of amazing that this thing that has entered into popular culture is a
1:12:29It's kind of amazing that this thing that has entered into popular culture is a
1:12:29It's kind of amazing that this thing that has entered into popular culture is a
1:12:29It's kind of amazing that this thing that has entered into popular culture is a
1:12:29It's kind of amazing that this thing that has entered into popular culture is a
1:12:34bacteria protection against bacteriophage. Now why has this caught the world of biology by storm?
1:12:34bacteria protection against bacteriophage. Now why has this caught the world of biology by storm?
1:12:34bacteria protection against bacteriophage. Now why has this caught the world of biology by storm?
1:12:34bacteria protection against bacteriophage. Now why has this caught the world of biology by storm?
1:12:34bacteria protection against bacteriophage. Now why has this caught the world of biology by storm?
1:12:41Well what was realized was that the way that CRISPR works to protect bacteria from
1:12:41Well what was realized was that the way that CRISPR works to protect bacteria from
1:12:41Well what was realized was that the way that CRISPR works to protect bacteria from
1:12:41Well what was realized was that the way that CRISPR works to protect bacteria from
1:12:41Well what was realized was that the way that CRISPR works to protect bacteria from
1:12:51viruses is that it can recognize particular sequences of DNA which are virus sequences and
1:12:51viruses is that it can recognize particular sequences of DNA which are virus sequences and
1:12:51viruses is that it can recognize particular sequences of DNA which are virus sequences and
1:12:51viruses is that it can recognize particular sequences of DNA which are virus sequences and
1:12:51viruses is that it can recognize particular sequences of DNA which are virus sequences and
1:12:58discriminate whether it's a virus sequence or its own bacteria sequence.
1:12:58discriminate whether it's a virus sequence or its own bacteria sequence.
1:12:58discriminate whether it's a virus sequence or its own bacteria sequence.
1:12:58discriminate whether it's a virus sequence or its own bacteria sequence.
1:12:58discriminate whether it's a virus sequence or its own bacteria sequence.
1:13:03And it actually does that by scanning across the DNA and finding something that's recognized
1:13:03And it actually does that by scanning across the DNA and finding something that's recognized
1:13:03And it actually does that by scanning across the DNA and finding something that's recognized
1:13:03And it actually does that by scanning across the DNA and finding something that's recognized
1:13:03And it actually does that by scanning across the DNA and finding something that's recognized
1:13:10as a virus target and not a bacteria target.
1:13:10as a virus target and not a bacteria target.
1:13:10as a virus target and not a bacteria target.
1:13:10as a virus target and not a bacteria target.
1:13:10as a virus target and not a bacteria target.
1:13:13And when it finds it, it makes a cut.
1:13:13And when it finds it, it makes a cut.
1:13:13And when it finds it, it makes a cut.
1:13:13And when it finds it, it makes a cut.
1:13:13And when it finds it, it makes a cut.
1:13:17Okay. Now this sounds technical, obscure, but what was recognized, and this became the basis
1:13:17Okay. Now this sounds technical, obscure, but what was recognized, and this became the basis
1:13:17Okay. Now this sounds technical, obscure, but what was recognized, and this became the basis
1:13:17Okay. Now this sounds technical, obscure, but what was recognized, and this became the basis
1:13:17Okay. Now this sounds technical, obscure, but what was recognized, and this became the basis
1:13:25for a Nobel Prize with Jennifer Doudna and Emmanuel Charpentier, many people around the world
1:13:25for a Nobel Prize with Jennifer Doudna and Emmanuel Charpentier, many people around the world
1:13:25for a Nobel Prize with Jennifer Doudna and Emmanuel Charpentier, many people around the world
1:13:25for a Nobel Prize with Jennifer Doudna and Emmanuel Charpentier, many people around the world
1:13:25for a Nobel Prize with Jennifer Doudna and Emmanuel Charpentier, many people around the world
1:13:31have contributed to this field.
1:13:31have contributed to this field.
1:13:31have contributed to this field.
1:13:31have contributed to this field.
1:13:31have contributed to this field.
1:13:34What was realized was that this could be repurposed as a tool.
1:13:34What was realized was that this could be repurposed as a tool.
1:13:34What was realized was that this could be repurposed as a tool.
1:13:34What was realized was that this could be repurposed as a tool.
1:13:34What was realized was that this could be repurposed as a tool.
1:13:39If we take it out of bacteria, we could actually exploit this CRISPR system that
1:13:39If we take it out of bacteria, we could actually exploit this CRISPR system that
1:13:39If we take it out of bacteria, we could actually exploit this CRISPR system that
1:13:39If we take it out of bacteria, we could actually exploit this CRISPR system that
1:13:39If we take it out of bacteria, we could actually exploit this CRISPR system that
1:13:44had evolved to protect bacteria.
1:13:44had evolved to protect bacteria.
1:13:44had evolved to protect bacteria.
1:13:44had evolved to protect bacteria.
1:13:44had evolved to protect bacteria.
1:13:45And the same rules that allowed bacteria to scan across DNA and find a virus
1:13:45And the same rules that allowed bacteria to scan across DNA and find a virus
1:13:45And the same rules that allowed bacteria to scan across DNA and find a virus
1:13:45And the same rules that allowed bacteria to scan across DNA and find a virus
1:13:45And the same rules that allowed bacteria to scan across DNA and find a virus
1:13:52sequence and cut it could be used to scan across any DNA and cut at
1:13:52sequence and cut it could be used to scan across any DNA and cut at
1:13:52sequence and cut it could be used to scan across any DNA and cut at
1:13:52sequence and cut it could be used to scan across any DNA and cut at
1:13:52sequence and cut it could be used to scan across any DNA and cut at
1:13:57a particular sequence. That's the power of CRISPR.
1:13:57a particular sequence. That's the power of CRISPR.
1:13:57a particular sequence. That's the power of CRISPR.
1:13:57a particular sequence. That's the power of CRISPR.
1:13:57a particular sequence. That's the power of CRISPR.
1:14:01Now why do we care so much about being able to cut a particular sequence?
1:14:01Now why do we care so much about being able to cut a particular sequence?
1:14:01Now why do we care so much about being able to cut a particular sequence?
1:14:01Now why do we care so much about being able to cut a particular sequence?
1:14:01Now why do we care so much about being able to cut a particular sequence?
1:14:04If you can cut, you can also start pasting.
1:14:04If you can cut, you can also start pasting.
1:14:04If you can cut, you can also start pasting.
1:14:04If you can cut, you can also start pasting.
1:14:04If you can cut, you can also start pasting.
1:14:06You can cut out genes that are limiting, that you don't want to be in
1:14:06You can cut out genes that are limiting, that you don't want to be in
1:14:06You can cut out genes that are limiting, that you don't want to be in
1:14:06You can cut out genes that are limiting, that you don't want to be in
1:14:06You can cut out genes that are limiting, that you don't want to be in
1:14:10a cell. You can start pasting in sequences to replace mutations that cause disease.
1:14:10a cell. You can start pasting in sequences to replace mutations that cause disease.
1:14:10a cell. You can start pasting in sequences to replace mutations that cause disease.
1:14:10a cell. You can start pasting in sequences to replace mutations that cause disease.
1:14:10a cell. You can start pasting in sequences to replace mutations that cause disease.
1:14:16We can start pasting in big sequences like the sequence for cars or other types
1:14:16We can start pasting in big sequences like the sequence for cars or other types
1:14:16We can start pasting in big sequences like the sequence for cars or other types
1:14:16We can start pasting in big sequences like the sequence for cars or other types
1:14:16We can start pasting in big sequences like the sequence for cars or other types
1:14:21of things that will make T cells more powerful.
1:14:21of things that will make T cells more powerful.
1:14:21of things that will make T cells more powerful.
1:14:21of things that will make T cells more powerful.
1:14:21of things that will make T cells more powerful.
1:14:23So, and this is, I'm focused on T cells, but this is now in every
1:14:23So, and this is, I'm focused on T cells, but this is now in every
1:14:23So, and this is, I'm focused on T cells, but this is now in every
1:14:23So, and this is, I'm focused on T cells, but this is now in every
1:14:23So, and this is, I'm focused on T cells, but this is now in every
1:14:28aspect of biology. People are studying this in plants and to make crops that will
1:14:28aspect of biology. People are studying this in plants and to make crops that will
1:14:28aspect of biology. People are studying this in plants and to make crops that will
1:14:28aspect of biology. People are studying this in plants and to make crops that will
1:14:28aspect of biology. People are studying this in plants and to make crops that will
1:14:34be drought resistant. People are studying this in every organ system to understand every type
1:14:34be drought resistant. People are studying this in every organ system to understand every type
1:14:34be drought resistant. People are studying this in every organ system to understand every type
1:14:34be drought resistant. People are studying this in every organ system to understand every type
1:14:34be drought resistant. People are studying this in every organ system to understand every type
1:14:40of disease and to build new types of molecular medicines.
1:14:40of disease and to build new types of molecular medicines.
1:14:40of disease and to build new types of molecular medicines.
1:14:40of disease and to build new types of molecular medicines.
1:14:40of disease and to build new types of molecular medicines.
1:14:45There's one other feature of CRISPR that's really important in this story.
1:14:45There's one other feature of CRISPR that's really important in this story.
1:14:45There's one other feature of CRISPR that's really important in this story.
1:14:45There's one other feature of CRISPR that's really important in this story.
1:14:45There's one other feature of CRISPR that's really important in this story.
1:14:48It's not just that this CRISPR can cut at a specific sequence, that it's evolved
1:14:48It's not just that this CRISPR can cut at a specific sequence, that it's evolved
1:14:48It's not just that this CRISPR can cut at a specific sequence, that it's evolved
1:14:48It's not just that this CRISPR can cut at a specific sequence, that it's evolved
1:14:48It's not just that this CRISPR can cut at a specific sequence, that it's evolved
1:14:53to cut at virus sequence.
1:14:53to cut at virus sequence.
1:14:53to cut at virus sequence.
1:14:53to cut at virus sequence.
1:14:53to cut at virus sequence.
1:14:54It's the way that it cuts that has made it really catch on in a
1:14:54It's the way that it cuts that has made it really catch on in a
1:14:54It's the way that it cuts that has made it really catch on in a
1:14:54It's the way that it cuts that has made it really catch on in a
1:14:54It's the way that it cuts that has made it really catch on in a
1:14:58way that none of these earlier technologies do.
1:14:58way that none of these earlier technologies do.
1:14:58way that none of these earlier technologies do.
1:14:58way that none of these earlier technologies do.
1:14:58way that none of these earlier technologies do.
1:15:00So, CRISPR, if you think of it as an enzyme that can cut DNA and
1:15:00So, CRISPR, if you think of it as an enzyme that can cut DNA and
1:15:00So, CRISPR, if you think of it as an enzyme that can cut DNA and
1:15:00So, CRISPR, if you think of it as an enzyme that can cut DNA and
1:15:00So, CRISPR, if you think of it as an enzyme that can cut DNA and
1:15:07it can cut essentially almost any sequence of DNA.
1:15:07it can cut essentially almost any sequence of DNA.
1:15:07it can cut essentially almost any sequence of DNA.
1:15:07it can cut essentially almost any sequence of DNA.
1:15:07it can cut essentially almost any sequence of DNA.
1:15:10So, how does it decide which sequence to cut?
1:15:10So, how does it decide which sequence to cut?
1:15:10So, how does it decide which sequence to cut?
1:15:10So, how does it decide which sequence to cut?
1:15:10So, how does it decide which sequence to cut?
1:15:14It does it by actually pairing with an RNA molecule.
1:15:14It does it by actually pairing with an RNA molecule.
1:15:14It does it by actually pairing with an RNA molecule.
1:15:14It does it by actually pairing with an RNA molecule.
1:15:14It does it by actually pairing with an RNA molecule.
1:15:18So, CRISPR, sometimes called Cas9, which is a particular type of CRISPR system, is a
1:15:18So, CRISPR, sometimes called Cas9, which is a particular type of CRISPR system, is a
1:15:18So, CRISPR, sometimes called Cas9, which is a particular type of CRISPR system, is a
1:15:18So, CRISPR, sometimes called Cas9, which is a particular type of CRISPR system, is a
1:15:18So, CRISPR, sometimes called Cas9, which is a particular type of CRISPR system, is a
1:15:26combination of a protein, which is a scissor, and then an RNA that sticks to
1:15:26combination of a protein, which is a scissor, and then an RNA that sticks to
1:15:26combination of a protein, which is a scissor, and then an RNA that sticks to
1:15:26combination of a protein, which is a scissor, and then an RNA that sticks to
1:15:26combination of a protein, which is a scissor, and then an RNA that sticks to
1:15:31it. And the RNA is what actually programs where that scissor will cut.
1:15:31it. And the RNA is what actually programs where that scissor will cut.
1:15:31it. And the RNA is what actually programs where that scissor will cut.
1:15:31it. And the RNA is what actually programs where that scissor will cut.
1:15:31it. And the RNA is what actually programs where that scissor will cut.
1:15:37Okay, so this, and what's so special about that is that we actually know with
1:15:37Okay, so this, and what's so special about that is that we actually know with
1:15:37Okay, so this, and what's so special about that is that we actually know with
1:15:37Okay, so this, and what's so special about that is that we actually know with
1:15:37Okay, so this, and what's so special about that is that we actually know with
1:15:42perfect, near perfect precision, the rules of how an RNA will recognize any DNA sequence.
1:15:42perfect, near perfect precision, the rules of how an RNA will recognize any DNA sequence.
1:15:42perfect, near perfect precision, the rules of how an RNA will recognize any DNA sequence.
1:15:42perfect, near perfect precision, the rules of how an RNA will recognize any DNA sequence.
1:15:42perfect, near perfect precision, the rules of how an RNA will recognize any DNA sequence.
1:15:50There's a complementarity where you can match up and know exactly which RNA you want
1:15:50There's a complementarity where you can match up and know exactly which RNA you want
1:15:50There's a complementarity where you can match up and know exactly which RNA you want
1:15:50There's a complementarity where you can match up and know exactly which RNA you want
1:15:50There's a complementarity where you can match up and know exactly which RNA you want
1:15:56to design. So, you can now cut DNA sequences at will.
1:15:56to design. So, you can now cut DNA sequences at will.
1:15:56to design. So, you can now cut DNA sequences at will.
1:15:56to design. So, you can now cut DNA sequences at will.
1:15:56to design. So, you can now cut DNA sequences at will.
1:16:00And it's gotten to the point where now, if we want to cut a piece
1:16:00And it's gotten to the point where now, if we want to cut a piece
1:16:00And it's gotten to the point where now, if we want to cut a piece
1:16:00And it's gotten to the point where now, if we want to cut a piece
1:16:00And it's gotten to the point where now, if we want to cut a piece
1:16:03of DNA, we order a piece of RNA off the internet, it shows up in
1:16:03of DNA, we order a piece of RNA off the internet, it shows up in
1:16:03of DNA, we order a piece of RNA off the internet, it shows up in
1:16:03of DNA, we order a piece of RNA off the internet, it shows up in
1:16:03of DNA, we order a piece of RNA off the internet, it shows up in
1:16:09the lab in a matter of days, we mix it with Cas9 protein, and then
1:16:09the lab in a matter of days, we mix it with Cas9 protein, and then
1:16:09the lab in a matter of days, we mix it with Cas9 protein, and then
1:16:09the lab in a matter of days, we mix it with Cas9 protein, and then
1:16:09the lab in a matter of days, we mix it with Cas9 protein, and then
1:16:14that's going in T cells the next day, and we're able to introduce a cut
1:16:14that's going in T cells the next day, and we're able to introduce a cut
1:16:14that's going in T cells the next day, and we're able to introduce a cut
1:16:14that's going in T cells the next day, and we're able to introduce a cut
1:16:14that's going in T cells the next day, and we're able to introduce a cut
1:16:18into any DNA sequence. So, now you go back to the genome sequence that was...
1:16:18into any DNA sequence. So, now you go back to the genome sequence that was...
1:16:18into any DNA sequence. So, now you go back to the genome sequence that was...
1:16:18into any DNA sequence. So, now you go back to the genome sequence that was...
1:16:18into any DNA sequence. So, now you go back to the genome sequence that was...
1:16:24It came out in 2010 and all of a sudden you can go on the
1:16:24It came out in 2010 and all of a sudden you can go on the
1:16:24It came out in 2010 and all of a sudden you can go on the
1:16:24It came out in 2010 and all of a sudden you can go on the
1:16:24It came out in 2010 and all of a sudden you can go on the
1:16:26internet, pick a place in the genome that you're interested in studying, order a piece
1:16:26internet, pick a place in the genome that you're interested in studying, order a piece
1:16:26internet, pick a place in the genome that you're interested in studying, order a piece
1:16:26internet, pick a place in the genome that you're interested in studying, order a piece
1:16:26internet, pick a place in the genome that you're interested in studying, order a piece
1:16:31of RNA, make your targeted CRISPR molecule, and make a cut or a cut and
1:16:31of RNA, make your targeted CRISPR molecule, and make a cut or a cut and
1:16:31of RNA, make your targeted CRISPR molecule, and make a cut or a cut and
1:16:31of RNA, make your targeted CRISPR molecule, and make a cut or a cut and
1:16:31of RNA, make your targeted CRISPR molecule, and make a cut or a cut and
1:16:36a paste at that particular site.
1:16:36a paste at that particular site.
1:16:36a paste at that particular site.
1:16:36a paste at that particular site.
1:16:36a paste at that particular site.
1:16:38And then in a very tangible way, read out the consequences.
1:16:38And then in a very tangible way, read out the consequences.
1:16:38And then in a very tangible way, read out the consequences.
1:16:38And then in a very tangible way, read out the consequences.
1:16:38And then in a very tangible way, read out the consequences.
1:16:42You're going into the source code of DNA inside of a cell and when you
1:16:42You're going into the source code of DNA inside of a cell and when you
1:16:42You're going into the source code of DNA inside of a cell and when you
1:16:42You're going into the source code of DNA inside of a cell and when you
1:16:42You're going into the source code of DNA inside of a cell and when you
1:16:47make that change, you can say, what happens to the cell?
1:16:47make that change, you can say, what happens to the cell?
1:16:47make that change, you can say, what happens to the cell?
1:16:47make that change, you can say, what happens to the cell?
1:16:47make that change, you can say, what happens to the cell?
1:16:51Is it a stronger response?
1:16:51Is it a stronger response?
1:16:51Is it a stronger response?
1:16:51Is it a stronger response?
1:16:51Is it a stronger response?
1:16:53Is it a different response?
1:16:53Is it a different response?
1:16:53Is it a different response?
1:16:53Is it a different response?
1:16:53Is it a different response?
1:16:54We can test it in test tubes, we can test it in models of disease,
1:16:54We can test it in test tubes, we can test it in models of disease,
1:16:54We can test it in test tubes, we can test it in models of disease,
1:16:54We can test it in test tubes, we can test it in models of disease,
1:16:54We can test it in test tubes, we can test it in models of disease,
1:16:58and then as we learn the rules, we can actually take those CRISPR -modified cells
1:16:58and then as we learn the rules, we can actually take those CRISPR -modified cells
1:16:58and then as we learn the rules, we can actually take those CRISPR -modified cells
1:16:58and then as we learn the rules, we can actually take those CRISPR -modified cells
1:16:58and then as we learn the rules, we can actually take those CRISPR -modified cells
1:17:03all the way and infuse them into patients.
1:17:03all the way and infuse them into patients.
1:17:03all the way and infuse them into patients.
1:17:03all the way and infuse them into patients.
1:17:03all the way and infuse them into patients.
1:17:07Incredible, and thank you for that incredibly clear and detailed explanation of the CRISPR -Cas9
1:17:07Incredible, and thank you for that incredibly clear and detailed explanation of the CRISPR -Cas9
1:17:07Incredible, and thank you for that incredibly clear and detailed explanation of the CRISPR -Cas9
1:17:07Incredible, and thank you for that incredibly clear and detailed explanation of the CRISPR -Cas9
1:17:07Incredible, and thank you for that incredibly clear and detailed explanation of the CRISPR -Cas9
1:17:14system. A couple of questions.
1:17:14system. A couple of questions.
1:17:14system. A couple of questions.
1:17:14system. A couple of questions.
1:17:14system. A couple of questions.
1:17:16How precise is the cut?
1:17:16How precise is the cut?
1:17:16How precise is the cut?
1:17:16How precise is the cut?
1:17:16How precise is the cut?
1:17:18Are you damaging adjacent nucleotides or can you home in exactly on the site that
1:17:18Are you damaging adjacent nucleotides or can you home in exactly on the site that
1:17:18Are you damaging adjacent nucleotides or can you home in exactly on the site that
1:17:18Are you damaging adjacent nucleotides or can you home in exactly on the site that
1:17:18Are you damaging adjacent nucleotides or can you home in exactly on the site that
1:17:26you want to cut? And then the related question is, if you're going to introduce
1:17:26you want to cut? And then the related question is, if you're going to introduce
1:17:26you want to cut? And then the related question is, if you're going to introduce
1:17:26you want to cut? And then the related question is, if you're going to introduce
1:17:26you want to cut? And then the related question is, if you're going to introduce
1:17:30a gene sequence there, how do you ensure that there aren't downstream effects?
1:17:30a gene sequence there, how do you ensure that there aren't downstream effects?
1:17:30a gene sequence there, how do you ensure that there aren't downstream effects?
1:17:30a gene sequence there, how do you ensure that there aren't downstream effects?
1:17:30a gene sequence there, how do you ensure that there aren't downstream effects?
1:17:37I mean, I think what you're getting at with both these questions are unintended consequences,
1:17:37I mean, I think what you're getting at with both these questions are unintended consequences,
1:17:37I mean, I think what you're getting at with both these questions are unintended consequences,
1:17:37I mean, I think what you're getting at with both these questions are unintended consequences,
1:17:37I mean, I think what you're getting at with both these questions are unintended consequences,
1:17:41and that's always present, right?
1:17:41and that's always present, right?
1:17:41and that's always present, right?
1:17:41and that's always present, right?
1:17:41and that's always present, right?
1:17:44I think this has been a major concerted effort for the field of CRISPR, of
1:17:44I think this has been a major concerted effort for the field of CRISPR, of
1:17:44I think this has been a major concerted effort for the field of CRISPR, of
1:17:44I think this has been a major concerted effort for the field of CRISPR, of
1:17:44I think this has been a major concerted effort for the field of CRISPR, of
1:17:48how do you get more and more precise.
1:17:48how do you get more and more precise.
1:17:48how do you get more and more precise.
1:17:48how do you get more and more precise.
1:17:48how do you get more and more precise.
1:17:49And it's come a long way, but nothing's perfect, right?
1:17:49And it's come a long way, but nothing's perfect, right?
1:17:49And it's come a long way, but nothing's perfect, right?
1:17:49And it's come a long way, but nothing's perfect, right?
1:17:49And it's come a long way, but nothing's perfect, right?
1:17:54So I think we've done a lot, the field has done a lot of work
1:17:54So I think we've done a lot, the field has done a lot of work
1:17:54So I think we've done a lot, the field has done a lot of work
1:17:54So I think we've done a lot, the field has done a lot of work
1:17:54So I think we've done a lot, the field has done a lot of work
1:17:58to test off targets, right?
1:17:58to test off targets, right?
1:17:58to test off targets, right?
1:17:58to test off targets, right?
1:17:58to test off targets, right?
1:18:00If you're programming to cut on one place on chromosome 6, do you accidentally ever
1:18:00If you're programming to cut on one place on chromosome 6, do you accidentally ever
1:18:00If you're programming to cut on one place on chromosome 6, do you accidentally ever
1:18:00If you're programming to cut on one place on chromosome 6, do you accidentally ever
1:18:00If you're programming to cut on one place on chromosome 6, do you accidentally ever
1:18:07cut anywhere else? And there's a range.
1:18:07cut anywhere else? And there's a range.
1:18:07cut anywhere else? And there's a range.
1:18:07cut anywhere else? And there's a range.
1:18:07cut anywhere else? And there's a range.
1:18:09Sometimes some sequences are a little bit more promiscuous than others, but we've gotten quite
1:18:09Sometimes some sequences are a little bit more promiscuous than others, but we've gotten quite
1:18:09Sometimes some sequences are a little bit more promiscuous than others, but we've gotten quite
1:18:09Sometimes some sequences are a little bit more promiscuous than others, but we've gotten quite
1:18:09Sometimes some sequences are a little bit more promiscuous than others, but we've gotten quite
1:18:14good at getting more and more precise to say, okay, we're making these high fidelity
1:18:14good at getting more and more precise to say, okay, we're making these high fidelity
1:18:14good at getting more and more precise to say, okay, we're making these high fidelity
1:18:14good at getting more and more precise to say, okay, we're making these high fidelity
1:18:14good at getting more and more precise to say, okay, we're making these high fidelity
1:18:18cuts at one place. There are still the second risks of bystander effects.
1:18:18cuts at one place. There are still the second risks of bystander effects.
1:18:18cuts at one place. There are still the second risks of bystander effects.
1:18:18cuts at one place. There are still the second risks of bystander effects.
1:18:18cuts at one place. There are still the second risks of bystander effects.
1:18:26Okay, you make a cut, what does the DNA get chewed back?
1:18:26Okay, you make a cut, what does the DNA get chewed back?
1:18:26Okay, you make a cut, what does the DNA get chewed back?
1:18:26Okay, you make a cut, what does the DNA get chewed back?
1:18:26Okay, you make a cut, what does the DNA get chewed back?
1:18:29And at the neighboring part, there's been in some extreme places pieces of chromosomes actually
1:18:29And at the neighboring part, there's been in some extreme places pieces of chromosomes actually
1:18:29And at the neighboring part, there's been in some extreme places pieces of chromosomes actually
1:18:29And at the neighboring part, there's been in some extreme places pieces of chromosomes actually
1:18:29And at the neighboring part, there's been in some extreme places pieces of chromosomes actually
1:18:33falling off. All of these things can happen, and I think what we're kind of
1:18:33falling off. All of these things can happen, and I think what we're kind of
1:18:33falling off. All of these things can happen, and I think what we're kind of
1:18:33falling off. All of these things can happen, and I think what we're kind of
1:18:33falling off. All of these things can happen, and I think what we're kind of
1:18:39at a place in a field where now we're thinking about for each disease a
1:18:39at a place in a field where now we're thinking about for each disease a
1:18:39at a place in a field where now we're thinking about for each disease a
1:18:39at a place in a field where now we're thinking about for each disease a
1:18:39at a place in a field where now we're thinking about for each disease a
1:18:43risk -benefit of, okay, there's always a risk for any medicine of some unintended consequences.
1:18:43risk -benefit of, okay, there's always a risk for any medicine of some unintended consequences.
1:18:43risk -benefit of, okay, there's always a risk for any medicine of some unintended consequences.
1:18:43risk -benefit of, okay, there's always a risk for any medicine of some unintended consequences.
1:18:43risk -benefit of, okay, there's always a risk for any medicine of some unintended consequences.
1:18:49We have to be on the lookout for them.
1:18:49We have to be on the lookout for them.
1:18:49We have to be on the lookout for them.
1:18:49We have to be on the lookout for them.
1:18:49We have to be on the lookout for them.
1:18:51We have to know what they are.
1:18:51We have to know what they are.
1:18:51We have to know what they are.
1:18:51We have to know what they are.
1:18:51We have to know what they are.
1:18:53Most cells, as we said, that get a mutation don't have a problem, they just
1:18:53Most cells, as we said, that get a mutation don't have a problem, they just
1:18:53Most cells, as we said, that get a mutation don't have a problem, they just
1:18:53Most cells, as we said, that get a mutation don't have a problem, they just
1:18:53Most cells, as we said, that get a mutation don't have a problem, they just
1:18:58die off. So if you have an unintended consequence, most will die, but there is
1:18:58die off. So if you have an unintended consequence, most will die, but there is
1:18:58die off. So if you have an unintended consequence, most will die, but there is
1:18:58die off. So if you have an unintended consequence, most will die, but there is
1:18:58die off. So if you have an unintended consequence, most will die, but there is
1:19:01always the risk of the unintended consequences.
1:19:01always the risk of the unintended consequences.
1:19:01always the risk of the unintended consequences.
1:19:01always the risk of the unintended consequences.
1:19:01always the risk of the unintended consequences.
1:19:03And I think as a field we have to be humble about that.
1:19:03And I think as a field we have to be humble about that.
1:19:03And I think as a field we have to be humble about that.
1:19:03And I think as a field we have to be humble about that.
1:19:03And I think as a field we have to be humble about that.
1:19:07That said, the CRISPR world is not static.
1:19:07That said, the CRISPR world is not static.
1:19:07That said, the CRISPR world is not static.
1:19:07That said, the CRISPR world is not static.
1:19:07That said, the CRISPR world is not static.
1:19:10And the story I told you was like the building block of CRISPR.
1:19:10And the story I told you was like the building block of CRISPR.
1:19:10And the story I told you was like the building block of CRISPR.
1:19:10And the story I told you was like the building block of CRISPR.
1:19:10And the story I told you was like the building block of CRISPR.
1:19:15It's a protein scissor that can be targeted to any piece of DNA with an
1:19:15It's a protein scissor that can be targeted to any piece of DNA with an
1:19:15It's a protein scissor that can be targeted to any piece of DNA with an
1:19:15It's a protein scissor that can be targeted to any piece of DNA with an
1:19:15It's a protein scissor that can be targeted to any piece of DNA with an
1:19:20RNA molecule. People are appropriately thinking, well, scissors can cause damage.
1:19:20RNA molecule. People are appropriately thinking, well, scissors can cause damage.
1:19:20RNA molecule. People are appropriately thinking, well, scissors can cause damage.
1:19:20RNA molecule. People are appropriately thinking, well, scissors can cause damage.
1:19:20RNA molecule. People are appropriately thinking, well, scissors can cause damage.
1:19:28Maybe that CRISPR molecule should actually be re -engineered, not to be a scissor, but
1:19:28Maybe that CRISPR molecule should actually be re -engineered, not to be a scissor, but
1:19:28Maybe that CRISPR molecule should actually be re -engineered, not to be a scissor, but
1:19:28Maybe that CRISPR molecule should actually be re -engineered, not to be a scissor, but
1:19:28Maybe that CRISPR molecule should actually be re -engineered, not to be a scissor, but
1:19:33to do other things. And now people have started engineering it to say, well, let's
1:19:33to do other things. And now people have started engineering it to say, well, let's
1:19:33to do other things. And now people have started engineering it to say, well, let's
1:19:33to do other things. And now people have started engineering it to say, well, let's
1:19:33to do other things. And now people have started engineering it to say, well, let's
1:19:37not make it a scissor, let's make it a thing that just introduces a more
1:19:37not make it a scissor, let's make it a thing that just introduces a more
1:19:37not make it a scissor, let's make it a thing that just introduces a more
1:19:37not make it a scissor, let's make it a thing that just introduces a more
1:19:37not make it a scissor, let's make it a thing that just introduces a more
1:19:41predictable mutation at a site.
1:19:41predictable mutation at a site.
1:19:41predictable mutation at a site.
1:19:41predictable mutation at a site.
1:19:41predictable mutation at a site.
1:19:42David Liu at Harvard has created these things called CRISPR base editors that doesn't introduce
1:19:42David Liu at Harvard has created these things called CRISPR base editors that doesn't introduce
1:19:42David Liu at Harvard has created these things called CRISPR base editors that doesn't introduce
1:19:42David Liu at Harvard has created these things called CRISPR base editors that doesn't introduce
1:19:42David Liu at Harvard has created these things called CRISPR base editors that doesn't introduce
1:19:47a double -stranded break but actually changes nucleotides in a more predictable way at that
1:19:47a double -stranded break but actually changes nucleotides in a more predictable way at that
1:19:47a double -stranded break but actually changes nucleotides in a more predictable way at that
1:19:47a double -stranded break but actually changes nucleotides in a more predictable way at that
1:19:47a double -stranded break but actually changes nucleotides in a more predictable way at that
1:19:52site by recruiting a deaminase domain, something that will change DNA nucleotides when it's recruited
1:19:52site by recruiting a deaminase domain, something that will change DNA nucleotides when it's recruited
1:19:52site by recruiting a deaminase domain, something that will change DNA nucleotides when it's recruited
1:19:52site by recruiting a deaminase domain, something that will change DNA nucleotides when it's recruited
1:19:52site by recruiting a deaminase domain, something that will change DNA nucleotides when it's recruited
1:19:59to a particular place. And you use CRISPR just to recruit that enzyme that makes
1:19:59to a particular place. And you use CRISPR just to recruit that enzyme that makes
1:19:59to a particular place. And you use CRISPR just to recruit that enzyme that makes
1:19:59to a particular place. And you use CRISPR just to recruit that enzyme that makes
1:19:59to a particular place. And you use CRISPR just to recruit that enzyme that makes
1:20:02that mutation at a targeted place.
1:20:02that mutation at a targeted place.
1:20:02that mutation at a targeted place.
1:20:02that mutation at a targeted place.
1:20:02that mutation at a targeted place.
1:20:04Other people have actually started using epigenetic enzymes.
1:20:04Other people have actually started using epigenetic enzymes.
1:20:04Other people have actually started using epigenetic enzymes.
1:20:04Other people have actually started using epigenetic enzymes.
1:20:04Other people have actually started using epigenetic enzymes.
1:20:09The DNA doesn't just get enacted by DNA sequences but can actually, pieces of it
1:20:09The DNA doesn't just get enacted by DNA sequences but can actually, pieces of it
1:20:09The DNA doesn't just get enacted by DNA sequences but can actually, pieces of it
1:20:09The DNA doesn't just get enacted by DNA sequences but can actually, pieces of it
1:20:09The DNA doesn't just get enacted by DNA sequences but can actually, pieces of it
1:20:15can be active or inactive, and this is called epigenetics, where there can be a
1:20:15can be active or inactive, and this is called epigenetics, where there can be a
1:20:15can be active or inactive, and this is called epigenetics, where there can be a
1:20:15can be active or inactive, and this is called epigenetics, where there can be a
1:20:15can be active or inactive, and this is called epigenetics, where there can be a
1:20:19stable program of things getting turned on or off without any change in the A's
1:20:19stable program of things getting turned on or off without any change in the A's
1:20:19stable program of things getting turned on or off without any change in the A's
1:20:19stable program of things getting turned on or off without any change in the A's
1:20:19stable program of things getting turned on or off without any change in the A's
1:20:24and T's and C's and G's.
1:20:24and T's and C's and G's.
1:20:24and T's and C's and G's.
1:20:24and T's and C's and G's.
1:20:24and T's and C's and G's.
1:20:25And now we and others are using CRISPR -based epigenetic editing.
1:20:25And now we and others are using CRISPR -based epigenetic editing.
1:20:25And now we and others are using CRISPR -based epigenetic editing.
1:20:25And now we and others are using CRISPR -based epigenetic editing.
1:20:25And now we and others are using CRISPR -based epigenetic editing.
1:20:32It's called epi -editing, where we don't make any cut in the genome but we
1:20:32It's called epi -editing, where we don't make any cut in the genome but we
1:20:32It's called epi -editing, where we don't make any cut in the genome but we
1:20:32It's called epi -editing, where we don't make any cut in the genome but we
1:20:32It's called epi -editing, where we don't make any cut in the genome but we
1:20:36just turn on or off.
1:20:36just turn on or off.
1:20:36just turn on or off.
1:20:36just turn on or off.
1:20:36just turn on or off.
1:20:38And it's in a large part to think about mitigating some of these risks that
1:20:38And it's in a large part to think about mitigating some of these risks that
1:20:38And it's in a large part to think about mitigating some of these risks that
1:20:38And it's in a large part to think about mitigating some of these risks that
1:20:38And it's in a large part to think about mitigating some of these risks that
1:20:42might come with the scissor function.
1:20:42might come with the scissor function.
1:20:42might come with the scissor function.
1:20:42might come with the scissor function.
1:20:42might come with the scissor function.
1:20:44Instead, all of a sudden we're thinking about we're using the same building block of
1:20:44Instead, all of a sudden we're thinking about we're using the same building block of
1:20:44Instead, all of a sudden we're thinking about we're using the same building block of
1:20:44Instead, all of a sudden we're thinking about we're using the same building block of
1:20:44Instead, all of a sudden we're thinking about we're using the same building block of
1:20:47recruiting an enzyme to a particular place in the DNA code but using the full
1:20:47recruiting an enzyme to a particular place in the DNA code but using the full
1:20:47recruiting an enzyme to a particular place in the DNA code but using the full
1:20:47recruiting an enzyme to a particular place in the DNA code but using the full
1:20:47recruiting an enzyme to a particular place in the DNA code but using the full
1:20:51set of things that we might do at that DNA site to program cells in
1:20:51set of things that we might do at that DNA site to program cells in
1:20:51set of things that we might do at that DNA site to program cells in
1:20:51set of things that we might do at that DNA site to program cells in
1:20:51set of things that we might do at that DNA site to program cells in
1:20:56the most precise possible way.
1:20:56the most precise possible way.
1:20:56the most precise possible way.
1:20:56the most precise possible way.
1:20:56the most precise possible way.
1:20:57I'd like to take a quick break and acknowledge one of our sponsors, Element.
1:20:57I'd like to take a quick break and acknowledge one of our sponsors, Element.
1:20:57I'd like to take a quick break and acknowledge one of our sponsors, Element.
1:20:57I'd like to take a quick break and acknowledge one of our sponsors, Element.
1:20:57I'd like to take a quick break and acknowledge one of our sponsors, Element.
1:21:01Element is an electrolyte drink that has everything you need and nothing you don't.
1:21:01Element is an electrolyte drink that has everything you need and nothing you don't.
1:21:01Element is an electrolyte drink that has everything you need and nothing you don't.
1:21:01Element is an electrolyte drink that has everything you need and nothing you don't.
1:21:01Element is an electrolyte drink that has everything you need and nothing you don't.
1:21:05That means the electrolytes, sodium, magnesium, and potassium all in the correct ratios but no
1:21:05That means the electrolytes, sodium, magnesium, and potassium all in the correct ratios but no
1:21:05That means the electrolytes, sodium, magnesium, and potassium all in the correct ratios but no
1:21:05That means the electrolytes, sodium, magnesium, and potassium all in the correct ratios but no
1:21:05That means the electrolytes, sodium, magnesium, and potassium all in the correct ratios but no
1:21:11sugar. Proper hydration is critical for brain and body function.
1:21:11sugar. Proper hydration is critical for brain and body function.
1:21:11sugar. Proper hydration is critical for brain and body function.
1:21:11sugar. Proper hydration is critical for brain and body function.
1:21:11sugar. Proper hydration is critical for brain and body function.
1:21:15Even a slight degree of dehydration can diminish your cognitive and physical performance.
1:21:15Even a slight degree of dehydration can diminish your cognitive and physical performance.
1:21:15Even a slight degree of dehydration can diminish your cognitive and physical performance.
1:21:15Even a slight degree of dehydration can diminish your cognitive and physical performance.
1:21:15Even a slight degree of dehydration can diminish your cognitive and physical performance.
1:21:19It's also important that you get adequate electrolytes.
1:21:19It's also important that you get adequate electrolytes.
1:21:19It's also important that you get adequate electrolytes.
1:21:19It's also important that you get adequate electrolytes.
1:21:19It's also important that you get adequate electrolytes.
1:21:22The electrolytes, sodium, magnesium, and potassium are vital for the functioning of all cells in
1:21:22The electrolytes, sodium, magnesium, and potassium are vital for the functioning of all cells in
1:21:22The electrolytes, sodium, magnesium, and potassium are vital for the functioning of all cells in
1:21:22The electrolytes, sodium, magnesium, and potassium are vital for the functioning of all cells in
1:21:22The electrolytes, sodium, magnesium, and potassium are vital for the functioning of all cells in
1:21:27your body especially your neurons or your nerve cells.
1:21:27your body especially your neurons or your nerve cells.
1:21:27your body especially your neurons or your nerve cells.
1:21:27your body especially your neurons or your nerve cells.
1:21:27your body especially your neurons or your nerve cells.
1:21:30Drinking Element makes it very easy to ensure that you're getting adequate hydration and adequate
1:21:30Drinking Element makes it very easy to ensure that you're getting adequate hydration and adequate
1:21:30Drinking Element makes it very easy to ensure that you're getting adequate hydration and adequate
1:21:30Drinking Element makes it very easy to ensure that you're getting adequate hydration and adequate
1:21:30Drinking Element makes it very easy to ensure that you're getting adequate hydration and adequate
1:21:35electrolytes. My days tend to start really fast meaning I have to jump right into
1:21:35electrolytes. My days tend to start really fast meaning I have to jump right into
1:21:35electrolytes. My days tend to start really fast meaning I have to jump right into
1:21:35electrolytes. My days tend to start really fast meaning I have to jump right into
1:21:35electrolytes. My days tend to start really fast meaning I have to jump right into
1:21:39work or right into exercise.
1:21:39work or right into exercise.
1:21:39work or right into exercise.
1:21:39work or right into exercise.
1:21:39work or right into exercise.
1:21:41So to make sure that I'm hydrated and I have sufficient electrolytes when I first
1:21:41So to make sure that I'm hydrated and I have sufficient electrolytes when I first
1:21:41So to make sure that I'm hydrated and I have sufficient electrolytes when I first
1:21:41So to make sure that I'm hydrated and I have sufficient electrolytes when I first
1:21:41So to make sure that I'm hydrated and I have sufficient electrolytes when I first
1:21:45wake up in the morning I drink 16 to 32 ounces of water with an
1:21:45wake up in the morning I drink 16 to 32 ounces of water with an
1:21:45wake up in the morning I drink 16 to 32 ounces of water with an
1:21:45wake up in the morning I drink 16 to 32 ounces of water with an
1:21:45wake up in the morning I drink 16 to 32 ounces of water with an
1:21:48element packet dissolved in it.
1:21:48element packet dissolved in it.
1:21:48element packet dissolved in it.
1:21:48element packet dissolved in it.
1:21:48element packet dissolved in it.
1:21:50I also drink element dissolved aboutих vehicle in the contra´s where I'm fishing and water
1:21:50I also drink element dissolved aboutих vehicle in the contra´s where I'm fishing and water
1:21:50I also drink element dissolved aboutих vehicle in the contra´s where I'm fishing and water
1:21:50I also drink element dissolved aboutих vehicle in the contra´s where I'm fishing and water
1:21:50I also drink element dissolved aboutих vehicle in the contra´s where I'm fishing and water
1:21:52during any kind of physical exercise that I'm doing, especially on hot days when I'm
1:21:52during any kind of physical exercise that I'm doing, especially on hot days when I'm
1:21:52during any kind of physical exercise that I'm doing, especially on hot days when I'm
1:21:52during any kind of physical exercise that I'm doing, especially on hot days when I'm
1:21:52during any kind of physical exercise that I'm doing, especially on hot days when I'm
1:21:56sweating a lot and losing water and electrolytes.
1:21:56sweating a lot and losing water and electrolytes.
1:21:56sweating a lot and losing water and electrolytes.
1:21:56sweating a lot and losing water and electrolytes.
1:21:56sweating a lot and losing water and electrolytes.
1:21:58Element has a bunch of great tasting flavors.
1:21:58Element has a bunch of great tasting flavors.
1:21:58Element has a bunch of great tasting flavors.
1:21:58Element has a bunch of great tasting flavors.
1:21:58Element has a bunch of great tasting flavors.
1:22:00In fact, I love them all.
1:22:00In fact, I love them all.
1:22:00In fact, I love them all.
1:22:00In fact, I love them all.
1:22:00In fact, I love them all.
1:22:02I love the watermelon, the raspberry, the citrus, and I really love the lemonade flavor.
1:22:02I love the watermelon, the raspberry, the citrus, and I really love the lemonade flavor.
1:22:02I love the watermelon, the raspberry, the citrus, and I really love the lemonade flavor.
1:22:02I love the watermelon, the raspberry, the citrus, and I really love the lemonade flavor.
1:22:02I love the watermelon, the raspberry, the citrus, and I really love the lemonade flavor.
1:22:05So if you'd like to try Element, you can go to drinkelement .com slash Huberman
1:22:05So if you'd like to try Element, you can go to drinkelement .com slash Huberman
1:22:05So if you'd like to try Element, you can go to drinkelement .com slash Huberman
1:22:05So if you'd like to try Element, you can go to drinkelement .com slash Huberman
1:22:05So if you'd like to try Element, you can go to drinkelement .com slash Huberman
1:22:10to claim a free Element sample pack with any purchase.
1:22:10to claim a free Element sample pack with any purchase.
1:22:10to claim a free Element sample pack with any purchase.
1:22:10to claim a free Element sample pack with any purchase.
1:22:10to claim a free Element sample pack with any purchase.
1:22:13Again, that's drinkelement .com slash Huberman to claim a free sample pack.
1:22:13Again, that's drinkelement .com slash Huberman to claim a free sample pack.
1:22:13Again, that's drinkelement .com slash Huberman to claim a free sample pack.
1:22:13Again, that's drinkelement .com slash Huberman to claim a free sample pack.
1:22:13Again, that's drinkelement .com slash Huberman to claim a free sample pack.
1:22:17I'm curious about getting CRISPR into the cells of interest.
1:22:17I'm curious about getting CRISPR into the cells of interest.
1:22:17I'm curious about getting CRISPR into the cells of interest.
1:22:17I'm curious about getting CRISPR into the cells of interest.
1:22:17I'm curious about getting CRISPR into the cells of interest.
1:22:23You know, the lentivirus example that you gave before, my understanding is it involved harvesting
1:22:23You know, the lentivirus example that you gave before, my understanding is it involved harvesting
1:22:23You know, the lentivirus example that you gave before, my understanding is it involved harvesting
1:22:23You know, the lentivirus example that you gave before, my understanding is it involved harvesting
1:22:23You know, the lentivirus example that you gave before, my understanding is it involved harvesting
1:22:29some T cells, introducing the lentivirus with the cargo that you want, putting that back
1:22:29some T cells, introducing the lentivirus with the cargo that you want, putting that back
1:22:29some T cells, introducing the lentivirus with the cargo that you want, putting that back
1:22:29some T cells, introducing the lentivirus with the cargo that you want, putting that back
1:22:29some T cells, introducing the lentivirus with the cargo that you want, putting that back
1:22:37into circulation, and the T cells know where to go and know what to do.
1:22:37into circulation, and the T cells know where to go and know what to do.
1:22:37into circulation, and the T cells know where to go and know what to do.
1:22:37into circulation, and the T cells know where to go and know what to do.
1:22:37into circulation, and the T cells know where to go and know what to do.
1:22:41For a lot of cell types like neurons in the brain, liver cells, pancreatic cells.
1:22:41For a lot of cell types like neurons in the brain, liver cells, pancreatic cells.
1:22:41For a lot of cell types like neurons in the brain, liver cells, pancreatic cells.
1:22:41For a lot of cell types like neurons in the brain, liver cells, pancreatic cells.
1:22:41For a lot of cell types like neurons in the brain, liver cells, pancreatic cells.
1:22:50I could imagine a surgery where you inject directly into those organs, but wouldn't it
1:22:50I could imagine a surgery where you inject directly into those organs, but wouldn't it
1:22:50I could imagine a surgery where you inject directly into those organs, but wouldn't it
1:22:50I could imagine a surgery where you inject directly into those organs, but wouldn't it
1:22:50I could imagine a surgery where you inject directly into those organs, but wouldn't it
1:22:55be wonderful if you could get the cells of interest without having to be so
1:22:55be wonderful if you could get the cells of interest without having to be so
1:22:55be wonderful if you could get the cells of interest without having to be so
1:22:55be wonderful if you could get the cells of interest without having to be so
1:22:55be wonderful if you could get the cells of interest without having to be so
1:23:01invasive? So what's being done there in terms of trafficking CRISPR -2 appropriate cell types
1:23:01invasive? So what's being done there in terms of trafficking CRISPR -2 appropriate cell types
1:23:01invasive? So what's being done there in terms of trafficking CRISPR -2 appropriate cell types
1:23:01invasive? So what's being done there in terms of trafficking CRISPR -2 appropriate cell types
1:23:01invasive? So what's being done there in terms of trafficking CRISPR -2 appropriate cell types
1:23:09and or organs? And then that sort of seeds another question that I'll hold off
1:23:09and or organs? And then that sort of seeds another question that I'll hold off
1:23:09and or organs? And then that sort of seeds another question that I'll hold off
1:23:09and or organs? And then that sort of seeds another question that I'll hold off
1:23:09and or organs? And then that sort of seeds another question that I'll hold off
1:23:15on about whether we should be banking cells for what's coming.
1:23:15on about whether we should be banking cells for what's coming.
1:23:15on about whether we should be banking cells for what's coming.
1:23:15on about whether we should be banking cells for what's coming.
1:23:15on about whether we should be banking cells for what's coming.
1:23:21First of all, I just want to pause.
1:23:21First of all, I just want to pause.
1:23:21First of all, I just want to pause.
1:23:21First of all, I just want to pause.
1:23:21First of all, I just want to pause.
1:23:22This is great. I love this conversation.
1:23:22This is great. I love this conversation.
1:23:22This is great. I love this conversation.
1:23:22This is great. I love this conversation.
1:23:22This is great. I love this conversation.
1:23:24I do too. I mean, you're taking us to the, I don't like the phrase
1:23:24I do too. I mean, you're taking us to the, I don't like the phrase
1:23:24I do too. I mean, you're taking us to the, I don't like the phrase
1:23:24I do too. I mean, you're taking us to the, I don't like the phrase
1:23:24I do too. I mean, you're taking us to the, I don't like the phrase
1:23:29bleeding edge. It sounds violent.
1:23:29bleeding edge. It sounds violent.
1:23:29bleeding edge. It sounds violent.
1:23:29bleeding edge. It sounds violent.
1:23:29bleeding edge. It sounds violent.
1:23:31But you're taking us to the cutting edge of molecular biology and medicine, and we
1:23:31But you're taking us to the cutting edge of molecular biology and medicine, and we
1:23:31But you're taking us to the cutting edge of molecular biology and medicine, and we
1:23:31But you're taking us to the cutting edge of molecular biology and medicine, and we
1:23:31But you're taking us to the cutting edge of molecular biology and medicine, and we
1:23:36are peering over into what's next, like what your children and my children and probably
1:23:36are peering over into what's next, like what your children and my children and probably
1:23:36are peering over into what's next, like what your children and my children and probably
1:23:36are peering over into what's next, like what your children and my children and probably
1:23:36are peering over into what's next, like what your children and my children and probably
1:23:42our parents also will be able to benefit from in the next 10 years, maybe
1:23:42our parents also will be able to benefit from in the next 10 years, maybe
1:23:42our parents also will be able to benefit from in the next 10 years, maybe
1:23:42our parents also will be able to benefit from in the next 10 years, maybe
1:23:42our parents also will be able to benefit from in the next 10 years, maybe
1:23:47sooner. Yeah, we're really talking about things that are happening now and happening at an
1:23:47sooner. Yeah, we're really talking about things that are happening now and happening at an
1:23:47sooner. Yeah, we're really talking about things that are happening now and happening at an
1:23:47sooner. Yeah, we're really talking about things that are happening now and happening at an
1:23:47sooner. Yeah, we're really talking about things that are happening now and happening at an
1:23:52accelerating rate. So you asked, part of what just made me have that reaction, I
1:23:52accelerating rate. So you asked, part of what just made me have that reaction, I
1:23:52accelerating rate. So you asked, part of what just made me have that reaction, I
1:23:52accelerating rate. So you asked, part of what just made me have that reaction, I
1:23:52accelerating rate. So you asked, part of what just made me have that reaction, I
1:23:56think you asked one of the key questions for this field of how is this
1:23:56think you asked one of the key questions for this field of how is this
1:23:56think you asked one of the key questions for this field of how is this
1:23:56think you asked one of the key questions for this field of how is this
1:23:56think you asked one of the key questions for this field of how is this
1:24:00being delivered into cells? So I told you, let me go backwards and then I'll
1:24:00being delivered into cells? So I told you, let me go backwards and then I'll
1:24:00being delivered into cells? So I told you, let me go backwards and then I'll
1:24:00being delivered into cells? So I told you, let me go backwards and then I'll
1:24:00being delivered into cells? So I told you, let me go backwards and then I'll
1:24:05go forward. I told you that in 2012 I sort of was sitting there thinking
1:24:05go forward. I told you that in 2012 I sort of was sitting there thinking
1:24:05go forward. I told you that in 2012 I sort of was sitting there thinking
1:24:05go forward. I told you that in 2012 I sort of was sitting there thinking
1:24:05go forward. I told you that in 2012 I sort of was sitting there thinking
1:24:09about I wanted to study T cells, the genetic control of T cells.
1:24:09about I wanted to study T cells, the genetic control of T cells.
1:24:09about I wanted to study T cells, the genetic control of T cells.
1:24:09about I wanted to study T cells, the genetic control of T cells.
1:24:09about I wanted to study T cells, the genetic control of T cells.
1:24:12I saw the power of CAR T cells.
1:24:12I saw the power of CAR T cells.
1:24:12I saw the power of CAR T cells.
1:24:12I saw the power of CAR T cells.
1:24:12I saw the power of CAR T cells.
1:24:14I saw the power of CRISPR, which at that time was being only used in
1:24:14I saw the power of CRISPR, which at that time was being only used in
1:24:14I saw the power of CRISPR, which at that time was being only used in
1:24:14I saw the power of CRISPR, which at that time was being only used in
1:24:14I saw the power of CRISPR, which at that time was being only used in
1:24:18highly artificial immortalized cell lines that grow easily in the lab.
1:24:18highly artificial immortalized cell lines that grow easily in the lab.
1:24:18highly artificial immortalized cell lines that grow easily in the lab.
1:24:18highly artificial immortalized cell lines that grow easily in the lab.
1:24:18highly artificial immortalized cell lines that grow easily in the lab.
1:24:24And it just wasn't clear that there would be a way to get CRISPR to
1:24:24And it just wasn't clear that there would be a way to get CRISPR to
1:24:24And it just wasn't clear that there would be a way to get CRISPR to
1:24:24And it just wasn't clear that there would be a way to get CRISPR to
1:24:24And it just wasn't clear that there would be a way to get CRISPR to
1:24:27work in real T cells that you would take out of a human blood sample
1:24:27work in real T cells that you would take out of a human blood sample
1:24:27work in real T cells that you would take out of a human blood sample
1:24:27work in real T cells that you would take out of a human blood sample
1:24:27work in real T cells that you would take out of a human blood sample
1:24:31that are not immortalized, that can only stay in a dish for a short amount
1:24:31that are not immortalized, that can only stay in a dish for a short amount
1:24:31that are not immortalized, that can only stay in a dish for a short amount
1:24:31that are not immortalized, that can only stay in a dish for a short amount
1:24:31that are not immortalized, that can only stay in a dish for a short amount
1:24:34of time and still retain their function.
1:24:34of time and still retain their function.
1:24:34of time and still retain their function.
1:24:34of time and still retain their function.
1:24:34of time and still retain their function.
1:24:36And I sort of tripled down on this was what my lab was going to
1:24:36And I sort of tripled down on this was what my lab was going to
1:24:36And I sort of tripled down on this was what my lab was going to
1:24:36And I sort of tripled down on this was what my lab was going to
1:24:36And I sort of tripled down on this was what my lab was going to
1:24:42do, that we were going to figure out a way.
1:24:42do, that we were going to figure out a way.
1:24:42do, that we were going to figure out a way.
1:24:42do, that we were going to figure out a way.
1:24:42do, that we were going to figure out a way.
1:24:44And we went through a long list of different ways that we might deliver and
1:24:44And we went through a long list of different ways that we might deliver and
1:24:44And we went through a long list of different ways that we might deliver and
1:24:44And we went through a long list of different ways that we might deliver and
1:24:44And we went through a long list of different ways that we might deliver and
1:24:47it wasn't obvious. Actually, a key collaboration early in my career was another serendipitous run
1:24:47it wasn't obvious. Actually, a key collaboration early in my career was another serendipitous run
1:24:47it wasn't obvious. Actually, a key collaboration early in my career was another serendipitous run
1:24:47it wasn't obvious. Actually, a key collaboration early in my career was another serendipitous run
1:24:47it wasn't obvious. Actually, a key collaboration early in my career was another serendipitous run
1:24:55-in. I met Jennifer Doudna through some persistence of my own.
1:24:55-in. I met Jennifer Doudna through some persistence of my own.
1:24:55-in. I met Jennifer Doudna through some persistence of my own.
1:24:55-in. I met Jennifer Doudna through some persistence of my own.
1:24:55-in. I met Jennifer Doudna through some persistence of my own.
1:24:59And Jennifer Doudna and I sat down and started thinking about how could we team
1:24:59And Jennifer Doudna and I sat down and started thinking about how could we team
1:24:59And Jennifer Doudna and I sat down and started thinking about how could we team
1:24:59And Jennifer Doudna and I sat down and started thinking about how could we team
1:24:59And Jennifer Doudna and I sat down and started thinking about how could we team
1:25:02up to take her expertise in CRISPR biochemistry and get it to work in T
1:25:02up to take her expertise in CRISPR biochemistry and get it to work in T
1:25:02up to take her expertise in CRISPR biochemistry and get it to work in T
1:25:02up to take her expertise in CRISPR biochemistry and get it to work in T
1:25:02up to take her expertise in CRISPR biochemistry and get it to work in T
1:25:07cells. And we settled on this thing that was not at the top of my
1:25:07cells. And we settled on this thing that was not at the top of my
1:25:07cells. And we settled on this thing that was not at the top of my
1:25:07cells. And we settled on this thing that was not at the top of my
1:25:07cells. And we settled on this thing that was not at the top of my
1:25:11list of things that would work but ended up opening up the field.
1:25:11list of things that would work but ended up opening up the field.
1:25:11list of things that would work but ended up opening up the field.
1:25:11list of things that would work but ended up opening up the field.
1:25:11list of things that would work but ended up opening up the field.
1:25:15We actually purified the CRISPR protein.
1:25:15We actually purified the CRISPR protein.
1:25:15We actually purified the CRISPR protein.
1:25:15We actually purified the CRISPR protein.
1:25:15We actually purified the CRISPR protein.
1:25:18So we had protein and RNA that we could make in a test tube.
1:25:18So we had protein and RNA that we could make in a test tube.
1:25:18So we had protein and RNA that we could make in a test tube.
1:25:18So we had protein and RNA that we could make in a test tube.
1:25:18So we had protein and RNA that we could make in a test tube.
1:25:22Now we order it off the internet.
1:25:22Now we order it off the internet.
1:25:22Now we order it off the internet.
1:25:22Now we order it off the internet.
1:25:22Now we order it off the internet.
1:25:25We can mix them together and we could make these protein RNA complexes and we
1:25:25We can mix them together and we could make these protein RNA complexes and we
1:25:25We can mix them together and we could make these protein RNA complexes and we
1:25:25We can mix them together and we could make these protein RNA complexes and we
1:25:25We can mix them together and we could make these protein RNA complexes and we
1:25:29could suspend that in liquid.
1:25:29could suspend that in liquid.
1:25:29could suspend that in liquid.
1:25:29could suspend that in liquid.
1:25:29could suspend that in liquid.
1:25:31And then what we did is we actually incubated T cells from a blood sample
1:25:31And then what we did is we actually incubated T cells from a blood sample
1:25:31And then what we did is we actually incubated T cells from a blood sample
1:25:31And then what we did is we actually incubated T cells from a blood sample
1:25:31And then what we did is we actually incubated T cells from a blood sample
1:25:36in that liquid. And then the question was how do you get these protein RNA
1:25:36in that liquid. And then the question was how do you get these protein RNA
1:25:36in that liquid. And then the question was how do you get these protein RNA
1:25:36in that liquid. And then the question was how do you get these protein RNA
1:25:36in that liquid. And then the question was how do you get these protein RNA
1:25:40complexes into the cells? And we used this trick that's been around for a long
1:25:40complexes into the cells? And we used this trick that's been around for a long
1:25:40complexes into the cells? And we used this trick that's been around for a long
1:25:40complexes into the cells? And we used this trick that's been around for a long
1:25:40complexes into the cells? And we used this trick that's been around for a long
1:25:44time. As long as it's been around, it sounds magical and no one quite understands
1:25:44time. As long as it's been around, it sounds magical and no one quite understands
1:25:44time. As long as it's been around, it sounds magical and no one quite understands
1:25:44time. As long as it's been around, it sounds magical and no one quite understands
1:25:44time. As long as it's been around, it sounds magical and no one quite understands
1:25:48how it works. We put the cells into a device that gives a small electrical
1:25:48how it works. We put the cells into a device that gives a small electrical
1:25:48how it works. We put the cells into a device that gives a small electrical
1:25:48how it works. We put the cells into a device that gives a small electrical
1:25:48how it works. We put the cells into a device that gives a small electrical
1:25:53current to the T cells.
1:25:53current to the T cells.
1:25:53current to the T cells.
1:25:53current to the T cells.
1:25:53current to the T cells.
1:25:55Electroporation. Electroporation. Electroporation. Oh, man.
1:25:55Electroporation. Electroporation. Electroporation. Oh, man.
1:25:55Electroporation. Electroporation. Electroporation. Oh, man.
1:25:55Electroporation. Electroporation. Electroporation. Oh, man.
1:25:55Electroporation. Electroporation. Electroporation. Oh, man.
1:25:58During my graduate career, I electroporated a lot of – well, I can just say
1:25:58During my graduate career, I electroporated a lot of – well, I can just say
1:25:58During my graduate career, I electroporated a lot of – well, I can just say
1:25:58During my graduate career, I electroporated a lot of – well, I can just say
1:25:58During my graduate career, I electroporated a lot of – well, I can just say
1:26:03it now because I don't do it anymore – electroporated a lot of brains of
1:26:03it now because I don't do it anymore – electroporated a lot of brains of
1:26:03it now because I don't do it anymore – electroporated a lot of brains of
1:26:03it now because I don't do it anymore – electroporated a lot of brains of
1:26:03it now because I don't do it anymore – electroporated a lot of brains of
1:26:07intact animals. Yeah. You inject DNA.
1:26:07intact animals. Yeah. You inject DNA.
1:26:07intact animals. Yeah. You inject DNA.
1:26:07intact animals. Yeah. You inject DNA.
1:26:07intact animals. Yeah. You inject DNA.
1:26:10It's floating around in the local tissue.
1:26:10It's floating around in the local tissue.
1:26:10It's floating around in the local tissue.
1:26:10It's floating around in the local tissue.
1:26:10It's floating around in the local tissue.
1:26:14You pass some square wave current.
1:26:14You pass some square wave current.
1:26:14You pass some square wave current.
1:26:14You pass some square wave current.
1:26:14You pass some square wave current.
1:26:16Yep. And the assumption is that it creates little transient pores in the cell membrane
1:26:16Yep. And the assumption is that it creates little transient pores in the cell membrane
1:26:16Yep. And the assumption is that it creates little transient pores in the cell membrane
1:26:16Yep. And the assumption is that it creates little transient pores in the cell membrane
1:26:16Yep. And the assumption is that it creates little transient pores in the cell membrane
1:26:21and it gets in. And sometimes you end up with four cells transfected and sometimes
1:26:21and it gets in. And sometimes you end up with four cells transfected and sometimes
1:26:21and it gets in. And sometimes you end up with four cells transfected and sometimes
1:26:21and it gets in. And sometimes you end up with four cells transfected and sometimes
1:26:21and it gets in. And sometimes you end up with four cells transfected and sometimes
1:26:26you end up with 40 ,000 cells transfected.
1:26:26you end up with 40 ,000 cells transfected.
1:26:26you end up with 40 ,000 cells transfected.
1:26:26you end up with 40 ,000 cells transfected.
1:26:26you end up with 40 ,000 cells transfected.
1:26:29It's a wildly useful technique, but it's a little bit hit or miss.
1:26:29It's a wildly useful technique, but it's a little bit hit or miss.
1:26:29It's a wildly useful technique, but it's a little bit hit or miss.
1:26:29It's a wildly useful technique, but it's a little bit hit or miss.
1:26:29It's a wildly useful technique, but it's a little bit hit or miss.
1:26:33That's a perfect description. And so we – my first postdoc in my lab, Catherine
1:26:33That's a perfect description. And so we – my first postdoc in my lab, Catherine
1:26:33That's a perfect description. And so we – my first postdoc in my lab, Catherine
1:26:33That's a perfect description. And so we – my first postdoc in my lab, Catherine
1:26:33That's a perfect description. And so we – my first postdoc in my lab, Catherine
1:26:39Schumann, sat there and tested different electroporation conditions all during these little pulse codes.
1:26:39Schumann, sat there and tested different electroporation conditions all during these little pulse codes.
1:26:39Schumann, sat there and tested different electroporation conditions all during these little pulse codes.
1:26:39Schumann, sat there and tested different electroporation conditions all during these little pulse codes.
1:26:39Schumann, sat there and tested different electroporation conditions all during these little pulse codes.
1:26:44One pulse, 12 pulses, long pulses.
1:26:44One pulse, 12 pulses, long pulses.
1:26:44One pulse, 12 pulses, long pulses.
1:26:44One pulse, 12 pulses, long pulses.
1:26:44One pulse, 12 pulses, long pulses.
1:26:46You're taking me back to my graduate.
1:26:46You're taking me back to my graduate.
1:26:46You're taking me back to my graduate.
1:26:46You're taking me back to my graduate.
1:26:46You're taking me back to my graduate.
1:26:47And to some extent, my postdoctoral years.
1:26:47And to some extent, my postdoctoral years.
1:26:47And to some extent, my postdoctoral years.
1:26:47And to some extent, my postdoctoral years.
1:26:47And to some extent, my postdoctoral years.
1:26:49It's unclear for given tissues, for given sequences, what's going to go into cells, what's
1:26:49It's unclear for given tissues, for given sequences, what's going to go into cells, what's
1:26:49It's unclear for given tissues, for given sequences, what's going to go into cells, what's
1:26:49It's unclear for given tissues, for given sequences, what's going to go into cells, what's
1:26:49It's unclear for given tissues, for given sequences, what's going to go into cells, what's
1:26:54going to not kill the cells.
1:26:54going to not kill the cells.
1:26:54going to not kill the cells.
1:26:54going to not kill the cells.
1:26:54going to not kill the cells.
1:26:57We're walking this tightrope of how do you make this pore as big enough that
1:26:57We're walking this tightrope of how do you make this pore as big enough that
1:26:57We're walking this tightrope of how do you make this pore as big enough that
1:26:57We're walking this tightrope of how do you make this pore as big enough that
1:26:57We're walking this tightrope of how do you make this pore as big enough that
1:27:01CRISPR will get in but that the cells don't die.
1:27:01CRISPR will get in but that the cells don't die.
1:27:01CRISPR will get in but that the cells don't die.
1:27:01CRISPR will get in but that the cells don't die.
1:27:01CRISPR will get in but that the cells don't die.
1:27:04And we did it, you know, and we did it and we've optimized this.
1:27:04And we did it, you know, and we did it and we've optimized this.
1:27:04And we did it, you know, and we did it and we've optimized this.
1:27:04And we did it, you know, and we did it and we've optimized this.
1:27:04And we did it, you know, and we did it and we've optimized this.
1:27:09And it was one of those things when it happens, you see it and you
1:27:09And it was one of those things when it happens, you see it and you
1:27:09And it was one of those things when it happens, you see it and you
1:27:09And it was one of those things when it happens, you see it and you
1:27:09And it was one of those things when it happens, you see it and you
1:27:13just realize it's binary. Like all of a sudden you're editing DNA inside of T
1:27:13just realize it's binary. Like all of a sudden you're editing DNA inside of T
1:27:13just realize it's binary. Like all of a sudden you're editing DNA inside of T
1:27:13just realize it's binary. Like all of a sudden you're editing DNA inside of T
1:27:13just realize it's binary. Like all of a sudden you're editing DNA inside of T
1:27:19cells. And it was a little bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19cells. And it was a little bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19cells. And it was a little bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19cells. And it was a little bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19cells. And it was a little bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a You know, we
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a You know, we
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a You know, we
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a You know, we
1:27:19bit of a bit of a bit of a bit of a You know, we
1:27:20got our foot in the door with some level of efficiency.
1:27:20got our foot in the door with some level of efficiency.
1:27:20got our foot in the door with some level of efficiency.
1:27:20got our foot in the door with some level of efficiency.
1:27:20got our foot in the door with some level of efficiency.
1:27:22We've gone through the roof.
1:27:22We've gone through the roof.
1:27:22We've gone through the roof.
1:27:22We've gone through the roof.
1:27:22We've gone through the roof.
1:27:23This is now used by labs widely, and it's incredibly efficient.
1:27:23This is now used by labs widely, and it's incredibly efficient.
1:27:23This is now used by labs widely, and it's incredibly efficient.
1:27:23This is now used by labs widely, and it's incredibly efficient.
1:27:23This is now used by labs widely, and it's incredibly efficient.
1:27:29And some cells die, but overwhelmingly you end up with cells that are gene -edited.
1:27:29And some cells die, but overwhelmingly you end up with cells that are gene -edited.
1:27:29And some cells die, but overwhelmingly you end up with cells that are gene -edited.
1:27:29And some cells die, but overwhelmingly you end up with cells that are gene -edited.
1:27:29And some cells die, but overwhelmingly you end up with cells that are gene -edited.
1:27:34She figured out the protocol.
1:27:34She figured out the protocol.
1:27:34She figured out the protocol.
1:27:34She figured out the protocol.
1:27:34She figured out the protocol.
1:27:36She really did, and it's been optimized.
1:27:36She really did, and it's been optimized.
1:27:36She really did, and it's been optimized.
1:27:36She really did, and it's been optimized.
1:27:36She really did, and it's been optimized.
1:27:38And then another grad student in my lab came in, this guy, amazing grad student,
1:27:38And then another grad student in my lab came in, this guy, amazing grad student,
1:27:38And then another grad student in my lab came in, this guy, amazing grad student,
1:27:38And then another grad student in my lab came in, this guy, amazing grad student,
1:27:38And then another grad student in my lab came in, this guy, amazing grad student,
1:27:41Theo Roth, and realized that he didn't have to stop there, that we thought we
1:27:41Theo Roth, and realized that he didn't have to stop there, that we thought we
1:27:41Theo Roth, and realized that he didn't have to stop there, that we thought we
1:27:41Theo Roth, and realized that he didn't have to stop there, that we thought we
1:27:41Theo Roth, and realized that he didn't have to stop there, that we thought we
1:27:45were limited to just putting CRISPR in and these very small pieces of DNA called
1:27:45were limited to just putting CRISPR in and these very small pieces of DNA called
1:27:45were limited to just putting CRISPR in and these very small pieces of DNA called
1:27:45were limited to just putting CRISPR in and these very small pieces of DNA called
1:27:45were limited to just putting CRISPR in and these very small pieces of DNA called
1:27:49oligonucleotides that were just changed a couple of nucleotides at a time.
1:27:49oligonucleotides that were just changed a couple of nucleotides at a time.
1:27:49oligonucleotides that were just changed a couple of nucleotides at a time.
1:27:49oligonucleotides that were just changed a couple of nucleotides at a time.
1:27:49oligonucleotides that were just changed a couple of nucleotides at a time.
1:27:53Our mindset was like, maybe we can fix a mutation, an individual mutation.
1:27:53Our mindset was like, maybe we can fix a mutation, an individual mutation.
1:27:53Our mindset was like, maybe we can fix a mutation, an individual mutation.
1:27:53Our mindset was like, maybe we can fix a mutation, an individual mutation.
1:27:53Our mindset was like, maybe we can fix a mutation, an individual mutation.
1:27:57Theo said, let's not stop there.
1:27:57Theo said, let's not stop there.
1:27:57Theo said, let's not stop there.
1:27:57Theo said, let's not stop there.
1:27:57Theo said, let's not stop there.
1:27:58Let's put big pieces of DNA in.
1:27:58Let's put big pieces of DNA in.
1:27:58Let's put big pieces of DNA in.
1:27:58Let's put big pieces of DNA in.
1:27:58Let's put big pieces of DNA in.
1:28:00And we've pushed this boundary of being able to say, let's pick a site, make
1:28:00And we've pushed this boundary of being able to say, let's pick a site, make
1:28:00And we've pushed this boundary of being able to say, let's pick a site, make
1:28:00And we've pushed this boundary of being able to say, let's pick a site, make
1:28:00And we've pushed this boundary of being able to say, let's pick a site, make
1:28:03a cut, and introduce hundreds or up to thousands of different nucleotides to be able
1:28:03a cut, and introduce hundreds or up to thousands of different nucleotides to be able
1:28:03a cut, and introduce hundreds or up to thousands of different nucleotides to be able
1:28:03a cut, and introduce hundreds or up to thousands of different nucleotides to be able
1:28:03a cut, and introduce hundreds or up to thousands of different nucleotides to be able
1:28:09to really write a piece of DNA code that doesn't even have to exist in
1:28:09to really write a piece of DNA code that doesn't even have to exist in
1:28:09to really write a piece of DNA code that doesn't even have to exist in
1:28:09to really write a piece of DNA code that doesn't even have to exist in
1:28:09to really write a piece of DNA code that doesn't even have to exist in
1:28:12nature. But then we have the precision using CRISPR to put it into a particular
1:28:12nature. But then we have the precision using CRISPR to put it into a particular
1:28:12nature. But then we have the precision using CRISPR to put it into a particular
1:28:12nature. But then we have the precision using CRISPR to put it into a particular
1:28:12nature. But then we have the precision using CRISPR to put it into a particular
1:28:16place in the DNA. We started a company when that technology worked, a company called
1:28:16place in the DNA. We started a company when that technology worked, a company called
1:28:16place in the DNA. We started a company when that technology worked, a company called
1:28:16place in the DNA. We started a company when that technology worked, a company called
1:28:16place in the DNA. We started a company when that technology worked, a company called
1:28:22Arsenal Biosciences that's now in clinical trials.
1:28:22Arsenal Biosciences that's now in clinical trials.
1:28:22Arsenal Biosciences that's now in clinical trials.
1:28:22Arsenal Biosciences that's now in clinical trials.
1:28:22Arsenal Biosciences that's now in clinical trials.
1:28:26It's actually in its third clinical trial right now for solid tumors.
1:28:26It's actually in its third clinical trial right now for solid tumors.
1:28:26It's actually in its third clinical trial right now for solid tumors.
1:28:26It's actually in its third clinical trial right now for solid tumors.
1:28:26It's actually in its third clinical trial right now for solid tumors.
1:28:30It's in a clinical trial for prostate cancer that's about to start enrolling patients.
1:28:30It's in a clinical trial for prostate cancer that's about to start enrolling patients.
1:28:30It's in a clinical trial for prostate cancer that's about to start enrolling patients.
1:28:30It's in a clinical trial for prostate cancer that's about to start enrolling patients.
1:28:30It's in a clinical trial for prostate cancer that's about to start enrolling patients.
1:28:34And that company can now do this at industrial scale.
1:28:34And that company can now do this at industrial scale.
1:28:34And that company can now do this at industrial scale.
1:28:34And that company can now do this at industrial scale.
1:28:34And that company can now do this at industrial scale.
1:28:38It takes patient cells, electroporates them, and has now ridden a long piece of like
1:28:38It takes patient cells, electroporates them, and has now ridden a long piece of like
1:28:38It takes patient cells, electroporates them, and has now ridden a long piece of like
1:28:38It takes patient cells, electroporates them, and has now ridden a long piece of like
1:28:38It takes patient cells, electroporates them, and has now ridden a long piece of like
1:28:4410 ,000 nucleotides of DNA code that put in a sequence of a combination of
1:28:4410 ,000 nucleotides of DNA code that put in a sequence of a combination of
1:28:4410 ,000 nucleotides of DNA code that put in a sequence of a combination of
1:28:4410 ,000 nucleotides of DNA code that put in a sequence of a combination of
1:28:4410 ,000 nucleotides of DNA code that put in a sequence of a combination of
1:28:51different receptors, including a car, and additional gene enhancements that will make these T cells
1:28:51different receptors, including a car, and additional gene enhancements that will make these T cells
1:28:51different receptors, including a car, and additional gene enhancements that will make these T cells
1:28:51different receptors, including a car, and additional gene enhancements that will make these T cells
1:28:51different receptors, including a car, and additional gene enhancements that will make these T cells
1:28:58more powerful in a tumor microenvironment.
1:28:58more powerful in a tumor microenvironment.
1:28:58more powerful in a tumor microenvironment.
1:28:58more powerful in a tumor microenvironment.
1:28:58more powerful in a tumor microenvironment.
1:29:01And then they go into the bloodstream.
1:29:01And then they go into the bloodstream.
1:29:01And then they go into the bloodstream.
1:29:01And then they go into the bloodstream.
1:29:01And then they go into the bloodstream.
1:29:02They navigate to the prostate, and they start fighting the cancer cells.
1:29:02They navigate to the prostate, and they start fighting the cancer cells.
1:29:02They navigate to the prostate, and they start fighting the cancer cells.
1:29:02They navigate to the prostate, and they start fighting the cancer cells.
1:29:02They navigate to the prostate, and they start fighting the cancer cells.
1:29:07And I imagine you can also put...
1:29:07And I imagine you can also put...
1:29:07And I imagine you can also put...
1:29:07And I imagine you can also put...
1:29:07And I imagine you can also put...
1:29:09It sounds like you're putting some kind of resilience genes in there as well.
1:29:09It sounds like you're putting some kind of resilience genes in there as well.
1:29:09It sounds like you're putting some kind of resilience genes in there as well.
1:29:09It sounds like you're putting some kind of resilience genes in there as well.
1:29:09It sounds like you're putting some kind of resilience genes in there as well.
1:29:12Yeah, that's exactly right. To bolster the healthy cells.
1:29:12Yeah, that's exactly right. To bolster the healthy cells.
1:29:12Yeah, that's exactly right. To bolster the healthy cells.
1:29:12Yeah, that's exactly right. To bolster the healthy cells.
1:29:12Yeah, that's exactly right. To bolster the healthy cells.
1:29:14To bolster the T cells that carry these receptors.
1:29:14To bolster the T cells that carry these receptors.
1:29:14To bolster the T cells that carry these receptors.
1:29:14To bolster the T cells that carry these receptors.
1:29:14To bolster the T cells that carry these receptors.
1:29:18Got it. To make them persist longer.
1:29:18Got it. To make them persist longer.
1:29:18Got it. To make them persist longer.
1:29:18Got it. To make them persist longer.
1:29:18Got it. To make them persist longer.
1:29:19Better warriors. And be able to...
1:29:19Better warriors. And be able to...
1:29:19Better warriors. And be able to...
1:29:19Better warriors. And be able to...
1:29:19Better warriors. And be able to...
1:29:20Exactly. Awesome. That's happening. And the way that that happens is that a patient will
1:29:20Exactly. Awesome. That's happening. And the way that that happens is that a patient will
1:29:20Exactly. Awesome. That's happening. And the way that that happens is that a patient will
1:29:20Exactly. Awesome. That's happening. And the way that that happens is that a patient will
1:29:20Exactly. Awesome. That's happening. And the way that that happens is that a patient will
1:29:27be selected, will go in for a blood donation, give a rather large blood donation,
1:29:27be selected, will go in for a blood donation, give a rather large blood donation,
1:29:27be selected, will go in for a blood donation, give a rather large blood donation,
1:29:27be selected, will go in for a blood donation, give a rather large blood donation,
1:29:27be selected, will go in for a blood donation, give a rather large blood donation,
1:29:33but those cells are then shipped to a facility that Arsenal maintains.
1:29:33but those cells are then shipped to a facility that Arsenal maintains.
1:29:33but those cells are then shipped to a facility that Arsenal maintains.
1:29:33but those cells are then shipped to a facility that Arsenal maintains.
1:29:33but those cells are then shipped to a facility that Arsenal maintains.
1:29:38The electroporation happens in the centralized facilities.
1:29:38The electroporation happens in the centralized facilities.
1:29:38The electroporation happens in the centralized facilities.
1:29:38The electroporation happens in the centralized facilities.
1:29:38The electroporation happens in the centralized facilities.
1:29:40The cells get grown up for a couple of days and tested.
1:29:40The cells get grown up for a couple of days and tested.
1:29:40The cells get grown up for a couple of days and tested.
1:29:40The cells get grown up for a couple of days and tested.
1:29:40The cells get grown up for a couple of days and tested.
1:29:43They get frozen down and then sent back to the patient, where the cells are
1:29:43They get frozen down and then sent back to the patient, where the cells are
1:29:43They get frozen down and then sent back to the patient, where the cells are
1:29:43They get frozen down and then sent back to the patient, where the cells are
1:29:43They get frozen down and then sent back to the patient, where the cells are
1:29:46then thawed, and they get...
1:29:46then thawed, and they get...
1:29:46then thawed, and they get...
1:29:46then thawed, and they get...
1:29:46then thawed, and they get...
1:29:48It's the equivalent of a blood transfusion.
1:29:48It's the equivalent of a blood transfusion.
1:29:48It's the equivalent of a blood transfusion.
1:29:48It's the equivalent of a blood transfusion.
1:29:48It's the equivalent of a blood transfusion.
1:29:50Now their own cells have been supercharged to allow them to recognize cancer, but also
1:29:50Now their own cells have been supercharged to allow them to recognize cancer, but also
1:29:50Now their own cells have been supercharged to allow them to recognize cancer, but also
1:29:50Now their own cells have been supercharged to allow them to recognize cancer, but also
1:29:50Now their own cells have been supercharged to allow them to recognize cancer, but also
1:29:56to have, as you said, added resilience, added strength in that battle against cancer.
1:29:56to have, as you said, added resilience, added strength in that battle against cancer.
1:29:56to have, as you said, added resilience, added strength in that battle against cancer.
1:29:56to have, as you said, added resilience, added strength in that battle against cancer.
1:29:56to have, as you said, added resilience, added strength in that battle against cancer.
1:30:01The cells that have been modified by the CRISPR -Cas9, they're sitting in this bag,
1:30:01The cells that have been modified by the CRISPR -Cas9, they're sitting in this bag,
1:30:01The cells that have been modified by the CRISPR -Cas9, they're sitting in this bag,
1:30:01The cells that have been modified by the CRISPR -Cas9, they're sitting in this bag,
1:30:01The cells that have been modified by the CRISPR -Cas9, they're sitting in this bag,
1:30:06they get infused. Are they designed...
1:30:06they get infused. Are they designed...
1:30:06they get infused. Are they designed...
1:30:06they get infused. Are they designed...
1:30:06they get infused. Are they designed...
1:30:11Is the CRISPR designed to only go after the prostate cancer cells?
1:30:11Is the CRISPR designed to only go after the prostate cancer cells?
1:30:11Is the CRISPR designed to only go after the prostate cancer cells?
1:30:11Is the CRISPR designed to only go after the prostate cancer cells?
1:30:11Is the CRISPR designed to only go after the prostate cancer cells?
1:30:17Or is there some version of this where you can inoculate against a number of
1:30:17Or is there some version of this where you can inoculate against a number of
1:30:17Or is there some version of this where you can inoculate against a number of
1:30:17Or is there some version of this where you can inoculate against a number of
1:30:17Or is there some version of this where you can inoculate against a number of
1:30:22different cancers? In other words, if I'm understanding correctly, if there are sort of canonical
1:30:22different cancers? In other words, if I'm understanding correctly, if there are sort of canonical
1:30:22different cancers? In other words, if I'm understanding correctly, if there are sort of canonical
1:30:22different cancers? In other words, if I'm understanding correctly, if there are sort of canonical
1:30:22different cancers? In other words, if I'm understanding correctly, if there are sort of canonical
1:30:29mutation sequences that occur in all cancerous cells, is there a version of this where
1:30:29mutation sequences that occur in all cancerous cells, is there a version of this where
1:30:29mutation sequences that occur in all cancerous cells, is there a version of this where
1:30:29mutation sequences that occur in all cancerous cells, is there a version of this where
1:30:29mutation sequences that occur in all cancerous cells, is there a version of this where
1:30:37I give some blood, you are a company, probably a company, electroporates them with the
1:30:37I give some blood, you are a company, probably a company, electroporates them with the
1:30:37I give some blood, you are a company, probably a company, electroporates them with the
1:30:37I give some blood, you are a company, probably a company, electroporates them with the
1:30:37I give some blood, you are a company, probably a company, electroporates them with the
1:30:44CRISPR -Cas9 system, brings in resilience genes for the T -cells, for my T -cells,
1:30:44CRISPR -Cas9 system, brings in resilience genes for the T -cells, for my T -cells,
1:30:44CRISPR -Cas9 system, brings in resilience genes for the T -cells, for my T -cells,
1:30:44CRISPR -Cas9 system, brings in resilience genes for the T -cells, for my T -cells,
1:30:44CRISPR -Cas9 system, brings in resilience genes for the T -cells, for my T -cells,
1:30:53plus some attack genes, right?
1:30:53plus some attack genes, right?
1:30:53plus some attack genes, right?
1:30:53plus some attack genes, right?
1:30:53plus some attack genes, right?
1:30:57So that are going to destroy the cancer cells.
1:30:57So that are going to destroy the cancer cells.
1:30:57So that are going to destroy the cancer cells.
1:30:57So that are going to destroy the cancer cells.
1:30:57So that are going to destroy the cancer cells.
1:30:59And then I get an infusion of these when I turn, well, I'm 50 now,
1:30:59And then I get an infusion of these when I turn, well, I'm 50 now,
1:30:59And then I get an infusion of these when I turn, well, I'm 50 now,
1:30:59And then I get an infusion of these when I turn, well, I'm 50 now,
1:30:59And then I get an infusion of these when I turn, well, I'm 50 now,
1:31:03so like 52. And then it protects against all cancers that probably are forming at
1:31:03so like 52. And then it protects against all cancers that probably are forming at
1:31:03so like 52. And then it protects against all cancers that probably are forming at
1:31:03so like 52. And then it protects against all cancers that probably are forming at
1:31:03so like 52. And then it protects against all cancers that probably are forming at
1:31:08multiple sites throughout my body, low mutations here, low mutations there.
1:31:08multiple sites throughout my body, low mutations here, low mutations there.
1:31:08multiple sites throughout my body, low mutations here, low mutations there.
1:31:08multiple sites throughout my body, low mutations here, low mutations there.
1:31:08multiple sites throughout my body, low mutations here, low mutations there.
1:31:11Hopefully they don't proliferate, but is there a way to just short -circuit cancer body
1:31:11Hopefully they don't proliferate, but is there a way to just short -circuit cancer body
1:31:11Hopefully they don't proliferate, but is there a way to just short -circuit cancer body
1:31:11Hopefully they don't proliferate, but is there a way to just short -circuit cancer body
1:31:11Hopefully they don't proliferate, but is there a way to just short -circuit cancer body
1:31:17-wide? I think that's a hope that all of us have to some extent.
1:31:17-wide? I think that's a hope that all of us have to some extent.
1:31:17-wide? I think that's a hope that all of us have to some extent.
1:31:17-wide? I think that's a hope that all of us have to some extent.
1:31:17-wide? I think that's a hope that all of us have to some extent.
1:31:21I think these technologies get proven out in patients where the risk -benefit of an
1:31:21I think these technologies get proven out in patients where the risk -benefit of an
1:31:21I think these technologies get proven out in patients where the risk -benefit of an
1:31:21I think these technologies get proven out in patients where the risk -benefit of an
1:31:28unproven technology is tolerated. And I think that in reality, that means that patients who
1:31:28unproven technology is tolerated. And I think that in reality, that means that patients who
1:31:28unproven technology is tolerated. And I think that in reality, that means that patients who
1:31:28unproven technology is tolerated. And I think that in reality, that means that patients who
1:31:36have exhausted other treatment opportunities get treated, and often those are the sickest patients.
1:31:36have exhausted other treatment opportunities get treated, and often those are the sickest patients.
1:31:36have exhausted other treatment opportunities get treated, and often those are the sickest patients.
1:31:36have exhausted other treatment opportunities get treated, and often those are the sickest patients.
1:31:41And I think there's good reasons for ethics where that's where we start.
1:31:41And I think there's good reasons for ethics where that's where we start.
1:31:41And I think there's good reasons for ethics where that's where we start.
1:31:41And I think there's good reasons for ethics where that's where we start.
1:31:45But our hope is that these technologies eventually will be proven to be safe, because
1:31:45But our hope is that these technologies eventually will be proven to be safe, because
1:31:45But our hope is that these technologies eventually will be proven to be safe, because
1:31:45But our hope is that these technologies eventually will be proven to be safe, because
1:31:50they'll get more and more precise.
1:31:50they'll get more and more precise.
1:31:50they'll get more and more precise.
1:31:50they'll get more and more precise.
1:31:51I hope the cost would go down.
1:31:51I hope the cost would go down.
1:31:51I hope the cost would go down.
1:31:51I hope the cost would go down.
1:31:53And I don't know, you know, you talk about the other extreme of doing it
1:31:53And I don't know, you know, you talk about the other extreme of doing it
1:31:53And I don't know, you know, you talk about the other extreme of doing it
1:31:53And I don't know, you know, you talk about the other extreme of doing it
1:31:57preventatively, but at least we should start marching earlier and earlier in the course of
1:31:57preventatively, but at least we should start marching earlier and earlier in the course of
1:31:57preventatively, but at least we should start marching earlier and earlier in the course of
1:31:57preventatively, but at least we should start marching earlier and earlier in the course of
1:32:02diagnosis. And the hope is that, you know, we're already seeing improved tools for early
1:32:02diagnosis. And the hope is that, you know, we're already seeing improved tools for early
1:32:02diagnosis. And the hope is that, you know, we're already seeing improved tools for early
1:32:02diagnosis. And the hope is that, you know, we're already seeing improved tools for early
1:32:08diagnosis of cancer where we're detecting the earlier signs of cancer.
1:32:08diagnosis of cancer where we're detecting the earlier signs of cancer.
1:32:08diagnosis of cancer where we're detecting the earlier signs of cancer.
1:32:08diagnosis of cancer where we're detecting the earlier signs of cancer.
1:32:12It'd be nice if we have the ability to start treating those early cancers that
1:32:12It'd be nice if we have the ability to start treating those early cancers that
1:32:12It'd be nice if we have the ability to start treating those early cancers that
1:32:12It'd be nice if we have the ability to start treating those early cancers that
1:32:17might be the ones that are the most responsive to the immune system.
1:32:17might be the ones that are the most responsive to the immune system.
1:32:17might be the ones that are the most responsive to the immune system.
1:32:17might be the ones that are the most responsive to the immune system.
1:32:20And then beyond that, preventative would be even better.
1:32:20And then beyond that, preventative would be even better.
1:32:20And then beyond that, preventative would be even better.
1:32:20And then beyond that, preventative would be even better.
1:32:25I think to get there, if we really want to scale up, I think we
1:32:25I think to get there, if we really want to scale up, I think we
1:32:25I think to get there, if we really want to scale up, I think we
1:32:25I think to get there, if we really want to scale up, I think we
1:32:30also have to think about you sort of going back to your last question about
1:32:30also have to think about you sort of going back to your last question about
1:32:30also have to think about you sort of going back to your last question about
1:32:30also have to think about you sort of going back to your last question about
1:32:33delivery. Maybe it's not always going to be these cells getting shipped to a centralized
1:32:33delivery. Maybe it's not always going to be these cells getting shipped to a centralized
1:32:33delivery. Maybe it's not always going to be these cells getting shipped to a centralized
1:32:33delivery. Maybe it's not always going to be these cells getting shipped to a centralized
1:32:38factory and electroparated, although that's been incredibly powerful and it's not stopping now.
1:32:38factory and electroparated, although that's been incredibly powerful and it's not stopping now.
1:32:38factory and electroparated, although that's been incredibly powerful and it's not stopping now.
1:32:38factory and electroparated, although that's been incredibly powerful and it's not stopping now.
1:32:43We're actually starting academically in an...
1:32:43We're actually starting academically in an...
1:32:43We're actually starting academically in an...
1:32:43We're actually starting academically in an...
1:32:47Institute that I run, the Gladstone UCSF Institute of Genomic Immunology.
1:32:47Institute that I run, the Gladstone UCSF Institute of Genomic Immunology.
1:32:47Institute that I run, the Gladstone UCSF Institute of Genomic Immunology.
1:32:47Institute that I run, the Gladstone UCSF Institute of Genomic Immunology.
1:32:50We're starting a philanthropically funded CRISPR trial for multiple myeloma where we're using a different
1:32:50We're starting a philanthropically funded CRISPR trial for multiple myeloma where we're using a different
1:32:50We're starting a philanthropically funded CRISPR trial for multiple myeloma where we're using a different
1:32:50We're starting a philanthropically funded CRISPR trial for multiple myeloma where we're using a different
1:32:56genetic program. So there's a huge number of diseases where we are thinking about what
1:32:56genetic program. So there's a huge number of diseases where we are thinking about what
1:32:56genetic program. So there's a huge number of diseases where we are thinking about what
1:32:56genetic program. So there's a huge number of diseases where we are thinking about what
1:33:01can we do with existing technologies.
1:33:01can we do with existing technologies.
1:33:01can we do with existing technologies.
1:33:01can we do with existing technologies.
1:33:03We're also starting to look for ways that the deliveries of the future will happen.
1:33:03We're also starting to look for ways that the deliveries of the future will happen.
1:33:03We're also starting to look for ways that the deliveries of the future will happen.
1:33:03We're also starting to look for ways that the deliveries of the future will happen.
1:33:08And different people are coming up with different solutions, but one emerging trend is that
1:33:08And different people are coming up with different solutions, but one emerging trend is that
1:33:08And different people are coming up with different solutions, but one emerging trend is that
1:33:08And different people are coming up with different solutions, but one emerging trend is that
1:33:14rather than taking the cells out of the body, and then exposing them to CRISPR
1:33:14rather than taking the cells out of the body, and then exposing them to CRISPR
1:33:14rather than taking the cells out of the body, and then exposing them to CRISPR
1:33:14rather than taking the cells out of the body, and then exposing them to CRISPR
1:33:18in these targeted ways with electroporation, what if we could put CRISPR into the body
1:33:18in these targeted ways with electroporation, what if we could put CRISPR into the body
1:33:18in these targeted ways with electroporation, what if we could put CRISPR into the body
1:33:18in these targeted ways with electroporation, what if we could put CRISPR into the body
1:33:23and just send it and address it just to the cells that we want to
1:33:23and just send it and address it just to the cells that we want to
1:33:23and just send it and address it just to the cells that we want to
1:33:23and just send it and address it just to the cells that we want to
1:33:27modify? We're interested in the T cells.
1:33:27modify? We're interested in the T cells.
1:33:27modify? We're interested in the T cells.
1:33:27modify? We're interested in the T cells.
1:33:29Someone else might be interested in modifying lung or heart or neurons, right, for different
1:33:29Someone else might be interested in modifying lung or heart or neurons, right, for different
1:33:29Someone else might be interested in modifying lung or heart or neurons, right, for different
1:33:29Someone else might be interested in modifying lung or heart or neurons, right, for different
1:33:35diseases. And that is a field that is now exploding.
1:33:35diseases. And that is a field that is now exploding.
1:33:35diseases. And that is a field that is now exploding.
1:33:35diseases. And that is a field that is now exploding.
1:33:41Thinking about technologies, it's another area where there's just tools that are happening so fast.
1:33:41Thinking about technologies, it's another area where there's just tools that are happening so fast.
1:33:41Thinking about technologies, it's another area where there's just tools that are happening so fast.
1:33:41Thinking about technologies, it's another area where there's just tools that are happening so fast.
1:33:47You know, when I was a postdoc, it was all about, it seemed, for a
1:33:47You know, when I was a postdoc, it was all about, it seemed, for a
1:33:47You know, when I was a postdoc, it was all about, it seemed, for a
1:33:47You know, when I was a postdoc, it was all about, it seemed, for a
1:33:51few years, like different ways to get genes into cells.
1:33:51few years, like different ways to get genes into cells.
1:33:51few years, like different ways to get genes into cells.
1:33:51few years, like different ways to get genes into cells.
1:33:55So there's electroporation, there are lentiviruses, there are adenoviruses, there are calcium phosphate transfection, there
1:33:55So there's electroporation, there are lentiviruses, there are adenoviruses, there are calcium phosphate transfection, there
1:33:55So there's electroporation, there are lentiviruses, there are adenoviruses, there are calcium phosphate transfection, there
1:33:55So there's electroporation, there are lentiviruses, there are adenoviruses, there are calcium phosphate transfection, there
1:34:01was an on and on.
1:34:01was an on and on.
1:34:01was an on and on.
1:34:01was an on and on.
1:34:02One of the things that was kind of interesting but at the time didn't really
1:34:02One of the things that was kind of interesting but at the time didn't really
1:34:02One of the things that was kind of interesting but at the time didn't really
1:34:02One of the things that was kind of interesting but at the time didn't really
1:34:06go anywhere was customize little liposomes, like little fatty bubbles because fatty stuff can get
1:34:06go anywhere was customize little liposomes, like little fatty bubbles because fatty stuff can get
1:34:06go anywhere was customize little liposomes, like little fatty bubbles because fatty stuff can get
1:34:06go anywhere was customize little liposomes, like little fatty bubbles because fatty stuff can get
1:34:14onto and through cell membranes, so it makes good sense.
1:34:14onto and through cell membranes, so it makes good sense.
1:34:14onto and through cell membranes, so it makes good sense.
1:34:14onto and through cell membranes, so it makes good sense.
1:34:17But with some sort of zip coding so that you could inject these fatty bubbles
1:34:17But with some sort of zip coding so that you could inject these fatty bubbles
1:34:17But with some sort of zip coding so that you could inject these fatty bubbles
1:34:17But with some sort of zip coding so that you could inject these fatty bubbles
1:34:22or swallow them even, get them into the bloodstream, and then those fatty bubbles would
1:34:22or swallow them even, get them into the bloodstream, and then those fatty bubbles would
1:34:22or swallow them even, get them into the bloodstream, and then those fatty bubbles would
1:34:22or swallow them even, get them into the bloodstream, and then those fatty bubbles would
1:34:27go to the very specific type of liver cell or brain cell that you wanted.
1:34:27go to the very specific type of liver cell or brain cell that you wanted.
1:34:27go to the very specific type of liver cell or brain cell that you wanted.
1:34:27go to the very specific type of liver cell or brain cell that you wanted.
1:34:30Has that technology moved forward at all, the liposome technology?
1:34:30Has that technology moved forward at all, the liposome technology?
1:34:30Has that technology moved forward at all, the liposome technology?
1:34:30Has that technology moved forward at all, the liposome technology?
1:34:33Dramatically. Oh, great. Dramatically. Relieved to hear and relieved to hear I wasn't the one
1:34:33Dramatically. Oh, great. Dramatically. Relieved to hear and relieved to hear I wasn't the one
1:34:33Dramatically. Oh, great. Dramatically. Relieved to hear and relieved to hear I wasn't the one
1:34:33Dramatically. Oh, great. Dramatically. Relieved to hear and relieved to hear I wasn't the one
1:34:38that had to do the work because I knew a lot of very frustrated people
1:34:38that had to do the work because I knew a lot of very frustrated people
1:34:38that had to do the work because I knew a lot of very frustrated people
1:34:38that had to do the work because I knew a lot of very frustrated people
1:34:41working on liposomes. Fortunately for me, electroporation adenoviruses worked spectacularly well for my experiments, but
1:34:41working on liposomes. Fortunately for me, electroporation adenoviruses worked spectacularly well for my experiments, but
1:34:41working on liposomes. Fortunately for me, electroporation adenoviruses worked spectacularly well for my experiments, but
1:34:41working on liposomes. Fortunately for me, electroporation adenoviruses worked spectacularly well for my experiments, but
1:34:48a lot of people needed cell type specific transfection through a vein injection.
1:34:48a lot of people needed cell type specific transfection through a vein injection.
1:34:48a lot of people needed cell type specific transfection through a vein injection.
1:34:48a lot of people needed cell type specific transfection through a vein injection.
1:34:56So all of these things have gone under rapid progress.
1:34:56So all of these things have gone under rapid progress.
1:34:56So all of these things have gone under rapid progress.
1:34:56So all of these things have gone under rapid progress.
1:35:01Let's talk about the viruses.
1:35:01Let's talk about the viruses.
1:35:01Let's talk about the viruses.
1:35:01Let's talk about the viruses.
1:35:02We talked about viruses as a tool, as a shuttle of DNA.
1:35:02We talked about viruses as a tool, as a shuttle of DNA.
1:35:02We talked about viruses as a tool, as a shuttle of DNA.
1:35:02We talked about viruses as a tool, as a shuttle of DNA.
1:35:07They naturally, each one will have some range of what cells it would infect.
1:35:07They naturally, each one will have some range of what cells it would infect.
1:35:07They naturally, each one will have some range of what cells it would infect.
1:35:07They naturally, each one will have some range of what cells it would infect.
1:35:11For a virus, this is called tropism.
1:35:11For a virus, this is called tropism.
1:35:11For a virus, this is called tropism.
1:35:11For a virus, this is called tropism.
1:35:14What cells are susceptible to infection with any virus?
1:35:14What cells are susceptible to infection with any virus?
1:35:14What cells are susceptible to infection with any virus?
1:35:14What cells are susceptible to infection with any virus?
1:35:17Those would be the cells that you would be able to deliver genetic material to
1:35:17Those would be the cells that you would be able to deliver genetic material to
1:35:17Those would be the cells that you would be able to deliver genetic material to
1:35:17Those would be the cells that you would be able to deliver genetic material to
1:35:20with an engineered virus. People have really advanced engineered tropism, engineering what cells a virus
1:35:20with an engineered virus. People have really advanced engineered tropism, engineering what cells a virus
1:35:20with an engineered virus. People have really advanced engineered tropism, engineering what cells a virus
1:35:20with an engineered virus. People have really advanced engineered tropism, engineering what cells a virus
1:35:28will deliver material to. And that can be dialed in quite precisely now in a
1:35:28will deliver material to. And that can be dialed in quite precisely now in a
1:35:28will deliver material to. And that can be dialed in quite precisely now in a
1:35:28will deliver material to. And that can be dialed in quite precisely now in a
1:35:33number of different ways. So people are working on engineered viruses that try, there's still
1:35:33number of different ways. So people are working on engineered viruses that try, there's still
1:35:33number of different ways. So people are working on engineered viruses that try, there's still
1:35:33number of different ways. So people are working on engineered viruses that try, there's still
1:35:38problems trying to make sure that they don't trigger immune responses, but they're getting more
1:35:38problems trying to make sure that they don't trigger immune responses, but they're getting more
1:35:38problems trying to make sure that they don't trigger immune responses, but they're getting more
1:35:38problems trying to make sure that they don't trigger immune responses, but they're getting more
1:35:42and more precise, both viruses and things that have virus -like properties that are sometimes
1:35:42and more precise, both viruses and things that have virus -like properties that are sometimes
1:35:42and more precise, both viruses and things that have virus -like properties that are sometimes
1:35:42and more precise, both viruses and things that have virus -like properties that are sometimes
1:35:47called virus -like particles that are essentially viruses that can just deliver either DNA or
1:35:47called virus -like particles that are essentially viruses that can just deliver either DNA or
1:35:47called virus -like particles that are essentially viruses that can just deliver either DNA or
1:35:47called virus -like particles that are essentially viruses that can just deliver either DNA or
1:35:52protein to a cell that's specified by what that virus tropism is.
1:35:52protein to a cell that's specified by what that virus tropism is.
1:35:52protein to a cell that's specified by what that virus tropism is.
1:35:52protein to a cell that's specified by what that virus tropism is.
1:35:57And people are working on engineering these tropisms with a lot of technologies.
1:35:57And people are working on engineering these tropisms with a lot of technologies.
1:35:57And people are working on engineering these tropisms with a lot of technologies.
1:35:57And people are working on engineering these tropisms with a lot of technologies.
1:36:01Because you could put drugs in them too.
1:36:01Because you could put drugs in them too.
1:36:01Because you could put drugs in them too.
1:36:01Because you could put drugs in them too.
1:36:03I mean, we talk about SSRIs have all these side effects.
1:36:03I mean, we talk about SSRIs have all these side effects.
1:36:03I mean, we talk about SSRIs have all these side effects.
1:36:03I mean, we talk about SSRIs have all these side effects.
1:36:06Well, that's because you're getting serotonin increases at locations you don't want it.
1:36:06Well, that's because you're getting serotonin increases at locations you don't want it.
1:36:06Well, that's because you're getting serotonin increases at locations you don't want it.
1:36:06Well, that's because you're getting serotonin increases at locations you don't want it.
1:36:13Like you could imagine only getting drugs to certain cells.
1:36:13Like you could imagine only getting drugs to certain cells.
1:36:13Like you could imagine only getting drugs to certain cells.
1:36:13Like you could imagine only getting drugs to certain cells.
1:36:16To me, it's super exciting and just seems so fundamental.
1:36:16To me, it's super exciting and just seems so fundamental.
1:36:16To me, it's super exciting and just seems so fundamental.
1:36:16To me, it's super exciting and just seems so fundamental.
1:36:20So I'm relieved to hear that there's progress being made.
1:36:20So I'm relieved to hear that there's progress being made.
1:36:20So I'm relieved to hear that there's progress being made.
1:36:20So I'm relieved to hear that there's progress being made.
1:36:23Anything that can be genetically encoded, you can start imagining these types of targeting.
1:36:23Anything that can be genetically encoded, you can start imagining these types of targeting.
1:36:23Anything that can be genetically encoded, you can start imagining these types of targeting.
1:36:23Anything that can be genetically encoded, you can start imagining these types of targeting.
1:36:27Now, you asked about liposomes.
1:36:27Now, you asked about liposomes.
1:36:27Now, you asked about liposomes.
1:36:27Now, you asked about liposomes.
1:36:30Now, liposomes have kind of come up with our new name is lipid nanoparticles.
1:36:30Now, liposomes have kind of come up with our new name is lipid nanoparticles.
1:36:30Now, liposomes have kind of come up with our new name is lipid nanoparticles.
1:36:30Now, liposomes have kind of come up with our new name is lipid nanoparticles.
1:36:35Lipid nanoparticles. That kind of rolls off the tongue nicely.
1:36:35Lipid nanoparticles. That kind of rolls off the tongue nicely.
1:36:35Lipid nanoparticles. That kind of rolls off the tongue nicely.
1:36:35Lipid nanoparticles. That kind of rolls off the tongue nicely.
1:36:37And the abbreviation we use is LNPs, but a billion people around the world have
1:36:37And the abbreviation we use is LNPs, but a billion people around the world have
1:36:37And the abbreviation we use is LNPs, but a billion people around the world have
1:36:37And the abbreviation we use is LNPs, but a billion people around the world have
1:36:43now been injected with LNPs.
1:36:43now been injected with LNPs.
1:36:43now been injected with LNPs.
1:36:43now been injected with LNPs.
1:36:45LNPs are the technology that delivered mRNA vaccines.
1:36:45LNPs are the technology that delivered mRNA vaccines.
1:36:45LNPs are the technology that delivered mRNA vaccines.
1:36:45LNPs are the technology that delivered mRNA vaccines.
1:36:49Ah, okay. That'll raise some eyebrows.
1:36:49Ah, okay. That'll raise some eyebrows.
1:36:49Ah, okay. That'll raise some eyebrows.
1:36:49Ah, okay. That'll raise some eyebrows.
1:36:53No, we're going to talk about vaccines.
1:36:53No, we're going to talk about vaccines.
1:36:53No, we're going to talk about vaccines.
1:36:53No, we're going to talk about vaccines.
1:36:55Listen, we're going into it all today.
1:36:55Listen, we're going into it all today.
1:36:55Listen, we're going into it all today.
1:36:55Listen, we're going into it all today.
1:36:58They were liposome bound. Essentially, these are lipids that can deliver genetic material to cells.
1:36:58They were liposome bound. Essentially, these are lipids that can deliver genetic material to cells.
1:36:58They were liposome bound. Essentially, these are lipids that can deliver genetic material to cells.
1:36:58They were liposome bound. Essentially, these are lipids that can deliver genetic material to cells.
1:37:03And this was done locally for the COVID vaccine, but people are now engineering them
1:37:03And this was done locally for the COVID vaccine, but people are now engineering them
1:37:03And this was done locally for the COVID vaccine, but people are now engineering them
1:37:03And this was done locally for the COVID vaccine, but people are now engineering them
1:37:08with the targeting molecules that he described so that they go to particular cells.
1:37:08with the targeting molecules that he described so that they go to particular cells.
1:37:08with the targeting molecules that he described so that they go to particular cells.
1:37:08with the targeting molecules that he described so that they go to particular cells.
1:37:11If you inject them into the body, lipid nanoparticles naturally tend to go to the
1:37:11If you inject them into the body, lipid nanoparticles naturally tend to go to the
1:37:11If you inject them into the body, lipid nanoparticles naturally tend to go to the
1:37:11If you inject them into the body, lipid nanoparticles naturally tend to go to the
1:37:16liver. So people are using these already to cure genetic diseases where the genetic burden
1:37:16liver. So people are using these already to cure genetic diseases where the genetic burden
1:37:16liver. So people are using these already to cure genetic diseases where the genetic burden
1:37:16liver. So people are using these already to cure genetic diseases where the genetic burden
1:37:21is affecting the cells in the liver because you can deliver CRISPR to cells in
1:37:21is affecting the cells in the liver because you can deliver CRISPR to cells in
1:37:21is affecting the cells in the liver because you can deliver CRISPR to cells in
1:37:21is affecting the cells in the liver because you can deliver CRISPR to cells in
1:37:25the liver pretty robustly with these.
1:37:25the liver pretty robustly with these.
1:37:25the liver pretty robustly with these.
1:37:25the liver pretty robustly with these.
1:37:28I have my strong view on the COVID vaccine.
1:37:28I have my strong view on the COVID vaccine.
1:37:28I have my strong view on the COVID vaccine.
1:37:28I have my strong view on the COVID vaccine.
1:37:30I think it was a miracle that we were able to develop something on a
1:37:30I think it was a miracle that we were able to develop something on a
1:37:30I think it was a miracle that we were able to develop something on a
1:37:30I think it was a miracle that we were able to develop something on a
1:37:35short timeline to address a pandemic that was killing people.
1:37:35short timeline to address a pandemic that was killing people.
1:37:35short timeline to address a pandemic that was killing people.
1:37:35short timeline to address a pandemic that was killing people.
1:37:40But I understand there's controversy.
1:37:40But I understand there's controversy.
1:37:40But I understand there's controversy.
1:37:40But I understand there's controversy.
1:37:43Leaving that aside, lipid nanoparticles, it's amazing that we were able to do this, that
1:37:43Leaving that aside, lipid nanoparticles, it's amazing that we were able to do this, that
1:37:43Leaving that aside, lipid nanoparticles, it's amazing that we were able to do this, that
1:37:43Leaving that aside, lipid nanoparticles, it's amazing that we were able to do this, that
1:37:49we took something that was an idea.
1:37:49we took something that was an idea.
1:37:49we took something that was an idea.
1:37:49we took something that was an idea.
1:37:51Most people thought it would be an obscure technical thing.
1:37:51Most people thought it would be an obscure technical thing.
1:37:51Most people thought it would be an obscure technical thing.
1:37:51Most people thought it would be an obscure technical thing.
1:37:55Like you talked about, like, would it ever work?
1:37:55Like you talked about, like, would it ever work?
1:37:55Like you talked about, like, would it ever work?
1:37:55Like you talked about, like, would it ever work?
1:37:58All of a sudden, it could be manufactured at scale, could deliver a synthetic piece
1:37:58All of a sudden, it could be manufactured at scale, could deliver a synthetic piece
1:37:58All of a sudden, it could be manufactured at scale, could deliver a synthetic piece
1:37:58All of a sudden, it could be manufactured at scale, could deliver a synthetic piece
1:38:02of mRNA to give a temporary instruction to cells to make a protein to protect
1:38:02of mRNA to give a temporary instruction to cells to make a protein to protect
1:38:02of mRNA to give a temporary instruction to cells to make a protein to protect
1:38:02of mRNA to give a temporary instruction to cells to make a protein to protect
1:38:08us. And whether that's for COVID or for other things, all of a sudden, we're,
1:38:08us. And whether that's for COVID or for other things, all of a sudden, we're,
1:38:08us. And whether that's for COVID or for other things, all of a sudden, we're,
1:38:08us. And whether that's for COVID or for other things, all of a sudden, we're,
1:38:12again, I just keep coming back.
1:38:12again, I just keep coming back.
1:38:12again, I just keep coming back.
1:38:12again, I just keep coming back.
1:38:14back to this theme where there's more and more ways that we can not only
1:38:14back to this theme where there's more and more ways that we can not only
1:38:14back to this theme where there's more and more ways that we can not only
1:38:14back to this theme where there's more and more ways that we can not only
1:38:17understand biology, but that we can intervene in it to treat disease.
1:38:17understand biology, but that we can intervene in it to treat disease.
1:38:17understand biology, but that we can intervene in it to treat disease.
1:38:17understand biology, but that we can intervene in it to treat disease.
1:38:21And so now we're talking about something totally different.
1:38:21And so now we're talking about something totally different.
1:38:21And so now we're talking about something totally different.
1:38:21And so now we're talking about something totally different.
1:38:23We're talking about delivering CRISPR, which is not an mRNA vaccine, but we're talking about
1:38:23We're talking about delivering CRISPR, which is not an mRNA vaccine, but we're talking about
1:38:23We're talking about delivering CRISPR, which is not an mRNA vaccine, but we're talking about
1:38:23We're talking about delivering CRISPR, which is not an mRNA vaccine, but we're talking about
1:38:27how would we get CRISPR into cells or how would we get extra pieces of
1:38:27how would we get CRISPR into cells or how would we get extra pieces of
1:38:27how would we get CRISPR into cells or how would we get extra pieces of
1:38:27how would we get CRISPR into cells or how would we get extra pieces of
1:38:31genetic material, which might be an mRNA, so into a T cell.
1:38:31genetic material, which might be an mRNA, so into a T cell.
1:38:31genetic material, which might be an mRNA, so into a T cell.
1:38:31genetic material, which might be an mRNA, so into a T cell.
1:38:36All of this can now be done even beyond the vaccine world with the same
1:38:36All of this can now be done even beyond the vaccine world with the same
1:38:36All of this can now be done even beyond the vaccine world with the same
1:38:36All of this can now be done even beyond the vaccine world with the same
1:38:40kind of building blocks of technologies like lipid nanoparticles.
1:38:40kind of building blocks of technologies like lipid nanoparticles.
1:38:40kind of building blocks of technologies like lipid nanoparticles.
1:38:40kind of building blocks of technologies like lipid nanoparticles.
1:38:43Actually, there's a company out of the University of Pennsylvania that actually developed recently a
1:38:43Actually, there's a company out of the University of Pennsylvania that actually developed recently a
1:38:43Actually, there's a company out of the University of Pennsylvania that actually developed recently a
1:38:43Actually, there's a company out of the University of Pennsylvania that actually developed recently a
1:38:51technology to make lipid nanoparticles that could be injected into the bloodstream.
1:38:51technology to make lipid nanoparticles that could be injected into the bloodstream.
1:38:51technology to make lipid nanoparticles that could be injected into the bloodstream.
1:38:51technology to make lipid nanoparticles that could be injected into the bloodstream.
1:38:55Think of them as these little fat bubbles, exactly as you said.
1:38:55Think of them as these little fat bubbles, exactly as you said.
1:38:55Think of them as these little fat bubbles, exactly as you said.
1:38:55Think of them as these little fat bubbles, exactly as you said.
1:38:58But in them, they included a protein that would recognize something on the surface of
1:38:58But in them, they included a protein that would recognize something on the surface of
1:38:58But in them, they included a protein that would recognize something on the surface of
1:38:58But in them, they included a protein that would recognize something on the surface of
1:39:05T cells so that as these lipid bubbles were going through the blood, they would
1:39:05T cells so that as these lipid bubbles were going through the blood, they would
1:39:05T cells so that as these lipid bubbles were going through the blood, they would
1:39:05T cells so that as these lipid bubbles were going through the blood, they would
1:39:09stick preferentially to T cells and deliver mRNA to T cells.
1:39:09stick preferentially to T cells and deliver mRNA to T cells.
1:39:09stick preferentially to T cells and deliver mRNA to T cells.
1:39:09stick preferentially to T cells and deliver mRNA to T cells.
1:39:13And you could actually put in an mRNA into T cells that would temporarily make
1:39:13And you could actually put in an mRNA into T cells that would temporarily make
1:39:13And you could actually put in an mRNA into T cells that would temporarily make
1:39:13And you could actually put in an mRNA into T cells that would temporarily make
1:39:19a gene that would encode a CAR, these artificial receptors against cancer.
1:39:19a gene that would encode a CAR, these artificial receptors against cancer.
1:39:19a gene that would encode a CAR, these artificial receptors against cancer.
1:39:19a gene that would encode a CAR, these artificial receptors against cancer.
1:39:25And they've done this now in testing in a number of models.
1:39:25And they've done this now in testing in a number of models.
1:39:25And they've done this now in testing in a number of models.
1:39:25And they've done this now in testing in a number of models.
1:39:28They can actually make these CAR T cells by injecting lipid nanoparticles into the body
1:39:28They can actually make these CAR T cells by injecting lipid nanoparticles into the body
1:39:28They can actually make these CAR T cells by injecting lipid nanoparticles into the body
1:39:28They can actually make these CAR T cells by injecting lipid nanoparticles into the body
1:39:34without ever taking the T cells out of the bloodstream.
1:39:34without ever taking the T cells out of the bloodstream.
1:39:34without ever taking the T cells out of the bloodstream.
1:39:34without ever taking the T cells out of the bloodstream.
1:39:37And I think we're going to see more and more things like that.
1:39:37And I think we're going to see more and more things like that.
1:39:37And I think we're going to see more and more things like that.
1:39:37And I think we're going to see more and more things like that.
1:39:40The pharma industry is all of a sudden saying, there's more ways that we can
1:39:40The pharma industry is all of a sudden saying, there's more ways that we can
1:39:40The pharma industry is all of a sudden saying, there's more ways that we can
1:39:40The pharma industry is all of a sudden saying, there's more ways that we can
1:39:43make drugs. Things don't have to just be pills anymore.
1:39:43make drugs. Things don't have to just be pills anymore.
1:39:43make drugs. Things don't have to just be pills anymore.
1:39:43make drugs. Things don't have to just be pills anymore.
1:39:47They can be engineered proteins or lipid nanoparticles or viruses or engineered cells, whatever is
1:39:47They can be engineered proteins or lipid nanoparticles or viruses or engineered cells, whatever is
1:39:47They can be engineered proteins or lipid nanoparticles or viruses or engineered cells, whatever is
1:39:47They can be engineered proteins or lipid nanoparticles or viruses or engineered cells, whatever is
1:39:54going to be most effective at getting to the root cause of disease.
1:39:54going to be most effective at getting to the root cause of disease.
1:39:54going to be most effective at getting to the root cause of disease.
1:39:54going to be most effective at getting to the root cause of disease.
1:39:57I want to just talk about the COVID vaccine briefly.
1:39:57I want to just talk about the COVID vaccine briefly.
1:39:57I want to just talk about the COVID vaccine briefly.
1:39:57I want to just talk about the COVID vaccine briefly.
1:40:02Yeah. Because in my role as a public health educator, I was exposed to a
1:40:02Yeah. Because in my role as a public health educator, I was exposed to a
1:40:02Yeah. Because in my role as a public health educator, I was exposed to a
1:40:02Yeah. Because in my role as a public health educator, I was exposed to a
1:40:09lot of voices. Yeah. And I can't speak for everybody, certainly.
1:40:09lot of voices. Yeah. And I can't speak for everybody, certainly.
1:40:09lot of voices. Yeah. And I can't speak for everybody, certainly.
1:40:09lot of voices. Yeah. And I can't speak for everybody, certainly.
1:40:15But I think that at least three of the things that caused a lot of
1:40:15But I think that at least three of the things that caused a lot of
1:40:15But I think that at least three of the things that caused a lot of
1:40:15But I think that at least three of the things that caused a lot of
1:40:20divide around the mRNA vaccines were, first of all, the difference between mandates versus optionality.
1:40:20divide around the mRNA vaccines were, first of all, the difference between mandates versus optionality.
1:40:20divide around the mRNA vaccines were, first of all, the difference between mandates versus optionality.
1:40:20divide around the mRNA vaccines were, first of all, the difference between mandates versus optionality.
1:40:31We don't have to go there, but I think that was a major player, right?
1:40:31We don't have to go there, but I think that was a major player, right?
1:40:31We don't have to go there, but I think that was a major player, right?
1:40:31We don't have to go there, but I think that was a major player, right?
1:40:36People, especially Americans, don't like to be told what to do.
1:40:36People, especially Americans, don't like to be told what to do.
1:40:36People, especially Americans, don't like to be told what to do.
1:40:36People, especially Americans, don't like to be told what to do.
1:40:41I've noticed that. Okay. Second of all, it was closely related to notions of the
1:40:41I've noticed that. Okay. Second of all, it was closely related to notions of the
1:40:41I've noticed that. Okay. Second of all, it was closely related to notions of the
1:40:41I've noticed that. Okay. Second of all, it was closely related to notions of the
1:40:50shutdown, which differentially impacted people.
1:40:50shutdown, which differentially impacted people.
1:40:50shutdown, which differentially impacted people.
1:40:50shutdown, which differentially impacted people.
1:40:54And that's an understatement, right?
1:40:54And that's an understatement, right?
1:40:54And that's an understatement, right?
1:40:54And that's an understatement, right?
1:40:57Some people maintained paychecks. Some people didn't.
1:40:57Some people maintained paychecks. Some people didn't.
1:40:57Some people maintained paychecks. Some people didn't.
1:40:57Some people maintained paychecks. Some people didn't.
1:40:59Some people could work. Some people couldn't.
1:40:59Some people could work. Some people couldn't.
1:40:59Some people could work. Some people couldn't.
1:40:59Some people could work. Some people couldn't.
1:41:01So there was that. I just, I'm not trying to, you know, soften anything here,
1:41:01So there was that. I just, I'm not trying to, you know, soften anything here,
1:41:01So there was that. I just, I'm not trying to, you know, soften anything here,
1:41:01So there was that. I just, I'm not trying to, you know, soften anything here,
1:41:06but I think that the vaccines were nested in a bunch of other issues.
1:41:06but I think that the vaccines were nested in a bunch of other issues.
1:41:06but I think that the vaccines were nested in a bunch of other issues.
1:41:06but I think that the vaccines were nested in a bunch of other issues.
1:41:12Again, at least three. This is not exhaustive.
1:41:12Again, at least three. This is not exhaustive.
1:41:12Again, at least three. This is not exhaustive.
1:41:12Again, at least three. This is not exhaustive.
1:41:14And then the other one, and I actually had this concern myself, which was, how
1:41:14And then the other one, and I actually had this concern myself, which was, how
1:41:14And then the other one, and I actually had this concern myself, which was, how
1:41:14And then the other one, and I actually had this concern myself, which was, how
1:41:19is it that it gets turned off?
1:41:19is it that it gets turned off?
1:41:19is it that it gets turned off?
1:41:19is it that it gets turned off?
1:41:22Right? Like, I can imagine a situation where I would want to put an mRNA
1:41:22Right? Like, I can imagine a situation where I would want to put an mRNA
1:41:22Right? Like, I can imagine a situation where I would want to put an mRNA
1:41:22Right? Like, I can imagine a situation where I would want to put an mRNA
1:41:27into me to do something biologically, but then I don't want it to continue to
1:41:27into me to do something biologically, but then I don't want it to continue to
1:41:27into me to do something biologically, but then I don't want it to continue to
1:41:27into me to do something biologically, but then I don't want it to continue to
1:41:34do that after a period of time.
1:41:34do that after a period of time.
1:41:34do that after a period of time.
1:41:34do that after a period of time.
1:41:36So what in the design of that vaccine allowed it to be targeted to the
1:41:36So what in the design of that vaccine allowed it to be targeted to the
1:41:36So what in the design of that vaccine allowed it to be targeted to the
1:41:36So what in the design of that vaccine allowed it to be targeted to the
1:41:42cells of interest and then not continue to express in all other cells in perpetuity?
1:41:42cells of interest and then not continue to express in all other cells in perpetuity?
1:41:42cells of interest and then not continue to express in all other cells in perpetuity?
1:41:42cells of interest and then not continue to express in all other cells in perpetuity?
1:41:47I'll answer the specific question, but I think the context that you give is also
1:41:47I'll answer the specific question, but I think the context that you give is also
1:41:47I'll answer the specific question, but I think the context that you give is also
1:41:47I'll answer the specific question, but I think the context that you give is also
1:41:50a really important part of this.
1:41:50a really important part of this.
1:41:50a really important part of this.
1:41:50a really important part of this.
1:41:52And I would take one second to talk about this.
1:41:52And I would take one second to talk about this.
1:41:52And I would take one second to talk about this.
1:41:52And I would take one second to talk about this.
1:41:55I think, to answer your first question, we talked about DNA as the sort of
1:41:55I think, to answer your first question, we talked about DNA as the sort of
1:41:55I think, to answer your first question, we talked about DNA as the sort of
1:41:55I think, to answer your first question, we talked about DNA as the sort of
1:42:01source code. We talked about proteins as what the DNA is ultimately encoding.
1:42:01source code. We talked about proteins as what the DNA is ultimately encoding.
1:42:01source code. We talked about proteins as what the DNA is ultimately encoding.
1:42:01source code. We talked about proteins as what the DNA is ultimately encoding.
1:42:05Let's just talk for a second about what mRNA is.
1:42:05Let's just talk for a second about what mRNA is.
1:42:05Let's just talk for a second about what mRNA is.
1:42:05Let's just talk for a second about what mRNA is.
1:42:08mRNA is the sort of temporary intermediate between those things.
1:42:08mRNA is the sort of temporary intermediate between those things.
1:42:08mRNA is the sort of temporary intermediate between those things.
1:42:08mRNA is the sort of temporary intermediate between those things.
1:42:13DNA will get what's called transcribed into mRNA, which is another nucleic acid, but doesn't
1:42:13DNA will get what's called transcribed into mRNA, which is another nucleic acid, but doesn't
1:42:13DNA will get what's called transcribed into mRNA, which is another nucleic acid, but doesn't
1:42:13DNA will get what's called transcribed into mRNA, which is another nucleic acid, but doesn't
1:42:21stick around permanently. It is the temporary instruction, which will then go to the ribosome
1:42:21stick around permanently. It is the temporary instruction, which will then go to the ribosome
1:42:21stick around permanently. It is the temporary instruction, which will then go to the ribosome
1:42:21stick around permanently. It is the temporary instruction, which will then go to the ribosome
1:42:27and become the template for a particular protein.
1:42:27and become the template for a particular protein.
1:42:27and become the template for a particular protein.
1:42:27and become the template for a particular protein.
1:42:32The idea of an mRNA vaccine is that you're using this temporary template so that
1:42:32The idea of an mRNA vaccine is that you're using this temporary template so that
1:42:32The idea of an mRNA vaccine is that you're using this temporary template so that
1:42:32The idea of an mRNA vaccine is that you're using this temporary template so that
1:42:36the cells that will take this up will make proteins from this temporary template for
1:42:36the cells that will take this up will make proteins from this temporary template for
1:42:36the cells that will take this up will make proteins from this temporary template for
1:42:36the cells that will take this up will make proteins from this temporary template for
1:42:42some period of time. Now, there could be some...
1:42:42some period of time. Now, there could be some...
1:42:42some period of time. Now, there could be some...
1:42:42some period of time. Now, there could be some...
1:42:45You can always imagine the extreme outliers of ways that this could last longer or
1:42:45You can always imagine the extreme outliers of ways that this could last longer or
1:42:45You can always imagine the extreme outliers of ways that this could last longer or
1:42:45You can always imagine the extreme outliers of ways that this could last longer or
1:42:50not, but fundamentally, this is...
1:42:50not, but fundamentally, this is...
1:42:50not, but fundamentally, this is...
1:42:50not, but fundamentally, this is...
1:42:53You're putting in an mRNA that gives a temporary instruction to the cell to make
1:42:53You're putting in an mRNA that gives a temporary instruction to the cell to make
1:42:53You're putting in an mRNA that gives a temporary instruction to the cell to make
1:42:53You're putting in an mRNA that gives a temporary instruction to the cell to make
1:42:58a small part of the COVID vaccine.
1:42:58a small part of the COVID vaccine.
1:42:58a small part of the COVID vaccine.
1:42:58a small part of the COVID vaccine.
1:43:01Now, we have the COVID virus, very small part, right?
1:43:01Now, we have the COVID virus, very small part, right?
1:43:01Now, we have the COVID virus, very small part, right?
1:43:01Now, we have the COVID virus, very small part, right?
1:43:04Now, just by comparison, if you get infected with COVID, you're also going to get
1:43:04Now, just by comparison, if you get infected with COVID, you're also going to get
1:43:04Now, just by comparison, if you get infected with COVID, you're also going to get
1:43:04Now, just by comparison, if you get infected with COVID, you're also going to get
1:43:08COVID mRNA transcribed in your cells.
1:43:08COVID mRNA transcribed in your cells.
1:43:08COVID mRNA transcribed in your cells.
1:43:08COVID mRNA transcribed in your cells.
1:43:12And, you know, that... So, we're talking about genetic material making mRNA either way, whether
1:43:12And, you know, that... So, we're talking about genetic material making mRNA either way, whether
1:43:12And, you know, that... So, we're talking about genetic material making mRNA either way, whether
1:43:12And, you know, that... So, we're talking about genetic material making mRNA either way, whether
1:43:19it's the mRNA from the COVID or a designed small part of that COVID vaccine,
1:43:19it's the mRNA from the COVID or a designed small part of that COVID vaccine,
1:43:19it's the mRNA from the COVID or a designed small part of that COVID vaccine,
1:43:19it's the mRNA from the COVID or a designed small part of that COVID vaccine,
1:43:25of that COVID genome that we're using as a vaccine.
1:43:25of that COVID genome that we're using as a vaccine.
1:43:25of that COVID genome that we're using as a vaccine.
1:43:25of that COVID genome that we're using as a vaccine.
1:43:28So, I think it's important to think about the risks in the context of the
1:43:28So, I think it's important to think about the risks in the context of the
1:43:28So, I think it's important to think about the risks in the context of the
1:43:28So, I think it's important to think about the risks in the context of the
1:43:32virus versus what we're doing with a vaccine.
1:43:32virus versus what we're doing with a vaccine.
1:43:32virus versus what we're doing with a vaccine.
1:43:32virus versus what we're doing with a vaccine.
1:43:35So, I got the COVID vaccine enthusiastically and I actually, I think overwhelmingly, my immunohist...
1:43:35So, I got the COVID vaccine enthusiastically and I actually, I think overwhelmingly, my immunohist...
1:43:35So, I got the COVID vaccine enthusiastically and I actually, I think overwhelmingly, my immunohist...
1:43:35So, I got the COVID vaccine enthusiastically and I actually, I think overwhelmingly, my immunohist...
1:43:42I'm... I know, overwhelmingly, my immunology colleagues do the same.
1:43:42I'm... I know, overwhelmingly, my immunology colleagues do the same.
1:43:42I'm... I know, overwhelmingly, my immunology colleagues do the same.
1:43:42I'm... I know, overwhelmingly, my immunology colleagues do the same.
1:43:46In people who live in this world of immunology, a great enthusiasm that this could
1:43:46In people who live in this world of immunology, a great enthusiasm that this could
1:43:46In people who live in this world of immunology, a great enthusiasm that this could
1:43:46In people who live in this world of immunology, a great enthusiasm that this could
1:43:51be done and built. Now, that doesn't answer what you said about the cultural phenomenon.
1:43:51be done and built. Now, that doesn't answer what you said about the cultural phenomenon.
1:43:51be done and built. Now, that doesn't answer what you said about the cultural phenomenon.
1:43:51be done and built. Now, that doesn't answer what you said about the cultural phenomenon.
1:43:58I'm talking just as a person, not as an immunologist.
1:43:58I'm talking just as a person, not as an immunologist.
1:43:58I'm talking just as a person, not as an immunologist.
1:43:58I'm talking just as a person, not as an immunologist.
1:44:01But I think we probably haven't done enough to talk about the trauma that we
1:44:01But I think we probably haven't done enough to talk about the trauma that we
1:44:01But I think we probably haven't done enough to talk about the trauma that we
1:44:01But I think we probably haven't done enough to talk about the trauma that we
1:44:06went through as a nation during COVID, of being fractured by people dying on one
1:44:06went through as a nation during COVID, of being fractured by people dying on one
1:44:06went through as a nation during COVID, of being fractured by people dying on one
1:44:06went through as a nation during COVID, of being fractured by people dying on one
1:44:13hand and all the negative consequences, as you said, of shutdown.
1:44:13hand and all the negative consequences, as you said, of shutdown.
1:44:13hand and all the negative consequences, as you said, of shutdown.
1:44:13hand and all the negative consequences, as you said, of shutdown.
1:44:18Shutdown of economic life, shutdown of social life.
1:44:18Shutdown of economic life, shutdown of social life.
1:44:18Shutdown of economic life, shutdown of social life.
1:44:18Shutdown of economic life, shutdown of social life.
1:44:21I think it was a period of major dislocation and we're still feeling the trauma.
1:44:21I think it was a period of major dislocation and we're still feeling the trauma.
1:44:21I think it was a period of major dislocation and we're still feeling the trauma.
1:44:21I think it was a period of major dislocation and we're still feeling the trauma.
1:44:27And the people's different relationships with things like vaccine but of science even more generally
1:44:27And the people's different relationships with things like vaccine but of science even more generally
1:44:27And the people's different relationships with things like vaccine but of science even more generally
1:44:27And the people's different relationships with things like vaccine but of science even more generally
1:44:34were dislodged or accentuated by this trauma that I think we all collectively went through
1:44:34were dislodged or accentuated by this trauma that I think we all collectively went through
1:44:34were dislodged or accentuated by this trauma that I think we all collectively went through
1:44:34were dislodged or accentuated by this trauma that I think we all collectively went through
1:44:40and we don't talk enough about.
1:44:40and we don't talk enough about.
1:44:40and we don't talk enough about.
1:44:40and we don't talk enough about.
1:44:43I'll just give one anecdote.
1:44:43I'll just give one anecdote.
1:44:43I'll just give one anecdote.
1:44:43I'll just give one anecdote.
1:44:45While I spent a lot of time isolated during COVID and was disheartened by the
1:44:45While I spent a lot of time isolated during COVID and was disheartened by the
1:44:45While I spent a lot of time isolated during COVID and was disheartened by the
1:44:45While I spent a lot of time isolated during COVID and was disheartened by the
1:44:52fact that on one hand I was watching the sort of scientific speed race, that
1:44:52fact that on one hand I was watching the sort of scientific speed race, that
1:44:52fact that on one hand I was watching the sort of scientific speed race, that
1:44:52fact that on one hand I was watching the sort of scientific speed race, that
1:44:57was actually I think one of the highlights of the first Trump administration, Operation Warp
1:44:57was actually I think one of the highlights of the first Trump administration, Operation Warp
1:44:57was actually I think one of the highlights of the first Trump administration, Operation Warp
1:44:57was actually I think one of the highlights of the first Trump administration, Operation Warp
1:45:03Speed, to streamline and get coordination both on the science and the regulatory side to
1:45:03Speed, to streamline and get coordination both on the science and the regulatory side to
1:45:03Speed, to streamline and get coordination both on the science and the regulatory side to
1:45:03Speed, to streamline and get coordination both on the science and the regulatory side to
1:45:10get vaccines approved in an extraordinary timeline, taking advantage of a number of technologies and
1:45:10get vaccines approved in an extraordinary timeline, taking advantage of a number of technologies and
1:45:10get vaccines approved in an extraordinary timeline, taking advantage of a number of technologies and
1:45:10get vaccines approved in an extraordinary timeline, taking advantage of a number of technologies and
1:45:16making them all. So I was watching this science unfold with some optimism but also
1:45:16making them all. So I was watching this science unfold with some optimism but also
1:45:16making them all. So I was watching this science unfold with some optimism but also
1:45:16making them all. So I was watching this science unfold with some optimism but also
1:45:21watching the trust in science being eroded.
1:45:21watching the trust in science being eroded.
1:45:21watching the trust in science being eroded.
1:45:21watching the trust in science being eroded.
1:45:24I developed a side hobby, which is I've gone back, and I've been reading presidential
1:45:24I developed a side hobby, which is I've gone back, and I've been reading presidential
1:45:24I developed a side hobby, which is I've gone back, and I've been reading presidential
1:45:24I developed a side hobby, which is I've gone back, and I've been reading presidential
1:45:31biographies sequentially. This is just a side hobby.
1:45:31biographies sequentially. This is just a side hobby.
1:45:31biographies sequentially. This is just a side hobby.
1:45:31biographies sequentially. This is just a side hobby.
1:45:37Now, in reading and thinking about this sort of frustration with how science was sort
1:45:37Now, in reading and thinking about this sort of frustration with how science was sort
1:45:37Now, in reading and thinking about this sort of frustration with how science was sort
1:45:37Now, in reading and thinking about this sort of frustration with how science was sort
1:45:43of tearing things apart, I found this sort of strange relief in reading about early
1:45:43of tearing things apart, I found this sort of strange relief in reading about early
1:45:43of tearing things apart, I found this sort of strange relief in reading about early
1:45:43of tearing things apart, I found this sort of strange relief in reading about early
1:45:48American history. In 1793, there was a yellow fever epidemic in Philadelphia.
1:45:48American history. In 1793, there was a yellow fever epidemic in Philadelphia.
1:45:48American history. In 1793, there was a yellow fever epidemic in Philadelphia.
1:45:48American history. In 1793, there was a yellow fever epidemic in Philadelphia.
1:45:56And actually, the early parties that were forming, the Federalists and the Democrats, actually took
1:45:56And actually, the early parties that were forming, the Federalists and the Democrats, actually took
1:45:56And actually, the early parties that were forming, the Federalists and the Democrats, actually took
1:45:56And actually, the early parties that were forming, the Federalists and the Democrats, actually took
1:46:04like wildly dissenting views of how to deal with an epidemic.
1:46:04like wildly dissenting views of how to deal with an epidemic.
1:46:04like wildly dissenting views of how to deal with an epidemic.
1:46:04like wildly dissenting views of how to deal with an epidemic.
1:46:07They had different views of what caused it, whether it was outside contagion or sanitation.
1:46:07They had different views of what caused it, whether it was outside contagion or sanitation.
1:46:07They had different views of what caused it, whether it was outside contagion or sanitation.
1:46:07They had different views of what caused it, whether it was outside contagion or sanitation.
1:46:14And the Democrats at that time, the Jeffersonian Democrats, were in favor of like really
1:46:14And the Democrats at that time, the Jeffersonian Democrats, were in favor of like really
1:46:14And the Democrats at that time, the Jeffersonian Democrats, were in favor of like really
1:46:14And the Democrats at that time, the Jeffersonian Democrats, were in favor of like really
1:46:20extreme bloodletting techniques. And the Hamiltonians and the Federalists had a totally different set of
1:46:20extreme bloodletting techniques. And the Hamiltonians and the Federalists had a totally different set of
1:46:20extreme bloodletting techniques. And the Hamiltonians and the Federalists had a totally different set of
1:46:20extreme bloodletting techniques. And the Hamiltonians and the Federalists had a totally different set of
1:46:28techniques of baths and more gentle treatments, and they just couldn't see it eye to
1:46:28techniques of baths and more gentle treatments, and they just couldn't see it eye to
1:46:28techniques of baths and more gentle treatments, and they just couldn't see it eye to
1:46:28techniques of baths and more gentle treatments, and they just couldn't see it eye to
1:46:33eye. Why am I saying all this?
1:46:33eye. Why am I saying all this?
1:46:33eye. Why am I saying all this?
1:46:33eye. Why am I saying all this?
1:46:34I think it's not new territory that these discussions of how we deal with infections,
1:46:34I think it's not new territory that these discussions of how we deal with infections,
1:46:34I think it's not new territory that these discussions of how we deal with infections,
1:46:34I think it's not new territory that these discussions of how we deal with infections,
1:46:42which are inherently societal diseases, unearth the societal tensions, and we deal with them in
1:46:42which are inherently societal diseases, unearth the societal tensions, and we deal with them in
1:46:42which are inherently societal diseases, unearth the societal tensions, and we deal with them in
1:46:42which are inherently societal diseases, unearth the societal tensions, and we deal with them in
1:46:49different ways, and we come to them from different perspectives.
1:46:49different ways, and we come to them from different perspectives.
1:46:49different ways, and we come to them from different perspectives.
1:46:49different ways, and we come to them from different perspectives.
1:46:53And there's a lot of things that are simultaneously being balanced in any decision of
1:46:53And there's a lot of things that are simultaneously being balanced in any decision of
1:46:53And there's a lot of things that are simultaneously being balanced in any decision of
1:46:53And there's a lot of things that are simultaneously being balanced in any decision of
1:46:59how we deal with thinking about the trade -offs that we're willing to make in
1:46:59how we deal with thinking about the trade -offs that we're willing to make in
1:46:59how we deal with thinking about the trade -offs that we're willing to make in
1:46:59how we deal with thinking about the trade -offs that we're willing to make in
1:47:03the face of a pandemic or an epidemic.
1:47:03the face of a pandemic or an epidemic.
1:47:03the face of a pandemic or an epidemic.
1:47:03the face of a pandemic or an epidemic.
1:47:07I really appreciate that, and I'm also impressed that you're reading these biographies.
1:47:07I really appreciate that, and I'm also impressed that you're reading these biographies.
1:47:07I really appreciate that, and I'm also impressed that you're reading these biographies.
1:47:07I really appreciate that, and I'm also impressed that you're reading these biographies.
1:47:10How do you know which biography to select?
1:47:10How do you know which biography to select?
1:47:10How do you know which biography to select?
1:47:10How do you know which biography to select?
1:47:13Because there are many of them.
1:47:13Because there are many of them.
1:47:13Because there are many of them.
1:47:13Because there are many of them.
1:47:14And unfortunately, Walter Isaacson hasn't written them all.
1:47:14And unfortunately, Walter Isaacson hasn't written them all.
1:47:14And unfortunately, Walter Isaacson hasn't written them all.
1:47:14And unfortunately, Walter Isaacson hasn't written them all.
1:47:17I love his books. So how do you select the author of each biography?
1:47:17I love his books. So how do you select the author of each biography?
1:47:17I love his books. So how do you select the author of each biography?
1:47:17I love his books. So how do you select the author of each biography?
1:47:23This is a project that I spend a lot of time.
1:47:23This is a project that I spend a lot of time.
1:47:23This is a project that I spend a lot of time.
1:47:23This is a project that I spend a lot of time.
1:47:26Each one, I go through a period of indecision about which one I should read.
1:47:26Each one, I go through a period of indecision about which one I should read.
1:47:26Each one, I go through a period of indecision about which one I should read.
1:47:26Each one, I go through a period of indecision about which one I should read.
1:47:31I can share my list.
1:47:31I can share my list.
1:47:31I can share my list.
1:47:31I can share my list.
1:47:33I'm not done yet. This has been over several years.
1:47:33I'm not done yet. This has been over several years.
1:47:33I'm not done yet. This has been over several years.
1:47:33I'm not done yet. This has been over several years.
1:47:36I'm now up to World War II.
1:47:36I'm now up to World War II.
1:47:36I'm now up to World War II.
1:47:36I'm now up to World War II.
1:47:38You should do a podcast someday.
1:47:38You should do a podcast someday.
1:47:38You should do a podcast someday.
1:47:38You should do a podcast someday.
1:47:40Just know in your copious amounts of spare time, not as a husband, father, running
1:47:40Just know in your copious amounts of spare time, not as a husband, father, running
1:47:40Just know in your copious amounts of spare time, not as a husband, father, running
1:47:40Just know in your copious amounts of spare time, not as a husband, father, running
1:47:44a giant lab, et cetera, and physician, you could do a podcast and teach us
1:47:44a giant lab, et cetera, and physician, you could do a podcast and teach us
1:47:44a giant lab, et cetera, and physician, you could do a podcast and teach us
1:47:44a giant lab, et cetera, and physician, you could do a podcast and teach us
1:47:49what you learn. Anyway, awesome.
1:47:49what you learn. Anyway, awesome.
1:47:49what you learn. Anyway, awesome.
1:47:49what you learn. Anyway, awesome.
1:47:51I'd like to take a quick break and acknowledge one of our sponsors, Function.
1:47:51I'd like to take a quick break and acknowledge one of our sponsors, Function.
1:47:51I'd like to take a quick break and acknowledge one of our sponsors, Function.
1:47:51I'd like to take a quick break and acknowledge one of our sponsors, Function.
1:47:55Last year, I became a Function member after searching for the most comprehensive approach to
1:47:55Last year, I became a Function member after searching for the most comprehensive approach to
1:47:55Last year, I became a Function member after searching for the most comprehensive approach to
1:47:55Last year, I became a Function member after searching for the most comprehensive approach to
1:48:00lab testing. Function provides over 100 advanced lab tests that give you a key snapshot
1:48:00lab testing. Function provides over 100 advanced lab tests that give you a key snapshot
1:48:00lab testing. Function provides over 100 advanced lab tests that give you a key snapshot
1:48:00lab testing. Function provides over 100 advanced lab tests that give you a key snapshot
1:48:05of your entire bodily health.
1:48:05of your entire bodily health.
1:48:05of your entire bodily health.
1:48:05of your entire bodily health.
1:48:07This snapshot offers you with insights on your heart health, hormone health, immune functioning, nutrient
1:48:07This snapshot offers you with insights on your heart health, hormone health, immune functioning, nutrient
1:48:07This snapshot offers you with insights on your heart health, hormone health, immune functioning, nutrient
1:48:07This snapshot offers you with insights on your heart health, hormone health, immune functioning, nutrient
1:48:12levels, and much more. They've also recently added tests for toxins, such as BPA exposure
1:48:12levels, and much more. They've also recently added tests for toxins, such as BPA exposure
1:48:12levels, and much more. They've also recently added tests for toxins, such as BPA exposure
1:48:12levels, and much more. They've also recently added tests for toxins, such as BPA exposure
1:48:17from harmful plastics and tests for PFASs or forever chemicals.
1:48:17from harmful plastics and tests for PFASs or forever chemicals.
1:48:17from harmful plastics and tests for PFASs or forever chemicals.
1:48:17from harmful plastics and tests for PFASs or forever chemicals.
1:48:22Function not only provides testing of over 100 biomarkers key to your physical and mental
1:48:22Function not only provides testing of over 100 biomarkers key to your physical and mental
1:48:22Function not only provides testing of over 100 biomarkers key to your physical and mental
1:48:22Function not only provides testing of over 100 biomarkers key to your physical and mental
1:48:26health, but it also analyzes these results and provides insights from top doctors who are
1:48:26health, but it also analyzes these results and provides insights from top doctors who are
1:48:26health, but it also analyzes these results and provides insights from top doctors who are
1:48:26health, but it also analyzes these results and provides insights from top doctors who are
1:48:31expert in the relevant areas.
1:48:31expert in the relevant areas.
1:48:31expert in the relevant areas.
1:48:31expert in the relevant areas.
1:48:33For example, in one of my first tests with Function, I learned that I had
1:48:33For example, in one of my first tests with Function, I learned that I had
1:48:33For example, in one of my first tests with Function, I learned that I had
1:48:33For example, in one of my first tests with Function, I learned that I had
1:48:36elevated levels of mercury in my blood.
1:48:36elevated levels of mercury in my blood.
1:48:36elevated levels of mercury in my blood.
1:48:36elevated levels of mercury in my blood.
1:48:38Function not only helped me detect that, but offered insights into how best to reduce
1:48:38Function not only helped me detect that, but offered insights into how best to reduce
1:48:38Function not only helped me detect that, but offered insights into how best to reduce
1:48:38Function not only helped me detect that, but offered insights into how best to reduce
1:48:42my mercury levels, which included limiting my tuna consumption.
1:48:42my mercury levels, which included limiting my tuna consumption.
1:48:42my mercury levels, which included limiting my tuna consumption.
1:48:42my mercury levels, which included limiting my tuna consumption.
1:48:46I'd been eating a lot of tuna, while also making an effort to eat more
1:48:46I'd been eating a lot of tuna, while also making an effort to eat more
1:48:46I'd been eating a lot of tuna, while also making an effort to eat more
1:48:46I'd been eating a lot of tuna, while also making an effort to eat more
1:48:49leafy greens and supplementing with NAC and acetylcysteine, both of which can support glutathione production
1:48:49leafy greens and supplementing with NAC and acetylcysteine, both of which can support glutathione production
1:48:49leafy greens and supplementing with NAC and acetylcysteine, both of which can support glutathione production
1:48:49leafy greens and supplementing with NAC and acetylcysteine, both of which can support glutathione production
1:48:54and detoxification. And I should say, by taking a second Function test, that approach worked.
1:48:54and detoxification. And I should say, by taking a second Function test, that approach worked.
1:48:54and detoxification. And I should say, by taking a second Function test, that approach worked.
1:48:54and detoxification. And I should say, by taking a second Function test, that approach worked.
1:48:59Comprehensive blood testing is vitally important.
1:48:59Comprehensive blood testing is vitally important.
1:48:59Comprehensive blood testing is vitally important.
1:48:59Comprehensive blood testing is vitally important.
1:49:01There's so many things related to your mental and physical health that can only be
1:49:01There's so many things related to your mental and physical health that can only be
1:49:01There's so many things related to your mental and physical health that can only be
1:49:01There's so many things related to your mental and physical health that can only be
1:49:05detected in a blood test.
1:49:05detected in a blood test.
1:49:05detected in a blood test.
1:49:05detected in a blood test.
1:49:07The problem is blood testing has always been very expensive and complicated.
1:49:07The problem is blood testing has always been very expensive and complicated.
1:49:07The problem is blood testing has always been very expensive and complicated.
1:49:07The problem is blood testing has always been very expensive and complicated.
1:49:10In contrast, I've been super impressed by Function's simplicity and at the level of cost.
1:49:10In contrast, I've been super impressed by Function's simplicity and at the level of cost.
1:49:10In contrast, I've been super impressed by Function's simplicity and at the level of cost.
1:49:10In contrast, I've been super impressed by Function's simplicity and at the level of cost.
1:49:15It is very affordable. As a consequence, I decided to join their scientific advisory board,
1:49:15It is very affordable. As a consequence, I decided to join their scientific advisory board,
1:49:15It is very affordable. As a consequence, I decided to join their scientific advisory board,
1:49:15It is very affordable. As a consequence, I decided to join their scientific advisory board,
1:49:20and I'm thrilled that they're sponsoring the podcast.
1:49:20and I'm thrilled that they're sponsoring the podcast.
1:49:20and I'm thrilled that they're sponsoring the podcast.
1:49:20and I'm thrilled that they're sponsoring the podcast.
1:49:22If you'd like to try Function, you can go to functionhealth .com slash Huberman.
1:49:22If you'd like to try Function, you can go to functionhealth .com slash Huberman.
1:49:22If you'd like to try Function, you can go to functionhealth .com slash Huberman.
1:49:22If you'd like to try Function, you can go to functionhealth .com slash Huberman.
1:49:26Function currently has a wait list of over 250 ,000 people, but they're offering early
1:49:26Function currently has a wait list of over 250 ,000 people, but they're offering early
1:49:26Function currently has a wait list of over 250 ,000 people, but they're offering early
1:49:26Function currently has a wait list of over 250 ,000 people, but they're offering early
1:49:31access to Huberman podcast listeners.
1:49:31access to Huberman podcast listeners.
1:49:31access to Huberman podcast listeners.
1:49:31access to Huberman podcast listeners.
1:49:34Again, that's functionhealth .com slash Huberman to get early access to Function.
1:49:34Again, that's functionhealth .com slash Huberman to get early access to Function.
1:49:34Again, that's functionhealth .com slash Huberman to get early access to Function.
1:49:34Again, that's functionhealth .com slash Huberman to get early access to Function.
1:49:39I have a question related to technologies to killing or altering cells that we didn't
1:49:39I have a question related to technologies to killing or altering cells that we didn't
1:49:39I have a question related to technologies to killing or altering cells that we didn't
1:49:39I have a question related to technologies to killing or altering cells that we didn't
1:49:46cover, but since we've touched on a number of them, the lipid nanoparticles, lentiviruses, since
1:49:46cover, but since we've touched on a number of them, the lipid nanoparticles, lentiviruses, since
1:49:46cover, but since we've touched on a number of them, the lipid nanoparticles, lentiviruses, since
1:49:46cover, but since we've touched on a number of them, the lipid nanoparticles, lentiviruses, since
1:49:53we're in a previous lifetime, I used in my experiments, and I was excited by
1:49:53we're in a previous lifetime, I used in my experiments, and I was excited by
1:49:53we're in a previous lifetime, I used in my experiments, and I was excited by
1:49:53we're in a previous lifetime, I used in my experiments, and I was excited by
1:50:00immunotoxins. So an antibody against, you generally need a cell surface protein, and then you
1:50:00immunotoxins. So an antibody against, you generally need a cell surface protein, and then you
1:50:00immunotoxins. So an antibody against, you generally need a cell surface protein, and then you
1:50:00immunotoxins. So an antibody against, you generally need a cell surface protein, and then you
1:50:07attach to it, and in our case, we use saporin toxin, which I think is
1:50:07attach to it, and in our case, we use saporin toxin, which I think is
1:50:07attach to it, and in our case, we use saporin toxin, which I think is
1:50:07attach to it, and in our case, we use saporin toxin, which I think is
1:50:11most infamous because it was put on the tip of an umbrella and used to
1:50:11most infamous because it was put on the tip of an umbrella and used to
1:50:11most infamous because it was put on the tip of an umbrella and used to
1:50:11most infamous because it was put on the tip of an umbrella and used to
1:50:16assassinate somebody on a bridge someplace in some sort of international spy warfare in the
1:50:16assassinate somebody on a bridge someplace in some sort of international spy warfare in the
1:50:16assassinate somebody on a bridge someplace in some sort of international spy warfare in the
1:50:16assassinate somebody on a bridge someplace in some sort of international spy warfare in the
1:50:22last 20 years or so.
1:50:22last 20 years or so.
1:50:22last 20 years or so.
1:50:22last 20 years or so.
1:50:24Saporin will kill you if it goes systemic, but the idea there is that you
1:50:24Saporin will kill you if it goes systemic, but the idea there is that you
1:50:24Saporin will kill you if it goes systemic, but the idea there is that you
1:50:24Saporin will kill you if it goes systemic, but the idea there is that you
1:50:28take the saporin toxin and you tether it to an antibody that then finds a
1:50:28take the saporin toxin and you tether it to an antibody that then finds a
1:50:28take the saporin toxin and you tether it to an antibody that then finds a
1:50:28take the saporin toxin and you tether it to an antibody that then finds a
1:50:33cell surface protein and then kills that cell and only cell.
1:50:33cell surface protein and then kills that cell and only cell.
1:50:33cell surface protein and then kills that cell and only cell.
1:50:33cell surface protein and then kills that cell and only cell.
1:50:36And it works remarkably well in experimental conditions if certain things are right.
1:50:36And it works remarkably well in experimental conditions if certain things are right.
1:50:36And it works remarkably well in experimental conditions if certain things are right.
1:50:36And it works remarkably well in experimental conditions if certain things are right.
1:50:41It doesn't always have the specificity you would like or the thoroughness.
1:50:41It doesn't always have the specificity you would like or the thoroughness.
1:50:41It doesn't always have the specificity you would like or the thoroughness.
1:50:41It doesn't always have the specificity you would like or the thoroughness.
1:50:45Has that been tried in cancer, directing toxins towards cancer cells?
1:50:45Has that been tried in cancer, directing toxins towards cancer cells?
1:50:45Has that been tried in cancer, directing toxins towards cancer cells?
1:50:45Has that been tried in cancer, directing toxins towards cancer cells?
1:50:51The short answer is yes.
1:50:51The short answer is yes.
1:50:51The short answer is yes.
1:50:51The short answer is yes.
1:50:53It's a really interesting area.
1:50:53It's a really interesting area.
1:50:53It's a really interesting area.
1:50:53It's a really interesting area.
1:50:56And what that toxin is can almost be thought of as like modular, that you
1:50:56And what that toxin is can almost be thought of as like modular, that you
1:50:56And what that toxin is can almost be thought of as like modular, that you
1:50:56And what that toxin is can almost be thought of as like modular, that you
1:51:02can put a different, that you can think of it as two components, right?
1:51:02can put a different, that you can think of it as two components, right?
1:51:02can put a different, that you can think of it as two components, right?
1:51:02can put a different, that you can think of it as two components, right?
1:51:05You have a targeting component, you have an antibody as a natural one where the
1:51:05You have a targeting component, you have an antibody as a natural one where the
1:51:05You have a targeting component, you have an antibody as a natural one where the
1:51:05You have a targeting component, you have an antibody as a natural one where the
1:51:11antibody is evolved to recognize one particular type of protein.
1:51:11antibody is evolved to recognize one particular type of protein.
1:51:11antibody is evolved to recognize one particular type of protein.
1:51:11antibody is evolved to recognize one particular type of protein.
1:51:16That can be the thing that targets something on the surface of cancer cells.
1:51:16That can be the thing that targets something on the surface of cancer cells.
1:51:16That can be the thing that targets something on the surface of cancer cells.
1:51:16That can be the thing that targets something on the surface of cancer cells.
1:51:22People have then developed what's called antibody drug conjugates where basically a drug or something
1:51:22People have then developed what's called antibody drug conjugates where basically a drug or something
1:51:22People have then developed what's called antibody drug conjugates where basically a drug or something
1:51:22People have then developed what's called antibody drug conjugates where basically a drug or something
1:51:29that's going to kill the cell gets appended to that antibody.
1:51:29that's going to kill the cell gets appended to that antibody.
1:51:29that's going to kill the cell gets appended to that antibody.
1:51:29that's going to kill the cell gets appended to that antibody.
1:51:33And so it's selectively delivered.
1:51:33And so it's selectively delivered.
1:51:33And so it's selectively delivered.
1:51:33And so it's selectively delivered.
1:51:36You don't have to deliver the drug at systemic doses, but you can actually increase
1:51:36You don't have to deliver the drug at systemic doses, but you can actually increase
1:51:36You don't have to deliver the drug at systemic doses, but you can actually increase
1:51:36You don't have to deliver the drug at systemic doses, but you can actually increase
1:51:40the local concentration by delivering it preferentially to the cancer cells that will be recognized
1:51:40the local concentration by delivering it preferentially to the cancer cells that will be recognized
1:51:40the local concentration by delivering it preferentially to the cancer cells that will be recognized
1:51:40the local concentration by delivering it preferentially to the cancer cells that will be recognized
1:51:45by that antibody. It doesn't have to be drugs.
1:51:45by that antibody. It doesn't have to be drugs.
1:51:45by that antibody. It doesn't have to be drugs.
1:51:45by that antibody. It doesn't have to be drugs.
1:51:49People are thinking about other things.
1:51:49People are thinking about other things.
1:51:49People are thinking about other things.
1:51:49People are thinking about other things.
1:51:50When people are now trying to attach radioactive isotopes, there's radioligand therapies that can be
1:51:50When people are now trying to attach radioactive isotopes, there's radioligand therapies that can be
1:51:50When people are now trying to attach radioactive isotopes, there's radioligand therapies that can be
1:51:50When people are now trying to attach radioactive isotopes, there's radioligand therapies that can be
1:51:59attached to these things. And I think in an extreme, that's essentially what we're doing
1:51:59attached to these things. And I think in an extreme, that's essentially what we're doing
1:51:59attached to these things. And I think in an extreme, that's essentially what we're doing
1:51:59attached to these things. And I think in an extreme, that's essentially what we're doing
1:52:05with these T cell therapies too.
1:52:05with these T cell therapies too.
1:52:05with these T cell therapies too.
1:52:05with these T cell therapies too.
1:52:07We're also using, when I've talked about this CAR, the chimeric antigen receptor, the outside
1:52:07We're also using, when I've talked about this CAR, the chimeric antigen receptor, the outside
1:52:07We're also using, when I've talked about this CAR, the chimeric antigen receptor, the outside
1:52:07We're also using, when I've talked about this CAR, the chimeric antigen receptor, the outside
1:52:13of it that is the sensor that's being used is also a part of an
1:52:13of it that is the sensor that's being used is also a part of an
1:52:13of it that is the sensor that's being used is also a part of an
1:52:13of it that is the sensor that's being used is also a part of an
1:52:17antibody. And so essentially what we're doing is now using the antibody to target, but
1:52:17antibody. And so essentially what we're doing is now using the antibody to target, but
1:52:17antibody. And so essentially what we're doing is now using the antibody to target, but
1:52:17antibody. And so essentially what we're doing is now using the antibody to target, but
1:52:22instead of dragging along a drug, it's dragging along a cell.
1:52:22instead of dragging along a drug, it's dragging along a cell.
1:52:22instead of dragging along a drug, it's dragging along a cell.
1:52:22instead of dragging along a drug, it's dragging along a cell.
1:52:27And so when that's engaged, the T cell is there and the T cell becomes
1:52:27And so when that's engaged, the T cell is there and the T cell becomes
1:52:27And so when that's engaged, the T cell is there and the T cell becomes
1:52:27And so when that's engaged, the T cell is there and the T cell becomes
1:52:31the killing module. But the T cell not only kills the cancer cell, but could
1:52:31the killing module. But the T cell not only kills the cancer cell, but could
1:52:31the killing module. But the T cell not only kills the cancer cell, but could
1:52:31the killing module. But the T cell not only kills the cancer cell, but could
1:52:36potentially be used to amplify that response, could release things and recruit other things.
1:52:36potentially be used to amplify that response, could release things and recruit other things.
1:52:36potentially be used to amplify that response, could release things and recruit other things.
1:52:36potentially be used to amplify that response, could release things and recruit other things.
1:52:41So I think this general way of thinking about designing things to drag something to
1:52:41So I think this general way of thinking about designing things to drag something to
1:52:41So I think this general way of thinking about designing things to drag something to
1:52:41So I think this general way of thinking about designing things to drag something to
1:52:49a cancer site is something that people are thinking a lot about.
1:52:49a cancer site is something that people are thinking a lot about.
1:52:49a cancer site is something that people are thinking a lot about.
1:52:49a cancer site is something that people are thinking a lot about.
1:52:52There's even another flavor of this that are called T cell engagers.
1:52:52There's even another flavor of this that are called T cell engagers.
1:52:52There's even another flavor of this that are called T cell engagers.
1:52:52There's even another flavor of this that are called T cell engagers.
1:52:56So I talked about, okay, we can genetically put an antibody fragment on a T
1:52:56So I talked about, okay, we can genetically put an antibody fragment on a T
1:52:56So I talked about, okay, we can genetically put an antibody fragment on a T
1:52:56So I talked about, okay, we can genetically put an antibody fragment on a T
1:53:00cell and use that to direct a T cell to a cancer.
1:53:00cell and use that to direct a T cell to a cancer.
1:53:00cell and use that to direct a T cell to a cancer.
1:53:00cell and use that to direct a T cell to a cancer.
1:53:02People are also making antibodies that are antibodies on both ends.
1:53:02People are also making antibodies that are antibodies on both ends.
1:53:02People are also making antibodies that are antibodies on both ends.
1:53:02People are also making antibodies that are antibodies on both ends.
1:53:08Okay, so this is sometimes, I think this is a proprietary term, but it can
1:53:08Okay, so this is sometimes, I think this is a proprietary term, but it can
1:53:08Okay, so this is sometimes, I think this is a proprietary term, but it can
1:53:08Okay, so this is sometimes, I think this is a proprietary term, but it can
1:53:13be called a bispecific or a bite.
1:53:13be called a bispecific or a bite.
1:53:13be called a bispecific or a bite.
1:53:13be called a bispecific or a bite.
1:53:16The bite is a proprietary term.
1:53:16The bite is a proprietary term.
1:53:16The bite is a proprietary term.
1:53:16The bite is a proprietary term.
1:53:18But basically these are two -headed antibodies.
1:53:18But basically these are two -headed antibodies.
1:53:18But basically these are two -headed antibodies.
1:53:18But basically these are two -headed antibodies.
1:53:21One side will recognize a cancer cell and the other side will recognize a T
1:53:21One side will recognize a cancer cell and the other side will recognize a T
1:53:21One side will recognize a cancer cell and the other side will recognize a T
1:53:21One side will recognize a cancer cell and the other side will recognize a T
1:53:25cell and essentially bring these things together so that you get the T cell action
1:53:25cell and essentially bring these things together so that you get the T cell action
1:53:25cell and essentially bring these things together so that you get the T cell action
1:53:25cell and essentially bring these things together so that you get the T cell action
1:53:29locally to the cancer cell without having to do any genetic modification to the T
1:53:29locally to the cancer cell without having to do any genetic modification to the T
1:53:29locally to the cancer cell without having to do any genetic modification to the T
1:53:29locally to the cancer cell without having to do any genetic modification to the T
1:53:34cell. You actually just take advantage of T cells that are already in the body.
1:53:34cell. You actually just take advantage of T cells that are already in the body.
1:53:34cell. You actually just take advantage of T cells that are already in the body.
1:53:34cell. You actually just take advantage of T cells that are already in the body.
1:53:38So all of these things are now under very active development, and some of them
1:53:38So all of these things are now under very active development, and some of them
1:53:38So all of these things are now under very active development, and some of them
1:53:38So all of these things are now under very active development, and some of them
1:53:43are approved. Others are still in development.
1:53:43are approved. Others are still in development.
1:53:43are approved. Others are still in development.
1:53:43are approved. Others are still in development.
1:53:46Very cool. So I'm sure people are catching on to this, but basically if you
1:53:46Very cool. So I'm sure people are catching on to this, but basically if you
1:53:46Very cool. So I'm sure people are catching on to this, but basically if you
1:53:46Very cool. So I'm sure people are catching on to this, but basically if you
1:53:51can understand the structure of things, including very, very small things, you can Lego them,
1:53:51can understand the structure of things, including very, very small things, you can Lego them,
1:53:51can understand the structure of things, including very, very small things, you can Lego them,
1:53:51can understand the structure of things, including very, very small things, you can Lego them,
1:53:56and you can put all sorts of interesting cargos and play matchmaker between cells, and
1:53:56and you can put all sorts of interesting cargos and play matchmaker between cells, and
1:53:56and you can put all sorts of interesting cargos and play matchmaker between cells, and
1:53:56and you can put all sorts of interesting cargos and play matchmaker between cells, and
1:54:03it's kind of infinite what you can do.
1:54:03it's kind of infinite what you can do.
1:54:03it's kind of infinite what you can do.
1:54:03it's kind of infinite what you can do.
1:54:08Once you start to understand things at that scale, that's really what it's about.
1:54:08Once you start to understand things at that scale, that's really what it's about.
1:54:08Once you start to understand things at that scale, that's really what it's about.
1:54:08Once you start to understand things at that scale, that's really what it's about.
1:54:13I'll push it one step further.
1:54:13I'll push it one step further.
1:54:13I'll push it one step further.
1:54:13I'll push it one step further.
1:54:15I'm actually helping to organize a cancer immunotherapy conference here in L .A.
1:54:15I'm actually helping to organize a cancer immunotherapy conference here in L .A.
1:54:15I'm actually helping to organize a cancer immunotherapy conference here in L .A.
1:54:15I'm actually helping to organize a cancer immunotherapy conference here in L .A.
1:54:21I'm simultaneously here for this and for that.
1:54:21I'm simultaneously here for this and for that.
1:54:21I'm simultaneously here for this and for that.
1:54:21I'm simultaneously here for this and for that.
1:54:24I was at the conference yesterday, and there was a talk by Amgen, a big
1:54:24I was at the conference yesterday, and there was a talk by Amgen, a big
1:54:24I was at the conference yesterday, and there was a talk by Amgen, a big
1:54:24I was at the conference yesterday, and there was a talk by Amgen, a big
1:54:29pharma company. I should disclose I'm an advisor to Amgen, but this talk was, and
1:54:29pharma company. I should disclose I'm an advisor to Amgen, but this talk was, and
1:54:29pharma company. I should disclose I'm an advisor to Amgen, but this talk was, and
1:54:29pharma company. I should disclose I'm an advisor to Amgen, but this talk was, and
1:54:35Amgen has been one of the leaders in these.
1:54:35Amgen has been one of the leaders in these.
1:54:35Amgen has been one of the leaders in these.
1:54:35Amgen has been one of the leaders in these.
1:54:37I think they actually trademarked this idea of bispecific T -cell engager.
1:54:37I think they actually trademarked this idea of bispecific T -cell engager.
1:54:37I think they actually trademarked this idea of bispecific T -cell engager.
1:54:37I think they actually trademarked this idea of bispecific T -cell engager.
1:54:44These are antibody fragments, but one of the leaders at Amgen talked yesterday about how
1:54:44These are antibody fragments, but one of the leaders at Amgen talked yesterday about how
1:54:44These are antibody fragments, but one of the leaders at Amgen talked yesterday about how
1:54:44These are antibody fragments, but one of the leaders at Amgen talked yesterday about how
1:54:50looking forward, these aren't being used as just traditional antibodies that come out of animals,
1:54:50looking forward, these aren't being used as just traditional antibodies that come out of animals,
1:54:50looking forward, these aren't being used as just traditional antibodies that come out of animals,
1:54:50looking forward, these aren't being used as just traditional antibodies that come out of animals,
1:54:56but they're actually being used as AI -designed protein engagers of any target you want.
1:54:56but they're actually being used as AI -designed protein engagers of any target you want.
1:54:56but they're actually being used as AI -designed protein engagers of any target you want.
1:54:56but they're actually being used as AI -designed protein engagers of any target you want.
1:55:03So essentially now it's getting to the point where if you know that something's on
1:55:03So essentially now it's getting to the point where if you know that something's on
1:55:03So essentially now it's getting to the point where if you know that something's on
1:55:03So essentially now it's getting to the point where if you know that something's on
1:55:06the surface of a cancer cell, people are increasingly using AI models to design a
1:55:06the surface of a cancer cell, people are increasingly using AI models to design a
1:55:06the surface of a cancer cell, people are increasingly using AI models to design a
1:55:06the surface of a cancer cell, people are increasingly using AI models to design a
1:55:13synthetic protein that doesn't even exist in nature that is designed to recognize and stick
1:55:13synthetic protein that doesn't even exist in nature that is designed to recognize and stick
1:55:13synthetic protein that doesn't even exist in nature that is designed to recognize and stick
1:55:13synthetic protein that doesn't even exist in nature that is designed to recognize and stick
1:55:20to something on the surface of a cancer cell.
1:55:20to something on the surface of a cancer cell.
1:55:20to something on the surface of a cancer cell.
1:55:20to something on the surface of a cancer cell.
1:55:22And that could be one of these Lego blocks for these modular, multifaceted cell engagers
1:55:22And that could be one of these Lego blocks for these modular, multifaceted cell engagers
1:55:22And that could be one of these Lego blocks for these modular, multifaceted cell engagers
1:55:22And that could be one of these Lego blocks for these modular, multifaceted cell engagers
1:55:29or drug engagers or any of these other things.
1:55:29or drug engagers or any of these other things.
1:55:29or drug engagers or any of these other things.
1:55:29or drug engagers or any of these other things.
1:55:32So this is another area where the crosstalk between experimental capabilities and computational capabilities is
1:55:32So this is another area where the crosstalk between experimental capabilities and computational capabilities is
1:55:32So this is another area where the crosstalk between experimental capabilities and computational capabilities is
1:55:32So this is another area where the crosstalk between experimental capabilities and computational capabilities is
1:55:42further accelerating what's possible. Incredible.
1:55:42further accelerating what's possible. Incredible.
1:55:42further accelerating what's possible. Incredible.
1:55:42further accelerating what's possible. Incredible.
1:55:46Would you mind if I asked a couple of questions about the kind of science,
1:55:46Would you mind if I asked a couple of questions about the kind of science,
1:55:46Would you mind if I asked a couple of questions about the kind of science,
1:55:46Would you mind if I asked a couple of questions about the kind of science,
1:55:51sociology, and ethics around CRISPR?
1:55:51sociology, and ethics around CRISPR?
1:55:51sociology, and ethics around CRISPR?
1:55:51sociology, and ethics around CRISPR?
1:55:55No, I would love it.
1:55:55No, I would love it.
1:55:55No, I would love it.
1:55:55No, I would love it.
1:55:56I'll keep this brief. A few years back, we all learned, meaning the entire world
1:55:56I'll keep this brief. A few years back, we all learned, meaning the entire world
1:55:56I'll keep this brief. A few years back, we all learned, meaning the entire world
1:55:56I'll keep this brief. A few years back, we all learned, meaning the entire world
1:56:02learned, that a scientist in China had done a CRISPR -Cas experiment on babies.
1:56:02learned, that a scientist in China had done a CRISPR -Cas experiment on babies.
1:56:02learned, that a scientist in China had done a CRISPR -Cas experiment on babies.
1:56:02learned, that a scientist in China had done a CRISPR -Cas experiment on babies.
1:56:10I don't know when he did the modification.
1:56:10I don't know when he did the modification.
1:56:10I don't know when he did the modification.
1:56:10I don't know when he did the modification.
1:56:12My guess is it was in utero.
1:56:12My guess is it was in utero.
1:56:12My guess is it was in utero.
1:56:12My guess is it was in utero.
1:56:14You'll tell us what exactly he did.
1:56:14You'll tell us what exactly he did.
1:56:14You'll tell us what exactly he did.
1:56:14You'll tell us what exactly he did.
1:56:15This hit close to home for me because he and I were postdocs at the
1:56:15This hit close to home for me because he and I were postdocs at the
1:56:15This hit close to home for me because he and I were postdocs at the
1:56:15This hit close to home for me because he and I were postdocs at the
1:56:19same time at Stanford, different labs, and the way the news hit the world was
1:56:19same time at Stanford, different labs, and the way the news hit the world was
1:56:19same time at Stanford, different labs, and the way the news hit the world was
1:56:19same time at Stanford, different labs, and the way the news hit the world was
1:56:26very interesting. One of the things I benefit from now as a podcaster and not
1:56:26very interesting. One of the things I benefit from now as a podcaster and not
1:56:26very interesting. One of the things I benefit from now as a podcaster and not
1:56:26very interesting. One of the things I benefit from now as a podcaster and not
1:56:30just a professor is that I can talk about the stuff that perhaps pure professors
1:56:30just a professor is that I can talk about the stuff that perhaps pure professors
1:56:30just a professor is that I can talk about the stuff that perhaps pure professors
1:56:30just a professor is that I can talk about the stuff that perhaps pure professors
1:56:36wouldn't be willing to. So I'll say it.
1:56:36wouldn't be willing to. So I'll say it.
1:56:36wouldn't be willing to. So I'll say it.
1:56:36wouldn't be willing to. So I'll say it.
1:56:38It was very interesting because the world kind of braced but didn't make a decision
1:56:38It was very interesting because the world kind of braced but didn't make a decision
1:56:38It was very interesting because the world kind of braced but didn't make a decision
1:56:38It was very interesting because the world kind of braced but didn't make a decision
1:56:43as to whether or not they were upset that he had done this.
1:56:43as to whether or not they were upset that he had done this.
1:56:43as to whether or not they were upset that he had done this.
1:56:43as to whether or not they were upset that he had done this.
1:56:46Like, put him in front of an ethics board, maybe even throw him in a
1:56:46Like, put him in front of an ethics board, maybe even throw him in a
1:56:46Like, put him in front of an ethics board, maybe even throw him in a
1:56:46Like, put him in front of an ethics board, maybe even throw him in a
1:56:49cell, or give him a Nobel Prize.
1:56:49cell, or give him a Nobel Prize.
1:56:49cell, or give him a Nobel Prize.
1:56:49cell, or give him a Nobel Prize.
1:56:52It was like there was this kind of moment where no one really knew what
1:56:52It was like there was this kind of moment where no one really knew what
1:56:52It was like there was this kind of moment where no one really knew what
1:56:52It was like there was this kind of moment where no one really knew what
1:56:54to do. Like, do you reward him?
1:56:54to do. Like, do you reward him?
1:56:54to do. Like, do you reward him?
1:56:54to do. Like, do you reward him?
1:56:56Do you punish him? Do you do nothing?
1:56:56Do you punish him? Do you do nothing?
1:56:56Do you punish him? Do you do nothing?
1:56:56Do you punish him? Do you do nothing?
1:56:59And it circulated back to Stanford because there was a question of what he had
1:56:59And it circulated back to Stanford because there was a question of what he had
1:56:59And it circulated back to Stanford because there was a question of what he had
1:56:59And it circulated back to Stanford because there was a question of what he had
1:57:05learned at Stanford, what was done at Stanford.
1:57:05learned at Stanford, what was done at Stanford.
1:57:05learned at Stanford, what was done at Stanford.
1:57:05learned at Stanford, what was done at Stanford.
1:57:07And the stance, as I recall, was everyone just kind of waited to see how
1:57:07And the stance, as I recall, was everyone just kind of waited to see how
1:57:07And the stance, as I recall, was everyone just kind of waited to see how
1:57:07And the stance, as I recall, was everyone just kind of waited to see how
1:57:12the world treated him. This is not a disparagement of any of my colleagues.
1:57:12the world treated him. This is not a disparagement of any of my colleagues.
1:57:12the world treated him. This is not a disparagement of any of my colleagues.
1:57:12the world treated him. This is not a disparagement of any of my colleagues.
1:57:16I think we didn't understand how to react to this.
1:57:16I think we didn't understand how to react to this.
1:57:16I think we didn't understand how to react to this.
1:57:16I think we didn't understand how to react to this.
1:57:19And then the decision was quickly made at large that he had done a bad
1:57:19And then the decision was quickly made at large that he had done a bad
1:57:19And then the decision was quickly made at large that he had done a bad
1:57:19And then the decision was quickly made at large that he had done a bad
1:57:25thing. And that's kind of the last we ever heard about him or those kids.
1:57:25thing. And that's kind of the last we ever heard about him or those kids.
1:57:25thing. And that's kind of the last we ever heard about him or those kids.
1:57:25thing. And that's kind of the last we ever heard about him or those kids.
1:57:30The Chinese government condemned it publicly.
1:57:30The Chinese government condemned it publicly.
1:57:30The Chinese government condemned it publicly.
1:57:30The Chinese government condemned it publicly.
1:57:34I think they said he was going to be punished, but it wasn't clear if
1:57:34I think they said he was going to be punished, but it wasn't clear if
1:57:34I think they said he was going to be punished, but it wasn't clear if
1:57:34I think they said he was going to be punished, but it wasn't clear if
1:57:37he was going to be punished by being put in a jail cell, being fined,
1:57:37he was going to be punished by being put in a jail cell, being fined,
1:57:37he was going to be punished by being put in a jail cell, being fined,
1:57:37he was going to be punished by being put in a jail cell, being fined,
1:57:40or given a larger laboratory and more resources.
1:57:40or given a larger laboratory and more resources.
1:57:40or given a larger laboratory and more resources.
1:57:40or given a larger laboratory and more resources.
1:57:43It was very unclear. It's playing God at some level, right?
1:57:43It was very unclear. It's playing God at some level, right?
1:57:43It was very unclear. It's playing God at some level, right?
1:57:43It was very unclear. It's playing God at some level, right?
1:57:48It's not the same as deciding to not implant some embryos that were created through
1:57:48It's not the same as deciding to not implant some embryos that were created through
1:57:48It's not the same as deciding to not implant some embryos that were created through
1:57:48It's not the same as deciding to not implant some embryos that were created through
1:57:55IVF because they carry an extra chromosome.
1:57:55IVF because they carry an extra chromosome.
1:57:55IVF because they carry an extra chromosome.
1:57:55IVF because they carry an extra chromosome.
1:57:58It's different than that. It's taking healthy children, in this case, and making a change
1:57:58It's different than that. It's taking healthy children, in this case, and making a change
1:57:58It's different than that. It's taking healthy children, in this case, and making a change
1:57:58It's different than that. It's taking healthy children, in this case, and making a change
1:58:06to try and make them, quote unquote, super people.
1:58:06to try and make them, quote unquote, super people.
1:58:06to try and make them, quote unquote, super people.
1:58:06to try and make them, quote unquote, super people.
1:58:09So I would love your thoughts on that particular instance, your awareness, if any, that
1:58:09So I would love your thoughts on that particular instance, your awareness, if any, that
1:58:09So I would love your thoughts on that particular instance, your awareness, if any, that
1:58:09So I would love your thoughts on that particular instance, your awareness, if any, that
1:58:16CRISPR in otherwise healthy humans has continued, and where you think this is all going.
1:58:16CRISPR in otherwise healthy humans has continued, and where you think this is all going.
1:58:16CRISPR in otherwise healthy humans has continued, and where you think this is all going.
1:58:16CRISPR in otherwise healthy humans has continued, and where you think this is all going.
1:58:21Yeah, I think you capture a lot of that moment.
1:58:21Yeah, I think you capture a lot of that moment.
1:58:21Yeah, I think you capture a lot of that moment.
1:58:21Yeah, I think you capture a lot of that moment.
1:58:25I wasn't there, but there was an international CRISPR conference that was being held, I
1:58:25I wasn't there, but there was an international CRISPR conference that was being held, I
1:58:25I wasn't there, but there was an international CRISPR conference that was being held, I
1:58:25I wasn't there, but there was an international CRISPR conference that was being held, I
1:58:31believe, in Hong Kong at the time.
1:58:31believe, in Hong Kong at the time.
1:58:31believe, in Hong Kong at the time.
1:58:31believe, in Hong Kong at the time.
1:58:33And the scientist got up and announced with extraordinary pride in one of these sessions
1:58:33And the scientist got up and announced with extraordinary pride in one of these sessions
1:58:33And the scientist got up and announced with extraordinary pride in one of these sessions
1:58:33And the scientist got up and announced with extraordinary pride in one of these sessions
1:58:41in this conference that he had done it.
1:58:41in this conference that he had done it.
1:58:41in this conference that he had done it.
1:58:41in this conference that he had done it.
1:58:43He had done genetic modification of embryos.
1:58:43He had done genetic modification of embryos.
1:58:43He had done genetic modification of embryos.
1:58:43He had done genetic modification of embryos.
1:58:47My understanding of what had happened was that there were two twins who were parents
1:58:47My understanding of what had happened was that there were two twins who were parents
1:58:47My understanding of what had happened was that there were two twins who were parents
1:58:47My understanding of what had happened was that there were two twins who were parents
1:58:56who wanted to have kids, and the father was HIV positive.
1:58:56who wanted to have kids, and the father was HIV positive.
1:58:56who wanted to have kids, and the father was HIV positive.
1:58:56who wanted to have kids, and the father was HIV positive.
1:59:01And the modifications that they decided to try to make were to delete a gene
1:59:01And the modifications that they decided to try to make were to delete a gene
1:59:01And the modifications that they decided to try to make were to delete a gene
1:59:01And the modifications that they decided to try to make were to delete a gene
1:59:08that is, if it's deleted, can confer resistance to HIV.
1:59:08that is, if it's deleted, can confer resistance to HIV.
1:59:08that is, if it's deleted, can confer resistance to HIV.
1:59:08that is, if it's deleted, can confer resistance to HIV.
1:59:15This is a gene called CCR5.
1:59:15This is a gene called CCR5.
1:59:15This is a gene called CCR5.
1:59:15This is a gene called CCR5.
1:59:17There's people who naturally have a certain mutation in this, at some frequency, and mutations
1:59:17There's people who naturally have a certain mutation in this, at some frequency, and mutations
1:59:17There's people who naturally have a certain mutation in this, at some frequency, and mutations
1:59:17There's people who naturally have a certain mutation in this, at some frequency, and mutations
1:59:23in this gene confer resistance to HIV if they're naturally occurring.
1:59:23in this gene confer resistance to HIV if they're naturally occurring.
1:59:23in this gene confer resistance to HIV if they're naturally occurring.
1:59:23in this gene confer resistance to HIV if they're naturally occurring.
1:59:26So that was the supposed rationale.
1:59:26So that was the supposed rationale.
1:59:26So that was the supposed rationale.
1:59:26So that was the supposed rationale.
1:59:28So there was a disease aspect to it.
1:59:28So there was a disease aspect to it.
1:59:28So there was a disease aspect to it.
1:59:28So there was a disease aspect to it.
1:59:31Okay, I wasn't aware of that.
1:59:31Okay, I wasn't aware of that.
1:59:31Okay, I wasn't aware of that.
1:59:31Okay, I wasn't aware of that.
1:59:32Thank you for that clarification.
1:59:32Thank you for that clarification.
1:59:32Thank you for that clarification.
1:59:32Thank you for that clarification.
1:59:34It was a prophylaxis against this potential risk of HIV.
1:59:34It was a prophylaxis against this potential risk of HIV.
1:59:34It was a prophylaxis against this potential risk of HIV.
1:59:34It was a prophylaxis against this potential risk of HIV.
1:59:37Now, there were a lot of troublesome features from what I understand.
1:59:37Now, there were a lot of troublesome features from what I understand.
1:59:37Now, there were a lot of troublesome features from what I understand.
1:59:37Now, there were a lot of troublesome features from what I understand.
1:59:42First of all, there's state -of -the -art methods to reduce the risk of HIV
1:59:42First of all, there's state -of -the -art methods to reduce the risk of HIV
1:59:42First of all, there's state -of -the -art methods to reduce the risk of HIV
1:59:42First of all, there's state -of -the -art methods to reduce the risk of HIV
1:59:47through sperm washing and things that can be done that would, from my understanding, essentially
1:59:47through sperm washing and things that can be done that would, from my understanding, essentially
1:59:47through sperm washing and things that can be done that would, from my understanding, essentially
1:59:47through sperm washing and things that can be done that would, from my understanding, essentially
1:59:52reduce the risk to near zero of transmission from a father to an embryo.
1:59:52reduce the risk to near zero of transmission from a father to an embryo.
1:59:52reduce the risk to near zero of transmission from a father to an embryo.
1:59:52reduce the risk to near zero of transmission from a father to an embryo.
1:59:58So I think it was a bit of a manufactured need, but there was the
1:59:58So I think it was a bit of a manufactured need, but there was the
1:59:58So I think it was a bit of a manufactured need, but there was the
1:59:58So I think it was a bit of a manufactured need, but there was the
2:00:02supposed justification. Second of all...
2:00:02supposed justification. Second of all...
2:00:02supposed justification. Second of all...
2:00:02supposed justification. Second of all...
2:00:05Second of all... It was done, so they actually ended up generating two twins and
2:00:05Second of all... It was done, so they actually ended up generating two twins and
2:00:05Second of all... It was done, so they actually ended up generating two twins and
2:00:05Second of all... It was done, so they actually ended up generating two twins and
2:00:10my understanding of how it was done, and I don't think that this was ever
2:00:10my understanding of how it was done, and I don't think that this was ever
2:00:10my understanding of how it was done, and I don't think that this was ever
2:00:10my understanding of how it was done, and I don't think that this was ever
2:00:15published, there was some publicity that was released, so I'm sort of piecing this together
2:00:15published, there was some publicity that was released, so I'm sort of piecing this together
2:00:15published, there was some publicity that was released, so I'm sort of piecing this together
2:00:15published, there was some publicity that was released, so I'm sort of piecing this together
2:00:20from what was public at that time, but I don't think any journal ever published
2:00:20from what was public at that time, but I don't think any journal ever published
2:00:20from what was public at that time, but I don't think any journal ever published
2:00:20from what was public at that time, but I don't think any journal ever published
2:00:24this in any peer -reviewed context.
2:00:24this in any peer -reviewed context.
2:00:24this in any peer -reviewed context.
2:00:24this in any peer -reviewed context.
2:00:28They did this in concert with essentially IVF techniques, so they were fertilizing embryos with
2:00:28They did this in concert with essentially IVF techniques, so they were fertilizing embryos with
2:00:28They did this in concert with essentially IVF techniques, so they were fertilizing embryos with
2:00:28They did this in concert with essentially IVF techniques, so they were fertilizing embryos with
2:00:35this father's sperm, there's the mother's eggs, they created multiple embryos, and then they delivered
2:00:35this father's sperm, there's the mother's eggs, they created multiple embryos, and then they delivered
2:00:35this father's sperm, there's the mother's eggs, they created multiple embryos, and then they delivered
2:00:35this father's sperm, there's the mother's eggs, they created multiple embryos, and then they delivered
2:00:43CRISPR into these embryos and trying to create mutations in the CCR5 gene.
2:00:43CRISPR into these embryos and trying to create mutations in the CCR5 gene.
2:00:43CRISPR into these embryos and trying to create mutations in the CCR5 gene.
2:00:43CRISPR into these embryos and trying to create mutations in the CCR5 gene.
2:00:49There was some variability, it was pretty early in days of CRISPR, and as I
2:00:49There was some variability, it was pretty early in days of CRISPR, and as I
2:00:49There was some variability, it was pretty early in days of CRISPR, and as I
2:00:49There was some variability, it was pretty early in days of CRISPR, and as I
2:00:53said, there's an unpredictability of what happens when you make a double -stranded break in
2:00:53said, there's an unpredictability of what happens when you make a double -stranded break in
2:00:53said, there's an unpredictability of what happens when you make a double -stranded break in
2:00:53said, there's an unpredictability of what happens when you make a double -stranded break in
2:00:57the genome, so it was a stretch to say, okay, they didn't exactly get the
2:00:57the genome, so it was a stretch to say, okay, they didn't exactly get the
2:00:57the genome, so it was a stretch to say, okay, they didn't exactly get the
2:00:57the genome, so it was a stretch to say, okay, they didn't exactly get the
2:01:01mutations that they wanted, but they proceeded nonetheless to implant these embryos.
2:01:01mutations that they wanted, but they proceeded nonetheless to implant these embryos.
2:01:01mutations that they wanted, but they proceeded nonetheless to implant these embryos.
2:01:01mutations that they wanted, but they proceeded nonetheless to implant these embryos.
2:01:07And I know less about this, but there were also serious concerns about the way
2:01:07And I know less about this, but there were also serious concerns about the way
2:01:07And I know less about this, but there were also serious concerns about the way
2:01:07And I know less about this, but there were also serious concerns about the way
2:01:11that consent was done on this, like how much was informed about what the actual
2:01:11that consent was done on this, like how much was informed about what the actual
2:01:11that consent was done on this, like how much was informed about what the actual
2:01:11that consent was done on this, like how much was informed about what the actual
2:01:16benefits would be to these patients.
2:01:16benefits would be to these patients.
2:01:16benefits would be to these patients.
2:01:16benefits would be to these patients.
2:01:19My understanding is that he got up and Ida wasn't in the room, but I
2:01:19My understanding is that he got up and Ida wasn't in the room, but I
2:01:19My understanding is that he got up and Ida wasn't in the room, but I
2:01:19My understanding is that he got up and Ida wasn't in the room, but I
2:01:23do think that there was some degree of immediate horror that this was being announced
2:01:23do think that there was some degree of immediate horror that this was being announced
2:01:23do think that there was some degree of immediate horror that this was being announced
2:01:23do think that there was some degree of immediate horror that this was being announced
2:01:28and that it was unfolding in this way and that it hadn't been considered, it
2:01:28and that it was unfolding in this way and that it hadn't been considered, it
2:01:28and that it was unfolding in this way and that it hadn't been considered, it
2:01:28and that it was unfolding in this way and that it hadn't been considered, it
2:01:33was not ready. In the wake of that, the Chinese government then announced that they
2:01:33was not ready. In the wake of that, the Chinese government then announced that they
2:01:33was not ready. In the wake of that, the Chinese government then announced that they
2:01:33was not ready. In the wake of that, the Chinese government then announced that they
2:01:39were going to punish this, and I don't know the details, but I believe that
2:01:39were going to punish this, and I don't know the details, but I believe that
2:01:39were going to punish this, and I don't know the details, but I believe that
2:01:39were going to punish this, and I don't know the details, but I believe that
2:01:41he underwent some period of house arrest.
2:01:41he underwent some period of house arrest.
2:01:41he underwent some period of house arrest.
2:01:41he underwent some period of house arrest.
2:01:44Okay, he was punished. I believe so, I think after there was some degree of
2:01:44Okay, he was punished. I believe so, I think after there was some degree of
2:01:44Okay, he was punished. I believe so, I think after there was some degree of
2:01:44Okay, he was punished. I believe so, I think after there was some degree of
2:01:51scientific outrage. Yeah, there was this pause moment that lasted maybe a week or two.
2:01:51scientific outrage. Yeah, there was this pause moment that lasted maybe a week or two.
2:01:51scientific outrage. Yeah, there was this pause moment that lasted maybe a week or two.
2:01:51scientific outrage. Yeah, there was this pause moment that lasted maybe a week or two.
2:01:58Okay, well, you're clarifying a lot of the important details.
2:01:58Okay, well, you're clarifying a lot of the important details.
2:01:58Okay, well, you're clarifying a lot of the important details.
2:01:58Okay, well, you're clarifying a lot of the important details.
2:02:02But my understanding, again, is that he's now free and I think is restarting a
2:02:02But my understanding, again, is that he's now free and I think is restarting a
2:02:02But my understanding, again, is that he's now free and I think is restarting a
2:02:02But my understanding, again, is that he's now free and I think is restarting a
2:02:09lab. I don't think in China, I think somewhere else.
2:02:09lab. I don't think in China, I think somewhere else.
2:02:09lab. I don't think in China, I think somewhere else.
2:02:09lab. I don't think in China, I think somewhere else.
2:02:12So the story might not be over yet.
2:02:12So the story might not be over yet.
2:02:12So the story might not be over yet.
2:02:12So the story might not be over yet.
2:02:14So that's my understanding of the facts.
2:02:14So that's my understanding of the facts.
2:02:14So that's my understanding of the facts.
2:02:14So that's my understanding of the facts.
2:02:18I'll tell you now what I think.
2:02:18I'll tell you now what I think.
2:02:18I'll tell you now what I think.
2:02:18I'll tell you now what I think.
2:02:20Yeah, please. I actually have a pretty hard line position on this, which I'm not
2:02:20Yeah, please. I actually have a pretty hard line position on this, which I'm not
2:02:20Yeah, please. I actually have a pretty hard line position on this, which I'm not
2:02:20Yeah, please. I actually have a pretty hard line position on this, which I'm not
2:02:25sure all my colleagues would agree with, but I think that we should have a
2:02:25sure all my colleagues would agree with, but I think that we should have a
2:02:25sure all my colleagues would agree with, but I think that we should have a
2:02:25sure all my colleagues would agree with, but I think that we should have a
2:02:29line in the sand where we do not introduce genetic edits that will be passed
2:02:29line in the sand where we do not introduce genetic edits that will be passed
2:02:29line in the sand where we do not introduce genetic edits that will be passed
2:02:29line in the sand where we do not introduce genetic edits that will be passed
2:02:34on to the next generation.
2:02:34on to the next generation.
2:02:34on to the next generation.
2:02:34on to the next generation.
2:02:37You know, I told you I've dedicated my life now to creating CRISPR technologies to
2:02:37You know, I told you I've dedicated my life now to creating CRISPR technologies to
2:02:37You know, I told you I've dedicated my life now to creating CRISPR technologies to
2:02:37You know, I told you I've dedicated my life now to creating CRISPR technologies to
2:02:41engineer individual cells in the immune system.
2:02:41engineer individual cells in the immune system.
2:02:41engineer individual cells in the immune system.
2:02:41engineer individual cells in the immune system.
2:02:44But these are what we call somatic edits.
2:02:44But these are what we call somatic edits.
2:02:44But these are what we call somatic edits.
2:02:44But these are what we call somatic edits.
2:02:47These are making edits to the DNA in individual cells where those genetic consequences will
2:02:47These are making edits to the DNA in individual cells where those genetic consequences will
2:02:47These are making edits to the DNA in individual cells where those genetic consequences will
2:02:47These are making edits to the DNA in individual cells where those genetic consequences will
2:02:53be passed on to the daughter's cells, but not to the next generation of human
2:02:53be passed on to the daughter's cells, but not to the next generation of human
2:02:53be passed on to the daughter's cells, but not to the next generation of human
2:02:53be passed on to the daughter's cells, but not to the next generation of human
2:02:57because we're not making genetic edits in sperm or in eggs.
2:02:57because we're not making genetic edits in sperm or in eggs.
2:02:57because we're not making genetic edits in sperm or in eggs.
2:02:57because we're not making genetic edits in sperm or in eggs.
2:03:02If you do it in an embryo, all of a sudden every cell in the
2:03:02If you do it in an embryo, all of a sudden every cell in the
2:03:02If you do it in an embryo, all of a sudden every cell in the
2:03:02If you do it in an embryo, all of a sudden every cell in the
2:03:06developing embryo will have it, including sperm and egg, and now you've not only made
2:03:06developing embryo will have it, including sperm and egg, and now you've not only made
2:03:06developing embryo will have it, including sperm and egg, and now you've not only made
2:03:06developing embryo will have it, including sperm and egg, and now you've not only made
2:03:11a genetic change to treat a disease or, in this case, to prevent a disease,
2:03:11a genetic change to treat a disease or, in this case, to prevent a disease,
2:03:11a genetic change to treat a disease or, in this case, to prevent a disease,
2:03:11a genetic change to treat a disease or, in this case, to prevent a disease,
2:03:14as you said, in some cases it will be imagined to make an enhancement.
2:03:14as you said, in some cases it will be imagined to make an enhancement.
2:03:14as you said, in some cases it will be imagined to make an enhancement.
2:03:14as you said, in some cases it will be imagined to make an enhancement.
2:03:18People have talked about, you know, maybe you want to add, we know genes that
2:03:18People have talked about, you know, maybe you want to add, we know genes that
2:03:18People have talked about, you know, maybe you want to add, we know genes that
2:03:18People have talked about, you know, maybe you want to add, we know genes that
2:03:22would make people be more muscular, or will there be a rush to, you know...
2:03:22would make people be more muscular, or will there be a rush to, you know...
2:03:22would make people be more muscular, or will there be a rush to, you know...
2:03:22would make people be more muscular, or will there be a rush to, you know...
2:03:26Or enhance memory. I mean, many years ago there was a paper, I mean, it
2:03:26Or enhance memory. I mean, many years ago there was a paper, I mean, it
2:03:26Or enhance memory. I mean, many years ago there was a paper, I mean, it
2:03:26Or enhance memory. I mean, many years ago there was a paper, I mean, it
2:03:29had some issues with replication down the line, but where I think it was Joe
2:03:29had some issues with replication down the line, but where I think it was Joe
2:03:29had some issues with replication down the line, but where I think it was Joe
2:03:29had some issues with replication down the line, but where I think it was Joe
2:03:34Chen at Princeton introduced maybe a mutant or an extra, I forget now, it's been
2:03:34Chen at Princeton introduced maybe a mutant or an extra, I forget now, it's been
2:03:34Chen at Princeton introduced maybe a mutant or an extra, I forget now, it's been
2:03:34Chen at Princeton introduced maybe a mutant or an extra, I forget now, it's been
2:03:41a while, case in point, I clearly don't have this receptor, to the NMDA receptor,
2:03:41a while, case in point, I clearly don't have this receptor, to the NMDA receptor,
2:03:41a while, case in point, I clearly don't have this receptor, to the NMDA receptor,
2:03:41a while, case in point, I clearly don't have this receptor, to the NMDA receptor,
2:03:48which is involved in plasticity in a sub -region of the hippocampus.
2:03:48which is involved in plasticity in a sub -region of the hippocampus.
2:03:48which is involved in plasticity in a sub -region of the hippocampus.
2:03:48which is involved in plasticity in a sub -region of the hippocampus.
2:03:50The idea was they were trying to make super smart mice.
2:03:50The idea was they were trying to make super smart mice.
2:03:50The idea was they were trying to make super smart mice.
2:03:50The idea was they were trying to make super smart mice.
2:03:53I remember that. That made quite a splash at the time, right?
2:03:53I remember that. That made quite a splash at the time, right?
2:03:53I remember that. That made quite a splash at the time, right?
2:03:53I remember that. That made quite a splash at the time, right?
2:03:55I forget where that went.
2:03:55I forget where that went.
2:03:55I forget where that went.
2:03:55I forget where that went.
2:03:57Maybe Joe followed up on that, I don't know.
2:03:57Maybe Joe followed up on that, I don't know.
2:03:57Maybe Joe followed up on that, I don't know.
2:03:57Maybe Joe followed up on that, I don't know.
2:03:59But that would be the sort of thing that people are both excited about and
2:03:59But that would be the sort of thing that people are both excited about and
2:03:59But that would be the sort of thing that people are both excited about and
2:03:59But that would be the sort of thing that people are both excited about and
2:04:04concerned about. You know, could you confer your offspring with better memory genes?
2:04:04concerned about. You know, could you confer your offspring with better memory genes?
2:04:04concerned about. You know, could you confer your offspring with better memory genes?
2:04:04concerned about. You know, could you confer your offspring with better memory genes?
2:04:11But, of course, we have no idea if that's a good or a bad thing.
2:04:11But, of course, we have no idea if that's a good or a bad thing.
2:04:11But, of course, we have no idea if that's a good or a bad thing.
2:04:11But, of course, we have no idea if that's a good or a bad thing.
2:04:14Forgetting certain things is very useful as well.
2:04:14Forgetting certain things is very useful as well.
2:04:14Forgetting certain things is very useful as well.
2:04:14Forgetting certain things is very useful as well.
2:04:17I completely agree with you.
2:04:17I completely agree with you.
2:04:17I completely agree with you.
2:04:17I completely agree with you.
2:04:18And I think the point you made is a key one, that we do live
2:04:18And I think the point you made is a key one, that we do live
2:04:18And I think the point you made is a key one, that we do live
2:04:18And I think the point you made is a key one, that we do live
2:04:23in a world where people do IVF and we do pre -implantation genetic testing and
2:04:23in a world where people do IVF and we do pre -implantation genetic testing and
2:04:23in a world where people do IVF and we do pre -implantation genetic testing and
2:04:23in a world where people do IVF and we do pre -implantation genetic testing and
2:04:28we select, people have the option to select, not implant embryos that have certain mutations.
2:04:28we select, people have the option to select, not implant embryos that have certain mutations.
2:04:28we select, people have the option to select, not implant embryos that have certain mutations.
2:04:28we select, people have the option to select, not implant embryos that have certain mutations.
2:04:34That's already a level of, like, avoiding disease in the next generation if there's a
2:04:34That's already a level of, like, avoiding disease in the next generation if there's a
2:04:34That's already a level of, like, avoiding disease in the next generation if there's a
2:04:34That's already a level of, like, avoiding disease in the next generation if there's a
2:04:39severe mutation. I think it's not, it's a qualitatively different step to then not just
2:04:39severe mutation. I think it's not, it's a qualitatively different step to then not just
2:04:39severe mutation. I think it's not, it's a qualitatively different step to then not just
2:04:39severe mutation. I think it's not, it's a qualitatively different step to then not just
2:04:46select but to actually make a genetic change.
2:04:46select but to actually make a genetic change.
2:04:46select but to actually make a genetic change.
2:04:46select but to actually make a genetic change.
2:04:49All of a sudden now you're really hampered.
2:04:49All of a sudden now you're really hampered.
2:04:49All of a sudden now you're really hampered.
2:04:49All of a sudden now you're really hampered.
2:04:52You have the ability to make some kind of mass -produced genetic edit in many
2:04:52You have the ability to make some kind of mass -produced genetic edit in many
2:04:52You have the ability to make some kind of mass -produced genetic edit in many
2:04:52You have the ability to make some kind of mass -produced genetic edit in many
2:04:59embryos. I worry a lot about what this means for our offspring if they are
2:04:59embryos. I worry a lot about what this means for our offspring if they are
2:04:59embryos. I worry a lot about what this means for our offspring if they are
2:04:59embryos. I worry a lot about what this means for our offspring if they are
2:05:05designed rather than just born by chance.
2:05:05designed rather than just born by chance.
2:05:05designed rather than just born by chance.
2:05:05designed rather than just born by chance.
2:05:08I worry about fads. You know, when you think about, like, the Pinterest culture that
2:05:08I worry about fads. You know, when you think about, like, the Pinterest culture that
2:05:08I worry about fads. You know, when you think about, like, the Pinterest culture that
2:05:08I worry about fads. You know, when you think about, like, the Pinterest culture that
2:05:14we live in where people see something on Pinterest and want to follow on, I
2:05:14we live in where people see something on Pinterest and want to follow on, I
2:05:14we live in where people see something on Pinterest and want to follow on, I
2:05:14we live in where people see something on Pinterest and want to follow on, I
2:05:18worry deeply about losing human diversity if we see fads in what genes are popular
2:05:18worry deeply about losing human diversity if we see fads in what genes are popular
2:05:18worry deeply about losing human diversity if we see fads in what genes are popular
2:05:18worry deeply about losing human diversity if we see fads in what genes are popular
2:05:26for our offspring and people can order those in concert with IVF.
2:05:26for our offspring and people can order those in concert with IVF.
2:05:26for our offspring and people can order those in concert with IVF.
2:05:26for our offspring and people can order those in concert with IVF.
2:05:31And I don't think we gain...
2:05:31And I don't think we gain...
2:05:31And I don't think we gain...
2:05:31And I don't think we gain...
2:05:33enough to come close to what we would lose as a society if we embark
2:05:33enough to come close to what we would lose as a society if we embark
2:05:33enough to come close to what we would lose as a society if we embark
2:05:33enough to come close to what we would lose as a society if we embark
2:05:39on that journey of editing offspring.
2:05:39on that journey of editing offspring.
2:05:39on that journey of editing offspring.
2:05:39on that journey of editing offspring.
2:05:43I appreciate the clear stance and answer.
2:05:43I appreciate the clear stance and answer.
2:05:43I appreciate the clear stance and answer.
2:05:43I appreciate the clear stance and answer.
2:05:46As long as we're there, I'd love your thoughts on some of the newer technologies
2:05:46As long as we're there, I'd love your thoughts on some of the newer technologies
2:05:46As long as we're there, I'd love your thoughts on some of the newer technologies
2:05:46As long as we're there, I'd love your thoughts on some of the newer technologies
2:05:51that are only available to those that can afford them.
2:05:51that are only available to those that can afford them.
2:05:51that are only available to those that can afford them.
2:05:51that are only available to those that can afford them.
2:05:54So that's an important caveat for deep sequencing embryos from IVF.
2:05:54So that's an important caveat for deep sequencing embryos from IVF.
2:05:54So that's an important caveat for deep sequencing embryos from IVF.
2:05:54So that's an important caveat for deep sequencing embryos from IVF.
2:05:58So typically with IVF, check to see that they're chromosomally normal, that they're euploid, as
2:05:58So typically with IVF, check to see that they're chromosomally normal, that they're euploid, as
2:05:58So typically with IVF, check to see that they're chromosomally normal, that they're euploid, as
2:05:58So typically with IVF, check to see that they're chromosomally normal, that they're euploid, as
2:06:03they say, and they'll do some sequencing of the parents, maybe of the embryos as
2:06:03they say, and they'll do some sequencing of the parents, maybe of the embryos as
2:06:03they say, and they'll do some sequencing of the parents, maybe of the embryos as
2:06:03they say, and they'll do some sequencing of the parents, maybe of the embryos as
2:06:08well for certain mutations. But there's this whole other industry now.
2:06:08well for certain mutations. But there's this whole other industry now.
2:06:08well for certain mutations. But there's this whole other industry now.
2:06:08well for certain mutations. But there's this whole other industry now.
2:06:12I believe a company in the Bay Area, Orchid, is probably the most popular one
2:06:12I believe a company in the Bay Area, Orchid, is probably the most popular one
2:06:12I believe a company in the Bay Area, Orchid, is probably the most popular one
2:06:12I believe a company in the Bay Area, Orchid, is probably the most popular one
2:06:18or well -known one, where if you pay a certain amount of money, they'll deep
2:06:18or well -known one, where if you pay a certain amount of money, they'll deep
2:06:18or well -known one, where if you pay a certain amount of money, they'll deep
2:06:18or well -known one, where if you pay a certain amount of money, they'll deep
2:06:24sequence. If you pay more, they'll deeper sequence.
2:06:24sequence. If you pay more, they'll deeper sequence.
2:06:24sequence. If you pay more, they'll deeper sequence.
2:06:24sequence. If you pay more, they'll deeper sequence.
2:06:27And so you're getting some additional readout of potential disease genes.
2:06:27And so you're getting some additional readout of potential disease genes.
2:06:27And so you're getting some additional readout of potential disease genes.
2:06:27And so you're getting some additional readout of potential disease genes.
2:06:32And I've looked at that technology, and they're very clear that at some point they
2:06:32And I've looked at that technology, and they're very clear that at some point they
2:06:32And I've looked at that technology, and they're very clear that at some point they
2:06:32And I've looked at that technology, and they're very clear that at some point they
2:06:37can't draw a causal relationship between, say, like a neural ligand mutation and autism, but
2:06:37can't draw a causal relationship between, say, like a neural ligand mutation and autism, but
2:06:37can't draw a causal relationship between, say, like a neural ligand mutation and autism, but
2:06:37can't draw a causal relationship between, say, like a neural ligand mutation and autism, but
2:06:42there are these implications based on the animal data.
2:06:42there are these implications based on the animal data.
2:06:42there are these implications based on the animal data.
2:06:42there are these implications based on the animal data.
2:06:45And so it starts to become this, it's not gene editing, but it is deeper
2:06:45And so it starts to become this, it's not gene editing, but it is deeper
2:06:45And so it starts to become this, it's not gene editing, but it is deeper
2:06:45And so it starts to become this, it's not gene editing, but it is deeper
2:06:52and deeper gene sequencing -based selection of embryos.
2:06:52and deeper gene sequencing -based selection of embryos.
2:06:52and deeper gene sequencing -based selection of embryos.
2:06:52and deeper gene sequencing -based selection of embryos.
2:06:57Yeah. First of all, I'm sympathetic to the idea, right?
2:06:57Yeah. First of all, I'm sympathetic to the idea, right?
2:06:57Yeah. First of all, I'm sympathetic to the idea, right?
2:06:57Yeah. First of all, I'm sympathetic to the idea, right?
2:07:00Like we want to protect our kids from suffering and from disease, right?
2:07:00Like we want to protect our kids from suffering and from disease, right?
2:07:00Like we want to protect our kids from suffering and from disease, right?
2:07:00Like we want to protect our kids from suffering and from disease, right?
2:07:05And I understand the idea of doing pre -implantation genetic testing.
2:07:05And I understand the idea of doing pre -implantation genetic testing.
2:07:05And I understand the idea of doing pre -implantation genetic testing.
2:07:05And I understand the idea of doing pre -implantation genetic testing.
2:07:09If you want to avoid a mutation or chromosomal abnormality, that would really impair lifespan
2:07:09If you want to avoid a mutation or chromosomal abnormality, that would really impair lifespan
2:07:09If you want to avoid a mutation or chromosomal abnormality, that would really impair lifespan
2:07:09If you want to avoid a mutation or chromosomal abnormality, that would really impair lifespan
2:07:16or quality of life for your offspring.
2:07:16or quality of life for your offspring.
2:07:16or quality of life for your offspring.
2:07:16or quality of life for your offspring.
2:07:20The impulse that we know that's this sort of straightforward chromosomal testing that's done from
2:07:20The impulse that we know that's this sort of straightforward chromosomal testing that's done from
2:07:20The impulse that we know that's this sort of straightforward chromosomal testing that's done from
2:07:20The impulse that we know that's this sort of straightforward chromosomal testing that's done from
2:07:26the first level will miss a lot of mutations.
2:07:26the first level will miss a lot of mutations.
2:07:26the first level will miss a lot of mutations.
2:07:26the first level will miss a lot of mutations.
2:07:30So people, I understand the idea of trying to fill that in with more deep
2:07:30So people, I understand the idea of trying to fill that in with more deep
2:07:30So people, I understand the idea of trying to fill that in with more deep
2:07:30So people, I understand the idea of trying to fill that in with more deep
2:07:34sequencing or comprehensive sequencing of the genome.
2:07:34sequencing or comprehensive sequencing of the genome.
2:07:34sequencing or comprehensive sequencing of the genome.
2:07:34sequencing or comprehensive sequencing of the genome.
2:07:36The problem is there are some mutations that if we see them, we will know
2:07:36The problem is there are some mutations that if we see them, we will know
2:07:36The problem is there are some mutations that if we see them, we will know
2:07:36The problem is there are some mutations that if we see them, we will know
2:07:41that they can cause severe disease.
2:07:41that they can cause severe disease.
2:07:41that they can cause severe disease.
2:07:41that they can cause severe disease.
2:07:44But there's a lot that have become probabilistic and statistical, and I think we're over
2:07:44But there's a lot that have become probabilistic and statistical, and I think we're over
2:07:44But there's a lot that have become probabilistic and statistical, and I think we're over
2:07:44But there's a lot that have become probabilistic and statistical, and I think we're over
2:07:49-promising what can be delivered.
2:07:49-promising what can be delivered.
2:07:49-promising what can be delivered.
2:07:49-promising what can be delivered.
2:07:52So all of a sudden you're using an algorithm to determine which embryos are more
2:07:52So all of a sudden you're using an algorithm to determine which embryos are more
2:07:52So all of a sudden you're using an algorithm to determine which embryos are more
2:07:52So all of a sudden you're using an algorithm to determine which embryos are more
2:07:58desirable than others. And I think the fact is that it's not an axis that
2:07:58desirable than others. And I think the fact is that it's not an axis that
2:07:58desirable than others. And I think the fact is that it's not an axis that
2:07:58desirable than others. And I think the fact is that it's not an axis that
2:08:04actually exists. There aren't categorically more desirable or less desirable.
2:08:04actually exists. There aren't categorically more desirable or less desirable.
2:08:04actually exists. There aren't categorically more desirable or less desirable.
2:08:04actually exists. There aren't categorically more desirable or less desirable.
2:08:09We want diverse people. And how successful you're going to be is an interplay of
2:08:09We want diverse people. And how successful you're going to be is an interplay of
2:08:09We want diverse people. And how successful you're going to be is an interplay of
2:08:09We want diverse people. And how successful you're going to be is an interplay of
2:08:16how your genes come around and influence your community, your environment.
2:08:16how your genes come around and influence your community, your environment.
2:08:16how your genes come around and influence your community, your environment.
2:08:16how your genes come around and influence your community, your environment.
2:08:22Those are unknowable from just looking at a DNA sequence alone.
2:08:22Those are unknowable from just looking at a DNA sequence alone.
2:08:22Those are unknowable from just looking at a DNA sequence alone.
2:08:22Those are unknowable from just looking at a DNA sequence alone.
2:08:26So I think that it introduces a false axis.
2:08:26So I think that it introduces a false axis.
2:08:26So I think that it introduces a false axis.
2:08:26So I think that it introduces a false axis.
2:08:31There's another book that I would recommend here that I read years ago, and I
2:08:31There's another book that I would recommend here that I read years ago, and I
2:08:31There's another book that I would recommend here that I read years ago, and I
2:08:31There's another book that I would recommend here that I read years ago, and I
2:08:36actually am probably overdue to go back and reread this.
2:08:36actually am probably overdue to go back and reread this.
2:08:36actually am probably overdue to go back and reread this.
2:08:36actually am probably overdue to go back and reread this.
2:08:39This predates CRISPR technology, but there's a Harvard philosopher, Michael Sandel, who years ago wrote
2:08:39This predates CRISPR technology, but there's a Harvard philosopher, Michael Sandel, who years ago wrote
2:08:39This predates CRISPR technology, but there's a Harvard philosopher, Michael Sandel, who years ago wrote
2:08:39This predates CRISPR technology, but there's a Harvard philosopher, Michael Sandel, who years ago wrote
2:08:45a short book called The Case Against Perfection.
2:08:45a short book called The Case Against Perfection.
2:08:45a short book called The Case Against Perfection.
2:08:45a short book called The Case Against Perfection.
2:08:48And it's a really beautiful meditation on what's lost when we enter into this illusion
2:08:48And it's a really beautiful meditation on what's lost when we enter into this illusion
2:08:48And it's a really beautiful meditation on what's lost when we enter into this illusion
2:08:48And it's a really beautiful meditation on what's lost when we enter into this illusion
2:08:56of thinking that we can engineer towards some axis of perfection rather than embracing the
2:08:56of thinking that we can engineer towards some axis of perfection rather than embracing the
2:08:56of thinking that we can engineer towards some axis of perfection rather than embracing the
2:08:56of thinking that we can engineer towards some axis of perfection rather than embracing the
2:09:02beauty of chance and happenstance, which is like a part of our relationship with our
2:09:02beauty of chance and happenstance, which is like a part of our relationship with our
2:09:02beauty of chance and happenstance, which is like a part of our relationship with our
2:09:02beauty of chance and happenstance, which is like a part of our relationship with our
2:09:08kids, with ourselves, of thinking, okay, this is the human experience.
2:09:08kids, with ourselves, of thinking, okay, this is the human experience.
2:09:08kids, with ourselves, of thinking, okay, this is the human experience.
2:09:08kids, with ourselves, of thinking, okay, this is the human experience.
2:09:12You're a product of some degree of chance and circumstance.
2:09:12You're a product of some degree of chance and circumstance.
2:09:12You're a product of some degree of chance and circumstance.
2:09:12You're a product of some degree of chance and circumstance.
2:09:17I'll definitely check out the book.
2:09:17I'll definitely check out the book.
2:09:17I'll definitely check out the book.
2:09:17I'll definitely check out the book.
2:09:20I know the whole point of life is not to be a quote -unquote high
2:09:20I know the whole point of life is not to be a quote -unquote high
2:09:20I know the whole point of life is not to be a quote -unquote high
2:09:20I know the whole point of life is not to be a quote -unquote high
2:09:24performer, but I'll just say as an example, I know of no single very successful
2:09:24performer, but I'll just say as an example, I know of no single very successful
2:09:24performer, but I'll just say as an example, I know of no single very successful
2:09:24performer, but I'll just say as an example, I know of no single very successful
2:09:30person that doesn't have some thing about themselves that initially they disliked or felt that
2:09:30person that doesn't have some thing about themselves that initially they disliked or felt that
2:09:30person that doesn't have some thing about themselves that initially they disliked or felt that
2:09:30person that doesn't have some thing about themselves that initially they disliked or felt that
2:09:39they had to overcome, which led them to pursue certain things, hopefully in a healthy
2:09:39they had to overcome, which led them to pursue certain things, hopefully in a healthy
2:09:39they had to overcome, which led them to pursue certain things, hopefully in a healthy
2:09:39they had to overcome, which led them to pursue certain things, hopefully in a healthy
2:09:43way, and that they eventually came to embrace and are now grateful for.
2:09:43way, and that they eventually came to embrace and are now grateful for.
2:09:43way, and that they eventually came to embrace and are now grateful for.
2:09:43way, and that they eventually came to embrace and are now grateful for.
2:09:50I know of no exception to that.
2:09:50I know of no exception to that.
2:09:50I know of no exception to that.
2:09:50I know of no exception to that.
2:09:53It's sort of the story of humans in many ways.
2:09:53It's sort of the story of humans in many ways.
2:09:53It's sort of the story of humans in many ways.
2:09:53It's sort of the story of humans in many ways.
2:09:56It's a story of humans.
2:09:56It's a story of humans.
2:09:56It's a story of humans.
2:09:56It's a story of humans.
2:09:58In fact, people who perhaps are told that they're perfect in every dimension their entire
2:09:58In fact, people who perhaps are told that they're perfect in every dimension their entire
2:09:58In fact, people who perhaps are told that they're perfect in every dimension their entire
2:09:58In fact, people who perhaps are told that they're perfect in every dimension their entire
2:10:04lives, I can only imagine the amount of pressure they must feel.
2:10:04lives, I can only imagine the amount of pressure they must feel.
2:10:04lives, I can only imagine the amount of pressure they must feel.
2:10:04lives, I can only imagine the amount of pressure they must feel.
2:10:09In fact, before today's discussion, we were talking about people that we knew that perhaps
2:10:09In fact, before today's discussion, we were talking about people that we knew that perhaps
2:10:09In fact, before today's discussion, we were talking about people that we knew that perhaps
2:10:09In fact, before today's discussion, we were talking about people that we knew that perhaps
2:10:12had been told that and some of the fragility that that can introduce to the
2:10:12had been told that and some of the fragility that that can introduce to the
2:10:12had been told that and some of the fragility that that can introduce to the
2:10:12had been told that and some of the fragility that that can introduce to the
2:10:17psyche. I think that's really well said.
2:10:17psyche. I think that's really well said.
2:10:17psyche. I think that's really well said.
2:10:17psyche. I think that's really well said.
2:10:19I think it goes in both ways.
2:10:19I think it goes in both ways.
2:10:19I think it goes in both ways.
2:10:19I think it goes in both ways.
2:10:20I think things that we think are hardships or disabilities often end up being the
2:10:20I think things that we think are hardships or disabilities often end up being the
2:10:20I think things that we think are hardships or disabilities often end up being the
2:10:20I think things that we think are hardships or disabilities often end up being the
2:10:26things that make us who we are and, you know, make us more sympathetic, give
2:10:26things that make us who we are and, you know, make us more sympathetic, give
2:10:26things that make us who we are and, you know, make us more sympathetic, give
2:10:26things that make us who we are and, you know, make us more sympathetic, give
2:10:32us added depth as humans.
2:10:32us added depth as humans.
2:10:32us added depth as humans.
2:10:32us added depth as humans.
2:10:34And the things that we think are the things that make us perfect are the
2:10:34And the things that we think are the things that make us perfect are the
2:10:34And the things that we think are the things that make us perfect are the
2:10:34And the things that we think are the things that make us perfect are the
2:10:38things that are really holding us back or creating all sorts of false ideas that
2:10:38things that are really holding us back or creating all sorts of false ideas that
2:10:38things that are really holding us back or creating all sorts of false ideas that
2:10:38things that are really holding us back or creating all sorts of false ideas that
2:10:42limit us. I couldn't agree more.
2:10:42limit us. I couldn't agree more.
2:10:42limit us. I couldn't agree more.
2:10:42limit us. I couldn't agree more.
2:10:45I'd love to know what right now you're most excited about for your own intellectual
2:10:45I'd love to know what right now you're most excited about for your own intellectual
2:10:45I'd love to know what right now you're most excited about for your own intellectual
2:10:45I'd love to know what right now you're most excited about for your own intellectual
2:10:53enrichment and in your lab and like what you really feel is like the thing
2:10:53enrichment and in your lab and like what you really feel is like the thing
2:10:53enrichment and in your lab and like what you really feel is like the thing
2:10:53enrichment and in your lab and like what you really feel is like the thing
2:10:58that has the most electricity for you.
2:10:58that has the most electricity for you.
2:10:58that has the most electricity for you.
2:10:58that has the most electricity for you.
2:11:00And And if you're willing to also give us a hint of what's just right
2:11:00And And if you're willing to also give us a hint of what's just right
2:11:00And And if you're willing to also give us a hint of what's just right
2:11:00And And if you're willing to also give us a hint of what's just right
2:11:06over the edge in terms of what you think will be the next big therapeutic
2:11:06over the edge in terms of what you think will be the next big therapeutic
2:11:06over the edge in terms of what you think will be the next big therapeutic
2:11:06over the edge in terms of what you think will be the next big therapeutic
2:11:09breakthrough that we can look forward to.
2:11:09breakthrough that we can look forward to.
2:11:09breakthrough that we can look forward to.
2:11:09breakthrough that we can look forward to.
2:11:13Thanks for asking that. So I'm going to give a little bit of a long
2:11:13Thanks for asking that. So I'm going to give a little bit of a long
2:11:13Thanks for asking that. So I'm going to give a little bit of a long
2:11:13Thanks for asking that. So I'm going to give a little bit of a long
2:11:17and meandering answer to that.
2:11:17and meandering answer to that.
2:11:17and meandering answer to that.
2:11:17and meandering answer to that.
2:11:19I mean, listen, when it comes to me, you don't have to.
2:11:19I mean, listen, when it comes to me, you don't have to.
2:11:19I mean, listen, when it comes to me, you don't have to.
2:11:19I mean, listen, when it comes to me, you don't have to.
2:11:22Succinct is not something that sort of like exists in my neural circuitry, although I
2:11:22Succinct is not something that sort of like exists in my neural circuitry, although I
2:11:22Succinct is not something that sort of like exists in my neural circuitry, although I
2:11:22Succinct is not something that sort of like exists in my neural circuitry, although I
2:11:25try. So I see this moment.
2:11:25try. So I see this moment.
2:11:25try. So I see this moment.
2:11:25try. So I see this moment.
2:11:28I talked about clinical trials that are already filling me with hope.
2:11:28I talked about clinical trials that are already filling me with hope.
2:11:28I talked about clinical trials that are already filling me with hope.
2:11:28I talked about clinical trials that are already filling me with hope.
2:11:33I talked about a biotech trial that I'm associated with for prostate cancer.
2:11:33I talked about a biotech trial that I'm associated with for prostate cancer.
2:11:33I talked about a biotech trial that I'm associated with for prostate cancer.
2:11:33I talked about a biotech trial that I'm associated with for prostate cancer.
2:11:39I talked about an academic trial that I put a lot of work in with
2:11:39I talked about an academic trial that I put a lot of work in with
2:11:39I talked about an academic trial that I put a lot of work in with
2:11:39I talked about an academic trial that I put a lot of work in with
2:11:42my colleagues over many years to open for multiple myeloma.
2:11:42my colleagues over many years to open for multiple myeloma.
2:11:42my colleagues over many years to open for multiple myeloma.
2:11:42my colleagues over many years to open for multiple myeloma.
2:11:46And we have a pipeline that we're developing.
2:11:46And we have a pipeline that we're developing.
2:11:46And we have a pipeline that we're developing.
2:11:46And we have a pipeline that we're developing.
2:11:49We didn't even talk today about...
2:11:49We didn't even talk today about...
2:11:49We didn't even talk today about...
2:11:49We didn't even talk today about...
2:11:52We haven't fully talked yet about the idea of CAR T -cells for autoimmunity.
2:11:52We haven't fully talked yet about the idea of CAR T -cells for autoimmunity.
2:11:52We haven't fully talked yet about the idea of CAR T -cells for autoimmunity.
2:11:52We haven't fully talked yet about the idea of CAR T -cells for autoimmunity.
2:11:56We left that open a little bit.
2:11:56We left that open a little bit.
2:11:56We left that open a little bit.
2:11:56We left that open a little bit.
2:11:58But that's an amazing moment that we're at right now, that the same CAR T
2:11:58But that's an amazing moment that we're at right now, that the same CAR T
2:11:58But that's an amazing moment that we're at right now, that the same CAR T
2:11:58But that's an amazing moment that we're at right now, that the same CAR T
2:12:02-cells that are being used to get rid of B -cell leukemias are also getting
2:12:02-cells that are being used to get rid of B -cell leukemias are also getting
2:12:02-cells that are being used to get rid of B -cell leukemias are also getting
2:12:02-cells that are being used to get rid of B -cell leukemias are also getting
2:12:05rid of B -cells, which are contributing to autoimmune disease.
2:12:05rid of B -cells, which are contributing to autoimmune disease.
2:12:05rid of B -cells, which are contributing to autoimmune disease.
2:12:05rid of B -cells, which are contributing to autoimmune disease.
2:12:08So without making any change, people are already starting to see incredible responses in the
2:12:08So without making any change, people are already starting to see incredible responses in the
2:12:08So without making any change, people are already starting to see incredible responses in the
2:12:08So without making any change, people are already starting to see incredible responses in the
2:12:12early trials for lupus and other autoimmune diseases with T -cells engineered to eliminate B
2:12:12early trials for lupus and other autoimmune diseases with T -cells engineered to eliminate B
2:12:12early trials for lupus and other autoimmune diseases with T -cells engineered to eliminate B
2:12:12early trials for lupus and other autoimmune diseases with T -cells engineered to eliminate B
2:12:18-cells. Fantastic. Could you just mention a few other disease targets?
2:12:18-cells. Fantastic. Could you just mention a few other disease targets?
2:12:18-cells. Fantastic. Could you just mention a few other disease targets?
2:12:18-cells. Fantastic. Could you just mention a few other disease targets?
2:12:22I know a few people with fibromyalgia.
2:12:22I know a few people with fibromyalgia.
2:12:22I know a few people with fibromyalgia.
2:12:22I know a few people with fibromyalgia.
2:12:24They suffer tremendously. Fibromyalgia is a disease that we just don't understand.
2:12:24They suffer tremendously. Fibromyalgia is a disease that we just don't understand.
2:12:24They suffer tremendously. Fibromyalgia is a disease that we just don't understand.
2:12:24They suffer tremendously. Fibromyalgia is a disease that we just don't understand.
2:12:30Like that is... Talk about understudied diseases.
2:12:30Like that is... Talk about understudied diseases.
2:12:30Like that is... Talk about understudied diseases.
2:12:30Like that is... Talk about understudied diseases.
2:12:34I think fibromyalgia is something that gets bucketed in a certain way and we just
2:12:34I think fibromyalgia is something that gets bucketed in a certain way and we just
2:12:34I think fibromyalgia is something that gets bucketed in a certain way and we just
2:12:34I think fibromyalgia is something that gets bucketed in a certain way and we just
2:12:39have not figured out what it really is, what causes it.
2:12:39have not figured out what it really is, what causes it.
2:12:39have not figured out what it really is, what causes it.
2:12:39have not figured out what it really is, what causes it.
2:12:44And so that is its own thing.
2:12:44And so that is its own thing.
2:12:44And so that is its own thing.
2:12:44And so that is its own thing.
2:12:46But for autoimmune diseases, these are diseases where we do know that there are immune
2:12:46But for autoimmune diseases, these are diseases where we do know that there are immune
2:12:46But for autoimmune diseases, these are diseases where we do know that there are immune
2:12:46But for autoimmune diseases, these are diseases where we do know that there are immune
2:12:51cells going after our own tissue in various ways.
2:12:51cells going after our own tissue in various ways.
2:12:51cells going after our own tissue in various ways.
2:12:51cells going after our own tissue in various ways.
2:12:55Lupus, people are talking about various engineered T -cell trials for rheumatoid arthritis, for childhood
2:12:55Lupus, people are talking about various engineered T -cell trials for rheumatoid arthritis, for childhood
2:12:55Lupus, people are talking about various engineered T -cell trials for rheumatoid arthritis, for childhood
2:12:55Lupus, people are talking about various engineered T -cell trials for rheumatoid arthritis, for childhood
2:13:02diabetes, for multiple sclerosis, and on and on.
2:13:02diabetes, for multiple sclerosis, and on and on.
2:13:02diabetes, for multiple sclerosis, and on and on.
2:13:02diabetes, for multiple sclerosis, and on and on.
2:13:06But those are a number that people are thinking about, different types of immunotherapies, including
2:13:06But those are a number that people are thinking about, different types of immunotherapies, including
2:13:06But those are a number that people are thinking about, different types of immunotherapies, including
2:13:06But those are a number that people are thinking about, different types of immunotherapies, including
2:13:11gene -edited T -cells, to treat these autoimmune diseases.
2:13:11gene -edited T -cells, to treat these autoimmune diseases.
2:13:11gene -edited T -cells, to treat these autoimmune diseases.
2:13:11gene -edited T -cells, to treat these autoimmune diseases.
2:13:15So I'm already, I guess what I'm saying is excited about the near future of
2:13:15So I'm already, I guess what I'm saying is excited about the near future of
2:13:15So I'm already, I guess what I'm saying is excited about the near future of
2:13:15So I'm already, I guess what I'm saying is excited about the near future of
2:13:21things that have come out of decades of lab work from labs around the world
2:13:21things that have come out of decades of lab work from labs around the world
2:13:21things that have come out of decades of lab work from labs around the world
2:13:21things that have come out of decades of lab work from labs around the world
2:13:27already starting to be assembled into things that are advancing through clinical pipelines.
2:13:27already starting to be assembled into things that are advancing through clinical pipelines.
2:13:27already starting to be assembled into things that are advancing through clinical pipelines.
2:13:27already starting to be assembled into things that are advancing through clinical pipelines.
2:13:31But the next wave of what's coming up behind that is just as exciting, if
2:13:31But the next wave of what's coming up behind that is just as exciting, if
2:13:31But the next wave of what's coming up behind that is just as exciting, if
2:13:31But the next wave of what's coming up behind that is just as exciting, if
2:13:38not more. So I think that one of the things that makes me feel like
2:13:38not more. So I think that one of the things that makes me feel like
2:13:38not more. So I think that one of the things that makes me feel like
2:13:38not more. So I think that one of the things that makes me feel like
2:13:42I have one of the great jobs out there is there's about 30 people in
2:13:42I have one of the great jobs out there is there's about 30 people in
2:13:42I have one of the great jobs out there is there's about 30 people in
2:13:42I have one of the great jobs out there is there's about 30 people in
2:13:48my lab. I get the joy of ideas bubbling up.
2:13:48my lab. I get the joy of ideas bubbling up.
2:13:48my lab. I get the joy of ideas bubbling up.
2:13:48my lab. I get the joy of ideas bubbling up.
2:13:52The ideas at the lab don't come top -down from me.
2:13:52The ideas at the lab don't come top -down from me.
2:13:52The ideas at the lab don't come top -down from me.
2:13:52The ideas at the lab don't come top -down from me.
2:13:55They come from grad students and post -docs who have come filled with NRJ to
2:13:55They come from grad students and post -docs who have come filled with NRJ to
2:13:55They come from grad students and post -docs who have come filled with NRJ to
2:13:55They come from grad students and post -docs who have come filled with NRJ to
2:14:00bring their own ideas. And progress is being made through this conversation of people in
2:14:00bring their own ideas. And progress is being made through this conversation of people in
2:14:00bring their own ideas. And progress is being made through this conversation of people in
2:14:00bring their own ideas. And progress is being made through this conversation of people in
2:14:06the lab reading papers, going to conferences, talking late at night in the lab.
2:14:06the lab reading papers, going to conferences, talking late at night in the lab.
2:14:06the lab reading papers, going to conferences, talking late at night in the lab.
2:14:06the lab reading papers, going to conferences, talking late at night in the lab.
2:14:10And I can't believe the surprises that are coming.
2:14:10And I can't believe the surprises that are coming.
2:14:10And I can't believe the surprises that are coming.
2:14:10And I can't believe the surprises that are coming.
2:14:14So I want to give you a couple of these.
2:14:14So I want to give you a couple of these.
2:14:14So I want to give you a couple of these.
2:14:14So I want to give you a couple of these.
2:14:17So just looking backwards to 2013, 2014, we were struggling to see if we could
2:14:17So just looking backwards to 2013, 2014, we were struggling to see if we could
2:14:17So just looking backwards to 2013, 2014, we were struggling to see if we could
2:14:17So just looking backwards to 2013, 2014, we were struggling to see if we could
2:14:23get CRISPR with electroporation to make one cut in a T cell.
2:14:23get CRISPR with electroporation to make one cut in a T cell.
2:14:23get CRISPR with electroporation to make one cut in a T cell.
2:14:23get CRISPR with electroporation to make one cut in a T cell.
2:14:28We could barely do it.
2:14:28We could barely do it.
2:14:28We could barely do it.
2:14:28We could barely do it.
2:14:29Now, if a grad student comes into my lab, within a month or two, they
2:14:29Now, if a grad student comes into my lab, within a month or two, they
2:14:29Now, if a grad student comes into my lab, within a month or two, they
2:14:29Now, if a grad student comes into my lab, within a month or two, they
2:14:35can routinely do a CRISPR experiment where we deliver a set of thousands, up to
2:14:35can routinely do a CRISPR experiment where we deliver a set of thousands, up to
2:14:35can routinely do a CRISPR experiment where we deliver a set of thousands, up to
2:14:35can routinely do a CRISPR experiment where we deliver a set of thousands, up to
2:14:44tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands of different CRISPRs into a population of T
2:14:44tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands of different CRISPRs into a population of T
2:14:44tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands of different CRISPRs into a population of T
2:14:44tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands of different CRISPRs into a population of T
2:14:49cells from a blood sample.
2:14:49cells from a blood sample.
2:14:49cells from a blood sample.
2:14:49cells from a blood sample.
2:14:50So each cell will get a different CRISPR modification.
2:14:50So each cell will get a different CRISPR modification.
2:14:50So each cell will get a different CRISPR modification.
2:14:50So each cell will get a different CRISPR modification.
2:14:53And then we can essentially race these cells against each other.
2:14:53And then we can essentially race these cells against each other.
2:14:53And then we can essentially race these cells against each other.
2:14:53And then we can essentially race these cells against each other.
2:14:56So we can put them into a tumor environment and see which ones continue to
2:14:56So we can put them into a tumor environment and see which ones continue to
2:14:56So we can put them into a tumor environment and see which ones continue to
2:14:56So we can put them into a tumor environment and see which ones continue to
2:15:00grow, which ones have markers that seem like they're going to be favorable and giving
2:15:00grow, which ones have markers that seem like they're going to be favorable and giving
2:15:00grow, which ones have markers that seem like they're going to be favorable and giving
2:15:00grow, which ones have markers that seem like they're going to be favorable and giving
2:15:04them characteristics that are going to be strong against cancer.
2:15:04them characteristics that are going to be strong against cancer.
2:15:04them characteristics that are going to be strong against cancer.
2:15:04them characteristics that are going to be strong against cancer.
2:15:06So we are able to do the type of genetics that was possible in fruit
2:15:06So we are able to do the type of genetics that was possible in fruit
2:15:06So we are able to do the type of genetics that was possible in fruit
2:15:06So we are able to do the type of genetics that was possible in fruit
2:15:12flies, but unimaginable in human cells.
2:15:12flies, but unimaginable in human cells.
2:15:12flies, but unimaginable in human cells.
2:15:12flies, but unimaginable in human cells.
2:15:15We're doing directly in the human cells that will be the therapies of the future.
2:15:15We're doing directly in the human cells that will be the therapies of the future.
2:15:15We're doing directly in the human cells that will be the therapies of the future.
2:15:15We're doing directly in the human cells that will be the therapies of the future.
2:15:19We're directly learning what are the genetic modifications that will make T cells do exactly
2:15:19We're directly learning what are the genetic modifications that will make T cells do exactly
2:15:19We're directly learning what are the genetic modifications that will make T cells do exactly
2:15:19We're directly learning what are the genetic modifications that will make T cells do exactly
2:15:24what we want. And one of the things that we just made publicly available is
2:15:24what we want. And one of the things that we just made publicly available is
2:15:24what we want. And one of the things that we just made publicly available is
2:15:24what we want. And one of the things that we just made publicly available is
2:15:28that we used to do these experiments and race these cells against each other and
2:15:28that we used to do these experiments and race these cells against each other and
2:15:28that we used to do these experiments and race these cells against each other and
2:15:28that we used to do these experiments and race these cells against each other and
2:15:32race them against each other for one characteristic, which ones would start to make one
2:15:32race them against each other for one characteristic, which ones would start to make one
2:15:32race them against each other for one characteristic, which ones would start to make one
2:15:32race them against each other for one characteristic, which ones would start to make one
2:15:39cytokine. I talked about these signals that immune cells can make.
2:15:39cytokine. I talked about these signals that immune cells can make.
2:15:39cytokine. I talked about these signals that immune cells can make.
2:15:39cytokine. I talked about these signals that immune cells can make.
2:15:44Now what we can do is we can, for each genetic modification, we can do
2:15:44Now what we can do is we can, for each genetic modification, we can do
2:15:44Now what we can do is we can, for each genetic modification, we can do
2:15:44Now what we can do is we can, for each genetic modification, we can do
2:15:50a complete measurement of the state of each individual cell.
2:15:50a complete measurement of the state of each individual cell.
2:15:50a complete measurement of the state of each individual cell.
2:15:50a complete measurement of the state of each individual cell.
2:15:55This is a technology called single -cell RNA sequencing.
2:15:55This is a technology called single -cell RNA sequencing.
2:15:55This is a technology called single -cell RNA sequencing.
2:15:55This is a technology called single -cell RNA sequencing.
2:15:58So we measure now simultaneously all of the RNA that's in that cell, giving us
2:15:58So we measure now simultaneously all of the RNA that's in that cell, giving us
2:15:58So we measure now simultaneously all of the RNA that's in that cell, giving us
2:15:58So we measure now simultaneously all of the RNA that's in that cell, giving us
2:16:03a snapshot of what that cell is now able to do.
2:16:03a snapshot of what that cell is now able to do.
2:16:03a snapshot of what that cell is now able to do.
2:16:03a snapshot of what that cell is now able to do.
2:16:06And we can also simultaneously measure which CRISPR was put into that cell.
2:16:06And we can also simultaneously measure which CRISPR was put into that cell.
2:16:06And we can also simultaneously measure which CRISPR was put into that cell.
2:16:06And we can also simultaneously measure which CRISPR was put into that cell.
2:16:10And so now we can essentially inactivate every gene in the genome in T cells
2:16:10And so now we can essentially inactivate every gene in the genome in T cells
2:16:10And so now we can essentially inactivate every gene in the genome in T cells
2:16:10And so now we can essentially inactivate every gene in the genome in T cells
2:16:15and read out the consequences on the overall state of the cells.
2:16:15and read out the consequences on the overall state of the cells.
2:16:15and read out the consequences on the overall state of the cells.
2:16:15and read out the consequences on the overall state of the cells.
2:16:19And this is technology that was developed by a number of labs around the world.
2:16:19And this is technology that was developed by a number of labs around the world.
2:16:19And this is technology that was developed by a number of labs around the world.
2:16:19And this is technology that was developed by a number of labs around the world.
2:16:23We've now deployed this at a massive scale directly in primary human immune cells.
2:16:23We've now deployed this at a massive scale directly in primary human immune cells.
2:16:23We've now deployed this at a massive scale directly in primary human immune cells.
2:16:23We've now deployed this at a massive scale directly in primary human immune cells.
2:16:28So we're going to do this at a massive scale.
2:16:28So we're going to do this at a massive scale.
2:16:28So we're going to do this at a massive scale.
2:16:28So we're going to do this at a massive scale.
2:16:28We just released 22 million cells where each one has a different CRISPR gene inactivated
2:16:28We just released 22 million cells where each one has a different CRISPR gene inactivated
2:16:28We just released 22 million cells where each one has a different CRISPR gene inactivated
2:16:28We just released 22 million cells where each one has a different CRISPR gene inactivated
2:16:34and we get a map of this.
2:16:34and we get a map of this.
2:16:34and we get a map of this.
2:16:34and we get a map of this.
2:16:36I think of this, not just what we're doing in T -cells, but what other
2:16:36I think of this, not just what we're doing in T -cells, but what other
2:16:36I think of this, not just what we're doing in T -cells, but what other
2:16:36I think of this, not just what we're doing in T -cells, but what other
2:16:40labs are doing around the world, using CRISPR to read out the consequence of every
2:16:40labs are doing around the world, using CRISPR to read out the consequence of every
2:16:40labs are doing around the world, using CRISPR to read out the consequence of every
2:16:40labs are doing around the world, using CRISPR to read out the consequence of every
2:16:44gene in different cell types, in different conditions, as a sequel to the Genome Project.
2:16:44gene in different cell types, in different conditions, as a sequel to the Genome Project.
2:16:44gene in different cell types, in different conditions, as a sequel to the Genome Project.
2:16:44gene in different cell types, in different conditions, as a sequel to the Genome Project.
2:16:51We talked about the genome giving us this draft of the DNA sequence.
2:16:51We talked about the genome giving us this draft of the DNA sequence.
2:16:51We talked about the genome giving us this draft of the DNA sequence.
2:16:51We talked about the genome giving us this draft of the DNA sequence.
2:16:55Now we can actually read out the function of every gene and see how each
2:16:55Now we can actually read out the function of every gene and see how each
2:16:55Now we can actually read out the function of every gene and see how each
2:16:55Now we can actually read out the function of every gene and see how each
2:17:00gene contributes to the behavior of every cell.
2:17:00gene contributes to the behavior of every cell.
2:17:00gene contributes to the behavior of every cell.
2:17:00gene contributes to the behavior of every cell.
2:17:03And this is being used as a basis for massive computational analysis.
2:17:03And this is being used as a basis for massive computational analysis.
2:17:03And this is being used as a basis for massive computational analysis.
2:17:03And this is being used as a basis for massive computational analysis.
2:17:09It's providing us a real roadmap of how cells are wired that will be the
2:17:09It's providing us a real roadmap of how cells are wired that will be the
2:17:09It's providing us a real roadmap of how cells are wired that will be the
2:17:09It's providing us a real roadmap of how cells are wired that will be the
2:17:16instruction manual for the next generation of T -cell immunotherapies.
2:17:16instruction manual for the next generation of T -cell immunotherapies.
2:17:16instruction manual for the next generation of T -cell immunotherapies.
2:17:16instruction manual for the next generation of T -cell immunotherapies.
2:17:20The lessons that we learn about how every gene behaves are now going to be
2:17:20The lessons that we learn about how every gene behaves are now going to be
2:17:20The lessons that we learn about how every gene behaves are now going to be
2:17:20The lessons that we learn about how every gene behaves are now going to be
2:17:24actionable and these are going to be genes that we tune or epigenetically edit or
2:17:24actionable and these are going to be genes that we tune or epigenetically edit or
2:17:24actionable and these are going to be genes that we tune or epigenetically edit or
2:17:24actionable and these are going to be genes that we tune or epigenetically edit or
2:17:29inactivate or add to genes that we will now have a recipe book for what
2:17:29inactivate or add to genes that we will now have a recipe book for what
2:17:29inactivate or add to genes that we will now have a recipe book for what
2:17:29inactivate or add to genes that we will now have a recipe book for what
2:17:34do we want an immune cell to do, what do we want it to recognize,
2:17:34do we want an immune cell to do, what do we want it to recognize,
2:17:34do we want an immune cell to do, what do we want it to recognize,
2:17:34do we want an immune cell to do, what do we want it to recognize,
2:17:37where do we want it to go, and we'll have a cheat sheet that tells
2:17:37where do we want it to go, and we'll have a cheat sheet that tells
2:17:37where do we want it to go, and we'll have a cheat sheet that tells
2:17:37where do we want it to go, and we'll have a cheat sheet that tells
2:17:42us, okay, here's what we should be adding or subtracting from that cell genetically to
2:17:42us, okay, here's what we should be adding or subtracting from that cell genetically to
2:17:42us, okay, here's what we should be adding or subtracting from that cell genetically to
2:17:42us, okay, here's what we should be adding or subtracting from that cell genetically to
2:17:47endow it with the powers that will give it precision and endurance against some disease
2:17:47endow it with the powers that will give it precision and endurance against some disease
2:17:47endow it with the powers that will give it precision and endurance against some disease
2:17:47endow it with the powers that will give it precision and endurance against some disease
2:17:53that we want to go after.
2:17:53that we want to go after.
2:17:53that we want to go after.
2:17:53that we want to go after.
2:17:55Amazing. I mean, truly amazing.
2:17:55Amazing. I mean, truly amazing.
2:17:55Amazing. I mean, truly amazing.
2:17:55Amazing. I mean, truly amazing.
2:17:58Should I be banking T -cells?
2:17:58Should I be banking T -cells?
2:17:58Should I be banking T -cells?
2:17:58Should I be banking T -cells?
2:18:00Well, I think the good news is that...
2:18:00Well, I think the good news is that...
2:18:00Well, I think the good news is that...
2:18:00Well, I think the good news is that...
2:18:04I never know what the answer is to this.
2:18:04I never know what the answer is to this.
2:18:04I never know what the answer is to this.
2:18:04I never know what the answer is to this.
2:18:06I was going to say the good news is that we largely have T -cells.
2:18:06I was going to say the good news is that we largely have T -cells.
2:18:06I was going to say the good news is that we largely have T -cells.
2:18:06I was going to say the good news is that we largely have T -cells.
2:18:11Are there exceptions to that?
2:18:11Are there exceptions to that?
2:18:11Are there exceptions to that?
2:18:11Are there exceptions to that?
2:18:13Yes, you know, there are patients who are getting treated for certain types of cancer
2:18:13Yes, you know, there are patients who are getting treated for certain types of cancer
2:18:13Yes, you know, there are patients who are getting treated for certain types of cancer
2:18:13Yes, you know, there are patients who are getting treated for certain types of cancer
2:18:17and the chemotherapy that they're getting depletes their T -cells.
2:18:17and the chemotherapy that they're getting depletes their T -cells.
2:18:17and the chemotherapy that they're getting depletes their T -cells.
2:18:17and the chemotherapy that they're getting depletes their T -cells.
2:18:23It's hard to know. I guess I can't say that there would never be a
2:18:23It's hard to know. I guess I can't say that there would never be a
2:18:23It's hard to know. I guess I can't say that there would never be a
2:18:23It's hard to know. I guess I can't say that there would never be a
2:18:27use, but I think we're getting better and better at being able to take whatever
2:18:27use, but I think we're getting better and better at being able to take whatever
2:18:27use, but I think we're getting better and better at being able to take whatever
2:18:27use, but I think we're getting better and better at being able to take whatever
2:18:32T -cells are there and I hope reactivate them, re -endow them with powers.
2:18:32T -cells are there and I hope reactivate them, re -endow them with powers.
2:18:32T -cells are there and I hope reactivate them, re -endow them with powers.
2:18:32T -cells are there and I hope reactivate them, re -endow them with powers.
2:18:38I would be disappointed if in the future we would need to go back and
2:18:38I would be disappointed if in the future we would need to go back and
2:18:38I would be disappointed if in the future we would need to go back and
2:18:38I would be disappointed if in the future we would need to go back and
2:18:43take bank T -cells and not be able to re -engineer cells that are already
2:18:43take bank T -cells and not be able to re -engineer cells that are already
2:18:43take bank T -cells and not be able to re -engineer cells that are already
2:18:43take bank T -cells and not be able to re -engineer cells that are already
2:18:47there. Are there edge cases where it might be?
2:18:47there. Are there edge cases where it might be?
2:18:47there. Are there edge cases where it might be?
2:18:47there. Are there edge cases where it might be?
2:18:50But it's not something that I would tell people to go out and do.
2:18:50But it's not something that I would tell people to go out and do.
2:18:50But it's not something that I would tell people to go out and do.
2:18:50But it's not something that I would tell people to go out and do.
2:18:53It's not something I'm doing.
2:18:53It's not something I'm doing.
2:18:53It's not something I'm doing.
2:18:53It's not something I'm doing.
2:18:55Yeah, I would only do it if you told me to.
2:18:55Yeah, I would only do it if you told me to.
2:18:55Yeah, I would only do it if you told me to.
2:18:55Yeah, I would only do it if you told me to.
2:18:57A colleague of yours, Yamanaka, won a Nobel Prize for essentially showing that you can
2:18:57A colleague of yours, Yamanaka, won a Nobel Prize for essentially showing that you can
2:18:57A colleague of yours, Yamanaka, won a Nobel Prize for essentially showing that you can
2:18:57A colleague of yours, Yamanaka, won a Nobel Prize for essentially showing that you can
2:19:03take a skin cell, put it in a dish, give it Yamanaka factors, as it
2:19:03take a skin cell, put it in a dish, give it Yamanaka factors, as it
2:19:03take a skin cell, put it in a dish, give it Yamanaka factors, as it
2:19:03take a skin cell, put it in a dish, give it Yamanaka factors, as it
2:19:07were, for in some cases only three transcription factors and essentially revert that cell to
2:19:07were, for in some cases only three transcription factors and essentially revert that cell to
2:19:07were, for in some cases only three transcription factors and essentially revert that cell to
2:19:07were, for in some cases only three transcription factors and essentially revert that cell to
2:19:12a stem cell and then give it some other transcription factors and turn it into,
2:19:12a stem cell and then give it some other transcription factors and turn it into,
2:19:12a stem cell and then give it some other transcription factors and turn it into,
2:19:12a stem cell and then give it some other transcription factors and turn it into,
2:19:16I don't know, a neuron or a pancreatic cell.
2:19:16I don't know, a neuron or a pancreatic cell.
2:19:16I don't know, a neuron or a pancreatic cell.
2:19:16I don't know, a neuron or a pancreatic cell.
2:19:19Should we be banking fibroblasts and putting them into that ready state, reverting them to
2:19:19Should we be banking fibroblasts and putting them into that ready state, reverting them to
2:19:19Should we be banking fibroblasts and putting them into that ready state, reverting them to
2:19:19Should we be banking fibroblasts and putting them into that ready state, reverting them to
2:19:27the stem cell state? In my mind, I always thought, well, if I ever need
2:19:27the stem cell state? In my mind, I always thought, well, if I ever need
2:19:27the stem cell state? In my mind, I always thought, well, if I ever need
2:19:27the stem cell state? In my mind, I always thought, well, if I ever need
2:19:30more cells of a given organ, I can always, assuming I'm alive, you know, they
2:19:30more cells of a given organ, I can always, assuming I'm alive, you know, they
2:19:30more cells of a given organ, I can always, assuming I'm alive, you know, they
2:19:30more cells of a given organ, I can always, assuming I'm alive, you know, they
2:19:36can take a skin cell and they can do all that.
2:19:36can take a skin cell and they can do all that.
2:19:36can take a skin cell and they can do all that.
2:19:36can take a skin cell and they can do all that.
2:19:38But I could imagine that there would be use for a cell bank, not a
2:19:38But I could imagine that there would be use for a cell bank, not a
2:19:38But I could imagine that there would be use for a cell bank, not a
2:19:38But I could imagine that there would be use for a cell bank, not a
2:19:45tissue bank, where there are a bunch of these pluripotent puberman, in my case, Marcin
2:19:45tissue bank, where there are a bunch of these pluripotent puberman, in my case, Marcin
2:19:45tissue bank, where there are a bunch of these pluripotent puberman, in my case, Marcin
2:19:45tissue bank, where there are a bunch of these pluripotent puberman, in my case, Marcin
2:19:52in your case, obviously, cells that if, you know, God forbid I needed a bunch
2:19:52in your case, obviously, cells that if, you know, God forbid I needed a bunch
2:19:52in your case, obviously, cells that if, you know, God forbid I needed a bunch
2:19:52in your case, obviously, cells that if, you know, God forbid I needed a bunch
2:19:57of pancreatic islet cells, boom, they can have those within a week.
2:19:57of pancreatic islet cells, boom, they can have those within a week.
2:19:57of pancreatic islet cells, boom, they can have those within a week.
2:19:57of pancreatic islet cells, boom, they can have those within a week.
2:20:00This field is something that's been amazing to watch.
2:20:00This field is something that's been amazing to watch.
2:20:00This field is something that's been amazing to watch.
2:20:00This field is something that's been amazing to watch.
2:20:04There's been ups and downs of it, of this induced pluripotent stem cell field that
2:20:04There's been ups and downs of it, of this induced pluripotent stem cell field that
2:20:04There's been ups and downs of it, of this induced pluripotent stem cell field that
2:20:04There's been ups and downs of it, of this induced pluripotent stem cell field that
2:20:08Shinya Yamanaka opened up. One of the interesting areas is actually imagining how these iPS
2:20:08Shinya Yamanaka opened up. One of the interesting areas is actually imagining how these iPS
2:20:08Shinya Yamanaka opened up. One of the interesting areas is actually imagining how these iPS
2:20:08Shinya Yamanaka opened up. One of the interesting areas is actually imagining how these iPS
2:20:16cells could be made into T cells, which would essentially create a limitless supply of
2:20:16cells could be made into T cells, which would essentially create a limitless supply of
2:20:16cells could be made into T cells, which would essentially create a limitless supply of
2:20:16cells could be made into T cells, which would essentially create a limitless supply of
2:20:20T cells. So I was thinking, you know, you don't have to even draw blood.
2:20:20T cells. So I was thinking, you know, you don't have to even draw blood.
2:20:20T cells. So I was thinking, you know, you don't have to even draw blood.
2:20:20T cells. So I was thinking, you know, you don't have to even draw blood.
2:20:23Exactly, which would negate the need for banking if you had your...
2:20:23Exactly, which would negate the need for banking if you had your...
2:20:23Exactly, which would negate the need for banking if you had your...
2:20:23Exactly, which would negate the need for banking if you had your...
2:20:27So I don't know if, again, it's probably not something that would be cost effective
2:20:27So I don't know if, again, it's probably not something that would be cost effective
2:20:27So I don't know if, again, it's probably not something that would be cost effective
2:20:27So I don't know if, again, it's probably not something that would be cost effective
2:20:32for everyone to have their iPS cells ready to go.
2:20:32for everyone to have their iPS cells ready to go.
2:20:32for everyone to have their iPS cells ready to go.
2:20:32for everyone to have their iPS cells ready to go.
2:20:36I understand in conversation with Shinya Yamanaka that one of the things that he's been
2:20:36I understand in conversation with Shinya Yamanaka that one of the things that he's been
2:20:36I understand in conversation with Shinya Yamanaka that one of the things that he's been
2:20:36I understand in conversation with Shinya Yamanaka that one of the things that he's been
2:20:43involved with is actually building sort of a bank of iPS cells that would be
2:20:43involved with is actually building sort of a bank of iPS cells that would be
2:20:43involved with is actually building sort of a bank of iPS cells that would be
2:20:43involved with is actually building sort of a bank of iPS cells that would be
2:20:47compatible, immune compatible with broad sets of different people so that it could essentially be
2:20:47compatible, immune compatible with broad sets of different people so that it could essentially be
2:20:47compatible, immune compatible with broad sets of different people so that it could essentially be
2:20:47compatible, immune compatible with broad sets of different people so that it could essentially be
2:20:53used as a transplant bank, which might be a way to be like an intermediate
2:20:53used as a transplant bank, which might be a way to be like an intermediate
2:20:53used as a transplant bank, which might be a way to be like an intermediate
2:20:53used as a transplant bank, which might be a way to be like an intermediate
2:20:56step that there would be iPS cells available that could be transplanted with various degrees
2:20:56step that there would be iPS cells available that could be transplanted with various degrees
2:20:56step that there would be iPS cells available that could be transplanted with various degrees
2:20:56step that there would be iPS cells available that could be transplanted with various degrees
2:21:01of ease into different people.
2:21:01of ease into different people.
2:21:01of ease into different people.
2:21:01of ease into different people.
2:21:03And then I do think that I hope it gets easier and easier to make
2:21:03And then I do think that I hope it gets easier and easier to make
2:21:03And then I do think that I hope it gets easier and easier to make
2:21:03And then I do think that I hope it gets easier and easier to make
2:21:07iPS cells that are matched to any patient when they're needed.
2:21:07iPS cells that are matched to any patient when they're needed.
2:21:07iPS cells that are matched to any patient when they're needed.
2:21:07iPS cells that are matched to any patient when they're needed.
2:21:10So, but I mean, again, like there's these different threads of things of being able
2:21:10So, but I mean, again, like there's these different threads of things of being able
2:21:10So, but I mean, again, like there's these different threads of things of being able
2:21:10So, but I mean, again, like there's these different threads of things of being able
2:21:16to make endless supplies of any cell, direct them to any tissue type, and then
2:21:16to make endless supplies of any cell, direct them to any tissue type, and then
2:21:16to make endless supplies of any cell, direct them to any tissue type, and then
2:21:16to make endless supplies of any cell, direct them to any tissue type, and then
2:21:22being able to program them when the language of CRISPR...
2:21:22being able to program them when the language of CRISPR...
2:21:22being able to program them when the language of CRISPR...
2:21:22being able to program them when the language of CRISPR...
2:21:25Actually, it's worth some moment.
2:21:25Actually, it's worth some moment.
2:21:25Actually, it's worth some moment.
2:21:25Actually, it's worth some moment.
2:21:28In 2020, I moved my lab from the main branch of UCSF to a separate
2:21:28In 2020, I moved my lab from the main branch of UCSF to a separate
2:21:28In 2020, I moved my lab from the main branch of UCSF to a separate
2:21:28In 2020, I moved my lab from the main branch of UCSF to a separate
2:21:35research institute in San Francisco called the Gladstone Institutes.
2:21:35research institute in San Francisco called the Gladstone Institutes.
2:21:35research institute in San Francisco called the Gladstone Institutes.
2:21:35research institute in San Francisco called the Gladstone Institutes.
2:21:39It's a non -profit research institute.
2:21:39It's a non -profit research institute.
2:21:39It's a non -profit research institute.
2:21:39It's a non -profit research institute.
2:21:42My grad students still come from UCSF, University of California, San Francisco, but my lab's
2:21:42My grad students still come from UCSF, University of California, San Francisco, but my lab's
2:21:42My grad students still come from UCSF, University of California, San Francisco, but my lab's
2:21:42My grad students still come from UCSF, University of California, San Francisco, but my lab's
2:21:48at Gladstone. And one of the reasons that I moved my lab to Gladstone was
2:21:48at Gladstone. And one of the reasons that I moved my lab to Gladstone was
2:21:48at Gladstone. And one of the reasons that I moved my lab to Gladstone was
2:21:48at Gladstone. And one of the reasons that I moved my lab to Gladstone was
2:21:54a conversation when they were recruiting me.
2:21:54a conversation when they were recruiting me.
2:21:54a conversation when they were recruiting me.
2:21:54a conversation when they were recruiting me.
2:21:56They brought me into the president's office, and in the president of Gladstone's office was
2:21:56They brought me into the president's office, and in the president of Gladstone's office was
2:21:56They brought me into the president's office, and in the president of Gladstone's office was
2:21:56They brought me into the president's office, and in the president of Gladstone's office was
2:22:02Shinya Yamanaka, who maintains a lab at Gladstone, and Jennifer Doudna, who also maintains a
2:22:02Shinya Yamanaka, who maintains a lab at Gladstone, and Jennifer Doudna, who also maintains a
2:22:02Shinya Yamanaka, who maintains a lab at Gladstone, and Jennifer Doudna, who also maintains a
2:22:02Shinya Yamanaka, who maintains a lab at Gladstone, and Jennifer Doudna, who also maintains a
2:22:08lab at Gladstone. You had to say yes.
2:22:08lab at Gladstone. You had to say yes.
2:22:08lab at Gladstone. You had to say yes.
2:22:08lab at Gladstone. You had to say yes.
2:22:10They're very clever. You had some psychologist inform that they got your number, so to
2:22:10They're very clever. You had some psychologist inform that they got your number, so to
2:22:10They're very clever. You had some psychologist inform that they got your number, so to
2:22:10They're very clever. You had some psychologist inform that they got your number, so to
2:22:14speak. I describe this, and I think this is not just a cliche.
2:22:14speak. I describe this, and I think this is not just a cliche.
2:22:14speak. I describe this, and I think this is not just a cliche.
2:22:14speak. I describe this, and I think this is not just a cliche.
2:22:18I actually remember kind of like that feeling of hair sticking up on the back
2:22:18I actually remember kind of like that feeling of hair sticking up on the back
2:22:18I actually remember kind of like that feeling of hair sticking up on the back
2:22:18I actually remember kind of like that feeling of hair sticking up on the back
2:22:21of your head of like, oh, all of a sudden these are the technologies that
2:22:21of your head of like, oh, all of a sudden these are the technologies that
2:22:21of your head of like, oh, all of a sudden these are the technologies that
2:22:21of your head of like, oh, all of a sudden these are the technologies that
2:22:25these two humans have made possible, and others, but we can now program what the
2:22:25these two humans have made possible, and others, but we can now program what the
2:22:25these two humans have made possible, and others, but we can now program what the
2:22:25these two humans have made possible, and others, but we can now program what the
2:22:32epigenetic state of a cell is thanks to the Yamanaka factors.
2:22:32epigenetic state of a cell is thanks to the Yamanaka factors.
2:22:32epigenetic state of a cell is thanks to the Yamanaka factors.
2:22:32epigenetic state of a cell is thanks to the Yamanaka factors.
2:22:35You can dial between skin and embryo and then back to anything else, and then
2:22:35You can dial between skin and embryo and then back to anything else, and then
2:22:35You can dial between skin and embryo and then back to anything else, and then
2:22:35You can dial between skin and embryo and then back to anything else, and then
2:22:41not only epigenetically program a cell, but take the power of CRISPR and genetically program.
2:22:41not only epigenetically program a cell, but take the power of CRISPR and genetically program.
2:22:41not only epigenetically program a cell, but take the power of CRISPR and genetically program.
2:22:41not only epigenetically program a cell, but take the power of CRISPR and genetically program.
2:22:45And when you put these things together, all of a sudden we have this ability
2:22:45And when you put these things together, all of a sudden we have this ability
2:22:45And when you put these things together, all of a sudden we have this ability
2:22:45And when you put these things together, all of a sudden we have this ability
2:22:48to imagine programmable cells that we can dial in and direct their behavior to either
2:22:48to imagine programmable cells that we can dial in and direct their behavior to either
2:22:48to imagine programmable cells that we can dial in and direct their behavior to either
2:22:48to imagine programmable cells that we can dial in and direct their behavior to either
2:22:56regenerate or to, in the case of the immune system, survey the body and get
2:22:56regenerate or to, in the case of the immune system, survey the body and get
2:22:56regenerate or to, in the case of the immune system, survey the body and get
2:22:56regenerate or to, in the case of the immune system, survey the body and get
2:23:01to the root cause of disease.
2:23:01to the root cause of disease.
2:23:01to the root cause of disease.
2:23:01to the root cause of disease.
2:23:02And my imagination still lies at that intersection of what's possible, and we combine that
2:23:02And my imagination still lies at that intersection of what's possible, and we combine that
2:23:02And my imagination still lies at that intersection of what's possible, and we combine that
2:23:02And my imagination still lies at that intersection of what's possible, and we combine that
2:23:09with immunology. I love it.
2:23:09with immunology. I love it.
2:23:09with immunology. I love it.
2:23:09with immunology. I love it.
2:23:12One question I don't expect you to answer, but your enthusiasm for this is tangible.
2:23:12One question I don't expect you to answer, but your enthusiasm for this is tangible.
2:23:12One question I don't expect you to answer, but your enthusiasm for this is tangible.
2:23:12One question I don't expect you to answer, but your enthusiasm for this is tangible.
2:23:18I'm excited. I know people listening are, and the question is, how do you sleep
2:23:18I'm excited. I know people listening are, and the question is, how do you sleep
2:23:18I'm excited. I know people listening are, and the question is, how do you sleep
2:23:18I'm excited. I know people listening are, and the question is, how do you sleep
2:23:22at night? Like, it's so exciting.
2:23:22at night? Like, it's so exciting.
2:23:22at night? Like, it's so exciting.
2:23:22at night? Like, it's so exciting.
2:23:25The tools are here. And mostly I want to say thank you.
2:23:25The tools are here. And mostly I want to say thank you.
2:23:25The tools are here. And mostly I want to say thank you.
2:23:25The tools are here. And mostly I want to say thank you.
2:23:31Thank you for coming here today and giving us an absolute master class on the
2:23:31Thank you for coming here today and giving us an absolute master class on the
2:23:31Thank you for coming here today and giving us an absolute master class on the
2:23:31Thank you for coming here today and giving us an absolute master class on the
2:23:36immune system, on cancer, on the technologies to improve the immune system, combat autoimmune diseases.
2:23:36immune system, on cancer, on the technologies to improve the immune system, combat autoimmune diseases.
2:23:36immune system, on cancer, on the technologies to improve the immune system, combat autoimmune diseases.
2:23:36immune system, on cancer, on the technologies to improve the immune system, combat autoimmune diseases.
2:23:45I mean, we got into molecular biology with some considerable degree of depth, and thanks
2:23:45I mean, we got into molecular biology with some considerable degree of depth, and thanks
2:23:45I mean, we got into molecular biology with some considerable degree of depth, and thanks
2:23:45I mean, we got into molecular biology with some considerable degree of depth, and thanks
2:23:50to you, it was incredibly clear.
2:23:50to you, it was incredibly clear.
2:23:50to you, it was incredibly clear.
2:23:50to you, it was incredibly clear.
2:23:52I know people learned a ton.
2:23:52I know people learned a ton.
2:23:52I know people learned a ton.
2:23:52I know people learned a ton.
2:23:53I know I learned a ton.
2:23:53I know I learned a ton.
2:23:53I know I learned a ton.
2:23:53I know I learned a ton.
2:23:54And I'm super excited about what you're doing.
2:23:54And I'm super excited about what you're doing.
2:23:54And I'm super excited about what you're doing.
2:23:54And I'm super excited about what you're doing.
2:23:56Also, just the heart and soul.
2:23:56Also, just the heart and soul.
2:23:56Also, just the heart and soul.
2:23:56Also, just the heart and soul.
2:23:59There are no other words, really.
2:23:59There are no other words, really.
2:23:59There are no other words, really.
2:23:59There are no other words, really.
2:24:01I think those are apt.
2:24:01I think those are apt.
2:24:01I think those are apt.
2:24:01I think those are apt.
2:24:03The heart and soul that you put into your work is so clear, and you
2:24:03The heart and soul that you put into your work is so clear, and you
2:24:03The heart and soul that you put into your work is so clear, and you
2:24:03The heart and soul that you put into your work is so clear, and you
2:24:07are definitely in the right job.
2:24:07are definitely in the right job.
2:24:07are definitely in the right job.
2:24:07are definitely in the right job.
2:24:09So just one request is that you come back and talk to us again when
2:24:09So just one request is that you come back and talk to us again when
2:24:09So just one request is that you come back and talk to us again when
2:24:09So just one request is that you come back and talk to us again when
2:24:13the next advancements are made.
2:24:13the next advancements are made.
2:24:13the next advancements are made.
2:24:13the next advancements are made.
2:24:15We'd love to have you back.
2:24:15We'd love to have you back.
2:24:15We'd love to have you back.
2:24:15We'd love to have you back.
2:24:16I'd be honored. And I just really want to thank you.
2:24:16I'd be honored. And I just really want to thank you.
2:24:16I'd be honored. And I just really want to thank you.
2:24:16I'd be honored. And I just really want to thank you.
2:24:19There are not enough forums that are dedicated really to the depth to talk about
2:24:19There are not enough forums that are dedicated really to the depth to talk about
2:24:19There are not enough forums that are dedicated really to the depth to talk about
2:24:19There are not enough forums that are dedicated really to the depth to talk about
2:24:24science. So much of the joy of science is in the details, and you do
2:24:24science. So much of the joy of science is in the details, and you do
2:24:24science. So much of the joy of science is in the details, and you do
2:24:24science. So much of the joy of science is in the details, and you do
2:24:29such a great job of letting those details really come through and sharing them broadly.
2:24:29such a great job of letting those details really come through and sharing them broadly.
2:24:29such a great job of letting those details really come through and sharing them broadly.
2:24:29such a great job of letting those details really come through and sharing them broadly.
2:24:34So it's an honor to be here.
2:24:34So it's an honor to be here.
2:24:34So it's an honor to be here.
2:24:34So it's an honor to be here.
2:24:36Well, thank you. It's a labor of love, and I've loved this.
2:24:36Well, thank you. It's a labor of love, and I've loved this.
2:24:36Well, thank you. It's a labor of love, and I've loved this.
2:24:36Well, thank you. It's a labor of love, and I've loved this.
2:24:40So come back again. Thanks.
2:24:40So come back again. Thanks.
2:24:40So come back again. Thanks.
2:24:40So come back again. Thanks.
2:24:41Thank you. That's the best way to support this podcast.
2:24:41Thank you. That's the best way to support this podcast.
2:24:41Thank you. That's the best way to support this podcast.
2:24:41Thank you. That's the best way to support this podcast.
2:25:14If you have questions for me or comments about the podcast, or guests or topics
2:25:14If you have questions for me or comments about the podcast, or guests or topics
2:25:14If you have questions for me or comments about the podcast, or guests or topics
2:25:14If you have questions for me or comments about the podcast, or guests or topics
2:25:17that you'd like me to consider for the Huberman Lab podcast, please put those in
2:25:17that you'd like me to consider for the Huberman Lab podcast, please put those in
2:25:17that you'd like me to consider for the Huberman Lab podcast, please put those in
2:25:17that you'd like me to consider for the Huberman Lab podcast, please put those in
2:25:21the comments section on YouTube.
2:25:21the comments section on YouTube.
2:25:21the comments section on YouTube.
2:25:21the comments section on YouTube.
2:25:22I do read all the comments.
2:25:22I do read all the comments.
2:25:22I do read all the comments.
2:25:22I do read all the comments.
2:25:24For those of you that haven't heard, I have a new book coming out.
2:25:24For those of you that haven't heard, I have a new book coming out.
2:25:24For those of you that haven't heard, I have a new book coming out.
2:25:24For those of you that haven't heard, I have a new book coming out.
2:25:26It's my very first book.
2:25:26It's my very first book.
2:25:26It's my very first book.
2:25:26It's my very first book.
2:25:28It's entitled Protocols, an Operating Manual for the Human Body.
2:25:28It's entitled Protocols, an Operating Manual for the Human Body.
2:25:28It's entitled Protocols, an Operating Manual for the Human Body.
2:25:28It's entitled Protocols, an Operating Manual for the Human Body.
2:25:31This is a book that I've been working on for more than five years, and
2:25:31This is a book that I've been working on for more than five years, and
2:25:31This is a book that I've been working on for more than five years, and
2:25:31This is a book that I've been working on for more than five years, and
2:25:34that's based on more than 30 years of research and experience.
2:25:34that's based on more than 30 years of research and experience.
2:25:34that's based on more than 30 years of research and experience.
2:25:34that's based on more than 30 years of research and experience.
2:25:38And it covers protocols for everything from sleep to exercise to stress control, protocols related
2:25:38And it covers protocols for everything from sleep to exercise to stress control, protocols related
2:25:38And it covers protocols for everything from sleep to exercise to stress control, protocols related
2:25:38And it covers protocols for everything from sleep to exercise to stress control, protocols related
2:25:44to focus and motivation. And of course, I provide the scientific substantiation for the protocols
2:25:44to focus and motivation. And of course, I provide the scientific substantiation for the protocols
2:25:44to focus and motivation. And of course, I provide the scientific substantiation for the protocols
2:25:44to focus and motivation. And of course, I provide the scientific substantiation for the protocols
2:25:50that are included. The book is now available by presale at protocolsbook .com.
2:25:50that are included. The book is now available by presale at protocolsbook .com.
2:25:50that are included. The book is now available by presale at protocolsbook .com.
2:25:50that are included. The book is now available by presale at protocolsbook .com.
2:25:55There you can find links to various vendors.
2:25:55There you can find links to various vendors.
2:25:55There you can find links to various vendors.
2:25:55There you can find links to various vendors.
2:25:57You can pick the one that you like best.
2:25:57You can pick the one that you like best.
2:25:57You can pick the one that you like best.
2:25:57You can pick the one that you like best.
2:25:59Again, the book is called Protocols, an Operating Manual for the Human Body.
2:25:59Again, the book is called Protocols, an Operating Manual for the Human Body.
2:25:59Again, the book is called Protocols, an Operating Manual for the Human Body.
2:25:59Again, the book is called Protocols, an Operating Manual for the Human Body.
2:26:03And if you're not already following me on social media, I am Huberman Lab on
2:26:03And if you're not already following me on social media, I am Huberman Lab on
2:26:03And if you're not already following me on social media, I am Huberman Lab on
2:26:03And if you're not already following me on social media, I am Huberman Lab on
2:26:07all social media platforms. So that's Instagram, X, Threads, Facebook, and LinkedIn.
2:26:07all social media platforms. So that's Instagram, X, Threads, Facebook, and LinkedIn.
2:26:07all social media platforms. So that's Instagram, X, Threads, Facebook, and LinkedIn.
2:26:07all social media platforms. So that's Instagram, X, Threads, Facebook, and LinkedIn.
2:26:12And on all those platforms, I discuss science and science -related tools, some of which
2:26:12And on all those platforms, I discuss science and science -related tools, some of which
2:26:12And on all those platforms, I discuss science and science -related tools, some of which
2:26:12And on all those platforms, I discuss science and science -related tools, some of which
2:26:17overlaps with the content of the Huberman Lab podcast, but much of which is distinct
2:26:17overlaps with the content of the Huberman Lab podcast, but much of which is distinct
2:26:17overlaps with the content of the Huberman Lab podcast, but much of which is distinct
2:26:17overlaps with the content of the Huberman Lab podcast, but much of which is distinct
2:26:20from the information on the Huberman Lab podcast.
2:26:20from the information on the Huberman Lab podcast.
2:26:20from the information on the Huberman Lab podcast.
2:26:20from the information on the Huberman Lab podcast.
2:26:22Again, it's Huberman Lab on all social media platforms.
2:26:22Again, it's Huberman Lab on all social media platforms.
2:26:22Again, it's Huberman Lab on all social media platforms.
2:26:22Again, it's Huberman Lab on all social media platforms.
2:26:25And if you haven't already subscribed to our Neural Network newsletter, the Neural Network newsletter
2:26:25And if you haven't already subscribed to our Neural Network newsletter, the Neural Network newsletter
2:26:25And if you haven't already subscribed to our Neural Network newsletter, the Neural Network newsletter
2:26:25And if you haven't already subscribed to our Neural Network newsletter, the Neural Network newsletter
2:26:30is a zero -cost monthly newsletter that includes podcast summaries, as well as what we
2:26:30is a zero -cost monthly newsletter that includes podcast summaries, as well as what we
2:26:30is a zero -cost monthly newsletter that includes podcast summaries, as well as what we
2:26:30is a zero -cost monthly newsletter that includes podcast summaries, as well as what we
2:26:34call protocols in the form of one to three -page PDFs that cover everything from
2:26:34call protocols in the form of one to three -page PDFs that cover everything from
2:26:34call protocols in the form of one to three -page PDFs that cover everything from
2:26:34call protocols in the form of one to three -page PDFs that cover everything from
2:26:39how to optimize your sleep, how to optimize dopamine, deliberate cold exposure.
2:26:39how to optimize your sleep, how to optimize dopamine, deliberate cold exposure.
2:26:39how to optimize your sleep, how to optimize dopamine, deliberate cold exposure.
2:26:39how to optimize your sleep, how to optimize dopamine, deliberate cold exposure.
2:26:42We have a foundational fitness protocol that covers cardiovascular training and resistance training.
2:26:42We have a foundational fitness protocol that covers cardiovascular training and resistance training.
2:26:42We have a foundational fitness protocol that covers cardiovascular training and resistance training.
2:26:42We have a foundational fitness protocol that covers cardiovascular training and resistance training.
2:26:47All of that is available completely zero cost.
2:26:47All of that is available completely zero cost.
2:26:47All of that is available completely zero cost.
2:26:47All of that is available completely zero cost.
2:26:50You simply go to HubermanLab .com, go to the menu tab in the top right
2:26:50You simply go to HubermanLab .com, go to the menu tab in the top right
2:26:50You simply go to HubermanLab .com, go to the menu tab in the top right
2:26:50You simply go to HubermanLab .com, go to the menu tab in the top right
2:26:53corner, scroll down to newsletter, and enter your email.
2:26:53corner, scroll down to newsletter, and enter your email.
2:26:53corner, scroll down to newsletter, and enter your email.
2:26:53corner, scroll down to newsletter, and enter your email.
2:26:56And I should emphasize that we do not share your email with anybody.
2:26:56And I should emphasize that we do not share your email with anybody.
2:26:56And I should emphasize that we do not share your email with anybody.
2:26:56And I should emphasize that we do not share your email with anybody.
2:26:59Thank you once again for joining me for today's discussion with Dr.
2:26:59Thank you once again for joining me for today's discussion with Dr.
2:26:59Thank you once again for joining me for today's discussion with Dr.
2:26:59Thank you once again for joining me for today's discussion with Dr.
2:27:03Alex Marcin. And last, but certainly not least, thank you for your interest in science.
2:27:03Alex Marcin. And last, but certainly not least, thank you for your interest in science.
2:27:03Alex Marcin. And last, but certainly not least, thank you for your interest in science.
2:27:03Alex Marcin. And last, but certainly not least, thank you for your interest in science.
2:27:14Monster Energy. Everybody knows White Monster, Zero Ultra.
2:27:14Monster Energy. Everybody knows White Monster, Zero Ultra.
2:27:14Monster Energy. Everybody knows White Monster, Zero Ultra.
2:27:14Monster Energy. Everybody knows White Monster, Zero Ultra.
2:27:18That's the OG. It kicked off this whole zero sugar energy drink thing.
2:27:18That's the OG. It kicked off this whole zero sugar energy drink thing.
2:27:18That's the OG. It kicked off this whole zero sugar energy drink thing.
2:27:18That's the OG. It kicked off this whole zero sugar energy drink thing.
2:27:22But Ultra is a whole line.
2:27:22But Ultra is a whole line.
2:27:22But Ultra is a whole line.
2:27:22But Ultra is a whole line.
2:27:23now. You've got Strawberry Dreams, Blue Hawaiian, Sunrise, and Vice Guava, and they all bring
2:27:23now. You've got Strawberry Dreams, Blue Hawaiian, Sunrise, and Vice Guava, and they all bring
2:27:23now. You've got Strawberry Dreams, Blue Hawaiian, Sunrise, and Vice Guava, and they all bring
2:27:23now. You've got Strawberry Dreams, Blue Hawaiian, Sunrise, and Vice Guava, and they all bring
2:27:30the monster energy punch. So if you've been living in the white can, branch out.
2:27:30the monster energy punch. So if you've been living in the white can, branch out.
2:27:30the monster energy punch. So if you've been living in the white can, branch out.
2:27:30the monster energy punch. So if you've been living in the white can, branch out.
2:27:35Ultra's got a flavor for every vibe, and every single one is zero sugar.
2:27:35Ultra's got a flavor for every vibe, and every single one is zero sugar.
2:27:35Ultra's got a flavor for every vibe, and every single one is zero sugar.
2:27:35Ultra's got a flavor for every vibe, and every single one is zero sugar.
2:27:40Tap the banner to learn more.
2:27:40Tap the banner to learn more.
2:27:40Tap the banner to learn more.
2:27:40Tap the banner to learn more.